General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Cramping Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2009-08-18 2:03 PM

User image

Expert
2555
20005002525
Colorado Springs, Colorado
Subject: Cramping
A friend did a HIM a couple weeks ago. He did fairly well in the swim and bike, then a couple miles into the run he started cramping in his calves. It was so bad he ended up walking a good portion, taking what could have been a 5:00 race and turning it into a 6:00 race. He is guessing his nutrition/hydration on the bike was insufficient. This is based on that assumption.

Is there anything he could have done to alleviate the cramping problem once it started? More fluids, more electrolytes, some kind of stretching, a combination of these things, something else, or nothing at all?

Obviously it would be better to do things to avoid the problem in the first place, but what, if anything, can be done to alleviate the problem after it occurs?


2009-08-18 2:07 PM
in reply to: #2356230

User image

Not a Coach
11473
5000500010001001001001002525
Media, PA
Subject: RE: Cramping
Can try slowing down and stretching the offending muscles.

Your friend was likely going too hard for his fitness.  Not insufficient nutrition/hydration.
2009-08-18 2:36 PM
in reply to: #2356230

User image

Expert
2555
20005002525
Colorado Springs, Colorado
Subject: RE: Cramping
That's a possibility. He had done a 46 minute 10K in an oly a month before with no problems. The bike course was tougher and the weather was hotter for the oly as well. He did try stretching and running slower but neither seemed to help and he struggled in with a 2:30 run.
2009-08-18 2:43 PM
in reply to: #2356345

User image

Not a Coach
11473
5000500010001001001001002525
Media, PA
Subject: RE: Cramping
Donskiman - 2009-08-18 3:36 PM That's a possibility. He had done a 46 minute 10K in an oly a month before with no problems. The bike course was tougher and the weather was hotter for the oly as well. He did try stretching and running slower but neither seemed to help and he struggled in with a 2:30 run.


Once the damage is done, there's only so much you can do.

And no offense to you or your friend, but an oly is not a HIM.  It was almost surely a fitness/pacing issue.
2009-08-18 3:17 PM
in reply to: #2356230

User image

Extreme Veteran
565
5002525
Jenison , MI
Subject: RE: Cramping
On all my races where I cramped up (marathons and long runs) it's because I pushed the pace to hard.

He burned himself out on the bike and paid the price on the run. That's how this game is played when you go hard.
2009-08-18 3:40 PM
in reply to: #2356230

User image

Extreme Veteran
391
100100100252525
Olive Branch, MS
Subject: RE: Cramping
Donskiman - 2009-08-18 2:03 PM

A friend did a HIM a couple weeks ago. He did fairly well in the swim and bike, then a couple miles into the run he started cramping in his calves. It was so bad he ended up walking a good portion, taking what could have been a 5:00 race and turning it into a 6:00 race. He is guessing his nutrition/hydration on the bike was insufficient. This is based on that assumption.

Is there anything he could have done to alleviate the cramping problem once it started? More fluids, more electrolytes, some kind of stretching, a combination of these things, something else, or nothing at all?

Obviously it would be better to do things to avoid the problem in the first place, but what, if anything, can be done to alleviate the problem after it occurs?


Same thing happened to me. The guys in the medical tent, said once the fluids are gone from your tissues, iv is the only way to get them back. I was into hour 7 in my him in the 90 degree Florida heat and not even sweating.

edited:going too hard and fast can cause fatique, but not cramps like I suffered. It was clearly a nutrition/hydration issue.

Edited by stateu 2009-08-18 3:41 PM


2009-08-18 4:55 PM
in reply to: #2356230

New user
1

Subject: RE: Cramping
I would like to give some thoughts on this and please respond. This is a huge issue with me right now.

I believe that cramping is not as simple as some of the replies are implying. He may or may not have been just going too hard, beyond his fitness level, and he may or may not have been dehydrated.

I am extremely prone to cramping. Not in every race, but sometimes. I can cramp in pure running races but also in triathlons.

Two days ago I did a HIM, and I cramped in the SWIM, really bad. In both legs (quads and calves) but horribly so in my left calf. In fact I had to wave down a boat and relax on it for about 3 minutes before I could start again, then swim with dead legs to keep them from cramping more. I was alright during the bike but during the whole run I was on the verge of cramping, and totally siezed up about 50 yards from the finish (trying to push it too hard to finish under 6 hrs, which I did with a time of 5:59:19).

Regarding causes, there seems to be a few factors.

1. Genetics. I'm convinced I'm just prone to tight muscles and cramping. Not only can my legs cramp but so do my arms, back, shoulders, neck and even face muscles. Only the leg cramps cause severe issues though.

2. Hydration/electrolytes. At this point, after 10 triathlons and many running races (including ultras) I'm convinced I'm getting in enough water and electrolytes.

3. Muscle tightness/flexibility/stretching. Recently we're reading more and more that stretching is useless, if not harmful. The Kenyans don't stretch, we hear. Others still do plenty of it though.

For me, it's Factors #1 and #3. I hate stretching. I rarely do it. Few things on earth bore me more than stretching does. All last week I was very tight in the legs. I stupidly ignored it and I paid the price. It's my own fault I cramped. The problem is that I really wanted to believe that just hydrating well and taking electrolytes would keep me from cramping. But I think that we must all pay attention to our OWN bodies. I need to bite the bullet and make myself loosen up, either by some conventional stretching or other strategies to keep loose. Or do some yoga. I don't think I have to be gymnast-flexible but it's ridiculous that I allow myself to be tight as a drum. I cannot touch my toes. There's no excuse in my case for losing so many valuable minutes just because I didn't take any time to become a little more flexible.

All the above is my current thinking. I'd appreciate any thoughtful replies/thoughts/suggestions. Thank you!
2009-08-18 5:02 PM
in reply to: #2356558

User image

Expert
2555
20005002525
Colorado Springs, Colorado
Subject: RE: Cramping
stateu - 2009-08-18 2:40 PM
Donskiman - 2009-08-18 2:03 PM A friend did a HIM a couple weeks ago. He did fairly well in the swim and bike, then a couple miles into the run he started cramping in his calves. It was so bad he ended up walking a good portion, taking what could have been a 5:00 race and turning it into a 6:00 race. He is guessing his nutrition/hydration on the bike was insufficient. This is based on that assumption.

Is there anything he could have done to alleviate the cramping problem once it started? More fluids, more electrolytes, some kind of stretching, a combination of these things, something else, or nothing at all?

Obviously it would be better to do things to avoid the problem in the first place, but what, if anything, can be done to alleviate the problem after it occurs?
Same thing happened to me. The guys in the medical tent, said once the fluids are gone from your tissues, iv is the only way to get them back. I was into hour 7 in my him in the 90 degree Florida heat and not even sweating. edited:going too hard and fast can cause fatique, but not cramps like I suffered. It was clearly a nutrition/hydration issue.


Thanks. That's what I wanted to know. Apparently there is nothing that can be done to alleviate the problem once it occurs, so it's crucial to do whatever is necessary to prevent it. Whether that means more training, easier racing paces, or whatever.
2009-08-18 6:12 PM
in reply to: #2356230

User image

Member
360
1001001002525
Denver, CO
Subject: RE: Cramping
I would venture to say that your friend found the solution to cramps by walking. I wouldn't think that it would have much to do with nutrition/hydration and more to do with the effort on the swim/bike portion.
2009-08-18 7:34 PM
in reply to: #2356230

User image

Extreme Veteran
417
100100100100
Davidson
Subject: RE: Cramping
I have had lots of cramping problems as well, in both races and training.  It CAN be caused by dehydration, but usually isn't.  Other than that, X2 to everything JohnnyKay said. 
Greg
2009-08-19 9:35 AM
in reply to: #2356726

User image

Extreme Veteran
391
100100100252525
Olive Branch, MS
Subject: RE: Cramping
Donskiman - 2009-08-18 5:02 PM

stateu - 2009-08-18 2:40 PM
Donskiman - 2009-08-18 2:03 PM A friend did a HIM a couple weeks ago. He did fairly well in the swim and bike, then a couple miles into the run he started cramping in his calves. It was so bad he ended up walking a good portion, taking what could have been a 5:00 race and turning it into a 6:00 race. He is guessing his nutrition/hydration on the bike was insufficient. This is based on that assumption.

Is there anything he could have done to alleviate the cramping problem once it started? More fluids, more electrolytes, some kind of stretching, a combination of these things, something else, or nothing at all?

Obviously it would be better to do things to avoid the problem in the first place, but what, if anything, can be done to alleviate the problem after it occurs?
Same thing happened to me. The guys in the medical tent, said once the fluids are gone from your tissues, iv is the only way to get them back. I was into hour 7 in my him in the 90 degree Florida heat and not even sweating. edited:going too hard and fast can cause fatique, but not cramps like I suffered. It was clearly a nutrition/hydration issue.


Thanks. That's what I wanted to know. Apparently there is nothing that can be done to alleviate the problem once it occurs, so it's crucial to do whatever is necessary to prevent it. Whether that means more training, easier racing paces, or whatever.


Precisely.


2009-08-19 2:54 PM
in reply to: #2356230

User image

Veteran
217
100100
Alexandria, VA
Subject: RE: Cramping
Last year, I got bad hammie cramps during the run in both Olys and the marathon (my first ever) that I did which was a total disappointment since I never got them training. This year after 2 Olys and a HIM, no cramps so far. I tried a few things:

* Did more sprint and hill workouts to build leg strength.

* Slowed down during the first mile of the run. Really stayed on myself to know what I was capable of doing based on training times. If I got out too fast, I slowed down to my realistic pace. If I had something left in the tank, I would use it in the last 1/2 mile. My overall time did not suffer.

* Did a basic sweat test. Weighed in before workouts and then weighed after adjusting for water intake. Realized I had been replacing less than half of what I was sweating. Started drinking more during races.

* Switched from Gatorade G2 to water plus tablets (Camelback I think) which have much more sodium

* Took electrolyte tabs during the HIM

So far so good. Of course, now I am destined to get a full body cramp at my next race.
2009-08-19 6:38 PM
in reply to: #2358626

User image

Master
1289
1000100100252525
Franklin, TN
Subject: RE: Cramping

Akrakowski - 2009-08-19 2:54 PM Last year, I got bad hammie cramps during the run in both Olys and the marathon (my first ever) that I did which was a total disappointment since I never got them training. This year after 2 Olys and a HIM, no cramps so far. I tried a few things: * Did more sprint and hill workouts to build leg strength. * Slowed down during the first mile of the run. Really stayed on myself to know what I was capable of doing based on training times. If I got out too fast, I slowed down to my realistic pace. If I had something left in the tank, I would use it in the last 1/2 mile. My overall time did not suffer. * Did a basic sweat test. Weighed in before workouts and then weighed after adjusting for water intake. Realized I had been replacing less than half of what I was sweating. Started drinking more during races. * Switched from Gatorade G2 to water plus tablets (Camelback I think) which have much more sodium * Took electrolyte tabs during the HIM So far so good. Of course, now I am destined to get a full body cramp at my next race.

X2 on the above and cramp severly. I sweat like a stuck pig and even gave up mtn bike racing due to leg cramps. I tried Infinit Nutrition, they dialed in my formula and suggested I drink more water on the bike portion. Infinit in my Aero Drink and water in my rear water bottle(s). My cramping issues are now gone.

New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Cramping Rss Feed