General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Decision, decisions...bike purchase Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2005-07-28 10:37 PM

User image

Expert
997
500100100100100252525
Littleton, CO
Subject: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
So dh gave me a $1000-1500 bike budget.  We have a very close connection with a manager of a Performance, which opens up Giant, Fuji, Tirreno, Iron Horse to me.  I'm considering the Giant OCR1 or TCR1 or 2.  But, I'd also like to try the Trek 1500 WSD, Felt F60-70, Scattante (the most bang for buck from Supergo, but not familiar with frame quality). 

I do not want a Tri specific bike as my cycling life does not entirely revolve around Tri's.  I am a 5'3" woman.  I also don't want to have to travel to 30 different stores to test ride all these bikes. BTW- friend at Performance is a professional bike fitter and will do it for free for me.  Tell me your opinions.

For reference, I have been riding a borrowed Cannondale frame with a double with Ultegra and Dura-ace Components, sweet wheels, aluminum fork(yuck). I don't want my new purchase to be disappointing compared to this bike.

If this has been asked too many times, please disregard and chastise me properly in a nice way.  ****Warning...I have PMS and am weaning from breastfeeding... that should say enough, be gentle with me *** And Bear - I DID do a search of past posts for the past year.  Still can't decide what way to go.

Thanks in advance - Melanie


2005-07-28 10:44 PM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Regular
67
2525
Pinecrest
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
Hi Mel,
I just traded in a FELT S25 that I rode for 9 months. It is the BEST bike for the $. I strongly suggest that you keep FELT as a top choice. The bike shop told me that they practically give away the frames and charge just for the components.

I just purchased a $5K Litespeed Blade and to be honest, I kinda miss the Felt.

Good luck
Bill



(kids 026.jpg)



(kids 006.jpg)



Attachments
----------------
kids 026.jpg (92KB - 34 downloads)
kids 006.jpg (92KB - 31 downloads)
2005-07-28 10:47 PM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Expert
1836
100050010010010025
Lafayette, CO
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase

Those Scattante frames aren't that bad - they're Asian-made 'blank' (no-name) frames, the same ones that other companies buy and use with their names.  I own a Felt, and may be biased, but I like the Giant's, too.

Just keep in mind that there are other things you may wish to buy about the same time: pedals, shoes, cyclocomputer, aerobars, just to name a few.  If you will be doing longer rides, or bike races, I'd spend a little more on the bike - if there is a chance it will end up NOT being used to it's potential, I'd scrimp a little bit...

Question for bill: how many times are you going to post a picture of your bike?  I *wish* I could afford a Lightspeed.  I think you're just rubbing it in to be mean...



Edited by joeinco 2005-07-28 10:49 PM
2005-07-28 10:47 PM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Elite
4344
2000200010010010025
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase

You might want to check with a former bike racer for a good deal on a used bike.  I think a guy named Armstrong just dropped out of road racing and might have some wheels he wants to unload.

Yust yokin. 

I personally crave a Trek or a Litespeed.  But I know nuttin' about it.  I currently ride a 30 year old Raleigh.

TW

2005-07-28 10:54 PM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Member
29
25
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
I'm riding a Felt F65. I'm happy with it for races (clipped on some aerobars) and it works for more casual rides. Keep in mind that I'm 6'2/185, so we probably fit a little different. However, i'm very happy with it as I wasn't ready to make the plunge for a tri specific bike (It's my first purchase, and all I tested was a trek, a specialized tri bike, and my dad's vintage 70s road bike)
2005-07-28 11:09 PM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Expert
997
500100100100100252525
Littleton, CO
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
I heard that Scattante Frames are Mavic, out of Taiwan from a company who has been making frames for 35 years.  Never heard of Mavic either.

BTW- Douglas bikes are actually Litespeeds by a different name, available through colorado Cyclery.

I have pedals, need shoes, new computer.


2005-07-28 11:10 PM
in reply to: #210461

User image

New user
117
100
Alberta(think texas with snow.)
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
I personally dislike Treks. A lot. Giants generally give you the best component package at any price range. And, if you've been riding ultegra and dura ace, you are not gonna wanna drop below ultegra. I love Giants, am on my second one, have yet to have a single problem or find a single fault. I also pass a lot of people on much, much more expensive bikes.
2005-07-29 12:23 AM
in reply to: #210483

User image

Expert
805
500100100100
Portland,OR
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase

Hey Melanie,

I too am in the market for a new bike and find my self in the same dilemma as you.  I talked to the owner of my local tri shop about it and according to him almost every aluminum bike out the for your (and my) price range is almost exactly the same.  The differences come in to play when you talk about upgraded components and carbon forks, etc.  He is akin to Specialized since they sponsored him in his elite triathlete days.  I am not able to ride those because of my size(I'm over 200lbs and they are only guaranteed to 220), but he has also recommended Giant and Felt.  His advice was to find the frame that fits you at the best price no matter who makes it and then spend your money on really good components and a professional fitting.  I have now idea which way to go, but I thought this info might help you.

2005-07-29 12:48 AM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Regular
81
252525
Adelaide, South Australia
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
I agree wholeheartedly with the person who said about felt... The price of their bikes is great. I got the Felt f60 full Ultegra for less than a Lemond Tourmalet which is 105 gear!!! and it was 2kg lighter as well, spose that extra cash I saved makes me a bit heavier though!!!
2005-07-29 9:07 AM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Expert
948
50010010010010025
Mount Vernon, Iowa
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
A few years ago when I wanted my first "real" road bike, I got a Terry Symmetry, their entry level road bike. It's not the lightest, doesn't have the best components, but it fits amazingly well. The handlebars are narrower, the top tube is shorter, the brake grips are made for a woman's smaller hands - in short, I've ridden bikes worth 3-4x the price and not had nearly as good a ride. Now that I'm thinking of upgrading I may go for a Terry Fast Woman. I'm 5'8", so I don't necessarily need woman-specific geometry, but dang I love that bike. They'll mail one to your LBS for free to test ride.

Edit: My bad, apparently they now charge for shpping to test ride. Basically you buy the bike but have 2 wks to return it, minus shipping charges.

Edited by CLLinIA 2005-07-29 9:12 AM
2005-07-29 9:14 AM
in reply to: #210461

User image

molto veloce mama
9311
500020002000100100100
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
EROS DONNA! i would have gotten one, but at 5'7", even the biggest frame was too small for me. i ended up with a bianchi veloce. if you want a good all around road bike, you can't beat an italian beauty!!!

http://www.bianchiusa.com/eros_donna.html


2005-07-29 9:15 AM
in reply to: #210696

User image

molto veloce mama
9311
500020002000100100100
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
ps.my husband has heard mixed reviews of the campy mirage, which is what is on the eros donna. i have campy veloce on my veloce (duh), and LOVE it.
2005-07-29 10:02 AM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Master
1889
1000500100100100252525
Ann Arbor, MI
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
I am not sure I like you anymore.. Wow! can I borrow your hubby?? Trade for a few days? Mine changes diapers.

2005-07-29 10:12 AM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Extreme Veteran
336
10010010025
Peachtree City, GA
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
Well I have a Trek 1000 and she's never done me wrong.
2005-07-29 10:19 AM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Regular
85
252525
Orange County, California
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
I am in the same boat as the starter of this thread. I am having a hard time deciding between a Cannondale R700 and a Scott Speedster S3. Anybody ride either of these?
2005-07-29 10:59 AM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Champion
4902
20002000500100100100100
Ottawa, Ontario
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase

Hi Melanie,  with the budget you have and the close connection with the manager, you should be able to get yourself a bike that is as good or even better than the loaner you now have.  Having a friend at Performance who is a professional bike fitter and will do the fitting for free is a big plus.  I don't know anything about the bikes available at the Performance site but the only one listed that might be close to your loaner is the Ironhorse Triumph Race.  It is hung with mostly Ultegra components and seems to be a decent enough bike.  At $1080, it is a good deal and leaves you enough in your budget to get pedals, shoes, helmet and gloves.  Or, if you have these things already, you can look into upgrading the saddle or the wheelset.  However, because of your height and the fact that you are a woman, this bike may not be the best in terms of fit.  You should look at the WSD; it might be the better choice for you.  Do try all the bikes available at Performance and at other bike shops and then make up your mind.

Good luck ...    



2005-07-29 11:01 AM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Expert
683
500100252525
Denver
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
Hey, Melanie, not a bad predicament to be in. I can understand not wanting to bolt all over town riding bikes at several different shops, but if you're dropping $1,000 - $1,500, I think that's enough money to warrant a half day shopping trip to ensure a proper purchase. Even if you get something from your friend at Performance, it might just help to reaffirm your decision. Nothing worse than buyer's remorse!! I had a range of $1,000 - $2,000 when I was shopping and rode about 10 different bikes at Campus Cycles, Bicycle Village, Turin, and Performance, and ended up getting the Felt F60. I think it's a great bike and it hasn't done me wrong yet, so that would be my (biased) recommendation. I think Stacers has a Tirreno that she really likes, so she could tell you about that one if you're interested. Regarding fit, will your friend do it for free even if you don't get the bike from him? If not, some of the shops will throw it in for free if you buy your bike there. It's at least worth asking about. In the end, I think you just need to ride several of the bikes you've mentioned or are interested in since what's comfortable for me, may not be the same for you. Good luck (coughFeltcough)!!
2005-07-29 11:53 AM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Elite
3022
20001000
Preferably on my bike somewhere
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
Hi Melanie,
I just bought an OCR1 over the ones you mentioned. I rode the Felt, and felt is was a little softer than I wanted. I also thought that the Giant gave better components than the others in that price range. The Ultegra setup is FANTASTIC. I opted for the OCR1 because the TCR2 only had a double and given that there are hills where I live, and that I envision doing some nice long rides in the mountains of NH and VT, I wanted than granny gears so I don't KILL myself going up hill.

I thought about buying online, but I like the idea of having a relationship with a local guy. As a small business manager, I go out of my way to take care of people who spend money with me.
2005-07-29 11:58 AM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Queen BTich
12411
500050002000100100100100
,
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase

I love my TCR2. I didn't need or want a triple ring. Only moderate hills here. And my races over the next few years aren't condusive to tri bikes.

No complaints.

2005-07-29 3:21 PM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Expert
997
500100100100100252525
Littleton, CO
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
Thanks for your help! I think I am debating between the Giant OCR1 or the Felt. I will test drive both. As Performance manager is dh best friend, he will fit me regardless of where I buy the bike, but I would like to give him my money....that will depend on if I like the Felt better.

I think I do want a Triple Ring. I hope to do the Boulder Peak Oly next summer, and Old Stage Hill has a 15% grade...unless I want to be pushing the bike, I'll need it!

I am set to spend a 1/2 day shopping on Tuesday, but have to factor in $40 for the sitter...does that have to come out of my bike budget?

BTW Nancy - My dh changes diapers, cooks dinner, bathes kids while I work out, AND gives me $1500 for a bike! I think I got my best bargain in marrying him! The new bike is just icing on the cake!

 



Edited by Colomingle 2005-07-29 3:23 PM
2005-07-30 7:47 AM
in reply to: #210461

User image

Extreme Veteran
455
1001001001002525
Centennial, CO
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
Melanie,

I'm in Colorado and looking for my first bike as well (been riding my daughter old mountain bike for now - ouch)

Do you have a recommendation on where in the Denver area to shop for a new bike?? I"m in Centennial, and am ashamed to admit, that I've never even stepped foot in a bike shop before!!

Any help is welcomed!

Carrie


2005-07-30 9:52 AM
in reply to: #211516

User image

Extreme Veteran
343
10010010025
Centennial, CO
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase

Carrie -

I'm in Centennial too.  Plenty of bike shops around.  Quick run down:

Treads @ Parker & Cottonwood (Hans or Jason are really good to talk to)

Campus Cycles (Evans & Washington, a little out of the "neighborhood" but worth the drive, Carol is very helpful)

Adventure Cycles (Parker & Quincy, very knowledgable but pricey)

Bicycle Village (Havana & Yale-ish, anything for everything)

Performance (Arapahoe & Yosemite)

That should be a good start.  Happy shopping!

Kupe

2005-08-01 6:26 PM
in reply to: #211210

User image

Veteran
200
100100
san francisco, ca
Subject: RE: Decision, decisions...bike purchase
Yes, you *do* want the triple ring for hills. Maybe really experienced bikers don't need it, but I'm sure glad I've got it. I tried to tell a friend to get a triple...she went out & got a double Felt (F65). Guess who was waiting at the top of the hill...

Yay new bike!!!

Colomingle - 2005-07-29 1:21 PM

Thanks for your help! I think I am debating between the Giant OCR1 or the Felt. I will test drive both. As Performance manager is dh best friend, he will fit me regardless of where I buy the bike, but I would like to give him my money....that will depend on if I like the Felt better.

I think I do want a Triple Ring. I hope to do the Boulder Peak Oly next summer, and Old Stage Hill has a 15% grade...unless I want to be pushing the bike, I'll need it!

I am set to spend a 1/2 day shopping on Tuesday, but have to factor in $40 for the sitter...does that have to come out of my bike budget?

BTW Nancy - My dh changes diapers, cooks dinner, bathes kids while I work out, AND gives me $1500 for a bike! I think I got my best bargain in marrying him! The new bike is just icing on the cake!

 

New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Decision, decisions...bike purchase Rss Feed