Gatorskin trouble.... Not drunk this time

So I installed my new gatorskins the other night while drinking old style. Yesterday I took it off and put it back on because I have a flat spot. I thought it wasnt seating right so I took it off again and it is still seating too deep on one side. Causing a very uncomfortable bump every time the tire rotates to that spot. So now I am playing with my tire again (w/old style) and am just lost. I am going to mark the tire where it isnt seating right and am going to take it off and inspect it. Does anybody know if biketiresdirect takes back tires that are bad? Thanks guys. And just because it is old style doesnt mean that I am cheap. I find it very soothing and economic. Haha