Other Resources My Cup of Joe » Healthcare Problem vs. Diet/Excercise Problem Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, the bear, DerekL, alicefoeller Reply
Healthcare Problem vs. Diet/Excercise Problem
OptionResults
Healthcare Cost Problem
Eating/Exercise Problem
Both
Health Insurance Problem
Peoples perception of the function of insurance
Laziness and Sense of Entitlement Problem
All of the above

2010-03-03 3:39 PM

User image

Expert
1310
1000100100100
Alabama
Subject: Healthcare Problem vs. Diet/Excercise Problem
A headline to an article got me thinking, and with all the healhcare reform talk....

Do we really have a healthcare cost problem in the US, or do we really have an diet/exercise problem?

If other industrialized nations (Italy, France, Japan, etc.) have lower healthcare costs than we do, maybe we really have a lifestyle/diet/exercise problem instead of a healthcare cost problem.  The diets in other places seem to be better than they are here, which leads to less health problems.  Also the fact that people tend to walk more places than they do here because of our great use of cars.  We as a society, tend to get less activity than other places.

How much of a drain is our diet/lifestyle choices on our healthcare costs?

What do you think?

Edited by pilotzs 2010-03-03 3:59 PM


2010-03-03 3:50 PM
in reply to: #2705643

User image

Champion
6046
5000100025
New York, NY
Subject: RE: Healthcare Problem vs. Eating/Excercise Problem
Every industrialized nation except for the US has a single payor system.
2010-03-03 6:28 PM
in reply to: #2705643

User image

Master
1790
1000500100100252525
Tyler, TX
Subject: RE: Healthcare Problem vs. Diet/Excercise Problem
I read somewhere that something like 10% or 20% of health care expenses are related to us generally not being healthy.  So it is a significant chunck of the problem but not the only problem that needs to be solved. 

In our current system you're still screwed if you can't afford insurance but get hit by a truck.  Doesn't matter much if you're healthy or not, you'll still have to declare bankruptcy if you survive.....

Brian
2010-03-03 7:14 PM
in reply to: #2705643

Expert
701
500100100
Boise
Subject: RE: Healthcare Problem vs. Diet/Excercise Problem
I did a research paper in undergrad about childhood obesity in Europe vs. the US. The rest of the industrialized world is quickly becoming just as fat as we are. I studied abroad in Australia and they were extremely worried about a growing obesity epidemic in their country. So the idea that only Americans are fat is eroding away.

But to answer the question. I think it's both. I don't think that one can be taken into account without the other and that they are both related concepts. I think that obesity taxes the health care system and drives costs up for everyone but also that the system itself is being taxed because of the baby boomer generation beginning to be able to take medicare benefits. That's the simplified version of my viewpoint but good question IMO.

Edited by crazyquick23 2010-03-03 7:15 PM
2010-03-03 8:24 PM
in reply to: #2705671

User image

Pro
4909
20002000500100100100100
Hailey, ID
Subject: RE: Healthcare Problem vs. Eating/Excercise Problem
TriToy - 2010-03-03 2:50 PM

Every industrialized nation except for the US has a single payor system.


Not really making a comment on the OP, but ....so? It's a fallacy.
http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/appeal-to-common-practice....

Just because someone else does it, does not make it any more right, better or correct. It should be able to stand on it's own merits.

2010-03-03 8:34 PM
in reply to: #2705643

User image

Elite
4547
2000200050025
Subject: RE: Healthcare Problem vs. Diet/Excercise Problem
diet/exercise is a huge component...but how do you enforce it?  Ya can't. 

unfortunately, it's not the only contributing factor...there are no easy answers to solving the healthcare crisis.  We have a lot of unhealthy folks living very long lives, and the end-of-life expenses are through the roof too.



2010-03-03 9:10 PM
in reply to: #2705643

User image

Pro
4189
20002000100252525
Pittsburgh, my heart is in Glasgow
Subject: RE: Healthcare Problem vs. Diet/Excercise Problem
I think that this is a much deeper problem than diet/exercise v. health care insurance etc.

When I lived in Britain, I did an insane amount of walking. Insane. I lived in a major metropolitan area in NI and Scotland. Everything was accessible to pedestrians and cyclists. I could walk or ride my bike or walk to a nearest train station or to a bus stop and get places. My doctor, a major museum, a major hospital, my university, a public library, a major park, two large grocery stores, a green grocer and a slew of newsagents were within a mile of home in both places I lived in Glasgow. It was the fact that walking, rather than driving (or taking the bus in most instances) was really the fastest/most efficient way to get around. The design of the city and the infrastructure was really set up to make things easy to get to.

Where my parents live in Pittsburgh, there are no sidewalks. No bike lanes. Even the shoulders of the road are pretty non-existent. Even though there is a grocery store less than a mile away, I wouldn't dare walk it because of the way people drive on the road. There's no pedestrian safety at all. It's the same where my brother lives, in a more upscale suburb. The things that could contribute to us getting fit or being fit or being more aware of the ways in which we use fuel are pretty removed from us.

Even in my little corner of the woods, there's one very scary major bridge that I must cross in order to get to get to the other side of the river so that I can go to the market, go to the city, go to work, etc. It's do-able on the bike, but only because people have tramped a little path into the median of the shoulder. But because of the snow, and the fact that the city hasn't cleared the snow on any of the bridges, that is impassable on foot or on bike. It's just a shame. I think that people would enjoy the city and their neighborhoods more if it was more pedestrian friendly, I think that they'd take a bit more pride in where the lived, and I think they'd have a little more pride in themselves and learn that exercise is pretty easy once you get started.

So perhaps my suggestion is a bit too broad. Make cities and suburbs walk-able. Put things in reach of the population. Make walking/biking/public transportation commutes a common thing. Make community markets and community centers (pools, libraries, etc) a central part of life. And while this isn't going to single-handedly solve the "obesity epidemic"...I doubt it would hurt.
2010-03-04 11:34 AM
in reply to: #2706290

User image

Member
1699
1000500100252525
Subject: RE: Healthcare Problem vs. Diet/Excercise Problem
I think it is both. I also predict more and more requirements on lifestyle based on the fact that more and more health care will be provided by the government.
New Thread
Other Resources My Cup of Joe » Healthcare Problem vs. Diet/Excercise Problem Rss Feed