General Discussion Triathlon Talk » ITB Issues - Should I train through it. Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 2
 
 
2008-08-14 10:12 AM

User image

Expert
934
50010010010010025
FL
Subject: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.

I am guessing that I am going to get alot of different answers but am going to ask anyway.

My ITB issue started 2 Mondays ago after about 4 miles of my 7 mile run.  I ran through the mild pain but as it got worse, at about 6 miles, I had to walk.  It was at least somewhat painfull the rest of the day.

The pain I am feeling is in my left knee on the outside. 

I went and saw a sports massage therapist on Thursday and he put me though some major pain.  He did a general lower extemity massage to get an idea of where I was overall.  I have alot of tighness everywhere.  I know I have not been stretching enough.  He confirmed the ITB issue and my hamstring issue on the other leg that has been causing pain behind my right knee when riding.

I tried running on Sat but at about 20 minutes, the pain started again but a 2 out of 10 pain level at that point.  I walked home.

I went back for a 2nd session including some ART on the IT Bands on Monday.  He also did some serious stretching of my glutes. 

The ITB does not bother me while riding.

I tried to run last night.  Again at about 20mins, mild pain in my knee started.  I walked home.  I iced my IT and did a bunch of stretching.

I have been doing more stretching than ever before the last few months but I am doing even more now. 

 I had a 8 mile run planned for Monday and a total 19 miles planned for this week.  Last week was supposed to be 17 miles.  Obviously, I have blown the training plan.  I have been building up for a Sprint on Aug 30th. 

So the question:  What should I do?  Should I run until the pain is to the point of not being able to continue.  Should I run until I feel the pain and then stop.  I don't want to stop all together as I don't want to drop off of the level I have got to.'

I am using a foam roller in my stretching sessions and that is extremely painful. 

Any comments are appreciated.  Sorry it got so long.



2008-08-14 10:20 AM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Pro
4608
20002000500100
Brooklyn, NY
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.

I similarly ran through ITB pain 2 years ago and ended up with acute ITBS to the point of not being able to walk down stairs, let alone run. I didn't know what the pain was in the early stages, otherwise I would have stopped. ITB issues can be tricky and it seems that rest is the best way to fully get past it. I ended up taking 6 weeks off of running entirely, but was able to bike during this time and was in PT twice weekly. After the 6 weeks, I did a 3 mile run, then a 5 mile run, then a half-mary (note: I was right in the middle of marathon training when the injury occurred, otherwise would never have increased distance that way).

I recommend not running for awhile if your schedule will allow it. What worked for me was a program of strength training on the hip adductors/abductors as most runners are weak here leading to ITB issues. I did the ITB stretches several times/day and always before and after any workouts. I iced a few times a day and used massage as well. I did the marathon that year, took a month break after, and went on to run the entire winter trouble-free.

Good luck getting past this. 

2008-08-14 10:24 AM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Pro
3906
20001000500100100100100
Libertyville, IL
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
whenever i have severe knee issues, its elliptical duty for 1.5-2 weeks for me vs running.  it only takes a few runs to get the mojo back, but the alternative here of running yourself into the ground and finding out before the race shouldnt be an option.  heal up so you can stay in the game.
2008-08-14 10:43 AM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Expert
606
500100
Lakeville, MN
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
Have you gone to a sports doctor or orthopedic? One of the contributors to ITB issues is improper running form. This could be gait, bad/improper shoes/inserts, hip issues, or any number of a bajillion other things in your from that cause imbalance. I read all these stories about people that suffer ITB issues for years, and really end up masking the problem w/ rollers, ibuprofen, etc w/out addressing the real culprit. Yeah, correcting the real issue can take a long time, but I'd hate for you to take a month off, feel better, start running again, hurt ITB again, get mad again, repeat...
2008-08-14 10:54 AM
in reply to: #1603267

User image

Expert
934
50010010010010025
FL
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.

cooutdoors - 2008-08-14 11:43 AM Have you gone to a sports doctor or orthopedic? One of the contributors to ITB issues is improper running form. This could be gait, bad/improper shoes/inserts, hip issues, or any number of a bajillion other things in your from that cause imbalance. I read all these stories about people that suffer ITB issues for years, and really end up masking the problem w/ rollers, ibuprofen, etc w/out addressing the real culprit. Yeah, correcting the real issue can take a long time, but I'd hate for you to take a month off, feel better, start running again, hurt ITB again, get mad again, repeat...

Not a doctor.  A sports therapist yes.  He is not just any massage therapist but has worked for the Yankees for many years.  Not that the Yankees is any big deal but I think he has a long track record of dealing with sports related issues....

Good point on the cause.  The cause could be shoes.  I was at the limit on my shoes and actually had my new shoes on hand but was lazy and had not switch over my yankz laces yet and decided to use my shoes that were bout 6 months old.  I have read that shoes that are worn can cause the issue. 

I agree, I don't want to take weeks off and then it crop right back up.  I did that with my foot pain and it did not help at all until I found the cause which was not what I thought. 

2008-08-14 11:13 AM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Member
16

Kingsport
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.

Being a competitive runner for more than 15 years, I have run into this issue on more than one occassion, and it always comes at the most inopportune time. Everyone has brought up good points here. The shoes may be part of the problem. If you over pronate during your stride it can set off a chain reaction through your lower extremity. If this is the case, when your ankle rolls inward it forces you to bear more weight on the lateral side of the knee. This does not allow proper mechanics for the knee and can lead to inflammation. This is why it happens later on in the run. Orthotics will help this

 You may also have weakness in your hips. When running, if you have a weakness you automatically recruit additional muscles to help with the problem. This also leads to bad mechanics and can stress the joint. Strengthening your hip adductors and your piriformis muscles will help you balance out and control your motion much better.

 I rarely see that the problem is actually the IT band, but these other things that I have mentioned.

Next time you run and it flares up, when you get home , take your thumb and press firmly all around the knee joint on the outside to determine the exact location of pain (this may take a little bit). Once found, mark it with a pen. then when you go to the sports physician he can determine if it is the IT band or not. Also have him test your strength.



2008-08-14 11:41 AM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Champion
5345
500010010010025
Carlsbad, California
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.

Back when I had some issues with ITBS, I was told (By Runners that I trusted) that this is the sort of running injury not to try and train through. Rest and whatever else you (or the profressionals are advising you to do) deem necessary but allow it to heal before heading back out on the road.

For me anyway, my ITB issues were caused by poor running form. I would get tired and start turning my knee in as my hips tightened up and this would quickly irritate my ITB where it crosses over the bumpy part of my knee. The trick for me was to stop running when my running form fell apart and not wait for the pain to tell me to stop.

It has been quite a while now since my last bout of ITB and my running form no longer breaks down when I get tired like it once did.

I hope you find a simple and easy solution to your problem before it becomes a bigger issue for you. Good Luck

2008-08-14 11:48 AM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Expert
934
50010010010010025
FL
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.

Do you think a gate analysis by a foot store could be helpful or are these just marketing gimicks?

There is a local store that does "video-taped gait analysis", but not the same store I bought my shoes from. 

When I purchased my shoes, the guys at the store (a locally owned running shoe store), did a quick look and determined that I overpronate.  With my weight at the time (about 220) and my overpronation, they recommended Brooks Beast.  I am now on my 3rd pair of the Beast and am at about 198lbs. 

 

2008-08-14 12:11 PM
in reply to: #1603545

User image

Champion
5345
500010010010025
Carlsbad, California
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
trimore - 2008-08-14 9:48 AM

Do you think a gate analysis by a foot store could be helpful or are these just marketing gimicks?

I was fitted for my running shoes a the LRS who did watch me run and have been quite happy with the results. I am an under-pronator so I guess it was pretty much a no brainer for them anyway.

I have also had a gait analysis done where they video taped me at the track at the beginning and again at the end of a workout and I found this to be very informative and interesting. (They did observe changes in my form as I got tired)

I personally think it was worth it but I know others may argue otherwise.



Edited by WaterDog66 2008-08-14 12:12 PM
2008-08-14 12:20 PM
in reply to: #1603133


25
25
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
No.
2008-08-14 12:21 PM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Master
1790
1000500100100252525
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
The Beast might be too much shoe for you. I know the women's version was for me. Also have you tried over-the-counter orthotics? Powersteps are decent, as are BFOs (those I got from my podiatrist but I have seen online). Both are only around $30.


2008-08-14 12:48 PM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Master
1662
10005001002525
Flagstaff and Phoenix, AZ
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.

I have no experience with ITB issues but you mention that your muscles are tight, that you are in pain when using a foam roller, and that you have hamstring issues. Others have said you should try to strengthen the hip abductors...

You can work on all these issues doing yoga! In addition to getting a stride analysis and working on your running form that would be a good way to make use of the down time you'll need for the ITB injury.

2008-08-14 12:58 PM
in reply to: #1603748

User image

Expert
934
50010010010010025
FL
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
SauseEnte - 2008-08-14 1:48 PM

I have no experience with ITB issues but you mention that your muscles are tight, that you are in pain when using a foam roller, and that you have hamstring issues. Others have said you should try to strengthen the hip abductors...

You can work on all these issues doing yoga! In addition to getting a stride analysis and working on your running form that would be a good way to make use of the down time you'll need for the ITB injury.

Thanks.  I have started some exersizes for the hip abductors. 

2008-08-14 1:22 PM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Expert
828
50010010010025
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
train through it, yes....but not with running. I had IT issues and tried what you did. Run till it twinged then quit. Well, it twinged at 3 miles for a month. A very very good runner friend I work with who has been running for 40 years said "stretch and limit training to walking". I did that for 3 weeks and have had no problems since. My advice (with limited experience personally)....stop running and let it calm down.
2008-08-14 3:11 PM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Champion
10471
500050001001001001002525
Dallas, TX
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
Well, I tried to train through mine last year... and the pain got so bad when I ran I coudn't run at all. I would say it was a 10 out of 10 on the pain scale.

That was about a month out from my first HIM. It grounded me from running the month before my HIM. In fact, it just hurt to walk. It's because I kept training when the pain started.

Everyone else had great advice on how to work on it... I'll just add that training through it will only make it worse to the point where you won't be able to walk or run. Take care of it before it gets to that point.
2008-08-14 6:15 PM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Veteran
142
10025
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
How did you feel after you HIM, having not run for a month?


2008-08-14 7:28 PM
in reply to: #1604723

Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
pain in my knee tag for later reading
2008-08-14 11:49 PM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Extreme Veteran
664
5001002525
Vancouver BC
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.

oh no - not you too!

I am dealing with this too - my suggestion is to NOT run....I was trying to run every few days when mine started up about 5 weeks ago or so....initially I could run about 15 mins or so....things progressed to my last run (just over a week ago) to only being able to go 8 minutes!

Initially the pain would stop when I would stop running....lately the pain doesn't go away and lingers (quite badly) for several days....stairs hurt....walking hurt....

I am going to chiro, physio, and taking a break from running (least until next week) to give my body a chance to 'improve' with the ART, and stretching/strengthening excercises I have been doing.

My advice is to give your body a chance to heal first...I was too impatient because I wanted to do two races on July 27 and AUgust 10....and I kept testing my knees to see if progress was being made hoping I would still be able to race....not only was progress not made but it got worse!

hope you heal soon though Matt - I know how badly this sucks!

2008-08-15 12:29 AM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Expert
938
50010010010010025
Orange County, California
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
Had ITBS 4 times. Running through it just makes it worse and takes longer to recover from.

Use that foam roller, it is your best way of resolving the pain.

If it hurts at the little bump on the outside of your knee, it is probably ITBS.

Like another poster said, ITBS is what happens when other muscles fail. My problem was a weak gluteus medius muscle.

Side leg lifts strenghten that muscle, so in the future it doesnt come back.

Google Walt's stretch for a stretch that may help.

If you need to race, a Patt strap works. It reduces the pain enough so that you can race, but does not solve the problem. Other similar straps didnt work for me. No I don't work for them.

2008-08-15 6:52 AM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Elite
2423
2000100100100100
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
I would also stop. I was stopped in May, I am back at full speed now. What helped me the most was stretching, and realizing that the roads I was running on was giving me my problems. You want to run on flat roads, hills are fine but downhill can agitate your ITB. When I say flat I mean level, you do not want to run on roads where the ends dip down, with one leg running lower than the other you will have problems over time. This was where my pain came from.
2008-08-15 7:06 AM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Extreme Veteran
474
1001001001002525
Sydney
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
Sat here now still with a little niggle in my knee. Lessons learnt from this, only my second running injury ever...

- don't run through it. Biking's fine (though see below comment on bike fit)

- something has caused it apart from too much training. Too much control from shoes is probably not it. More likely is that the Beast is not enough on its own. It wasn't for me and I am 20lbs lighter than you. I finished up with very aggressive orthotics and a lighter shoe which kept me going

- it might be bike fit, or bike shoes. Get it checked (probably not just by your LBS if they also sell bikes with streamers...).

- go and see a Podiatrist. Running stores can tell you a lot, especially good ones. But if you saw my orthotics they could never be replaced by an over the counter model (though at $500 every 12months I wish they could!)

- when the physio tells you to do certain exercises and stretches DO THEM. The exercises I am doing to get me over this (strengthen glutes, stretch calves, stretch hip flexors) are things that a physio told me to do 12months ago... but I got over my last injury without needing to do much of them and stopped quickly. Irritating that I could have avoided the injury and avoided missing an "A" race for me.


2008-08-15 8:16 AM
in reply to: #1603133

User image

Expert
934
50010010010010025
FL
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.

Thanks everyone.  I will stop.  At least until 8/30 at my next tri and maybe a few short bricks to prepare for that.  On that day, I guess it will be alot of advil and one of those bands to help with the pain. 

I have done alot of research and there are several things that are a common thread:

1. The issue is likely not the ITB but rather the buttocks or lack there of.  Strengthen the buttocks and do other strengthing exersizes related to the ITB

2. Shoes may be an issue.  Either worn out or the wrong kind.   This could be part of my issue.  My shoes were worn out but I also should have my gait checked and make sure the Brooks Beast are still right for me.  I have lost about 40lbs since I started using those.  I have read many stories of people switching to a nuetral shoe and relieaving the isssue.

3.  At least a few weeks of rest is mandatory and a regimen of Advil & ice to help get the inflamation down.

4.  Be consistent in stretching every part of the legs.  I am not good enough at this, have been getting better but this will likely make me get better.  Also, use a foam roller or TB products to help work out tightness.  Use a tennis ball on the buttocks to work out any knots.

5.  See a ART therapist.  I have seen one twice.  He did ART the last time.  He confirmed the ITB issue.  I have read that most people that used this to help required 4-6 treatments.

That is what I can think of for now. 

2008-08-15 8:29 AM
in reply to: #1603133


10

Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.

Your last post is reassuring trimore. Sounds like a plan!

As an ex marathoner with more running years under my shoes than I care to admit, I would suggest you should never train through ITB issues - I have trained through many injuries of various sorts over the (many) years - some more successfully than others - but with ITB issues, they just don't go away until you STOP running, allow time for the irritated tissue to heal and meanwhile figure out and correct what caused the problem in the first place.

Mine were usually lack of stretching, lack of glute strength, worn shoes - oh and a real bad flare up after running a race on a heavily cambered road - the itb on the downhill side didn't like it!

Good Luck

Triassic



Edited by triassic 2008-08-15 8:30 AM
2008-08-15 9:00 AM
in reply to: #1603133

Expert
638
50010025
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.
What are you training for? With your mileage, sounds like an HIM?

It is funny that you bring up the 20-minute mark as the point where it kicks in. A year ago, when I had my ITB issue, I could pretty much set my watch to 20 mins and that is when I'd feel it.

I do Sprints so I was able to alter my training plan. I did about a week and a half of no running, then began doing intense, 20-minute workouts. In my case, it isn't the intensity of the workout that causes the ITB to flare up, but rather the duration. So, it was a good month for track workouts and the like.

The other trick I found... If I stopped running the moment I felt my ITB, switched to the bike, biked for 20 mins, and then went back on running, I could manage through the entire workout with little pain. Basically a Brick on the fly. It was probably just allowing certain ligaments and bands to loosen up before I continued running. Much easier to do at a health club where the bikes are 20 feet away...

My run times suffered last season because of it, but the good news is that with proper stretching and taking a couple months off last winter, I've been able to manage it pretty well. My run times are back up this season.
2008-08-15 9:24 AM
in reply to: #1605658

User image

Expert
934
50010010010010025
FL
Subject: RE: ITB Issues - Should I train through it.

Hazelmn - 2008-08-15 10:00 AM What are you training for? With your mileage, sounds like an HIM? It is funny that you bring up the 20-minute mark as the point where it kicks in. A year ago, when I had my ITB issue, I could pretty much set my watch to 20 mins and that is when I'd feel it. I do Sprints so I was able to alter my training plan. I did about a week and a half of no running, then began doing intense, 20-minute workouts. In my case, it isn't the intensity of the workout that causes the ITB to flare up, but rather the duration. So, it was a good month for track workouts and the like.

I am just training for a sprint now but have a Olympic in view for later this year if possible or at beginning of season next year. 

Both times, I have run, it was right about 20 minutes.  I have heard others say that they could do some track workouts without pain.  I am just concerned that the issue is still there but the imflamation does not get to be enough until about the 20 minute mark.  I am definately going to stop until doing maybe a 10 min brick a few times before my tri on the 30th. 

Fortunately, I don't think biking is causing it any pain. 

New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » ITB Issues - Should I train through it. Rss Feed  
 
 
of 2