General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Resting between Swim Intervals Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 2
 
 
2008-04-18 3:15 PM
in reply to: #1347842

User image

Veteran
300
100100100
Tacoma
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
KSH - 2008-04-18 12:45 PM
I'm confused as to why you kick on your back for 600 meters with fins. ???? What has made you decided to do this?

I might also add that it would be OK to change up your routine some. Kind of like if you go in and lift the same amount of weights every single day in the exact same way, at some point you stop seeing returns.

If you get the book Swim Workouts in a Binder for Triathlets, you can get some swim workouts to do from there. And you can pick your workout based on what you need to do that day. Endurance, speed, etc.


The instuctor used to have me do kicks with the fins on my side. I started to do it on my back so I could remove the uncomfortable goggles. I have sice bought better goggles but continue on my back. The instructor explained the difference, but said it was negligible at this point.

I'm trying to keep my swim workouts as simple as possible until I can get comfortably into the masters class. I pretty much do the same thing with my strength training. The variance is increasing distance & weight.

Is what I'm doing a fairly effecient way to improve over the next 2 or 3 months, or should I be seeking more structure? Should I start using the kickboard again? I'm trying to up my swimming as much as possible without burning out & dreading it. Any advise is appreciated.


2008-04-18 3:57 PM
in reply to: #1347670

User image

Bob
2194
2000100252525
Binghamton, NY
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
bryancd - 2008-04-18 2:43 PM
mbmoran2 - 2008-04-18 1:38 PM

bryancd - 2008-04-18 2:27 PM

 100's w/ 10sec Rest Intervals is a swimming staple. It really forces you to work hard but does provide sufficient rest to catch your breath and settle down your HR before pushing off again. This kind of near constant stimulus really helps. In your case, you should try doing a set of 10x100 on the 1:50. You can dtermine how much rest you get by how fast you and you will have to really work hard towards the end, but it's a great kind of workout. I also agree that straight swims are excellent, but they provide a different kind of stimulus, constant effort, anbd chances are the pacing is less.

As long as the intervals are a reasonable duration, if you come to the wall and only have a few seconds left, you go, don't slow down. If you get to the wall and there's no time left, you go. If you get to the wall and you are over and you still have a few to do, you set the bar too high.

What I really need is Bryan on the deck barking at me after each 100m:

"WTF are you doing hangin' on the gd wall!  Get your A$$ in gear and swim!  Swim you MF'er, SWIM!  HTFU and SWIM!!!

 

What we all need is Bob Stocks to teach us! Hopefully he will chime in here as well.

I like the idea of Bryan barking at all of us. I need some barking at when I'm on the bike trying to get my HR into Z-4! Let's get back to the swimming though.

Bryan's right on the money with his advice. 30 sec rest is a good rest interval for a beginning swimmer but doesn't serve much purpose as far as training goes. It's too short to fully recover to work on speed and too long of a rest to really work on your endurance pacing.

If your workout calls for 10 x 100, set up your interval so that you get 10 sec rest on the first swim. The last swim of the set you may only get 3 or 4 sec rest but that will improve each time you do the set. If you come in on the first 100 on 1:40 and your interval is set for 1:50 keep that interval until you can get 9 or 10 sec rest on the last one. At that time you may actually find yourself getting 13 sec rest on the first one. When you can do this, move the interval to 1:45.

There are several ways to keep sets of 100's interesting. Splitting a set of 10 x 100 into 2 sets of 5 x 100 with 1:00 breat after 5 works well. My all time favorite set is one we did every Monday in college. It kind of ruined your Monday but looking back it did it's job! When you look at this set plug in your own intervals and be prepared to work your a$$ off.

15 minute warm-up
16 x 100 @ 1:05 (If you miss the interval, sit it out and start on the next one)
4 x 500 @ 5:20 (Pay attention to stroke count
15 min cool down

If you are doing 1:30 100's, set your interval for 1:35 or 1:40. When you can make the set without sitting a swim out move the interval down 5 sec.

The key to doing 100's is to swim like they are 500's. Keep your stroke long and efficient. Try to keep track of your strole count because you will notice your stroke count go up as you tire. When your stroke count goes up you are wasting energy and need to "get long" again.

Good luck, sorry this is so long winded.

2008-04-18 4:09 PM
in reply to: #1347522

User image

Master
1292
1000100100252525
McKinney, TX
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
mbmoran2 - 2008-04-18 1:00 PM

I think if I did 100's with 10 second rests, my times would look something like this:

1:39, 1:41, 1:42, 1:43, 1:44, 1:45, 1:46, 1:47, 1:48, 1:49...

On the otherhand, a straight 1,000m at 1:50/100m pace seems quite manageable.  I guess I treat the swim intervals too much like track intervals and tend to go pretty hard.

Our masters coach is very big on descending sets. Typically we do sets of 4x150s on 3:00. Descending forces you to start out at what feels like a ridiculously slow pace, but by the end you are hauling butt to go faster. So...if you blow out the first one and stay the same speed or get (gasp) slower...you get yelled at. He's fun like that.

2008-04-18 4:43 PM
in reply to: #1347604

User image

Master
2621
2000500100
Mechanicsburg, PA
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
parrj - 2008-04-18 2:20 PM

I generally recommend for my athletes about a 15-20s rest for hard 100yd/m intervals. The purpose is to allow yourself to lower your heart rate, but not allow it to go to low. The goal is to be able to do 10x100 hard on short rest, so that you train your body to be better prepared to do 1000 at the same pace.



Yep this is something I'll second. :)

Edited by tasr 2008-04-18 4:45 PM
2008-04-18 5:05 PM
in reply to: #1347454

User image

Champion
9600
500020002000500100
Fountain Hills, AZ
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
Waaaaaa, 100's with only 10 seconds rest are hard, waaaaaaaaaa!

SUCK IT UP, BUTTERCUP'S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2008-04-19 1:51 AM
in reply to: #1347592

User image

Veteran
125
10025
Kailua-Kona now in Oregon,
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
yaqui - 2008-04-18 9:17 AM

JohnnyKay - 2008-04-18 9:54 AM

bryancd - 2008-04-18 12:48 PM 100's w/ 10sec Rest Intervals is a swimming staple. It really forces you to work hard but does provide sufficient rest to catch your breath and settle down your HR before pushing off again. This kind of near constant stimulus really helps.
scott


Today at masters we did 3x150 on 10 sec. for a warm up and finished the day with 16 x50 on 5 sec. with every other 50 all out. And I was hurting by the end of it. I think when I swim 2500 yards continuous I'm not nearly as tired as today's workout. Sort of like fartleks. Trains the body to speed up then recover, then go hard again, then recover.


2008-04-20 6:20 AM
in reply to: #1348221

User image

Expert
750
5001001002525
Harrisburg, PA
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
bryancd - 2008-04-18 5:05 PM

Waaaaaa, 100's with only 10 seconds rest are hard, waaaaaaaaaa!

SUCK IT UP, BUTTERCUP'S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Go ahead, rub it the hell in. Just be glad you were born with the ability to swim. It is not a skill that is learned; you can either do it or you can't, period. My instructor can yell and scream at me as much as he wants, but that doesn't make one able to breath. Maybe just for spite I'll drown just to prove my point. I'm f***ing tired of being able to only swim 25 yards at a time and having to stop and gasp. Believe me, if someone screaming, "Swim, swim!" is all it takes to do continuous laps, then I should be able to swim 3000 yards in one shot. And it's not because I'm lazy or not motivated. I have been putting more time in floundering in pools than running or riding my bike. All this talk of, "It will just 'click'," I don't believe there is a 'click'. If there is one, it doesn't appear it will happen before the tri's I was planning on doing in July and August. Of course I'm not Ironman material, and never said I was. There still are beginners on beginnertriathlete. com, right.
2008-04-20 12:51 PM
in reply to: #1347454

User image

Pro
6582
50001000500252525
Melbourne FL
Gold member
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
Good topic, thanks.
2008-04-20 1:14 PM
in reply to: #1349493

User image

Bob
2194
2000100252525
Binghamton, NY
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals

nxm165 - 2008-04-20 7:20 AM
bryancd - 2008-04-18 5:05 PM Waaaaaa, 100's with only 10 seconds rest are hard, waaaaaaaaaa! SUCK IT UP, BUTTERCUP'S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Go ahead, rub it the hell in. Just be glad you were born with the ability to swim. It is not a skill that is learned; you can either do it or you can't, period. My instructor can yell and scream at me as much as he wants, but that doesn't make one able to breath. Maybe just for spite I'll drown just to prove my point. I'm f***ing tired of being able to only swim 25 yards at a time and having to stop and gasp. Believe me, if someone screaming, "Swim, swim!" is all it takes to do continuous laps, then I should be able to swim 3000 yards in one shot. And it's not because I'm lazy or not motivated. I have been putting more time in floundering in pools than running or riding my bike. All this talk of, "It will just 'click'," I don't believe there is a 'click'. If there is one, it doesn't appear it will happen before the tri's I was planning on doing in July and August. Of course I'm not Ironman material, and never said I was. There still are beginners on beginnertriathlete. com, right.

Nick, I don't think Bryan was really rubbing anything in. What motivates some I guess rubs others the wrong way. I am sorry you are frustrated with your swimming. I have taught enough people to swim to say that it is not a skill you are born with.

I can say from experience that adult athletes, especially runners,  are by far the hardest group of people to teach mechanics to. They take everything an instructor says literally and want formulas and exact angles to hold their hands and elbows, etc.

A large part of swimming is to develop a feel for the water and your body position in the water. In the water, as I am sure your coach has gone over with you, your lungs act as a center of buoyancy. If there is no air in your lungs, there won't be any floating. If you aren't floating, you can't be relaxing and staying relaxed is a key to swimming more efficiently.

Feel free to PM me if you have any specific problems you are having in the water. Most of the time there is actually a "click" when it comes to individual drills. I wouldn't say the "click" is from being a struggling swimmer to a competitive swimmer.

Keep up the work in the pool and it will pay off. 

2008-04-20 1:32 PM
in reply to: #1349493

Champion
6539
5000100050025
South Jersey
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals

nxm165 - 2008-04-20 7:20 AM
bryancd - 2008-04-18 5:05 PM Waaaaaa, 100's with only 10 seconds rest are hard, waaaaaaaaaa! SUCK IT UP, BUTTERCUPS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Go ahead, rub it the hell in.

Bryan wasn't being mean. Someone had mentioned they need Bryan up on the pool deck barking at him when he's doing his 100s. I think Bryan was merely demonstrated what he would say to the guy that asked him to yell at him. No worries.

2008-04-20 1:38 PM
in reply to: #1349834

Champion
6539
5000100050025
South Jersey
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals

How about descending intervals? I like those, but they are TOUGH. I usually just end up doing touch and go for the last few 100s and just hope I finish the last one on time .



2008-04-20 5:21 PM
in reply to: #1347454

User image

Expert
750
5001001002525
Harrisburg, PA
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
My apologies to Bryan.

Didn't mean to jump down anyone's throat. Just that the sh*t starting hitting the fan for my this week. It's all in the timing. Today is the proverbial 13 weeks from my first (sprint) tri and I'm comfortable with the bike and run, but I'm now wondering if the swim will keep me from doing any tri's, at least this year, if at all. I'm feeling the frustration, and I don't want to do an event I know I can't finish.

I have an instructor who has cleaned up my technique, and has even speeded me up, put the breathing issue is becoming insurmountable, and I'm starting to get freaked, stressed, etc.

Again, I'm sorry; don't want to be like a drunk at a bar that starts picking fights. Not trying to explain away bad behavior; I should have pressed 'delete' as opposed to 'submit'.
2008-04-20 5:47 PM
in reply to: #1350067

Champion
6539
5000100050025
South Jersey
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals

No worries, and you'll do fine. Thirteen weeks is still a long time. Is the breathing issue a panic thing? If so, I can tell you what a friend did that really helped. I've recommended it to other people, and it's helped them as well.

He said, he would just put on a pair of fins, kick EZ and swim underwater (arms at side or above head, not sure). This is NOT a swim drill, and NOT a hypoxic drill...if you need air, come up and breathe. But he said it really helped him to relax in the water and really calm him down, because it was nerves/panic that was most interfering with his breathing when swimming. Once he was comfortable underwater, he said he could do anything above water.

Good luck and keep at it. you'll be fine !

2008-04-21 3:26 PM
in reply to: #1347454

Champion
9430
50002000200010010010010025
No excuses!
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
Popcorn, who's got popcorn? Laughing
2008-04-21 8:29 PM
in reply to: #1347604

User image

Expert
986
500100100100100252525
Michiana
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
mbmoran2 - 2008-04-18 2:20 PM

OK.  You guys have given me a personal challenge:

  • week of 4/21:  10x100 at 1:50 on 2:00 (high confidence)
  • week of 4/28:  10x100 at 1:45 on 1:55 (seems doable)
  • week of 5/5:    10x100 at 1:40 on 1:50 (we'll see)

I managed the 10x100m on 2:00's today.  I should be doing 1:55's, but forgot my watch and didn't want to attempt that much thinking while in oxygen debt.  .

Splits started at 1:40 and migrated up to 1:46.  Work-out was plenty hard as my form deteriorated badly during the last few intervals.  Again, probably need to go with leaving on the 1:55's, and slow to a more manageable 1:45/100m.  I'll give that a shot next week.

From today...

5x200 (swim,pull,kick,swim,pull)
10x100 on 2:00's (1:40-1:46/100m)
100 kick (on back) with zoomers
4x50m sprints on 2:00's (0:36,0:39,0:40,0:41)
75 breast EZ
25 back EZ

2008-04-21 8:47 PM
in reply to: #1349493

User image

Expert
973
5001001001001002525
Berkeley, Calif.
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
nxm165 - 2008-04-20 4:20 AM
All this talk of, "It will just 'click'," I don't believe there is a 'click'. If there is one, it doesn't appear it will happen before the tri's I was planning on doing in July and August.


I don't share your breathing problems (usually), but I feel for you, definitely. It's hard for me to admit, but I am clearly not a natural swimmer. Sometimes I get very frustrated reading the posts here from people talking about that magical "click." I can swim pretty long distances, but even with A LOT of time in the pool and one-on-one coaching, I am still ridiculously slow, and in races I seem to fall apart completely.

You're definitely not alone -- there are lots of us here who struggle big-time with swimming. As my awesome mentor Yanti pointed out, it's usually the people having breakthroughs who post in the forums about "clicking" and overnight progress and whatnot. Us strugglers are usually hiding in our logs.

One thing to keep in mind, especially with the sprint distances, is that it's perfectly acceptable to not freestyle and just move forward any way you can. A couple weeks ago I did a mini-mini tri, only 100 yards, and completely freaked out for some reason. I ended up swimming the whole thing doing basically a dog paddle (and I wasn't even last out of the water); I'm sure I could have done it for a longer race. Your biking and running are so strong -- don't give up now!


2008-04-22 10:33 AM
in reply to: #1348101

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
2008-04-22 10:43 AM
in reply to: #1354279

Expert
986
500100100100100252525
Michiana
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals

surfwallace - 2008-04-22 11:33 AM

I like descending sets. Actually most of the intervals I do are kind of descends by the nature of effort but not by descending time. My intensity increases with each interval in a set. I think Johnny Kay said it earlier to shoot for the same pace on each interval. I don't swim with rest intervals; I swim on a set interval (say 1:30). My first interval no matter how slow I try to swim it will always be 15 seconds below what I am trying to do. The next 2 will also be pretty easy. The middle 4 will be work and I will usually slow a couple seconds. The last 3 are painful. The 5-10 seconds I have to rest on those last 3 is just enough time for some lactic to get out of my arms (I know recent studies have shown lactic acid to be different than what it was previously thought to be but this is how I was raised). After the hell is over, I usually wait about a minute and start the next set. There is never a whole lot of sitting around.

I would say 5 seconds rest for 50's, 10 seconds rest for 100's, and 20 seconds tops for anything more (maybe 30 if you are doing sets of 500's, 800's or 1000's).

It sometimes feels like you are just swimming straight but that 5-10 seconds makes all the difference. My feeling is that you want to get as close to "the wall" as many times as you can during a swim workout. It isn't like running where you can hit the wall and then it all goes to hell. When swimming competitively, there was rarely a practice that went by without hitting the wall and breaking through the wall to the point where you get some energy from some place that you didn't think you had. I remember doing 10k-15k yard workouts and literally thinking I couldn't move my arms for another lap to within that same interval going as fast as when I started. It is something I can't explain but I remember breaking through the wall 2-3 times during some of those workouts. That is why IMO it is important to get right up to the redline, then rest for a little while but not enough to move too far away from that redline.

I actually really like 2-3 seconds rest. And if you think if you are only allowing yourself that short of rest because you aren't swimming fast enough, I can still manage to do a set of 10 50's on :35

I venture to guess, most triathletes, who just recently learned to swim like myself, don't push that hard.  I generally have been focused on endurance and form for the first two years of learning to swim.  Just recently, have I attempted to get faster.  For both my Olys and my HIM last year, my pace was right around 2:00/100m.  Probably because that's pretty much the pace I did most of my trianing.  I can swim a fully rested 1:22/100m and a 0:36/50m.  I'd love to translate something close to a 1:40/100m in a triathlon (Oly/HIM).

It sounds like faster intervals with less rest will get me closer to that goal.

Thanks a ton for the insight.

2008-04-30 8:21 PM
in reply to: #1347454

Expert
986
500100100100100252525
Michiana
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals

OK. I pushed harder today and feel like I've made some progress.  10x100m swim today.  Met goal of 1:45 on 1:55 intervals.  Here's how it went...

  time rest interval
1:350:151:50
1:380:131:51
1:400:121:52
1:410:091:50
1:420:121:54
1:440:091:53
1:430:121:55
1:440:091:53
1:470:101:57
1:47
Average1:42 0:11 1:53

Clearly need to continue endurance work as my pace/form faded big time.  It's definitely a harder work-out than 1,000m straight-through at a 1:53 pace.

2008-04-30 9:07 PM
in reply to: #1347454

Master
2202
2000100100
St. Louis
Subject: RE: Resting between Swim Intervals
This has been a great thread. Swimming is something I struggle with and I am really going to take some of these tips. I seem to be stagnating, or even digressing from a month ago.

Thanks everyone for the great tips :D

Now, what can I do to make myself really LIKE swimming more???? Thats the $1,000,000 question!
2008-04-30 10:09 PM
in reply to: #1373879

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.


New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Resting between Swim Intervals Rss Feed  
 
 
of 2