General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Road bike on a budget Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2009-07-11 10:05 PM

Member
163
1002525
Houston
Subject: Road bike on a budget
So i'm curently looking for a road bike.  I have a few friends that have some nice bikes but I'm not as into it as they are and I'm not sure if I'll be as into it as they are until I do my first tri.  I do however think that I will enjoy and continue to cycle in the future.

So all my friends have "name brand" bikes (Specialized and Cannondale).  They however have Sora/Tiagra components. or 105 Rear and Tiagra front.  After 1 year they are all "wanting" to upgrade to at least 105 all-around.

My question is for my budget should I got with a not so name brand bike (Scattante, Motobecane) with higher end 105 components or a "name" bike with lower components.

Which one would most people put a priority on?


2009-07-12 12:25 AM
in reply to: #2278735

User image

On your right
Subject: RE: Road bike on a budget
I'm putting my priority on the bike in my price range that I just like more for whatever reason.  Sorry I have no real help.
2009-07-12 12:30 AM
in reply to: #2278735

User image

Member
32
25
Seattle, WA
Subject: RE: Road bike on a budget
depending on what the frame is comprised of will determine how good the frame is and how flexible and how it will adapt, where as better components can make quite the difference.  so i would say that the "name brand" frame is not going to matter nearly as much as the "better" components....i would go with the not so "name brand" bike, better bang for your bike


...unless you're into it for show in which case who can beat a good 'ol fashion name brand
2009-07-12 5:32 AM
in reply to: #2278735

User image

Veteran
130
10025
Subject: RE: Road bike on a budget
I'm in the same boat, so a friend suggested I check out Canyon bikes. It's a German brand. You get them directly from the factory, so you save a lot of $$$. I'm between this one with ultegra components for 1099 euros and that one for 849 euros with 105 components.

Another option is to buy a cheap used one, see if you like cycling and get a new one in a year.

Good luck
2009-07-12 5:46 AM
in reply to: #2278735

User image

Extreme Veteran
357
1001001002525
Ft. Myers, Florida
Subject: RE: Road bike on a budget
Put your money into the components.  The most important thing about the frame is to make sure it fits you.

Edited by jkholden 2009-07-12 5:47 AM
2009-07-12 6:54 AM
in reply to: #2278735

New user
476
100100100100252525
Subject: RE: Road bike on a budget
Why not get the basic Giant Defy 3.  It's a nice bike with decent component for around $700.00  Each  year buy a new component for it.  In a couple years you'll have a real nice bike.

You can sell you old parts on eBay to recoup a couple bucks.


2009-07-12 7:42 AM
in reply to: #2278735


2

Subject: RE: Road bike on a budget
I just bought a Motobecane Nemesis for $859 new. It was on Ebay. She has some left if you are interested. The components are Dura Ace and Ultegra.
  • FRAME: Motobecane Z-Matrix6 Aero A-6 Quaternary phase Aluminum alloy, custom butted and Aero shaped, Integrated Head Tube, Double water bottle mounts shaped seat stays Motobecane forged dropout with replaceable derailleur hanger

  • FORK: MOTOBECANE FC-770 Bonded Aero Carbon w/ 1 1/8

  • DERAILLEURS RR/FR: FRONT: Shimano ULTEGRA 6600, Braze-on REAR: Shimano ULTEGRA 6600

  • SHIFTERS: Shimano DuraAce, SL-BS78 20-speed

  • BRAKES: Tektro RX40 w/Cartridge Pads

  • HUBS: Formula Xero XR-1 OR Ritchey ProDS Sealed Cartridge Bearing

  • RIMS: Formula Xero XR-1 OR Ritchey ProDS, Black w/ CNC sidewalls

  • CRANK: TruVativ Rouleur GXP w/ Integrated Spindle, 7075 CNC 39/53T Chainring

  • CASSETTE: Shimano ULTEGRA, 10-speed, 12-23T

  • CHAIN: Shimano Ultegra 6600, 10-Speed

  • SADDLE: Motobecane Velo UltraLite Racing with Cro-Mo rails

  • SEATPOST: Ritchey PRO Aluminum, 27.2

  • STEM: Ritchey PRO Aluminum

  • HANDLEBARS: RITCHEY PRO Cow Bar with RITCHEY PRO Clip-on Aero bars

  • PEDALS: NONE

  • TIRES: Continental ULTRASport, 700x23c with Ultralite presta tubes

  • COLORS: BLACK

  • SIZES: 49cm, 52cm, 54cm, 56cm, 58cm, 61cm



  • Edited by masonh 2009-07-12 7:44 AM
    2009-07-12 7:54 AM
    in reply to: #2278735

    User image

    Member
    42
    25
    Subject: RE: Road bike on a budget
    I bought a new Cannondale Synapse 5 and added some nice aero bars to it. I didn't want a TT bike b/c my knees are questionable and I may switch to just road bike riding. I love this bike and it has decent components, fits me really well. I got it home and the next day there was a used one exactly like mine on craigslist for $500 less than I paid. Oh well.
    2009-07-13 8:09 AM
    in reply to: #2278735

    User image

    Master
    1222
    1000100100
    Lafayette, IN
    Subject: RE: Road bike on a budget

    Not sure how much you want to spend, but I would try to get a bike with at least 105 components.  Tiagra and Sora are really for recreational riders and the shifting is different than the higher group sets.

    As far as the frame goes, I would suggest doing a lot of research before you purchase a "no-name" frame.  Anyone can build a frame, stick a slick paint job on it and sell it for less.  The frame should be your first priority.  It is the foundation of your bike and if it's bad, then nothing else will be good.  If you are going carbon, there are a myriad of carbon layups, construction processes, and types of carbon fiber.  Make sure the frame comes from a reputable maker.

    There are a lot of bikes out there with Ultegra group sets, good frames, and decent wheels for realtively low prices that you could ride for years without needing to spend any additional money.  If you spend a little more now, you won't have any added costs to upgrade later.

    2009-07-13 11:02 AM
    in reply to: #2278735

    User image

    Member
    53
    2525
    Nor Cal - Bay Area
    Subject: RE: Road bike on a budget
    Price of bike is not the only consideration. The after sales service from you dealer will also make a difference in the longer run.

    All the "name" bike manufacturers have good entry lever models, that will not be much more than the internet specials, that will have no warranty, or after sales service. Most good bike shops offer free adjustments/tune ups for some period of time which is certainly worth something.

    I recommend finding a good local bike shop, buy a "name brand" bike (Trek, Specialized, Bianchi, etc...) with decent components. This can be had for less than $1,000.00 if you watch for sales. With the economy like it is most bike shops are reducing their prices to stimulate sales.

    You will never regret buying decent quality. You will be much happier long term if you spend a bit more today.

    Good luck,

    John
    2009-07-13 11:33 AM
    in reply to: #2278735

    User image

    Champion
    7558
    500020005002525
    Albuquerque, New Mexico
    Subject: RE: Road bike on a budget

    No matter how much you spend on the bike/components, there is always a newer/sleeker/shinier/lighter/(better) option to upgrade.  People with Sora/Tiagra pine for 105's.  People with Ultegra dream about justifying the Dura-Ace components.  Even guys with D/A want the latest iteration. 

    What is your temperment?  Are you inclined to "need" the latest-highest stuff?  If not, even Sora is serviceable and can give you years and years of service.  As for upgrading by parts, check Shimano's website as not everything is readily swapable.  Sora is often 8 speed (sometimes 9) and often has the option for a triple chainring (24 gears) which may give novice cyclists a little better range of gears for climbing hills.  As you move up to 105 and beyond, they are typically 20-speed (2x10).  Gearing on the floor bikes with 105/Ultegra/D-A caters to avid cyclists who ride enough to push a bigger gear up the hills. 

    If you "need" the latest and greatest, just buy something and plan to replace it next year like your friends.  Unless you're competent to do everything yourself, you can't usually justify paying someone to swap components from one frame to another.  Yes, it gets expensive and you rarely get what you think the old bike is worth, but that's the cost of playing in this space. 



    New Thread
    General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Road bike on a budget Rss Feed