Other Resources My Cup of Joe » Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, the bear, DerekL, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 17
 
 
2013-04-04 2:33 PM
in reply to: #4687001

User image

Member
5452
50001001001001002525
NC
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
trishie - 2013-04-04 3:18 PM

Yes, IF she was offended and the touch was unwanted then it's a second deg assault/ 4th deg so.

If not, then it's not a crime.

So it is impossible to tell from the picture, even making a reasonable assumption that it was was unwanted.

 

 



2013-04-04 2:36 PM
in reply to: #4687023

User image

Master
1460
10001001001001002525
Burlington, Vermont
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

2013-04-04 2:42 PM
in reply to: #4687036

User image

Extreme Veteran
3025
2000100025
Maryland
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 2:36 PM

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

ok but it works both ways. so you filter the responses and reactions of people. take me for instance, i'm a 23 year old man, recently in college where that is extremely commonplace. that is my bias. trianna has been attacked before, that is her bias. and i never said "maybe she likes it" or whatever words you want to put in my mouth.  HOWEVER the question "is it really a big deal?" seems to me to be a reasonable one. and I don't think it is a big deal, at all. He did something stupid, and apologized.

2013-04-04 2:52 PM
in reply to: #4687032

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
Goosedog - 2013-04-04 2:33 PM
trishie - 2013-04-04 3:18 PM

Yes, IF she was offended and the touch was unwanted then it's a second deg assault/ 4th deg so.

If not, then it's not a crime.

So it is impossible to tell from the picture, even making a reasonable assumption that it was was unwanted.

 

 

You do realize that you may have just called in an airstrike on your own position by "those who will be offended", right?

2013-04-04 2:55 PM
in reply to: #4687050

User image

Champion
18680
50005000500020001000500100252525
Lost in the Luminiferous Aether
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:42 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 2:36 PM

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

ok but it works both ways. so you filter the responses and reactions of people. take me for instance, i'm a 23 year old man, recently in college where that is extremely commonplace. that is my bias. trianna has been attacked before, that is her bias. and i never said "maybe she likes it" or whatever words you want to put in my mouth.  HOWEVER the question "is it really a big deal?" seems to me to be a reasonable one. and I don't think it is a big deal, at all. He did something stupid, and apologized.

The problem is this statement right there.  Why is that acceptable to you?

2013-04-04 2:56 PM
in reply to: #4687068

User image

Member
5452
50001001001001002525
NC
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
Left Brain - 2013-04-04 3:52 PM

You do realize that you may have just called in an airstrike on your own position by "those who will be offended", right?

Hey, I'm just trying to figure out if I'm a lurch for calling the pinch inappropriate and shameful, but not definitely criminal.  

 

 



2013-04-04 2:57 PM
in reply to: #4687068

User image

Champion
18680
50005000500020001000500100252525
Lost in the Luminiferous Aether
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
Left Brain - 2013-04-04 3:52 PM
Goosedog - 2013-04-04 2:33 PM
trishie - 2013-04-04 3:18 PM

Yes, IF she was offended and the touch was unwanted then it's a second deg assault/ 4th deg so.

If not, then it's not a crime.

So it is impossible to tell from the picture, even making a reasonable assumption that it was was unwanted.

 

 

You do realize that you may have just called in an airstrike on your own position by "those who will be offended", right?

Yes but they are still targeting most of their drones on you so he is still pretty safe.

2013-04-04 2:59 PM
in reply to: #4687070

User image

Extreme Veteran
3025
2000100025
Maryland
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
trinnas - 2013-04-04 2:55 PM
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:42 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 2:36 PM

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

ok but it works both ways. so you filter the responses and reactions of people. take me for instance, i'm a 23 year old man, recently in college where that is extremely commonplace. that is my bias. trianna has been attacked before, that is her bias. and i never said "maybe she likes it" or whatever words you want to put in my mouth.  HOWEVER the question "is it really a big deal?" seems to me to be a reasonable one. and I don't think it is a big deal, at all. He did something stupid, and apologized.

The problem is this statement right there.  Why is that acceptable to you?

because it happens all the time. guys grab girls butts, girls grab guys butts. why is it so evil? what makes this so horrendously unacceptable? now obviously the situation etc. clearly does have significant bearing on whether or not a behavior is acceptable. but what i am getting from this thread is that grabbing someone's but should get you arrested and thrown in jail, and i find that ridiculous.

2013-04-04 3:00 PM
in reply to: #4687077

User image

Extreme Veteran
3025
2000100025
Maryland
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
trinnas - 2013-04-04 2:57 PM
Left Brain - 2013-04-04 3:52 PM
Goosedog - 2013-04-04 2:33 PM
trishie - 2013-04-04 3:18 PM

Yes, IF she was offended and the touch was unwanted then it's a second deg assault/ 4th deg so.

If not, then it's not a crime.

So it is impossible to tell from the picture, even making a reasonable assumption that it was was unwanted.

 

 

You do realize that you may have just called in an airstrike on your own position by "those who will be offended", right?

Yes but they are still targeting most of their drones on you so he is still pretty safe.

i've already been flamed by the drones at least 5 times, you kinda get used to it!

2013-04-04 3:01 PM
in reply to: #4687050

User image

Master
1460
10001001001001002525
Burlington, Vermont
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:42 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 2:36 PM

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

ok but it works both ways. so you filter the responses and reactions of people. take me for instance, i'm a 23 year old man, recently in college where that is extremely commonplace. that is my bias. trianna has been attacked before, that is her bias. and i never said "maybe she likes it" or whatever words you want to put in my mouth.  HOWEVER the question "is it really a big deal?" seems to me to be a reasonable one. and I don't think it is a big deal, at all. He did something stupid, and apologized.

I happen to have a lot of experience working with this population of men who are shocked when they realize that it truly is a big deal.

Regardless of how common place it is, when it gets (appropriately) defined as assault (or, eventually, rape), your small deal is going to intersect the reality of how conduct codes and the law define it.

In this case you're biased by seeing the behavior at any house party you attend on a Thursday, Friday, Saturday night. The judge in the Steubenville case, in his comments, made a statement to the effect of "this (rape) is happening across the country every night". The "this" is clueless men not calling what they see what it is. When that happens, our collective bias of minimizing the matter results in tragic consequences for both the accused and the victim/survivor. 

2013-04-04 3:02 PM
in reply to: #4687081

User image

Member
5452
50001001001001002525
NC
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:59 PM . .  but what i am getting from this thread is that grabbing someone's but should get you arrested and thrown in jail, and i find that ridiculous.

Nah, we cleared that up.  It could get you arrested.



2013-04-04 3:04 PM
in reply to: #4684426

User image

Master
1460
10001001001001002525
Burlington, Vermont
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
And I'm more than willing to discuss why we don't call it an assault on men when they get grabbed. That's just not the topic of the OP's picture. Just because it happens in reverse doesn't make it okay from either direction. Either will, eventually, be called what it is ... assault.
2013-04-04 3:04 PM
in reply to: #4687085

User image

Extreme Veteran
3025
2000100025
Maryland
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 3:01 PM
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:42 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 2:36 PM

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

ok but it works both ways. so you filter the responses and reactions of people. take me for instance, i'm a 23 year old man, recently in college where that is extremely commonplace. that is my bias. trianna has been attacked before, that is her bias. and i never said "maybe she likes it" or whatever words you want to put in my mouth.  HOWEVER the question "is it really a big deal?" seems to me to be a reasonable one. and I don't think it is a big deal, at all. He did something stupid, and apologized.

I happen to have a lot of experience working with this population of men who are shocked when they realize that it truly is a big deal.

Regardless of how common place it is, when it gets (appropriately) defined as assault (or, eventually, rape), your small deal is going to intersect the reality of how conduct codes and the law define it.

In this case you're biased by seeing the behavior at any house party you attend on a Thursday, Friday, Saturday night. The judge in the Steubenville case, in his comments, made a statement to the effect of "this (rape) is happening across the country every night". The "this" is clueless men not calling what they see what it is. When that happens, our collective bias of minimizing the matter results in tragic consequences for both the accused and the victim/survivor. 

grabbing a butt is not equivalent to rape, and girls do it too my friend. over the top rhetoric doesnt equal correctness either.

2013-04-04 3:05 PM
in reply to: #4687081

User image

Champion
18680
50005000500020001000500100252525
Lost in the Luminiferous Aether
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:59 PM
trinnas - 2013-04-04 2:55 PM
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:42 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 2:36 PM

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

ok but it works both ways. so you filter the responses and reactions of people. take me for instance, i'm a 23 year old man, recently in college where that is extremely commonplace. that is my bias. trianna has been attacked before, that is her bias. and i never said "maybe she likes it" or whatever words you want to put in my mouth.  HOWEVER the question "is it really a big deal?" seems to me to be a reasonable one. and I don't think it is a big deal, at all. He did something stupid, and apologized.

The problem is this statement right there.  Why is that acceptable to you?

because it happens all the time. guys grab girls butts, girls grab guys butts. why is it so evil? what makes this so horrendously unacceptable? now obviously the situation etc. clearly does have significant bearing on whether or not a behavior is acceptable. but what i am getting from this thread is that grabbing someone's but should get you arrested and thrown in jail, and i find that ridiculous.

Arrested and thrown in jail no, you will be fired from your job if you do it at work though. 

So you find it acceptable fro a stranger to walk up to you and grab your butt?

2013-04-04 3:06 PM
in reply to: #4687082

User image

Champion
18680
50005000500020001000500100252525
Lost in the Luminiferous Aether
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 4:00 PM
trinnas - 2013-04-04 2:57 PM
Left Brain - 2013-04-04 3:52 PM
Goosedog - 2013-04-04 2:33 PM
trishie - 2013-04-04 3:18 PM

Yes, IF she was offended and the touch was unwanted then it's a second deg assault/ 4th deg so.

If not, then it's not a crime.

So it is impossible to tell from the picture, even making a reasonable assumption that it was was unwanted.

 

 

You do realize that you may have just called in an airstrike on your own position by "those who will be offended", right?

Yes but they are still targeting most of their drones on you so he is still pretty safe.

i've already been flamed by the drones at least 5 times, you kinda get used to it!

Pffft only 5.... Amature!!!

 

2013-04-04 3:07 PM
in reply to: #4687092

User image

Extreme Veteran
3025
2000100025
Maryland
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
trinnas - 2013-04-04 3:05 PM
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:59 PM
trinnas - 2013-04-04 2:55 PM
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:42 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 2:36 PM

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

ok but it works both ways. so you filter the responses and reactions of people. take me for instance, i'm a 23 year old man, recently in college where that is extremely commonplace. that is my bias. trianna has been attacked before, that is her bias. and i never said "maybe she likes it" or whatever words you want to put in my mouth.  HOWEVER the question "is it really a big deal?" seems to me to be a reasonable one. and I don't think it is a big deal, at all. He did something stupid, and apologized.

The problem is this statement right there.  Why is that acceptable to you?

because it happens all the time. guys grab girls butts, girls grab guys butts. why is it so evil? what makes this so horrendously unacceptable? now obviously the situation etc. clearly does have significant bearing on whether or not a behavior is acceptable. but what i am getting from this thread is that grabbing someone's but should get you arrested and thrown in jail, and i find that ridiculous.

Arrested and thrown in jail no, you will be fired from your job if you do it at work though. 

So you find it acceptable fro a stranger to walk up to you and grab your butt?

No I don't, I would probably be pretty annoyed if I were the girl Sagan grabbed. However about 5 minutes later i would never think of it again and be over it. I don't think it is right, I just don't think its a freaking international incident! (although it probably technically is!)



2013-04-04 3:11 PM
in reply to: #4687090

User image

Master
1460
10001001001001002525
Burlington, Vermont
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 4:04 PM 

grabbing a butt is not equivalent to rape, and girls do it too my friend. over the top rhetoric doesnt equal correctness either.



I didn't equate the two. I placed them on the same continuum of behavior.

And you need to understand that I'm not spouting rhetoric. I'm explaining how assault is legally defined. This isn't opinion. I hear far too many of these cases every year and they begin because men confuse that.

I guess you don't NEED to understand it. 

2013-04-04 3:11 PM
in reply to: #4687085

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 3:01 PM
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:42 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 2:36 PM

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

ok but it works both ways. so you filter the responses and reactions of people. take me for instance, i'm a 23 year old man, recently in college where that is extremely commonplace. that is my bias. trianna has been attacked before, that is her bias. and i never said "maybe she likes it" or whatever words you want to put in my mouth.  HOWEVER the question "is it really a big deal?" seems to me to be a reasonable one. and I don't think it is a big deal, at all. He did something stupid, and apologized.

I happen to have a lot of experience working with this population of men who are shocked when they realize that it truly is a big deal.

Regardless of how common place it is, when it gets (appropriately) defined as assault (or, eventually, rape), your small deal is going to intersect the reality of how conduct codes and the law define it.

In this case you're biased by seeing the behavior at any house party you attend on a Thursday, Friday, Saturday night. The judge in the Steubenville case, in his comments, made a statement to the effect of "this (rape) is happening across the country every night". The "this" is clueless men not calling what they see what it is. When that happens, our collective bias of minimizing the matter results in tragic consequences for both the accused and the victim/survivor. 

Bernard.....here's a secret.  That's BULLCHIT!  I don't believe for a single minute that they don't know it's wrong.  And to say they are shocked is crazy.  They may want you to believe they were shocked, that may be what the defense attorney tells them to say, but that is an absolute load of crap most of the time.  The high school football players who recently "didn't know it was rape".....for crying out loud, who believes that?  Certainly, a jury didn't, and good for them.

My crew actually investigates rapes and sexual offenses, among other Part 1 crimes. I hear the same load of garbage that you are saying you hear.....but unlike you, I don't believe a word of it.

Sagan knows he was out of line, that's why he apologized...which may be all that is warranted in this case unless the girl wants more. 

Still, you cannot paint with the brush you want to paint with......you'll lose the part of the audience that is already on your side.  Look what you did with this Sagan case......and you don't know anything about it.

2013-04-04 3:12 PM
in reply to: #4687090

User image

Champion
18680
50005000500020001000500100252525
Lost in the Luminiferous Aether
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 4:04 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 3:01 PM
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:42 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 2:36 PM

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

ok but it works both ways. so you filter the responses and reactions of people. take me for instance, i'm a 23 year old man, recently in college where that is extremely commonplace. that is my bias. trianna has been attacked before, that is her bias. and i never said "maybe she likes it" or whatever words you want to put in my mouth.  HOWEVER the question "is it really a big deal?" seems to me to be a reasonable one. and I don't think it is a big deal, at all. He did something stupid, and apologized.

I happen to have a lot of experience working with this population of men who are shocked when they realize that it truly is a big deal.

Regardless of how common place it is, when it gets (appropriately) defined as assault (or, eventually, rape), your small deal is going to intersect the reality of how conduct codes and the law define it.

In this case you're biased by seeing the behavior at any house party you attend on a Thursday, Friday, Saturday night. The judge in the Steubenville case, in his comments, made a statement to the effect of "this (rape) is happening across the country every night". The "this" is clueless men not calling what they see what it is. When that happens, our collective bias of minimizing the matter results in tragic consequences for both the accused and the victim/survivor. 

grabbing a butt is not equivalent to rape, and girls do it too my friend. over the top rhetoric doesnt equal correctness either.

I do not know anyone here who has said it is equivalent to rape.  I believe he was referencing another case where the lack of a clear boundaries helped lead to escalating issues.

2013-04-04 3:16 PM
in reply to: #4687103

User image

Extreme Veteran
3025
2000100025
Maryland
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
trinnas - 2013-04-04 3:12 PM
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 4:04 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 3:01 PM
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:42 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 2:36 PM

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

ok but it works both ways. so you filter the responses and reactions of people. take me for instance, i'm a 23 year old man, recently in college where that is extremely commonplace. that is my bias. trianna has been attacked before, that is her bias. and i never said "maybe she likes it" or whatever words you want to put in my mouth.  HOWEVER the question "is it really a big deal?" seems to me to be a reasonable one. and I don't think it is a big deal, at all. He did something stupid, and apologized.

I happen to have a lot of experience working with this population of men who are shocked when they realize that it truly is a big deal.

Regardless of how common place it is, when it gets (appropriately) defined as assault (or, eventually, rape), your small deal is going to intersect the reality of how conduct codes and the law define it.

In this case you're biased by seeing the behavior at any house party you attend on a Thursday, Friday, Saturday night. The judge in the Steubenville case, in his comments, made a statement to the effect of "this (rape) is happening across the country every night". The "this" is clueless men not calling what they see what it is. When that happens, our collective bias of minimizing the matter results in tragic consequences for both the accused and the victim/survivor. 

grabbing a butt is not equivalent to rape, and girls do it too my friend. over the top rhetoric doesnt equal correctness either.

I do not know anyone here who has said it is equivalent to rape.  I believe he was referencing another case where the lack of a clear boundaries helped lead to escalating issues.

My apologies, I think I read the bolded sentence wrong the first time.

2013-04-04 3:16 PM
in reply to: #4687102

User image

Master
1460
10001001001001002525
Burlington, Vermont
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
Left Brain - 2013-04-04 4:11 PM

Bernard.....here's a secret.  That's BULLCHIT!  I don't believe for a single minute that they don't know it's wrong.  And to say they are shocked is crazy.  They may want you to believe they were shocked, that may be what the defense attorney tells them to say, but that is an absolute load of crap most of the time.  The high school football players who recently "didn't know it was rape".....for crying out loud, who believes that?  Certainly, a jury didn't, and good for them.

My crew actually investigates rapes and sexual offenses, among other Part 1 crimes. I hear the same load of garbage that you are saying you hear.....but unlike you, I don't believe a word of it.

Sagan knows he was out of line, that's why he apologized...which may be all that is warranted in this case unless the girl wants more. 

Still, you cannot paint with the brush you want to paint with......you'll lose the part of the audience that is already on your side.  Look what you did with this Sagan case......and you don't know anything about it.



If you were to ask a group of men on any campus how often they think rape occurs there, they would underestimate the numbers by a significant amount. Mostly because they don't realize how assault (and, ultimately, rape) are defined. They don't realize what constitutes a lack of consent.

True ... many men falsely claim ignorance. But far too many have never had it explained to them. We have men participating in this very discussion who have clearly never had it explained. They're accustomed to seeing behavior associated with the "hook up" culture as normal and acceptable. They truly can't fathom that it constitutes assault or, on the other end of the continuum, rape. 


2013-04-04 3:22 PM
in reply to: #4687107

User image

Extreme Veteran
3025
2000100025
Maryland
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 3:16 PM
Left Brain - 2013-04-04 4:11 PM

Bernard.....here's a secret.  That's BULLCHIT!  I don't believe for a single minute that they don't know it's wrong.  And to say they are shocked is crazy.  They may want you to believe they were shocked, that may be what the defense attorney tells them to say, but that is an absolute load of crap most of the time.  The high school football players who recently "didn't know it was rape".....for crying out loud, who believes that?  Certainly, a jury didn't, and good for them.

My crew actually investigates rapes and sexual offenses, among other Part 1 crimes. I hear the same load of garbage that you are saying you hear.....but unlike you, I don't believe a word of it.

Sagan knows he was out of line, that's why he apologized...which may be all that is warranted in this case unless the girl wants more. 

Still, you cannot paint with the brush you want to paint with......you'll lose the part of the audience that is already on your side.  Look what you did with this Sagan case......and you don't know anything about it.



If you were to ask a group of men on any campus how often they think rape occurs there, they would underestimate the numbers by a significant amount. Mostly because they don't realize how assault (and, ultimately, rape) are defined. They don't realize what constitutes a lack of consent.

True ... many men falsely claim ignorance. But far too many have never had it explained to them. We have men participating in this very discussion who have clearly never had it explained. They're accustomed to seeing behavior associated with the "hook up" culture as normal and acceptable. They truly can't fathom that it constitutes assault or, on the other end of the continuum, rape. 

There is a disconnect between the relationship of underestimating that number and not understand what rape is.

2013-04-04 3:24 PM
in reply to: #4687114

User image

Master
1460
10001001001001002525
Burlington, Vermont
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 4:22 PM

There is a disconnect between the relationship of underestimating that number and not understand what rape is.



We agree.

And if you think that rape isn't happening because you don't know how it's defined, you're not going to interrupt rape-supportive behavior that could get your bros in a lot of trouble. 
2013-04-04 3:25 PM
in reply to: #4687096

User image

Champion
18680
50005000500020001000500100252525
Lost in the Luminiferous Aether
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 4:07 PM
trinnas - 2013-04-04 3:05 PM
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:59 PM
trinnas - 2013-04-04 2:55 PM
dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:42 PM
BernardDogs - 2013-04-04 2:36 PM

dmiller5 - 2013-04-04 3:28 PM Precisely trinnas! But knowing and understand those bias' (biases?) is essential when dissecting an issue like this. Men have a bias as to not want to be blamed, women have a bias as to not want to be attacked. It is all important.

 

See. Now this I can work with. I wouldn't call it a bias, but I would call it a self interest. We don't want to be blamed. We want to be taken as who we are ... not lumped into the group that we become when we don't challenge the behavior, exhibited by the least of our peers, that reinforces the generalizations that we're all pigs (scum, heathens, clueless, etc.).

Then, when we jump to the collective "it's not that big of a deal", "it's just a pinch", "maybe she likes it", we affiliate ourselves with the bro club that creates those generalizations in the first place. 

ok but it works both ways. so you filter the responses and reactions of people. take me for instance, i'm a 23 year old man, recently in college where that is extremely commonplace. that is my bias. trianna has been attacked before, that is her bias. and i never said "maybe she likes it" or whatever words you want to put in my mouth.  HOWEVER the question "is it really a big deal?" seems to me to be a reasonable one. and I don't think it is a big deal, at all. He did something stupid, and apologized.

The problem is this statement right there.  Why is that acceptable to you?

because it happens all the time. guys grab girls butts, girls grab guys butts. why is it so evil? what makes this so horrendously unacceptable? now obviously the situation etc. clearly does have significant bearing on whether or not a behavior is acceptable. but what i am getting from this thread is that grabbing someone's but should get you arrested and thrown in jail, and i find that ridiculous.

Arrested and thrown in jail no, you will be fired from your job if you do it at work though. 

So you find it acceptable fro a stranger to walk up to you and grab your butt?

No I don't, I would probably be pretty annoyed if I were the girl Sagan grabbed. However about 5 minutes later i would never think of it again and be over it. I don't think it is right, I just don't think its a freaking international incident! (although it probably technically is!)

and when it happens to you again and again and again and again because to the "group" that is doing it, it is just not that a big deal and you should just get over it?

 

2013-04-04 3:26 PM
in reply to: #4687117

User image

Extreme Veteran
3025
2000100025
Maryland
Subject: RE: Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch

and when it happens to you again and again and again and again because to the "group" that is doing it, it is just not that a big deal and you should just get over it?

 

where is this coming from? this is not the issue we are discussing.

New Thread
Other Resources My Cup of Joe » Peter Sagan....it was just a pinch Rss Feed  
 
 
of 17