General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Easy bike question Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2007-09-18 7:58 PM

Regular
58
2525
New Minas, Nova Scotia
Subject: Easy bike question
We all know about Bikesdirect by now I'm sure. My question, they have two triathlon bikes on there one with Ultegra components ($995) and the other with Dura Ace stuff ($1195). Is it worth the extra money for a relative beginner, or will I not even really notice it? It will be my first tri bike, looking for something cheap.

Also, does anyone here actually own one of these bikes? I cant find anyone that does... Thanks guys and gals


2007-09-18 8:00 PM
in reply to: #970078

User image

Resident Curmudgeon
25290
50005000500050005000100100252525
The Road Back
Gold member
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
I doubt even the more experienced cyclists out there would be able to tell the difference. Of course that won't stop them from saying they can.
2007-09-18 8:37 PM
in reply to: #970078

User image

Expert
1023
1000
Ft Gordon, GA
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
For an extra $200 bucks it's worth it in my opinion.

I do not understand how they sell their stuff so cheaply.

A Dura-Ace groupo along must be over a $1000 normally.

How do they do it?
2007-09-18 8:48 PM
in reply to: #970078

User image

Member
29
25
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
I run with ultegra components right now on my bike and haven't had any problems. I have a friend who just replaced his old components with slightly used Dura Ace stuff and loves them. I don't remember what he paid for the used set but I want to say it was definitely over $200. So it's a really good deal IMO if you're not pushing your budget too much.
2007-09-18 9:21 PM
in reply to: #970117

User image

Extreme Veteran
490
100100100100252525
Michigan
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
Karl Hungus - 2007-09-18 9:37 PM

For an extra $200 bucks it's worth it in my opinion.

I do not understand how they sell their stuff so cheaply.

A Dura-Ace groupo along must be over a $1000 normally.

How do they do it?


The Dura-Ace groupo that you are referring to includes STI shifters, brake calipers, a crank and BB, cassette, and chain. What they are selling to you is a DA mix. Even considering that, it's still dirt cheap!
2007-09-18 9:44 PM
in reply to: #970078

User image

Master
2468
20001001001001002525
Muskego, Wisconsin
Subject: RE: Easy bike question

I have the Motobecane Ultegra set up that I bought from a LBS that buys their stuff from  bikesdirect.com.  Awesome bike, awesome set up.  At the last Olympic I raced the overall male winner rode the same bike with zipp wheels.  The funny thing was the prize for winning was a $3000 frameset.  We talked after the race and he loves his bike as much as I do. 

 Before I bought mine I shopped for each individual part on the bike online and selected the lowest price I could find.  What I came out with was the components costing more than I spent on the bike not even including the frame.  When I asked the bikeshop why they can sell them so cheap he said it was because they buy them in bulk and keep them in a warehouse waiting for them to sell.  I felt better about the bike since I found an LBS that sold them.  If you buy it from the net I would have a LBS put it together for you so then you have a place where they know you and know your bike.

If thats true or not I don't know but i love my bike and for the price I paid I am able to decide if I'm going full bore into this sport or if it's going to be just a past time I enjoy.  As of now I've done 2 sprints, 1 olympic with an olympic this sunday.  No problems with the bike.  If you have anymore specific questions just let me know. 



2007-09-18 10:14 PM
in reply to: #970200

User image

Master
1890
1000500100100100252525
Cypress, CA
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
papson14 - 2007-09-18 7:44 PM

I have the Motobecane Ultegra set up that I bought from a LBS that buys their stuff from  bikesdirect.com.  Awesome bike, awesome set up.   

Which one have you got, if I might ask?  I've been eyeballing the Sprint, with Ultegra triple and carbon stays.  And, how are the stock wheels?

2007-09-18 10:39 PM
in reply to: #970078

User image

Master
3019
20001000
West Jordan, UT
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
For $200 you get carbon cranks and a nicer wheelset.  You also get the upgraded
Dura Ace Deraileurs and slightly nicer brakes.  This is stuff that would probably cost
$500+to upgrade later.  So, if you have the money, I'd do it.   That said, the upgrades
will probably only save a few seconds on race day.  The nicer wheels are still the 
same 30mm depth, which isn't super aero anyway.   
2007-09-18 10:43 PM
in reply to: #970117

User image

Master
3019
20001000
West Jordan, UT
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
Karl Hungus - 2007-09-18 7:37 PM For an extra $200 bucks it's worth it in my opinion. I do not understand how they sell their stuff so cheaply. A Dura-Ace groupo along must be over a $1000 normally. How do they do it?


They use basic frame designs and then use mixes of parts to get the cost down.  This is a Tri bike, so they save $300 on the STI by going bar end.   Also have you seen their web page?  They must have $25 of overhead per month!   No shop overhead means they only have to mark up the bikes maybe $100-$150 to turn a nice profit.   
2007-09-19 9:03 AM
in reply to: #970078

Regular
58
2525
New Minas, Nova Scotia
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
I didnt even know that LBS sold these bikes, I know mine don't anyways. Good idea about bringing it to them though, I know my last bike I set it up, and my friend (a LBS worker) laughed and reset it up. Might as well just skip the laughter and cut out the middle man (me).
I also feel better that I know people on the board use these bikes. Thanks guys
2007-09-19 9:43 AM
in reply to: #970080

User image

Cycling Guru
15134
50005000500010025
Fulton, MD
Subject: RE: Easy bike question

the bear - 2007-09-18 9:00 PM I doubt even the more experienced cyclists out there would be able to tell the difference. Of course that won't stop them from saying they can.

On this bike (tri bike), no you couldn't, but in a heads up road bike with full Ultegra Sti versus full DA Sti bike, yes, you can, by far.  Even a beginner will be able to feel the difference.

But for an upgrade in level which is really only the derailleurs you won't be able to tell the difference like this bike, and is probably not worth the extra dough.  Especially since you will still need to think about shoes, helmet and other accessories.  Your money can go further that way.



2007-09-19 9:47 AM
in reply to: #970078

Regular
58
2525
New Minas, Nova Scotia
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
I've already got the helmet, shoes and pedals. I have a hook up with a Montreal company, Cycle Lambert, I get everything at cost. Its pretty sweet, but now that you mention it, I did want to upgrade my shoes and pedals...hmmmm

Completely off topic, but I used to fantisize about cars and motorcycles, now all I can think of are tri-bikes (bike porn as I like to call it). Its a sad time when a 21 year old man would rather go bike riding then test drive cars
2007-09-19 9:54 AM
in reply to: #970555

User image

Cycling Guru
15134
50005000500010025
Fulton, MD
Subject: RE: Easy bike question

TrileteNewb - 2007-09-19 10:47 AM  Completely off topic, but I used to fantisize about cars and motorcycles, now all I can think of are tri-bikes (bike porn as I like to call it). Its a sad time when a 21 year old man would rather go bike riding then test drive cars

Been there, done that ..... albeit at a later age.  My problem was I was a shop service manager/salesmen so I would just order anything new and cool that came out at the trade shows as long as it shaved a few grams off of my bike.

Then I REALLY got into cars and was doing double duty buying fast car parts and lighter/faster bike parts.  Needless to say it took me about 5 years to dig myself out of the credit card debt .....

2007-09-19 11:33 AM
in reply to: #970078

User image

Master
2202
2000100100
St. Louis
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
Personally, Id rather have a better frame and wheels and cheaper components.
2007-09-19 11:51 AM
in reply to: #970078

Veteran
198
100252525
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
Time for the pot to call the kettle black. I'm still riding my first ever road bike (A Windsor Bristol - although I did buy wheels from an LBS) and I got it from bikesdirect because it was the cheapest bike I could find. I wasn't sure if I was going to like cycling when I bought it so I figured it was a good idea to go cheap. However, now that I know I love riding I won't be buying another bike from them. Why? Because they are the Walmart of bicycle sales. They have prices that the LBS can't possibly compete with. I don't know about you guys but I really like the LBS. I want them to stick around and the way that they stick around is by selling bikes.

So if you have any love at all for the local bike shop then why not support them when its time for a big upgrade? Sure it will cost more but when you buy a bike from an LBS you are paying for more than just a bike. Not only will you most likely be getting the perfect fit as well as tune-ups for life from them but you will be support local business and making it possible for others from your community to make a living doing what they love to do. If everyone out there starts buying online then you're not going to see local shops anymore. They can't make a living just off of inner tube sales. So come on, support the local shop and pay top dollar for that ride.

If you don't buy the karma argument then how about this: buying a tri bike from a tri shop that professionally fits you to the bike will increase your time far more than a DA group on a generic carbon frame. Its quite possible that you can get better performance from a crappier bike that fits you than a nice bike that doesn't.

*end of soapbox*
2007-09-19 12:15 PM
in reply to: #970817

User image

Master
2468
20001001001001002525
Muskego, Wisconsin
Subject: RE: Easy bike question

stuartjeff - 2007-09-19 11:51 AM Time for the pot to call the kettle black. I'm still riding my first ever road bike (A Windsor Bristol - although I did buy wheels from an LBS) and I got it from bikesdirect because it was the cheapest bike I could find. I wasn't sure if I was going to like cycling when I bought it so I figured it was a good idea to go cheap. However, now that I know I love riding I won't be buying another bike from them. Why? Because they are the Walmart of bicycle sales. They have prices that the LBS can't possibly compete with. I don't know about you guys but I really like the LBS. I want them to stick around and the way that they stick around is by selling bikes. So if you have any love at all for the local bike shop then why not support them when its time for a big upgrade? Sure it will cost more but when you buy a bike from an LBS you are paying for more than just a bike. Not only will you most likely be getting the perfect fit as well as tune-ups for life from them but you will be support local business and making it possible for others from your community to make a living doing what they love to do. If everyone out there starts buying online then you're not going to see local shops anymore. They can't make a living just off of inner tube sales. So come on, support the local shop and pay top dollar for that ride. If you don't buy the karma argument then how about this: buying a tri bike from a tri shop that professionally fits you to the bike will increase your time far more than a DA group on a generic carbon frame. Its quite possible that you can get better performance from a crappier bike that fits you than a nice bike that doesn't. *end of soapbox*

 

So what is the difference between the LBS thats sells windsor/motobecane/etc compared to the higher end bikes?  Don't they need love too?  Since I just got into this sport why should I risk paying "top dollar" before I know if i'm here to stay.  Maybe in a year or so you'll find my Motobecane in the classifieds as I try to upgrade to some sweet expensive bike, but for now my cool bike with great components that fits great is enough.  As for the other LBS around the Jacksonville/Orange Park area the best stocked shop with the friendliest people have marked up there prices so high it made me sick.  $25 for an aero bottle and $28 for the bracket?  Profile design single water bottle cage $17.  When a shop around the corner sold them for a small percent over cost.  I love the LBS but screw them if their going to screw me.  Not all LBS are equal no matter how nice they look. 



2007-09-19 12:18 PM
in reply to: #970225

User image

Master
2468
20001001001001002525
Muskego, Wisconsin
Subject: RE: Easy bike question
tjh - 2007-09-18 10:14 PM
papson14 - 2007-09-18 7:44 PM

I have the Motobecane Ultegra set up that I bought from a LBS that buys their stuff from  bikesdirect.com.  Awesome bike, awesome set up.   

Which one have you got, if I might ask?  I've been eyeballing the Sprint, with Ultegra triple and carbon stays.  And, how are the stock wheels?

I ride the Motobecane Nemesis Ultegra set up.  As someone mentioned later the DA setup was probably the better way to go but $100+ shoes, $100+ bottles, cages, tubes, pump....$100+ tri shorts, shirt,......and the entry fees.....I could use the few hundred bones I saved on the ultegra parts to get me even further into the sport.

2007-09-19 12:25 PM
in reply to: #970817

User image

Master
1472
10001001001001002525
Subject: RE: Easy bike question

stuartjeff - 2007-09-19 9:51 AM Time for the pot to call the kettle black. I'm still riding my first ever road bike (A Windsor Bristol - although I did buy wheels from an LBS) and I got it from bikesdirect because it was the cheapest bike I could find. I wasn't sure if I was going to like cycling when I bought it so I figured it was a good idea to go cheap. However, now that I know I love riding I won't be buying another bike from them. Why? Because they are the Walmart of bicycle sales. They have prices that the LBS can't possibly compete with. I don't know about you guys but I really like the LBS. I want them to stick around and the way that they stick around is by selling bikes. So if you have any love at all for the local bike shop then why not support them when its time for a big upgrade? Sure it will cost more but when you buy a bike from an LBS you are paying for more than just a bike. Not only will you most likely be getting the perfect fit as well as tune-ups for life from them but you will be support local business and making it possible for others from your community to make a living doing what they love to do. If everyone out there starts buying online then you're not going to see local shops anymore. They can't make a living just off of inner tube sales. So come on, support the local shop and pay top dollar for that ride. If you don't buy the karma argument then how about this: buying a tri bike from a tri shop that professionally fits you to the bike will increase your time far more than a DA group on a generic carbon frame. Its quite possible that you can get better performance from a crappier bike that fits you than a nice bike that doesn't. *end of soapbox*

Well, sure. I would agree, to a degree...

When I was looking for my first bike I had a pretty strict budget. I was tempted to buy from LBS for many of the reasons stated but when it boiled down to it I could not find it in me to spend my hard earned money on LESS bike. It did not make sense.

I personally did not have the money to spend on "principle".

That said, my next purchase could well come from LBS, but I will not settle for less bike or pay more for an equivelant bike just out of priciple. I have a family and look to get the most out of my hard earned dollar.

New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Easy bike question Rss Feed