General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2013-03-27 6:42 AM

User image

Extreme Veteran
759
5001001002525
Villanova
Subject: Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad

Hey TR users, or anyone that has a lot of experience in training with HR and Power. 

Here is a ride I did the other day on TR: http://www.trainerroad.com/cycling/rides/270533

If you go down to the tabs with time spent in specific zones based on Power and on HR you can see that I'm spending more time in higher zones based on the HR metric than the power metric.  IE the two aren't in "sync".  Is this normal/should I be worried about this and how it will effect training?  Thoughts?

Thanks!



2013-03-27 7:37 AM
in reply to: #4676100

User image

Expert
2192
2000100252525
Greenville, SC
Subject: RE: Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad

not sure, might have something do to with your aerobic base.  i'm actually the complete opposite on my trainer road workouts.  below is a typical trainer workout for me

 

 HEART RATEPOWER
ZoneTimePercentTimePercent
Active Recovery0:00:130.30%0:19:0525.50%
Endurance0:19:2625.90%0:02:333.40%
Tempo0:20:2327.20%0:03:294.60%
Sweet Spot0:13:4718.40%0:07:209.80%
Threshold0:21:0828.20%0:18:0724.20%
VO2 Max0:00:000.00%0:21:0228.10%
Anaerobic Capacity0:00:000.00%0:03:214.50%

 

2013-03-27 7:39 AM
in reply to: #4676100

User image

Extreme Veteran
933
50010010010010025
Connecticut
Subject: RE: Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad

Lots to read to answer your questions in here:

http://support.trainerroad.com/entries/20655098-Power-vs-VirtualPower-vs-Heart-Rate-Which-one-is-right-for-me-

2013-03-27 7:44 AM
in reply to: #4676100

User image

Expert
4924
20002000500100100100100
Middle River, Maryland
Silver member
Subject: RE: Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad

How was your LTHR measured?  The 20 minute test?

Also remember that HR is a lagging indicator and you will pretty much always experience cardiac drift on a trainer, so I'm not surprised your HR may be a little more in a higher zone than your wattage.  And TR is only a fair estimate of power anyway.

And the "sweet spot" definition is only two beats wide in TR...which I find a little weird.

I've been trying to do more Z2 riding lately, and that Guyat workout creeps me up into low Z4 during the final interval (so I won't use it for a Z2 ride).

2013-03-27 7:58 AM
in reply to: #4676100

Veteran
645
50010025
Tennessee
Subject: RE: Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad
I may be wrong but I thought you are suppose to train either by power or heart rate. Not both. Sure pay attention to both but when doing you work outs you either train by power or train by heart rate.
2013-03-27 8:33 AM
in reply to: #4676100


1660
10005001002525
Subject: RE: Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad

Use power.

The problem with HR is that the fitter you get, the LOWER your HR goes for a particular power level. It becomes very pronounced when you significantly improve. I just got a powermeter, and if you looked at my HR despite increasing power, it looks like I'm getting worse or slacking off, whereas my TSS & FTP have both gone up progressively.

Don't worry about being in 'higher' HR zones based on the virtualpower training - if you're working off your power test results, you're exactly where you need to be, even if the HR seems high.

 



2013-03-27 9:49 AM
in reply to: #4676100

User image

Extreme Veteran
5722
5000500100100
Subject: RE: Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad
japewang - 2013-03-27 6:42 AM

Hey TR users, or anyone that has a lot of experience in training with HR and Power. 

Here is a ride I did the other day on TR: http://www.trainerroad.com/cycling/rides/270533

If you go down to the tabs with time spent in specific zones based on Power and on HR you can see that I'm spending more time in higher zones based on the HR metric than the power metric.  IE the two aren't in "sync".  Is this normal/should I be worried about this and how it will effect training?  Thoughts?

Thanks!

I suspect your HR zones are too low or your FTP setting is too high. It's not normal that you ended up above your threshold HR zones 4 minutes into a threshold interval.

How you determined each set may give a hint of which one may be better.

And there is nothing wrong with looking at HR and power. Choose which one will guide you, but be aware of the other and use it as a backup.

How hard was that workout for you ?

2013-03-27 11:17 AM
in reply to: #4676100

User image

Veteran
487
100100100100252525
Nova Scotia, Canada
Subject: RE: Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad
japewang - 2013-03-27 8:42 AM

Hey TR users, or anyone that has a lot of experience in training with HR and Power. 

Here is a ride I did the other day on TR: http://www.trainerroad.com/cycling/rides/270533

If you go down to the tabs with time spent in specific zones based on Power and on HR you can see that I'm spending more time in higher zones based on the HR metric than the power metric.  IE the two aren't in "sync".  Is this normal/should I be worried about this and how it will effect training?  Thoughts?

Thanks!

Im the same way.  Here is my ride from this morning. http://www.trainerroad.com/cycling/rides/272531   Im guessing my HR zones are lower because I only did the 8 minute test.  I have another test on Monday(my third) and plan to use the 20 minute test.  My In my first two tests my LTHR stayed the same wile my FTP went from 217 to 247.  I expect the LTHR will change with this next test.

2013-03-27 11:20 AM
in reply to: #4676571

User image

Extreme Veteran
759
5001001002525
Villanova
Subject: RE: Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad
Thanks for the insight all.  I did the 20 min test on TR to set both the FTP and the LTHR.  While training on the TR I use power not both, but just was intrigued by the numbers when looking back on past rides.
2013-03-27 12:31 PM
in reply to: #4676576

User image

Veteran
284
100100252525
Subject: RE: Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad
I've done the 20 minute test a couple of times. (With great improvement, BTW, following Jorge's 8 week plan).

Both times Trainerroad pegged my LTHR at lower than what I knew it to be based on other tests.

So I just manually adjusted it in my profile.

JC
New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Power vs. HR on TrainerRoad Rss Feed