General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Pool vs OWS time difference Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2011-01-24 10:59 AM

User image

Extreme Veteran
409
100100100100
Subject: Pool vs OWS time difference
Most of my swimming (like most) is in a pool. I slide change from one side of my lane to the other to keep count on long swims (I'm to cheep to buy a counter).

My Question is: Does the additional time required to do that and touch the wall on the other side of the pool equally offset the additional breathes I get? I do not push off the wall hard to not "cheat". I want to get an idea of an accurate 1500m swim time. Last night I did a 36:26 1650 yrd swim using that scenario.

Oh yea, how far back of the pack does that time sound... I have only been lap swimming for 9 mo


2011-01-24 11:06 AM
in reply to: #3318084

User image

Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference
Push off the wall to return to the speed you were going when you got to the wall. Quite a few like doing flip turns, quite a few don't.

You're probably going to be 10-15 seconds per 100 slower in open water until you get used to it. Then again you gain about 10 seconds per hundred with a wetsuit so there you go

2011-01-24 11:13 AM
in reply to: #3318106

User image

Sensei
Sin City
Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference

Pool swim with flip turnes = OWS with wetsuit.  (in my case)

2011-01-24 12:00 PM
in reply to: #3318084

User image

Expert
1168
10001002525
Vancouver (not Canada) Washington (not D.C.)
Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference
If this will be your first open water 1.5k swim you will do two things.

1. You will set a PR.

2. You will learn that you need to focus on different things when swimming in the pool.

My recommendation is to not focus on "cheating" but instead focus on swimming well. What that means to me is learning to swim multiple strong sets of 100-400 distances . This will build your speed and endurance. Practice swimming with you head out of the water. Work on swimming with your eyes closed. Share a lane.

I've never heard anyone evaluate their race day performance and say, "I could have won if I hadn't flip turned so much."

2011-01-24 12:14 PM
in reply to: #3318084

User image

Pro
5361
50001001001002525
Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference
a 36min/mi is respectable.  you'll be MOP.

I agree with the above.  My pool times are roughly equivalent to my wet-suited open water times, although given that it's a race- I tend to swim faster/harder in a race.  Plus there's the drafting opportunities of a race.   You gain a little by the push off, but you lose a little stopping and turning.  How much is individual.

keep swimmin'
have fun.
2011-01-24 12:52 PM
in reply to: #3318271

User image

Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference

IMO, there is no reason to mimic your OWS pace in the pool by slowing down or speeding up your turns.  Just swim and work on technique. 

If you push off the walls hard and do really fast turns, then your pool pace might be faster than your OWS pace.  Really...what difference does that make?  Does someone who keeps their pool pace closer to their OWS pace have some type of advantage?



2011-01-24 1:14 PM
in reply to: #3318303

User image

Master
1929
100050010010010010025
Midlothian, VA
Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference
morey000 - although given that it's a race- I tend to swim faster/harder in a race.  Plus there's the drafting opportunities of a race.


I agree.  Factor in the adrenaline  and your OWS race swim will likely be faster than your pool swims. Could be lower too though, it depends on so MANY things.

Does the water temp mess you up?  How well do you sight?  Do kicks and other hits in the water break your rhythm? Do you draft?

If you are well prepared I would expect the OWS to equal or exceed anything you do in practice.

-eric
2011-01-24 1:24 PM
in reply to: #3318084

User image

Master
2355
20001001001002525
Houston, TX
Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference
1. Stop thinking about OWS vs Pool. Swim the pool as well as you can. This means flip turns, push, glide, dolphin kick... etc. On your shorter harder sets, you can incorpate not breathing inside the flags. These are things that are specificly for swimming good in the pool, but they translate to OW by making you very comfotable in the water. The more comfortable in the water you are, the better feel for the water you have, the better swimmer you will be in all situations! This will make you a better swimmer in the pool AND in open water. This seems to go over most peoples heads for whatever reason. Don't skip out on all the swimmer things in the pool. I don't know a good swimmer that does.

2. 36 minute is on the slower end for 1500 the fact that you swam 1500 is respectable, but the time... not so much. Sorry, sometimes I think BT can be a bit too nice. No worries though, no one starts out fast! My first 1500m was much slower.

3. Your time from the pool to OW will be a tad slower, but it shouldn't be very much. Depending on conditions of course. Swimming from one side of the lane to the other won't make much noticeable difference on time in the pool.
2011-01-24 1:35 PM
in reply to: #3318490

User image

Extreme Veteran
374
1001001002525
Southeast Michigan
Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference
For me it works like this in training.  No wall pushoff in pool + wet suit in the open water = if swimming longer laps in a roped off OW area = probably 5 secs/100 faster in open water, maybe 10. 

In a race it works like this since my siting is so bad and I can't swim straight.   Take race distance in pool add 15% more to the number of meters I will ultimately swim, subtract out aforementioned 5 sec gain from wetsuit = probable race time, assuming other factors are negligable like water current and so forth.
2011-01-24 1:40 PM
in reply to: #3318084

User image

Extreme Veteran
565
5002525
Jenison , MI
Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference
My open water swims are always faster then the pool.
For one the pool I swim in is a shallow pool (chest deep the whole way) this makes for a harder swim and slower times.
Two I flip turn and don't worry about how fast I flip. I can get a pit lazy in the flip. I also don't push off hard. When I do that in long sets I tend to get leg cramps from it so I just don't do it.

So in OWS I don't have the lazy flip, 90%+ I have deep water, there is also drafting and the adrenaline of the race.

Two years ago I was swimming a lot. I would only pull a 1:55/100 time in the pool but in races I would pull 1:30/100 and would be in the top 10 out of the water.
Don't let the pool dictate what your OWS will be.
2011-01-24 3:08 PM
in reply to: #3318084

User image

Expert
703
500100100
Palm Springs, California
Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference
Like some of the others, I'm about the same in a pool as I am in a wetsuit OW, but a wetsuit is faster if you subtract-out running to the timing mat. I averaged 1:34 from the gun to T1 in a sprint Saturday, and am lucky to swim sets at 1:30.

Forget handicapping yourself at the wall. Swim like a swimmer, and you'll have a better handle on your progress relative to others. If anything, swimming hard into and away from the wall is a better workout.

Now, as for your first wetsuit ows, there's a good chance you'll have the common experience that adrenaline+neoprene = fastest time ever.


2011-01-24 8:51 PM
in reply to: #3318084

User image

Master
1325
100010010010025
Lake Oswego, OR
Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference

It will be greatly affected by how well you draft in a race

2011-01-24 9:59 PM
in reply to: #3319434

User image

Master
2372
20001001001002525
Subject: RE: Pool vs OWS time difference
E=H2O - 2011-01-24 8:51 PM

It will be greatly affected by how well you draft in a race



It will be greatly affected by how well you swim straight.  First OWS like this I wouldn't worry too much about drafting.  More likely than not to get kicked instead of getting a good draft, particularly that far back.  Worry about swimming straight (practice sighting, swim with eyes closed to figure out which way you lean, etc.).
New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Pool vs OWS time difference Rss Feed