Other Resources My Cup of Joe » School shootings, enough is enough Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, the bear, DerekL, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 2
 
 
2006-10-10 9:38 AM

User image

Elite
2768
20005001001002525
Raleigh
Subject: School shootings, enough is enough

A local syndicated radio hosts was talking about the school shootings that have been happening everywhere right now and he came up with a simple solution that I totally agree with.

In every school there should be one person that has been trained to carry a conceled firearm. It could be a teacher, janitor, or a giudence counselor. Only that person and the principal knows who it is; kind of like the air marshalls, that are secret. That way when these kids come in to shoot people they will not be able to kill as many people because the person (the school marshall) has been certified and can take them out.

Reason for this is two things: First Almsot all the school here has cops in them (in nashville) any student looking to kill students will go to the opposite end of the school from the cop or take the cop out first.
Second, a student would be less likely to walk into a class room to shoot students if there is a possibility that when he gets in the room, the teacher may be the school marshall that can take them out.

reason I like this, it is cheap... Putting real marshalls or for the school to hire private cops full time to be undercover is really costly and just because you wear a badge doesnt mean you are a good shot. The person that is the Marshall would go thru a training class and a intensive background check to make sure they are safe and not some crazy nut.

Also I like it because although I dont think it will deter all school shootings (i.e. the Penn Amish thing). It does sound like almost all of these shooting are premeditated because when investigators do checks into the shooters they have been planning this a while and have wrote thingts down in dairies and such. So it will deter some... z

School have become these soft targets, because of all of these silly no guns allowed on school property unless you are a cop, and the kids that are killing people know this. I think it is time we start protecting our children.,...

 

Your thoughts?



2006-10-10 9:45 AM
in reply to: #565358

User image

Extreme Veteran
452
1001001001002525
Ottawa, Ontario
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
Aaargh. The scary thing about this world is that people will take that suggestion seriously while dismissing mine as naive and somehow stepping on someones rights.

My solution - Look, if you remove one thing from the equation none of these shootings could take place. What's that item??? THE GUN.

BAN ALL GUNS, THEIR MANUFACTURE, AND TRADE.

Sorry, but the solution is less guns, not more.

Flame away, I'm a voice in the wilderness.

D

Edited by herridge 2006-10-10 9:45 AM
2006-10-10 9:48 AM
in reply to: #565358

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
2006-10-10 9:50 AM
in reply to: #565358

Runner
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
Disagree.

First, depending on the size of the school, one person will not be enough to prevent much.
Second, in most of these cases, everything was premeditated. Given enough time, they will find ways to either a) determine the carrier, or b) not give a fig and go for a more wholesale level of destruction, or c) find a work-around
Third, finding a candidate to fill said position could be difficult at best, providing them with proper training could be prohibitive in time and cost, and where are they hiding the gun? On their persons? That's risky in and of itself.
Fourth, it's a vigilante solution, which won't help matters. If outwardly displayed weapons don't deter these crimes, hidden ones certainly won't either.

How about this for a solution? Get parents involved in their kids' lives and education. Provide kids with outlets for the anger and frustration that is creative, not destructive. Teach kids how to handle failure, as well as how to determine their own self-worth, and not let others do it for them. Lofty goals, I know, but an ounce of prevention....
2006-10-10 9:54 AM
in reply to: #565370

Runner
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
herridge - 2006-10-10 10:45 AM

Aaargh. The scary thing about this world is that people will take that suggestion seriously while dismissing mine as naive and somehow stepping on someones rights.

My solution - Look, if you remove one thing from the equation none of these shootings could take place. What's that item??? THE GUN.

BAN ALL GUNS, THEIR MANUFACTURE, AND TRADE.

Sorry, but the solution is less guns, not more.

Flame away, I'm a voice in the wilderness.

D


The only real issue with that is the Constitutional right. Besides, I know people who hunt, not for fun, but to feed their families.

Oh, and what about the military? They need guns.
2006-10-10 9:54 AM
in reply to: #565380

Expert
789
500100100252525
Lake Forest, Illinois
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough

Scout7 - 2006-10-10 9:50 AM  How about this for a solution? Get parents involved in their kids' lives and education. Provide kids with outlets for the anger and frustration that is creative, not destructive. Teach kids how to handle failure, as well as how to determine their own self-worth, and not let others do it for them. Lofty goals, I know, but an ounce of prevention....

My god man are you MAD!!!!!



2006-10-10 9:55 AM
in reply to: #565370

Expert
893
500100100100252525
Livermore, Ca
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
herridge - 2006-10-10 10:45 AM

Aaargh. The scary thing about this world is that people will take that suggestion seriously while dismissing mine as naive and somehow stepping on someones rights.

My solution - Look, if you remove one thing from the equation none of these shootings could take place. What's that item??? THE GUN.

BAN ALL GUNS, THEIR MANUFACTURE, AND TRADE.

Sorry, but the solution is less guns, not more.

Flame away, I'm a voice in the wilderness.

D



HAHAHAHHAA..... ohh man I needed a good laugh this morning. priceless.
2006-10-10 9:59 AM
in reply to: #565386

Runner
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
jmcelroy - 2006-10-10 10:54 AM

Scout7 - 2006-10-10 9:50 AM How about this for a solution? Get parents involved in their kids' lives and education. Provide kids with outlets for the anger and frustration that is creative, not destructive. Teach kids how to handle failure, as well as how to determine their own self-worth, and not let others do it for them. Lofty goals, I know, but an ounce of prevention....

My god man are you MAD!!!!!



Yes. Yes I am.
2006-10-10 10:01 AM
in reply to: #565370

Giver
18427
5000500050002000100010010010010025
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough

herridge - 2006-10-10 10:45 AM Aaargh. The scary thing about this world is that people will take that suggestion seriously while dismissing mine as naive and somehow stepping on someones rights. My solution - Look, if you remove one thing from the equation none of these shootings could take place. What's that item??? THE GUN. BAN ALL GUNS, THEIR MANUFACTURE, AND TRADE. Sorry, but the solution is less guns, not more. Flame away, I'm a voice in the wilderness. D

I'd be happy if just handguns and assault weapons were banned. Most gun crimes are probably committed with them, so take them out of the equation and these things start to go away (shotguns would probably be pretty difficult to smuggle on campus, for instance).

The notion of injecting a big dose of good parenting is always appropriate, but there were always, always, always be disaffected kids. BUt if you take away their access to firearms, maybe they would resort to more acceptable acts of rebellion.

Like skateboarding, for example. Heck, even pot smoking would be better.

2006-10-10 10:07 AM
in reply to: #565385

Extreme Veteran
452
1001001001002525
Ottawa, Ontario
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
Scout7 - 2006-10-10 10:54 AM

herridge - 2006-10-10 10:45 AM

Aaargh. The scary thing about this world is that people will take that suggestion seriously while dismissing mine as naive and somehow stepping on someones rights.

My solution - Look, if you remove one thing from the equation none of these shootings could take place. What's that item??? THE GUN.

BAN ALL GUNS, THEIR MANUFACTURE, AND TRADE.

Sorry, but the solution is less guns, not more.

Flame away, I'm a voice in the wilderness.

D


The only real issue with that is the Constitutional right. Besides, I know people who hunt, not for fun, but to feed their families.

Oh, and what about the military? They need guns.


My understanding of it is that your "constitutional right" was established in order to raise citizen militia's to beat off the English. I think that need may have passed, and constitutions can be amended.

As for the military, explain the need if the other side has no guns. (I admit this is a little idealistic, but it's a fun argument)

D
2006-10-10 10:13 AM
in reply to: #565370

Expert
694
500100252525
Charleston, SC
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough

herridge - 2006-10-10 9:45 AM Aaargh. The scary thing about this world is that people will take that suggestion seriously while dismissing mine as naive and somehow stepping on someones rights. My solution - Look, if you remove one thing from the equation none of these shootings could take place. What's that item??? THE GUN. BAN ALL GUNS, THEIR MANUFACTURE, AND TRADE. Sorry, but the solution is less guns, not more. Flame away, I'm a voice in the wilderness. D

My issue with this is that you can only ban guns from law abiding citizens.  Criminals, who by deffinition do not follow the law, will only have a little harder time getting the guns. 



2006-10-10 10:20 AM
in reply to: #565358

Got Wahoo?
5423
5000100100100100
San Antonio
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough

Problem with that is everyone won't do it. The kids who have good parenting are not the kids who shoot and kill anyone.

 

Herridge, you're probably right but more importantly, you're just as entitled to state your opinion as the folks who post theirs constantly. Post away. 

2006-10-10 10:32 AM
in reply to: #565409

Expert
789
500100100252525
Lake Forest, Illinois
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough

herridge - 2006-10-10 10:07 AM
Scout7 - 2006-10-10 10:54 AM
herridge - 2006-10-10 10:45 AM Aaargh. The scary thing about this world is that people will take that suggestion seriously while dismissing mine as naive and somehow stepping on someones rights. My solution - Look, if you remove one thing from the equation none of these shootings could take place. What's that item??? THE GUN. BAN ALL GUNS, THEIR MANUFACTURE, AND TRADE. Sorry, but the solution is less guns, not more. Flame away, I'm a voice in the wilderness. D
The only real issue with that is the Constitutional right. Besides, I know people who hunt, not for fun, but to feed their families. Oh, and what about the military? They need guns.
My understanding of it is that your "constitutional right" was established in order to raise citizen militia's to beat off the English. D

It is your constitutional right to beat off whoever you like.  They don't even have to be English.  They do have to consent though.

I'm sorry I couldn't help it...that line cracked me up 8)

I understand your argument and would be completely behind it if it were at all plausible.

2006-10-10 10:43 AM
in reply to: #565358

Extreme Veteran
413
100100100100
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
School have become these soft targets, because of all of these silly no guns allowed on school property unless you are a cop, and the kids that are killing people know this. I think it is time we start protecting our children.,...

Your thoughts?

That's possibly one of the most disturbing things I've ever read on a messageboard.  Quite incredible.

The wide proliferation of gun ownership and how easy it is for an American citizen to put his hand on a gun and use it if they want is absolutely crazy - at least to the rest of the world looking in.

2006-10-10 11:00 AM
in reply to: #565358

Elite
2768
20005001001002525
Raleigh
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough

Cando,

 

I have a question for you since you are in England. So do you guys not have any gun crimes at all??? I mean are guns not banned in England? But I understand that crimes still happen there with guns... So obviously banning the guns is not the problem.

Here is a scenerio... If a robber is going to attack to houses one with someone who owns a gun and one with someone who doesnt; who do you think he attacks???? There are hundreds of stories every week of people who have defended their families with guns and a good result has came about it but you never hear about those.

And for the people who say what about a school being too big.. Well then you just have two school marshalls... I didnt say it was going to end school violance... I said it might deter a few and maybe it is just me but if we have 3 less school shootings a year because of it, that sounds like a good thing.
Nothing else is working... We have a zero policy here in TN where if you bring a gun to school you get suspended for a year but yet every week there is some kid in Metro Nashville that brings a gun to school and I bet money on it that it isnt the straight A student that is worried about his grades if he gets suspended and cannot get into college.

 

2006-10-10 11:13 AM
in reply to: #565358

Pro
4189
20002000100252525
Pittsburgh, my heart is in Glasgow
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
wow...i can't say on how many levels I disagree with this.

Here's my thinking...things start happening. Bombs go off, shots are fired, kids ignore the safety plans or panic and head into the hallway, running, yelling, pushing, smoke, fear. Confrontation between marshall and gun toting student with 200 students in a narrow brick hallway...I hope to God Allmighty that that guy's aim is 120% accurate.


2006-10-10 11:18 AM
in reply to: #565485

Extreme Veteran
413
100100100100
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough

Trigods - our gun crime is almost exclusively limited to the criminal element - ie; criminals shooting criminals.  Very rarely does someone get shot who is not of poor character themselves. 

Harldy anyone owns a gun - most robberies are committed by junkies who just want to get enough of your property to pay for their next fix - they'd never rob your house if you were in it and if they did they'd run for the hills.

Having so many guns in a country, having their ownership so widespread and people believing they have a consitutional right to pull a trigger 'normalises' and devalues human life.  At least that's my perception from over here.

When you watch documentries here you see cops getting out of cars to pull over people speeding with their guns drawn!  WTF is that all about?!

2006-10-10 11:23 AM
in reply to: #565517

Pro
4189
20002000100252525
Pittsburgh, my heart is in Glasgow
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
Cando - 2006-10-10 12:18 PM

When you watch documentries here you see cops getting out of cars to pull over people speeding with their guns drawn! WTF is that all about?!



Hehe, I was fascinated by the fact that An Garda Siochana and the PSNI are not *required* to carry guns...very interesting.
2006-10-10 11:34 AM
in reply to: #565517

Elite
2768
20005001001002525
Raleigh
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
Cando - 2006-10-10 11:18 AM

Trigods - our gun crime is almost exclusively limited to the criminal element - ie; criminals shooting criminals.  Very rarely does someone get shot who is not of poor character themselves. 

Harldy anyone owns a gun - most robberies are committed by junkies who just want to get enough of your property to pay for their next fix - they'd never rob your house if you were in it and if they did they'd run for the hills.

Having so many guns in a country, having their ownership so widespread and people believing they have a consitutional right to pull a trigger 'normalises' and devalues human life.  At least that's my perception from over here.

When you watch documentries here you see cops getting out of cars to pull over people speeding with their guns drawn!  WTF is that all about?!

 

Sorry but I really find that hard to believe that only druggies break into homes and steal only what the need for the next fix...  and if there are no guns why would they (the junkies) run for the hills if someone was home? What is the home owner going to do, beat them with their tea pot???

We the US value life as much as anyone. It is not a constitutional right to pull the trigger. It is to protect yourself and your family. My dad owned plenty of guns and he only shot them while hunting (yes we ate what he killed, we lived in the country). So there was no need to be all trigger happy but if for some reason someone broke into our home to hurt our family then that is when my Dad would have got the gun but he would not have shot someone unless he absolutely had to!

2006-10-10 11:42 AM
in reply to: #565546

Extreme Veteran
413
100100100100
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough

We come from different cultures and they'll be plenty that both of us find hard to believe about where the other is from - that's the beauty of the internet.  We can find out.

I can assure you that burglars do everything they can to ensure there is no one at home before they break in.  Further, if I did come home and find someone in my house and a teapot was to hand they'd be at a very high risk of being seriously hurt with it.  It also worries me that if I came home and I knew there was a gun hidden away that I might shoot them with it - I don't want to walk around knowing that I did that for the rest of my days.

The burglars don't carry guns - we're beginning to have a problem with people carrying knives and perhaps guns is the next step.

You've grown up with guns - I don't think I've ever even seen one out of a holster (when on holiday) or in a museum.  They are revered and something to be extremely scared of over here.

People hunt over here and I don't have a problem with that and perhaps it's a Country v Townie thing but as a 'Townie' there is just no place for guns in our community (here) - they serve no purpose.

2006-10-10 11:50 AM
in reply to: #565358

Elite
2768
20005001001002525
Raleigh
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough

Cando

I agree that we do come from different cultures. I find it hard to believe that you guys used to kill your criminals and people with guillotines and I am sure you guys freak out because we have "old Sparky" (electric chair).

It must be a "townie" thing because out in the country over here you hardly ever hear of people being killed in the streets like in Metro area's. And most people hunt and have bows and arrows etc in the country. I live in a town of only 9000 people but we have never had a murder in the last 15 years.

All I have to say is I hope it never happens to you and if it does use that big tea pot over the stove....



2006-10-10 11:56 AM
in reply to: #565583

Giver
18427
5000500050002000100010010010010025
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
trigods - 2006-10-10 12:50 PM

 I live in a town of only 9000 people but we have never had a murder in the last 15 years.

 

I thought you lived in Nashville?

2006-10-10 12:01 PM
in reply to: #565358

Elite
2768
20005001001002525
Raleigh
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough

I live in White House, 25 minutes from downtown... We have a Kroger and are just now have the land cleared for a wal-mart. Our only non mexican sit down resturant is a cracker B...

No one's ever heard of white house TN so I say nashville

2006-10-10 12:25 PM
in reply to: #565358

Runner
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough
Another issue to consider when looking at crime in Europe is the police. I know in Germany, the Polizei have no qualms about putting someone down if they so much as get touched. I've seen it with my own eyes. Police brutality? No such thing. Now if a cop were to do to that here....Lawsuit time. Also, on European tv, these things get reported in a fashion to make it look like the Wild West all the time here. I assure you, that is not the case. Most burglars do try to rob a home when no one is in it. However, we have a higher rate of drug-induced crime, and they're the dumb ones. Additionally, you don't have street gangs like we have in the U.S. Not to say they don't exist, but it's not on the same level. I know in Philly, most of the violent crime is either drug or gang-related in some way (mostly drive-bys and such).

Honestly, violence in is country is high. But remember, we also have the third highest population in the world. School shootings are only a hot-button issue because they've happened recently. Keep in mind that at least one of them was not perpetrated by a student, too.
2006-10-10 12:27 PM
in reply to: #565385

Elite Veteran
1817
1000500100100100
Cedar Rapids, Iowa
Subject: RE: School shootings, enough is enough

Scout7 - 2006-10-10 9:54 AM
herridge - 2006-10-10 10:45 AM Aaargh. The scary thing about this world is that people will take that suggestion seriously while dismissing mine as naive and somehow stepping on someones rights. My solution - Look, if you remove one thing from the equation none of these shootings could take place. What's that item??? THE GUN. BAN ALL GUNS, THEIR MANUFACTURE, AND TRADE. Sorry, but the solution is less guns, not more. Flame away, I'm a voice in the wilderness. D
The only real issue with that is the Constitutional right. Besides, I know people who hunt, not for fun, but to feed their families. Oh, and what about the military? They need guns.

I see another issue.  In the future world as any of us see it....there is no way in humanity to get the guns away from the criminals.  This simply is NOT going to occur.  You must accept this as fact, and base your decisions from there.  Drugs and guns are with us, and they will continue to be with us. There is no solution to this, there is only acceptance.  And if you say you do not believe this, it is simply because you do not want to believe it.   Acceptance of this is a painful thing and some people can't live happily if they let themselves ever truly believe that this is the world we live in.  But the test is this: name me one time, in the history of the known world, where we have been able to get the criminals to stop doing what we don't want them to do.   We haven't and we can't.  We only enfore / impose (depending on how you see it) "control" laws over people we can actually control, and as it happens, this can often time be to their detriment.   What would be, honestly as you see it, the benefit of denying a gun to a law abiding citizen for personal protection, once you accept the fact that the people who wish to harm him and his family will most certainly possess one.

 

 

New Thread
Other Resources My Cup of Joe » School shootings, enough is enough Rss Feed  
 
 
of 2