General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Road bike vs tri bike Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2004-07-08 1:19 PM

User image

Veteran
115
100
San Antonio, TX
Subject: Road bike vs tri bike
I'm getting back into the sport after a 6 year haitus and will be purchasing a new bike in the next 3 months or so. I already have a Gunnar road bike that I do all my training on, but am really torn on which type of bicycle to purchase. Cycling was my first love, but I wanted to expand and got into triathlon. I've always ridden road bikes in past triathlons and hated getting passed by the riders on dedicated tri bikes.

Now my big question: Is there a clear advantage to riding a dedicated tri bike over a road bike that is set up for triathlon (i.e. aerobars, etc.)?? I ask because I am considering a Trek 5200, Waterford road bike, or a Cervelo P2K and I noticed that Cervelo makes tri bikes with road geometries.


2004-07-08 1:46 PM
in reply to: #36119

User image

Master
2447
200010010010010025
Marietta, Ga
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
David,

I just went through the same predicament (sp?). The geometry of a tri bike works your quads and saves your hammies for the run, whereas a road bike will make more use of your hamstrings during the ride. When I went on my first ride on a dedicated tri bike (after riding a road bike for a few months) I was surprised by how much my quads burned. Its really a tremendous difference.

I took my Cannondale road bike into the shop and had them explain how I could convert it to a tri bike. After hearing the pro's and cons, I decided to keep my road bike as is and purchase a tri bike. Having both is an advantage since I do like to participate in group rides.

There are some articles out there that explain all the differences between a tri bike and road bike, and if you search through some of the threads here, you'll probably find a few.

Good luck.
2004-07-08 2:29 PM
in reply to: #36119

User image

Veteran
102
100
San Diego, CA
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
Look at the Cervelo Dual. It will allow you to switch the seatpost to get the benifit of either road or tri geometry depending on what you feel like riding.
2004-07-08 2:46 PM
in reply to: #36119

User image

Champion
4902
20002000500100100100100
Ottawa, Ontario
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
As you already have a road which you use for training, you would profit largely by getting a tri specific bike for triathlons. A good tri bike offers a more aerodynamic position which allows you to expend less energy on the bike leg. The bottom bracket is set farther back, which sets the center of gravity back thereby enhancing the steering when you are in the aero bars (when you put clip-ons on a road bike, the weight is thrown over the front making the balance a bit precarious). Also, as has already been said, you use different muscles which allows you to remain a bit fresher for the run leg.
If, on the other hand you opt for a combination road/tri bike, the Soloist is a great bike. Review at this site: http://www.bikesportmichigan.com/reviews/soloist.shtml
PS. The P2K also has the seat post that switches from road to tri geometry.
2004-07-08 3:06 PM
in reply to: #36119

User image

Veteran
138
10025
Lakeland, Florida
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
WOW..That article recomended by MACHIAVELO is really worth the time ...
2004-07-08 9:56 PM
in reply to: #36119

User image

Veteran
275
100100252525
San Diego, CA
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
Hey, I just posted this in the products section, but it looks like the experts are all hanging here....

Need a little help here, I am new ti the sport, and am in a bit of a quandry as far as my bike goes. I have a high quality hardtail MTB that I have been using for the past year for trail riding. I can't afford a new bike (although the new Cervello looks sooooooo sweet), so I was thinking........change to some road tires, loose the excess weight (trail pump, light ect), a set of cow horn bars and some aero clip ons. Anyone see any major problems that I am missing? The bike fits me very well, and I don't see myself doing anything more than a sprint or maybe an olympis distance in the forseeable future. Anty advice will be appreciated.


2004-07-09 9:56 AM
in reply to: #36119

User image

Extreme Veteran
454
1001001001002525
PR
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
You guys have any idea if this seatpost are sold separetly?  Or any other reversible seatpost?
2004-07-09 11:11 AM
in reply to: #36227

User image

Resident Curmudgeon
25290
50005000500050005000100100252525
The Road Back
Gold member
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
will race for beer,

Sounds like you're talking about spending $300-$400 on handlebar, aerobars, tires, etc. After all that is installed, you will still have a pimped out "high quality hardtail MTB," not a tri bike, heavier, more rolling resistance, and inappropriate geometry. If it were me, I'd save my nickels for a while and buy a dedicated tri-bike, or at least a roadie.

Or, maybe look into doing some off-road tris?
2004-07-09 12:15 PM
in reply to: #36227

User image

Extreme Veteran
448
10010010010025
Edmonton, Alberta
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
I think you will be fine, get some slicks and go for it, at this point until you do a tri wait to see what you need.

I would also save to buy a Road or Tri bike once you see if you like the sport.

I think that an Oly would be a little long for mountain bike, but you will have nothing but fun doing a sprint.

I don't know if you have been out to any of your local races, but I find that is a great way to see what is out there.

You can talk to some people that have mountain bikes and get an idea what works and what doesn't.

Most tri athletes are more then willing to share there experiences and give an opinion

Have fun..

Roy
2004-07-09 2:37 PM
in reply to: #36316

User image

Veteran
275
100100252525
San Diego, CA
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
I though about the off-road tri's, even went and watched one of the EXTERRA events, looks like it would be a kick in the britches, might tri it after I do a sprint or 2. Here in the inland valleys of San Diego, there are plenty of places to train!
2004-07-09 4:39 PM
in reply to: #36119

User image

Extreme Veteran
377
100100100252525
Midcoast, Maine
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
david

I agree with Machiavelo on benifiting from owning both road and tri specitic bikes, even if for different reasons, having both bikes would allow you to be ready for any triathlon course, what makes for good aero on a tt makes for dificult climbing and corning, with both types of bikes you could handle any course that presents itself


2004-07-16 1:14 PM
in reply to: #36119

User image

Veteran
115
100
San Antonio, TX
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
Thanks for all the replies. I will go ahead with the tribike although the Cervelo soloist really caught my interest.

Thanks again
2004-07-16 1:21 PM
in reply to: #36119

User image

Extreme Veteran
427
10010010010025
Shiloh Illinois
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
It would make a **** load of money if a bike company could make a snap on handle bar set for road style handlebars or tri style bars with easy to connect cables sorta like the cables that connect your tv. On a bike with a steep seat tube angle but not tri or road geometry.

Edited by silent 2004-07-16 1:22 PM
2004-07-16 2:14 PM
in reply to: #36119

Regular
99
252525
Guelph, ON
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
Beer guy,

It's my first season, and all I had in the garage was a cheapo MTB. I put on the slickest road tires ($40), toe clips ($12), a computer ($35), and had the whole thing tuned up ($75). I have been quite happy with the result- the speed is vastly improved and my bike leg has been in the top 25% in both of my races.

The downside: it 'aint as fast as what most of your fellow racers will be riding. The largest gear isn't large enough, so you'll just have to tuck going down hills and coast. Plus, you will not be able to hide your bike envy in the transition area!

IMHO you will be happy for a season or two of sprint/OLY with a modified MTB, but if you stick with the sport you will want to get a road or tri bike.
2004-07-16 2:58 PM
in reply to: #38070

User image

Veteran
275
100100252525
San Diego, CA
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
How did you like the MTB Bars? I was thinking about a set of clip on Aero bars as well, but I am not sure if they will help much due to the geometry. Any other suggestions would be appreciated,
2004-07-16 4:07 PM
in reply to: #38090

User image

Pro
6582
50001000500252525
Melbourne FL
Gold member
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
will race for beer - 2004-07-16 2:58 PM

How did you like the MTB Bars? I was thinking about a set of clip on Aero bars as well, but I am not sure if they will help much due to the geometry. Any other suggestions would be appreciated,

------------------------------------------
If you want I can send you a pix of my Trek 4500 MTB that I ride in Tri fat-tire division. I’ve added aero bars, lower resistance but heavy road/trail tires and a 12-23 cog set. So far I did one sprint at 18.9 mph, and one Olympic at 17.9 mph. May not be the best setup for all out oomph, but I am in a fat-tire division so it works out. The Aero bars stay on now all the time, even when trail riding, it takes a few minutes to change out tires. I don’t notice the cog diff on trail riding, I now just actually use the smaller front chain rings more. For me it was a decision between a full suspension MTB and/or a Tri-bike, or a 100 year anniversary Harley-Davidson 1200 Custom Sportster, the HD won out this year :-)

Don


2004-07-16 4:19 PM
in reply to: #38116

User image

Veteran
275
100100252525
San Diego, CA
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
Yes, please send a pic to [email protected] I was beginning to think the the MTB in a tri was crazy, glad I'm not the only one in this boat......BTW, congrats on the Sportster
2004-07-18 10:21 PM
in reply to: #36316

Member
20

Byram, ms
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
im in the market for a Tri bike and willprobably get the Cervelo t3 or t2k,
i currently have a hardtail MTB with slicks, i did my first tri, an oly with my MTB, can in last in my class on the bike but had the best time ever. a tri bike is the only way to go.

Good luck, buy it once or buy it twice, spend the money now. not later
2004-07-19 4:19 AM
in reply to: #36119

User image

Veteran
202
100100
St. Catharines, Ontario
Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
I love road bikes. I pass a lot of big $ tri bikes. Road bike are a lot more comfortable and it is good to have one for training. Because I am a long didstance guy I think a road bike is better for me and the more experience you have in cycling the less the bike actually matters.
2004-07-19 9:20 AM
in reply to: #36119

Subject: RE: Road bike vs tri bike
Charlie

They do sell the seatposts by themselves. http://www.tri-zone.com/Catalog/BigTHSSB.html
New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Road bike vs tri bike Rss Feed