General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Question about race awards Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2008-10-07 2:01 PM

User image

Elite
2999
2000500100100100100252525
Hattiesburg, Mississippi
Subject: Question about race awards

Just looking for people's thoughts, past experiences and maybe race directors knowledge.

But one of the members of our TriGator team has won the overall (had the fastest time in the race) but was not recognized as the overall winner.  I will not mention the names of either race but the first was a sprint distance.  They said he could not win overall because he was in the age-group catergory and there was an elite division.  And only athletes registered in the elite division are eligible for the overall award.  Next was an Olympic distance race that is a Florida Colleigete Conference race.  Again he won overall (had the fastest time) but was not awarded the overall prize because he registered in the colleigete division.

Has anyone had a similiar experience or have knowledge of how awards are actually given.  USAT has no rules or regulations on how awards are handed out so I assume it is left up to the race director of that specific race.

Should not the Overall Award go to the individual with the fastest time in the race, regardless of age, gender or division they race?



2008-10-07 2:06 PM
in reply to: #1724576

User image

Cycling Guru
15134
50005000500010025
Fulton, MD
Subject: RE: Question about race awards

It is an RD based thing as to what most races will do.  The rules from USAT pertain to money and if the race has a purse of over $4,999.99 cash (total) then AGers are not eligible to win the money, only professionals (and not even elites ..... you need to hold a pro card if I remember correctly).

But I have not heard of someone not being declared the overall winner when they posted the fastest time.  That is strange.

2008-10-07 2:26 PM
in reply to: #1724576

User image

Coach
10487
50005000100100100100252525
Boston, MA
Subject: RE: Question about race awards
parrj - 2008-10-07 2:01 PM

Just looking for people's thoughts, past experiences and maybe race directors knowledge.

But one of the members of our TriGator team has won the overall (had the fastest time in the race) but was not recognized as the overall winner.  I will not mention the names of either race but the first was a sprint distance.  They said he could not win overall because he was in the age-group catergory and there was an elite division.  And only athletes registered in the elite division are eligible for the overall award.  Next was an Olympic distance race that is a Florida Colleigete Conference race.  Again he won overall (had the fastest time) but was not awarded the overall prize because he registered in the colleigete division.

Has anyone had a similiar experience or have knowledge of how awards are actually given.  USAT has no rules or regulations on how awards are handed out so I assume it is left up to the race director of that specific race.

Should not the Overall Award go to the individual with the fastest time in the race, regardless of age, gender or division they race?

As Rick said the USAT states a parameter for cash prices to protect those who have make the choice to race as an elite. I not only agree with the rule but I also know the race the pros/elites has is the majority of the cases is a very different race of which AGers have. Starting on the AG usually are not as policed as elites and they get benefits of drafting (legally or not) which grants a big advantage pros/elites don't get. 

If the member of trigator wants to be able to claim overall prices then he should race in the elite/pro wave.

2008-10-07 2:30 PM
in reply to: #1724576

User image

Elite
2999
2000500100100100100252525
Hattiesburg, Mississippi
Subject: RE: Question about race awards

I understand the cash purse over $5000 for the pro catergory.  In the sprint there was nothing given out prize wise, so it wasn't a big deal.  The elite who won actually gave him the placque for the overall award.  In the Olympic there was a $100 gift certificate to a running store.  The Olympic had no pro/elite catergory, just wouldn't give it to him because he raced as a colleigete.

But if you have the fastest overall time you should be recognized as the overall winner.



Edited by parrj 2008-10-07 2:32 PM
2008-10-07 3:17 PM
in reply to: #1724685

User image

Cycling Guru
15134
50005000500010025
Fulton, MD
Subject: RE: Question about race awards

NCAA rules prohibit prizes to maintain your collegiate status ...... maybe they were just trying to enforce that???  But then again, triathlon is usually a club sport as opposed to track and x-country which are scholarship sports.

Yeah, it still sounds bogus though.

2008-10-07 5:02 PM
in reply to: #1724873

User image

Elite
2999
2000500100100100100252525
Hattiesburg, Mississippi
Subject: RE: Question about race awards
Daremo - 2008-10-07 4:17 PM

NCAA rules prohibit prizes to maintain your collegiate status ...... maybe they were just trying to enforce that???  But then again, triathlon is usually a club sport as opposed to track and x-country which are scholarship sports.

Yeah, it still sounds bogus though.

No, we are just a club team so no NCAA oversite.  However we had a swimmer and a x-country girl here that did Tris and had to be careful about what they accepted if they won.



2008-10-07 9:52 PM
in reply to: #1724576

Expert
810
500100100100
Southeast
Subject: RE: Question about race awards
If the race conditions are materially different for pros/elites than for ams/collegiates, then no, he shouldn't be declared winner. If they are the same, then yes, he should be.  One can be declared winner without accepting a cash prize, if that's an issue.  I've seen it done in other sports.
2008-10-07 10:51 PM
in reply to: #1724576

User image

Member
53
2525
Melbourne, FL
Subject: RE: Question about race awards

- There are no NCAA violations here because triathlon is a club sport on the college level, and it does not fall under the umbrella of the NCAA or the rules regulated by that association.

- The prize pool was medals, plaques, and a few gift certificates to a local store.  So even if there were rules to be broken or USAT regulations to follow, no cash prizes were handed out for the pro level.

- I've been to a few races where they have "collegiate" waves included with the regular athletes.  Because they registered as something other than a normal AGer that should have given you the first red flag as to how awards may be handed out.

My two cents goes back to my original remark.  College triathlon clubs are pushing hard to become NCAA recognized and I think the USAT sees this.  Thus, in order to prevent future problems with prizes for OA winners being "college athletes" they have gone ahead and created a seperate registry for the college tri team members.  I know you all have some sort of "points" system with all of the college tri clubs, but in the future if your teammates are worried about prizes just decide whether or not they should sign up under the collegiate level or AG level.  Until the NCAA picks up Triathletes, they are free to register or even go pro in order to win prizes.

2008-10-08 6:43 AM
in reply to: #1724576

User image

Master
2946
200050010010010010025
Centennial, CO
Subject: RE: Question about race awards

for the college club team there may be some thought that the person competing in the collegiate wave may also have some team dynamics that could affect their time.  Wether that is in pacing, drafting etc. that would give them an unfair advantage over others that are there by themselves. 

I'm not saying that occured, but it is likely that the RD takes those things into account.

2008-10-08 8:50 AM
in reply to: #1724576

User image

Extreme Veteran
739
50010010025
Westlake, OH
Subject: RE: Question about race awards

Did the RD make this stuff up on the fly are did they spell out how the OA winners were to be determined? 

That would make a difference to me.  If the latter, its like complaining that the RD wouldn't give someone a refund even though no refunds are clearly stated in the race documents.

2008-10-08 11:43 AM
in reply to: #1724576

User image

Expert
938
50010010010010025
Subject: RE: Question about race awards
Do it like the US Open does golf.  Show up, play well enough, win, take Tiger's money.  I don't care if the winner is an AG'r, elite, collegian, pro, or Jesus come down from the heavens, the winner is the person with the least amount of legal (didn't cheat) combined time, period.  Just my opinion though.


2008-10-08 11:51 AM
in reply to: #1727186

User image

Coach
10487
50005000100100100100252525
Boston, MA
Subject: RE: Question about race awards
kagoscuba - 2008-10-08 11:43 AM Do it like the US Open does golf.  Show up, play well enough, win, take Tiger's money.  I don't care if the winner is an AG'r, elite, collegian, pro, or Jesus come down from the heavens, the winner is the person with the least amount of legal (didn't cheat) combined time, period.  Just my opinion though.
exactly, hence the race pros/elite have vs the race AGers is different and not equivilant to produce a fair result. If they would all start at the same time (same wave) then it would be a different story.
2008-10-08 11:52 AM
in reply to: #1727186

User image

Cycling Guru
15134
50005000500010025
Fulton, MD
Subject: RE: Question about race awards

kagoscuba - 2008-10-08 12:43 PM Do it like the US Open does golf.  Show up, play well enough, win, take Tiger's money.  I don't care if the winner is an AG'r, elite, collegian, pro, or Jesus come down from the heavens, the winner is the person with the least amount of legal (didn't cheat) combined time, period.  Just my opinion though.

Never happen ....... there is not a lot of money in the sport, and some of the "local" pros that just go to smaller races to make some money wouldn't participate as much since a lot of them would still get schooled by AG people and lose out on prize money.  That is part of the reasoning for the USAT rule.

2008-10-08 12:47 PM
in reply to: #1727186

User image

Extreme Veteran
391
100100100252525
Olive Branch, MS
Subject: RE: Question about race awards
kagoscuba - 2008-10-08 11:43 AM

Do it like the US Open does golf.  Show up, play well enough, win, take Tiger's money.  I don't care if the winner is an AG'r, elite, collegian, pro, or Jesus come down from the heavens, the winner is the person with the least amount of legal (didn't cheat) combined time, period.  Just my opinion though.


If an amateur beats Tiger, they don't get paid. Actually, no matter where they finish they don't get paid.

Edited by stateu 2008-10-08 12:48 PM
2008-10-08 1:03 PM
in reply to: #1727410

User image

Expert
938
50010010010010025
Subject: RE: Question about race awards

stateu - 2008-10-08 1:47 PM
kagoscuba - 2008-10-08 11:43 AM Do it like the US Open does golf.  Show up, play well enough, win, take Tiger's money.  I don't care if the winner is an AG'r, elite, collegian, pro, or Jesus come down from the heavens, the winner is the person with the least amount of legal (didn't cheat) combined time, period.  Just my opinion though.
If an amateur beats Tiger, they don't get paid. Actually, no matter where they finish they don't get paid.

I stand corrected.  I thought amateurs had the choice after the final round to declare themselves as a pro and collect the money.   That is not the case, after searching about it.  They still get to call themselves US Open Champion though, if they win it fair and square.

2008-10-08 1:06 PM
in reply to: #1727459

User image

Extreme Veteran
391
100100100252525
Olive Branch, MS
Subject: RE: Question about race awards
kagoscuba - 2008-10-08 1:03 PM

  They still get to call themselves US Open Champion though, if they win it fair and square.



True. And get a kick a** trophy.


2008-10-08 1:37 PM
in reply to: #1726582

User image

Elite
2999
2000500100100100100252525
Hattiesburg, Mississippi
Subject: RE: Question about race awards
ohiost90 - 2008-10-08 9:50 AM

Did the RD make this stuff up on the fly are did they spell out how the OA winners were to be determined? 

That would make a difference to me.  If the latter, its like complaining that the RD wouldn't give someone a refund even though no refunds are clearly stated in the race documents.

I think this is the biggest problem.  The RD did not and RD's usually do not spell out how awards are going to be handed out in advance.  And while the 2nd race did have a gift certificate, the 1st race had nothing of cash value and at neither race was he recognized as the overall winner. 

While the US Open is a great example, ametuars know in advance they cannot take home money, but are still recognized if they win.

2008-10-09 2:15 AM
in reply to: #1724576

User image

Master
2665
20005001002525
The Whites, New Hampshire
Subject: RE: Question about race awards
Have you considered asking - politely, of course - the race director about this? Finding out what he/she was thinking might help. We can guess until we're blue in the face, but only they know their motivation in decision-making. And it might just provide a correction.
New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Question about race awards Rss Feed