Other Resources My Cup of Joe » Can o' Worms Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, the bear, DerekL, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 2
 
 
2005-12-06 10:11 AM

Pro
4040
2000200025
Subject: Can o' Worms
Okay, I just have to say, I watched a documentary on John Kerry's Vietnam service and his subsequent anti-war activities. The one thing that is starkly apparent upon viewing this film is how terribly these guys the "Swiftboat Veterans for Truth" screwed a fellow soldier.

Whatever personal failings Kerry has, there can be no doubt that he put his life in grave danger and, according to his crew, saved their lives at least once. That people could have minimized this and put his record in doubt for political ends is beneath contempt.

Not saying that I have any other opinions on Americans politics, I'm just saying....


2005-12-06 10:20 AM
in reply to: #299947

User image

Elite
2421
2000100100100100
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
Admittedly having not seen it I can't really say one way or the other. Although I would be curious as to see who sponsored the film. What channel was it on?

And while I'm not saying that Kerry did, it's not at all uncommon for peoples actions to be played up for the benefit of a citation. This problem was especially rampant in Vietnam.

I'm sure both sides have valid points. Personally I ignored most of what SBVFT said during the campaign anyway. And same goes for what Kerry said about Bush. How can you possibly trust what a politician says about another politician?

bts
2005-12-06 10:26 AM
in reply to: #299947

User image

Buttercup
14334
500050002000200010010010025
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms

"Swiftboat Veterans for Lies & Distortions" is more like it. They are pigs, scum, swine.

2005-12-06 10:37 AM
in reply to: #299973

Pro
4040
2000200025
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
Brett - 2005-12-06 11:20 AM

Admittedly having not seen it I can't really say one way or the other. Although I would be curious as to see who sponsored the film. What channel was it on?

And while I'm not saying that Kerry did, it's not at all uncommon for peoples actions to be played up for the benefit of a citation. This problem was especially rampant in Vietnam.

I'm sure both sides have valid points. Personally I ignored most of what SBVFT said during the campaign anyway. And same goes for what Kerry said about Bush. How can you possibly trust what a politician says about another politician?


What was interesting was the testimony of his crew and the general description of swiftboat missions. These poor guys were told to motor up the Mekong in these noisy, twin-engined diesel boats. They could be heard for miles, so they were little more than bait. The men on these boats said that they were getting into a minimum of two firefights per day for awhile, sometimes as many as four. That's nuts. One boat commander said he had a 95% casualty rate.

What I'm saying is, just having served on one of those boats deserves respect, especially by the other soldiers who saw the same thing. It's clear that the people under his command respected him and credited him with having saved their lives, so why would others would try to put this in doubt?

The doc was on the Documentary Channel.
2005-12-06 10:44 AM
in reply to: #299947

User image

Champion
5183
5000100252525
Wisconsin
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
you wanna know how media mismanages information and mismanages itself? I just watched a REALLY interesting documenatry: Control Room. Al Jazeerah like you've never seen it. Frustrated CNN reprters, us Marines dogging Fox news...

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0002X8U4I/102-6853506-7983367?v=g...

Kept me riveted on the trainer yesterday!
2005-12-06 10:45 AM
in reply to: #299947

User image

Giver
18427
5000500050002000100010010010010025
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
The Swiftboat Vets had a mission and they carried (Kerried--I kill myself) it out. Their purpose was exactly as you described, to impune a fellow soldier damn the consequences and the truth. ANd they did it.

Special place in hell for those guys, I'm thinking.


2005-12-06 10:52 AM
in reply to: #300017

User image

Elite
2421
2000100100100100
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
possum - 2005-12-06 9:44 AM

you wanna know how media mismanages information and mismanages itself? I just watched a REALLY interesting documenatry: Control Room. Al Jazeerah like you've never seen it. Frustrated CNN reprters, us Marines dogging Fox news...

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0002X8U4I/102-6853506-7983367?v=g...

Kept me riveted on the trainer yesterday!


Not sure I'll put it on my wish list, but I'm sure they had a most interesting perspective. Talk about being in a lose-lose situation.

Not sure why the Grunts would dog Fox news, the one network accused of having a slant to the right. Or did you mean dogging them trying to get on TV?

bts
2005-12-06 11:09 AM
in reply to: #299947

User image

Champion
5183
5000100252525
Wisconsin
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
more like dogging them for not getting it right, for not being objective. The Lt in charge of the press said it was like you had Al Jazeera on one side and fox on the other and the truth was somewhere in between.

Also very interesting to learn about how little we (american press) really understood about the culture, so we reported on a LOT of things we completely misunderstood.

One reporter was telling cameramen that the piles of people behind her were cheering for Bush. they were really saying, "Bush go to Hell."

2005-12-06 11:19 AM
in reply to: #300062

User image

Elite
2421
2000100100100100
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
possum - 2005-12-06 10:09 AM

The Lt in charge of the press said it was like you had Al Jazeera on one side and fox on the other and the truth was somewhere in between.


That line pretty much sums it up.

It was pretty funny (in a depressing sort of way) watching CNN on Sat-TV while there and watching them tell a completely different story from what I saw happen.

bts
2005-12-06 11:22 AM
in reply to: #299947

User image

Champion
5183
5000100252525
Wisconsin
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
you were there!? Wow. Then I'd really be interested in what you think about that movie....
2005-12-06 11:23 AM
in reply to: #299947

User image

Expert
760
5001001002525
Mt. Morris, IL
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms

My opinion (not that it matters) is that the military must do lots of things that I don't want or need to know about in order to keep us safe.  It has always been that way and always will!



2005-12-06 12:00 PM
in reply to: #299947

User image

Elite
2768
20005001001002525
Raleigh
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms

IMO I think if you really want to find out what is going on you need to ask the solders. I work right off Ft Capmbell in KY and 90% of my clients are solders and their families and I keep in good contact with the guys and girls I have over there. I am telling you they are giving a different opinion of the good we are doing over there; than what you guys are getting on local news and BSNBC and CNN. Just talk to a solder...

As for the Swift boat guys. You have to understand that solders (I was one so I can speak on the topic) are kind of like Policeman and when you out or tell on a policman then all the others hate you. Kerry still held and participated in anti war rallies and most veterans see him (like Jane Fonda) as traitors to our country. It is kind of like your family, you can talk about how big of a slut your sister is and how dumb she is but if someother person says it you beat them up. You just dont bad mouth the solders when they are over there fighting. It is a code that he broke... just like the dont leave a man behind code.

If your not in the military or a police you dont understand. In war time your fellow solders are all you have to rely upon for your life, if all the suddon some guy starts bad mouthing what you are doing and bring down moral, that gets people killed...

2005-12-06 12:09 PM
in reply to: #300084

User image

Elite
2421
2000100100100100
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
possum - 2005-12-06 10:22 AM

you were there!? Wow. Then I'd really be interested in what you think about that movie....


Grrrreat, now I feel all this pressure. I'll have to check it out one of these days. I can't say that I ever delt with the "local" networks, just American/British/etc. Like I said, that line pretty much summed it up, the truth of a particular incident was somewhere between what Al-J. said and what CNN said. It's not as rosy as one might say, and not as bleak as the other. Or nowadays it's more like, it's not as bad as what either of them say.

bts
2005-12-06 12:24 PM
in reply to: #300150

User image

Elite
2777
2000500100100252525
In my bunk with new shoes and purple sweats.
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
golfinggods - 2005-12-06 1:00 PM

IMO I think if you really want to find out what is going on you need to ask the solders. I work right off Ft Capmbell in KY and 90% of my clients are solders and their families and I keep in good contact with the guys and girls I have over there. I am telling you they are giving a different opinion of the good we are doing over there; than what you guys are getting on local news and BSNBC and CNN. Just talk to a solder...

As for the Swift boat guys. You have to understand that solders (I was one so I can speak on the topic) are kind of like Policeman and when you out or tell on a policman then all the others hate you. Kerry still held and participated in anti war rallies and most veterans see him (like Jane Fonda) as traitors to our country. It is kind of like your family, you can talk about how big of a slut your sister is and how dumb she is but if someother person says it you beat them up. You just dont bad mouth the solders when they are over there fighting. It is a code that he broke... just like the dont leave a man behind code.

If your not in the military or a police you dont understand. In war time your fellow solders are all you have to rely upon for your life, if all the suddon some guy starts bad mouthing what you are doing and bring down moral, that gets people killed...

But you know Chris that code goes both ways. In my military career I never thought I would see a group of veterans attack another veteran. But I seen it happen to McCain and Kerry and the Republican party was the common denominator. Kerry may have protested the war, but his protest was most legitimate, after all he had been there. I didn't but a lot of veterans were adamantly opposed to the war when they returned. Not against their comrades but rather the bs that was causing so many good men to die. I mean really ask yourself, what were they dying for as I ask today, why are Americans dying in Iraq.

Support the troops, yes I support the troops. This bs the prez talks about , about supporting the troops and honoring their sacrifice. I never knew killing someone was the ultimate sign of supporting and honoring them. Do they serve honorably, you bet. Is their purpose askew, you bet.

Veterans can believe in different causes and be of opposing political parties but they should always put their service above that bs and stand by one another. And veterans should guard against those who would politicize their service otherwise we become one big Central America..

OK I'm alright now. Carry on.

2005-12-06 12:44 PM
in reply to: #300180

Pro
4040
2000200025
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
Yeah, Gullahcracker has it right. Kerry did not say that the soldiers were bad, he said the cause was bad. What some soldiers did say at the Winter Soldier hearings, and what other soldiers may have mistaken for betrayal, was that atrocities were committed. I'm sure nobody likes to be reminded of having been present or having taken part in atrocities.

In any case, it's sad to see soldiers gratuitously attack another with purely political motives. Nobody can argue that Kerry did not risk his life going there and serving like he did, which I think is the fundamental truth here.
2005-12-06 3:00 PM
in reply to: #300180

User image

Expert
916
500100100100100
San mateo California
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
gullahcracker - 2005-12-06 11:24 AM
golfinggods - 2005-12-06 1:00 PM

Veterans can believe in different causes and be of opposing political parties but they should always put their service above that bs and stand by one another. And veterans should guard against those who would politicize their service otherwise we become one big Central America..

OK I'm alright now. Carry on.



hummmm...   what do you mean by a big Central America....     explain yourself...


2005-12-06 7:07 PM
in reply to: #300376

User image

Elite
2777
2000500100100252525
In my bunk with new shoes and purple sweats.
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
velasqu7 - 2005-12-06 4:00 PM
gullahcracker - 2005-12-06 11:24 AM
golfinggods - 2005-12-06 1:00 PM

Veterans can believe in different causes and be of opposing political parties but they should always put their service above that bs and stand by one another. And veterans should guard against those who would politicize their service otherwise we become one big Central America..

OK I'm alright now. Carry on.



hummmm...   what do you mean by a big Central America....     explain yourself...
  Luis do I really have to explain that statement. Take a quick read of the history , past and present of most Central American countries and most South American countries and you will find military dictatorships. Do not read this as an indictment  of the people ( I love everybody, well except for a few people on this site) but rather as intended ie when the military serves a freely elected government, then the freedom of the citizens they protect is maximized. But when the ruling political party climbs in the rack with it's military then there's going to be problems. The purpose of our military is to support and defend the CONSTITUTION of the United States. A problem today is that a lot of folks confuse patriotism with partisanship.

So Luis, exhale, relax, whatever, I wasn't taking shots at anybody's ethnicity, just stating historical fact. That's all the explanation .

2005-12-06 8:01 PM
in reply to: #299947

User image

Expert
916
500100100100100
San mateo California
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms

 Russ..   I agree that the history of central american countries is full of conflicts that at one time or another have placed military dictatorships in power to the detriment of the people living in those countries.  However, these dictatorships had been placed and manupulated by foreign forces fighting their battles away from home.   

In Nicaragua for instance   Prime target of US-backed war efforts in the region. Over 6,000 counter-revolutionaries, trained and outfitted by the CIA and led by ex-Somocista national guardsmen, make forays from their bases in Honduras. 150 covert CIA agents are involved — the largest CIA operation since Vietnam.

In el Salvador Guerrilla forces were formed in the early 1970s. Farabundo Marti National Liberation Fmnt (FMLN) is a tightly-organized fighting force of an estimated 10,000. Government troops armed, trained and advised by the US, which has poured almost a billion dollars into the country during the peak of the insurgence.

In Honduras Main base of US action against the Sandinistas and Salvadoran guerrillas. Air strips, radar stations and new troop training facilities are being built. There were more than 300 US military advisors and technicians, 125 Green Berets and 150 CIA agents in the country. Contras operate freely inside Honduras. .

in Guatemala.  Scattered guerrilla forces fought from mountain strongholds since late 1950s; peasant support and government repression have accelerated since late 1970s. The army is the largest and most sophisticated in Central America, trained in counter-insurgency techniques by US advisors. Recent military aid will help Gen. Mejia escalate the armys campaign against the guerrillas. 

I grew up in one of these countries....   I remember stepping over dead bodies in my way to school (I still remember those days, and smell the dead).   I was a boy then, but even I understood that we were just pawns in a chess board controlled by a bear and a eagle...     So you see Russ, the rise and fall of the governemtes in Latin America did not happen just because...  They had been engineered, planned and executed from far away places.....  

Thank God...   those times are over....  at least in Central America....     

2005-12-06 8:14 PM
in reply to: #299947

User image

Elite
2777
2000500100100252525
In my bunk with new shoes and purple sweats.
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
Let's hope they are over for real and forever.
2005-12-07 7:55 AM
in reply to: #299947

User image

Champion
6786
50001000500100100252525
Two seat rocket plane
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms

They way I see it both the attacks on Kerry and McCain were the work of the cynical, win-political-power-at-any-cost mentality of the Cheny/Rove/Rumsfeld cabal. There is simply no depth to which these guys won't stoop. The sad part is that they were successful, they managed to smear the records and reputations of two genuine military heroes for the purpose of getting their puppet into the white house.

2005-12-07 9:15 AM
in reply to: #300760

User image

Elite
4344
2000200010010010025
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
ride_like_u_stole_it - 2005-12-07 8:55 AM

They way I see it both the attacks on Kerry and McCain were the work of the cynical, win-political-power-at-any-cost mentality of the Cheny/Rove/Rumsfeld cabal. There is simply no depth to which these guys won't stoop. The sad part is that they were successful, they managed to smear the records and reputations of two genuine military heroes for the purpose of getting their puppet into the white house.

You left out Murtha.

TW



2005-12-07 9:29 AM
in reply to: #300760

User image

Giver
18427
5000500050002000100010010010010025
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
And don't forget the DL smear campaign against McCain. Rumors about his daughter being the product of a black prostitute and his wife's addiciton issues.

Anyone catch him talking to Terri Gross yesterday on NPR?

ride_like_u_stole_it - 2005-12-07 7:55 AM

They way I see it both the attacks on Kerry and McCain were the work of the cynical, win-political-power-at-any-cost mentality of the Cheny/Rove/Rumsfeld cabal. There is simply no depth to which these guys won't stoop. The sad part is that they were successful, they managed to smear the records and reputations of two genuine military heroes for the purpose of getting their puppet into the white house.

2005-12-07 10:25 AM
in reply to: #300862

User image

Buttercup
14334
500050002000200010010010025
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms

Hang on a sec. You can't point to a 30 year period and say that it's to blame for 500 years worth of politico-socio-economic dysfunction in South America.

South America's history goes back 500 years. Their history of military coups/overthrows/political instability extends further back than the entire USA history, beginning to present.

While the 1900s saw very ugly interventions/meddling by the US (and United Fruit), and the 60s/70s/80s were particularly ugly, South America has been a political and economic mess for 400 years previous, going all the way back to when Spain got its first foothold/neck choke and was killing indiginous peoples en masse. The US was used by the ruling class just as much as the ruling class was used by the US.

The US didn't create the dysfunctions found in South America.



Edited by Renee 2005-12-07 10:26 AM
2005-12-07 10:52 AM
in reply to: #300938

User image

Champion
6786
50001000500100100252525
Two seat rocket plane
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms
Renee - 2005-12-07 10:25 AM

Hang on a sec. You can't point to a 30 year period and say that it's to blame for 500 years worth of politico-socio-economic dysfunction in South America.

South America's history goes back 500 years. Their history of military coups/overthrows/political instability extends further back than the entire USA history, beginning to present.

While the 1900s saw very ugly interventions/meddling by the US (and United Fruit), and the 60s/70s/80s were particularly ugly, South America has been a political and economic mess for 400 years previous, going all the way back to when Spain got its first foothold/neck choke and was killing indiginous peoples en masse. The US was used by the ruling class just as much as the ruling class was used by the US.

The US didn't create the dysfunctions found in South America.

Quick.....Blame the Spanish!

2005-12-07 11:00 AM
in reply to: #300985

User image

Buttercup
14334
500050002000200010010010025
Subject: RE: Can o' Worms

Nahh... I blame the Spanish, Portuguese, English, the greedy, the ruling elitists, the clerics, the opportunists, and the military that have always pursued their own agendas, stability be damned.

The Epic of Latin America, by John Crow. Read it.

New Thread
Other Resources My Cup of Joe » Can o' Worms Rss Feed  
 
 
of 2