Guest cannot access my log

My coach would like to be able to view my log without logging into BT, but I can't seem to create a link to it that works.  Every time I try, the link re-directs you to a log-in page that says you have to be logged in to view the log.  But I made the log public, and I checked the option in my control panel to allow guests to view all my public logs. 

Am I doing something wrong?  My husband has the same setup on his log, and our coach can access it with no problems.