General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Cramping in the pool Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2008-10-31 9:45 PM

User image

Veteran
406
100100100100
Subject: Cramping in the pool
First of all, thanks to everyone who responded to my Anxiety Over Masters thread. I did it. I joined and had my first swim with them Wed night. It was amazing. They got me to swim more in one night than I'd probably done in the previous month combined.

Only thing is...

I started getting some pretty strong cramps in my right calf after about 1000 yards freestyle. Did some breaststroke kicks for a few minutes then managed to keep going another 250 freestyle. Then the cramps came back.

Not sure what caused it. Before that swim my longest one had been 400. So that could have been part of it. That morning, I ran 9 miles, so that coud have been part of it. Or it could be the Zoomers. I had to use them to try to keep up with the others in my lane. We were doing circle swim and I didn't want to cause a pile up. I've never kept zoomers on for more than a few lenghts but we did continous laps. (Well, I did pause at the wall but you know what I mean) So maybe that was it. Or maybe it was something completely different.

So I have a few questions. How do I avoid cramping in the future? Is that even possible or is it part of the process? And what do you do when you get a cramp? Do you keep swimming? Tread water for a while? Or come to a dead stop, which is what I did.



Edited by WhenAllElseFails 2008-10-31 9:48 PM


2008-10-31 9:54 PM
in reply to: #1779572

Expert
810
500100100100
Southeast
Subject: RE: Cramping in the pool

Causes:  probably all of the above.

Cure:  Short term:  When it starts to happen (try to catch it early and you'll recover much faster) pause, work it out, stretch if that helps, then cautiously continue.  Long term:  keep swimming.

Same thing happened to me, and still does when I try something more intense than before (especially more intense kicking, especially with any kind of fins on, and especially after a harder run or bike workout).  The more I swim, the less it happens.

 

2008-10-31 10:24 PM
in reply to: #1779572

User image

Member
42
25
Medford, NJ
Subject: RE: Cramping in the pool
It may be dehydration. For me, hydration the day before and morning of a swim is more important than with biking or running. If it's a night group, watch your water during the day and see if the problem subsides.

Since you're in the water, you don't get the sensation of being dehydrated, just the effects
2008-10-31 11:46 PM
in reply to: #1779572

User image

Regular
102
100
Glendale
Subject: RE: Cramping in the pool

It is dehydration.  I had cramping once when I was swimming with my masters team and my coach said that it was due to that.

 p.s. I agree completely with RNH re feeling effects!



Edited by chowbisou 2008-10-31 11:48 PM
2008-11-01 6:19 AM
in reply to: #1779572

User image

Veteran
406
100100100100
Subject: RE: Cramping in the pool
Makes sense. I am horrible about hydrating. Horrible. I live off coffee which only makes it worse. But I think the cramps just helped me find my motivation.

Thanks!

Edited by WhenAllElseFails 2008-11-01 6:20 AM
2008-11-01 7:34 AM
in reply to: #1779572

Extreme Veteran
1030
100025
West Windsor, NJ
Subject: RE: Cramping in the pool
It also could be fatigue. I found that I just cannot do a long run and then swim (much anyway). I never cramp in the pool unless I do that brick combination. It used to bother me and I tried a bunch of things to fix it...and then I got tired of getting massive/painful cramps, so I just said "screw it" and I dont do this combination any more.


2008-11-01 7:57 AM
in reply to: #1779572

User image

Champion
9407
500020002000100100100100
Montague Gold Mines, Nova Scotia
Subject: RE: Cramping in the pool

It is not likely due to hydration; although hydration is most often blamed for cramping, it is often not the cause.

More than likely, you over swam your condition, especially when it comes to kicking with fins.  When ramping up their swimming, many athletes will suffer cramps of the legs/feet because they are pushing harder then their fitness would allow.

The cure is to keep swimming, I would watch how hard you push off the wall and limit your time in fins if possible.

Shane

2008-11-01 8:15 AM
in reply to: #1779572

Expert
810
500100100100
Southeast
Subject: RE: Cramping in the pool

I hope that hydration helps.  I doubt it will.  But if you are chronically dehydrated, then, of course, you should drink (water!).

The link between hydration and cramping is at best complex, and at worst a perpetuated myth.  There are plenty of studies to support various views, from 'no link at all' (e.g., this one ) to 'may delay onset but does not prevent and is not the sole cause' (e.g., this one ).  A common theme amongst studies (such as this one ) is that the two biggest risk factors are previous history (sorry), and fatigue.  You can't do anything about your previous history, but you can do something about fatigue -- train yourself to get fatigued less and later.

If you look at studies or claims of a strong link between hydration and cramping, you'll often find that behind them there is (a) nothing, or (b) a sports drink company.  (I have nothing against sports drinks.  I use them.)

Many people can feel a cramp coming on, and prevent it from happening by pausing and stretching, and perhaps changing the workout in some helpful way (stop the kicking drills and do some pulling for a while would be an obvious example). This is absolutely better than letting it happen, not only because you don't have to suffer from the cramp, but because a severe cramp can leave you with soreness for the next couple of days, and this can effect training.  So it is worthwhile learning what it feels like just before the cramp really hits.

New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Cramping in the pool Rss Feed