Other Resources My Cup of Joe » Is Harry going to die? Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, the bear, DerekL, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 5
 
 
2007-06-21 3:30 PM

User image

Expert
929
50010010010010025
Hawaii
Subject: Is Harry going to die?

Okay, it’s a month until the last book comes out.  Time to discuss, right?  Will Harry go down in a battle with Voldemort?  Is Harry a horcrux?  Is Snape evil?  Will Hogwarts re-open?  What do you all think?  I need to re-read the last couple of books, but those questions are forefront in my mind.




2007-06-21 3:41 PM
in reply to: #854812

User image

Buttercup
14334
500050002000200010010010025
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?
naners - 2007-06-21 4:30 PM

Okay, it’s a month until the last book comes out.  Time to discuss, right?  Will Harry go down in a battle with Voldemort?  Is Harry a horcrux?  Is Snape evil?  Will Hogwarts re-open?  What do you all think?  I need to re-read the last couple of books, but those questions are forefront in my mind.


Will Harry go down in a battle with Voldemort? 

NO! Maybe. Probably. I hope not!

Is Harry a horcrux?

Geez, I can't even remember what that is...

Is Snape evil? 

No. Snape will be very instrumental in battling Voldemort. Wash and give his hair a dry fluff and he suddenly doesn't look so evil, does he?

Will Hogwarts re-open? 

Yes. 

I need to re-read the last couple of books, 

I started re-reading the last book this weekend (see question 2 above). Then I realized I couldn't remember the details from the 5th book! So I'm almost done re-reading the 5th book and expect to begin re-reading the 6th book this weekend. I wanted to be ready for the 7th book.



Edited by Renee 2007-06-21 3:46 PM
2007-06-21 3:42 PM
in reply to: #854812

User image

Elite
3221
20001000100100
the desert
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?

My predictions

  • Harry will go down - ditto with Voldemort
  • Snape is not evil
  • Hogwarts will reopen

Is Dumbeldore really dead though?

2007-06-21 3:44 PM
in reply to: #854851

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
2007-06-21 3:45 PM
in reply to: #854856

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
2007-06-21 3:55 PM
in reply to: #854851

Expert
929
50010010010010025
Hawaii
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?

I started re-reading the last book this weekend (see question 2 above). Then I realized I couldn't remember the details from the 5th book! So I'm almost done re-reading the 5th book and expect to begin re-reading the 6th book this weekend. I wanted to be ready for the 7th book.

I meant to re-read them all, but I think that I'm running out of time.  So, I'm starting on the fifth.  I think that'll be enough for me not to be lost during the seventh.  I hope.



2007-06-21 3:56 PM
in reply to: #854896

Buttercup
14334
500050002000200010010010025
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?

Ah, well I cheated a bit. I own the 4 dvd's so I watched those first. Then I started reading.

My nephew likes to discuss and speculate and he remembers many more details than I do - gotta stay on my toes!



Edited by Renee 2007-06-21 3:57 PM
2007-06-21 3:58 PM
in reply to: #854851

COURT JESTER
12230
50005000200010010025
ROCKFORD, IL
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?

 

Will Harry go down in a battle with Voldemort? 

Yes.  And to answer the next question:  Yes.  Voldemort transfered some of his powers to Harry when he tried to kill him as a child and probably tranfered some of his life force.  I'm thinking Harry finds out he's a Horcrux and in the battle with Voldemort, Harry detroys himself in order to detroy the last remaining life force Voldemort needs, and therefore destroys Voldemort.

Also, Rowling doesn't want to be pestered for the rest of time about writing more Harry Potter books, with titles like:  Harry Potter and his Headmaster Years.

Is Harry a horcrux?

Yup.

Is Snape evil? 

No.  He and Dumbledore had a carefully planned "killing" at the end of 'Half Blood Prince' so that Dumbledore could continue seeking and detroying the Horcruxes.  Dumbledore is powerful enough to pull off faking his death and probably put himself into a sort of temporary catatonic state.

Will Hogwarts re-open? 

Yes. 

 

2007-06-21 3:58 PM
in reply to: #854864

Expert
929
50010010010010025
Hawaii
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?

Right.  I don't like that argument because I don't want Harry to die, but it seems like a plausible J.K. Rowling-like plot twist.  On the other hand, I kind of refuse to think that she'd kill Harry. 

spokes - 2007-06-21 2:44 PM

A Horcrux is an object that holds a piece of person's soul... the only way to put a portion of your soul into a Horcrux is to kill someone.. the reason Voldemort can't be killed is because his soul is in a number of Horcruxes... at least two have been destroyed, and there's speculation that his snake, Nagini, is also a Horcrux along with Harry.

 

Renee - 2007-06-21 1:41 PM
naners - 2007-06-21 4:30 PM

Okay, it’s a month until the last book comes out. Time to discuss, right? Will Harry go down in a battle with Voldemort? Is Harry a horcrux? Is Snape evil? Will Hogwarts re-open? What do you all think? I need to re-read the last couple of books, but those questions are forefront in my mind.


Will Harry go down in a battle with Voldemort?

NO! Maybe. Probably. I hope not!

Is Harry a horcrux?

Geez, I can't even remember what that is...

Is Snape evil?

No. Snape will be very instrumental in battling Voldemort. Wash and give his hair a dry fluff and he suddenly doesn't look so evil, does he?

Will Hogwarts re-open?

Yes.

I need to re-read the last couple of books,

I started re-reading the last book this weekend. Then I realized I couldn't remember the details from the 5th book! So I'm almost done re-reading the 5th book and expect to begin re-reading the 6th book this weekend.

2007-06-21 4:06 PM
in reply to: #854907

Buttercup
14334
500050002000200010010010025
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?

Have you been to the Warner Bros. website? They've got a great trailer and some cute stuff to download. They did a nice job, I thought.

BTW - Helena Bonham Carter as Bellatrix Lestrange - looks GREAT!



Edited by Renee 2007-06-21 4:07 PM
2007-06-21 4:10 PM
in reply to: #854905

Mountain View, CA
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?
Will Harry go down in a battle with Voldemort?

Yes. And to answer the next question: Yes. Voldemort transfered some of his powers to Harry when he tried to kill him as a child and probably tranfered some of his life force. I'm thinking Harry finds out he's a Horcrux and in the battle with Voldemort, Harry detroys himself in order to detroy the last remaining life force Voldemort needs, and therefore destroys Voldemort.

I like this theory. Good call.

And I'm inclined to think that Dumbledore is no more dead than Sirius is (that is to say, either not dead at all or only dead to an as-yet-undetermined extent).

I think that Snape is indeed loyal to Dumbledore, but I think it's due less to a major gestalt shift and more to some serious vindictiveness turning him against Voldemort (my favorite theory in this camp involves Snape being in love with Lily Potter).

If Hogwarts doesn't reopen, I can see senior members of the DA taking the club and turning it into some sort of (pseudo-)school. But I'm not sure if there's enough room in one book to develop that in addition to everything else. 



2007-06-21 4:12 PM
in reply to: #854944

Buttercup
14334
500050002000200010010010025
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?

My 12YO nephew insists Sirius is not dead.

Another detail I have to look for - I couldn't even remember how he died. Geez the memory is going/gone...

2007-06-21 4:14 PM
in reply to: #854948

COURT JESTER
12230
50005000200010010025
ROCKFORD, IL
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?
Renee - 2007-06-21 3:12 PM

My 12YO nephew insists Sirius is not dead.

Another detail I have to look for - I couldn't even remember how he died. Geez the memory is going/gone...

In the batte the the Death Eaters, Sirius is hit and is thrown (whatever) behind this black curtain is GONE.  Magic ya know.  Could be alive, could be dead.

2007-06-21 4:15 PM
in reply to: #854944

COURT JESTER
12230
50005000200010010025
ROCKFORD, IL
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?
puellasolis - 2007-06-21 3:10 PM
Will Harry go down in a battle with Voldemort?

Yes. And to answer the next question: Yes. Voldemort transfered some of his powers to Harry when he tried to kill him as a child and probably tranfered some of his life force. I'm thinking Harry finds out he's a Horcrux and in the battle with Voldemort, Harry detroys himself in order to detroy the last remaining life force Voldemort needs, and therefore destroys Voldemort.

I like this theory. Good call.

Guess I'm just full of good theories today.

2007-06-21 4:16 PM
in reply to: #854950

Buttercup
14334
500050002000200010010010025
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?
tupuppy - 2007-06-21 5:14 PM
Renee - 2007-06-21 3:12 PM

My 12YO nephew insists Sirius is not dead.

Another detail I have to look for - I couldn't even remember how he died. Geez the memory is going/gone...

In the batte the the Death Eaters, Sirius is hit and is thrown (whatever) behind this black curtain is GONE.  Magic ya know.  Could be alive, could be dead.

Don't tell me! That's like a spoiler. But different. Cuz I already read the book but I think those memories are floating in a pensieve somewhere...

Now that you mention it, yeah I remember that. QUIT TELLING ME PSEUDO-SPOILERS!

2007-06-21 4:17 PM
in reply to: #854958

Elite
3130
2000100010025
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?
Renee - 2007-06-21 3:16 PM
tupuppy - 2007-06-21 5:14 PM
Renee - 2007-06-21 3:12 PM

My 12YO nephew insists Sirius is not dead.

Another detail I have to look for - I couldn't even remember how he died. Geez the memory is going/gone...

In the batte the the Death Eaters, Sirius is hit and is thrown (whatever) behind this black curtain is GONE.  Magic ya know.  Could be alive, could be dead.

Don't tell me! That's like a spoiler. But different. Cuz I already read the book but I think those memories are floating in a pensieve somewhere...

Now that you mention it, yeah I remember that. QUIT TELLING ME PSEUDO-SPOILERS!

If somebody tells you something that you already knew, but forgot it, is that a spoiler?

 



2007-06-21 4:19 PM
in reply to: #854958

COURT JESTER
12230
50005000200010010025
ROCKFORD, IL
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?
Renee - 2007-06-21 3:16 PM
tupuppy - 2007-06-21 5:14 PM
Renee - 2007-06-21 3:12 PM

My 12YO nephew insists Sirius is not dead.

Another detail I have to look for - I couldn't even remember how he died. Geez the memory is going/gone...

In the batte the the Death Eaters, Sirius is hit and is thrown (whatever) behind this black curtain is GONE.  Magic ya know.  Could be alive, could be dead.

Don't tell me! That's like a spoiler. But different. Cuz I already read the book but I think those memories are floating in a pensieve somewhere...

Now that you mention it, yeah I remember that. QUIT TELLING ME PSEUDO-SPOILERS!

WACK!!!!    sorry...................

anthing else you don't want to know?

2007-06-21 4:20 PM
in reply to: #854933

Expert
929
50010010010010025
Hawaii
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?
Renee - 2007-06-21 3:06 PM

Have you been to the Warner Bros. website? They've got a great trailer and some cute stuff to download. They did a nice job, I thought.

BTW - Helena Bonham Carter as Bellatrix Lestrange - looks GREAT!



I hadn't seen the theatrical trailer before.  It looks really good!  I love how Alan Rickman plays Snape.   

2007-06-21 4:21 PM
in reply to: #854964

Buttercup
14334
500050002000200010010010025
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?
ScottoNM - 2007-06-21 5:17 PM

If somebody tells you something that you already knew, but forgot it, is that a spoiler?

No. Yes. Makes perfect sense to me! I'm gonna have to duck out of this thread before I get any more not-surprises.

2007-06-21 4:25 PM
in reply to: #854933

Mountain View, CA
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?
BTW - Helena Bonham Carter as Bellatrix Lestrange - looks GREAT!


I know!!!! Definitely getting psyched for this movie...

 

2007-06-21 4:28 PM
in reply to: #854944

Expert
929
50010010010010025
Hawaii
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?

And I'm inclined to think that Dumbledore is no more dead than Sirius is (that is to say, either not dead at all or only dead to an as-yet-undetermined extent).

Dumbledore's gone.  J.K. Rowling has been pretty adamant about that one.  Plot-wise he kind of needs to be gone.  Harry's the one that needs to stand up to Voldemort.  I don't think that could've (or would've) happened if Dumbledore was around.  Dumbledore knew.  Right before he died, he was pleading with Snape.  I think he was pleading with Snape to kill him.  It was a part of the prophecy.

Now, Sirius is another story.  His death was so abrupt.  I think that there's still some way for Harry to contact Sirius. 



2007-06-21 4:31 PM
in reply to: #854993

Mountain View, CA
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?

Dumbledore's gone. J.K. Rowling has been pretty adamant about that one.

Clearly I have been delinquent about keeping up with info from Rowling. Thanks for the correction.  

2007-06-21 4:35 PM
in reply to: #854980

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
2007-06-21 4:40 PM
in reply to: #854812

Master
1670
10005001002525
Harvard, Illinois
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?
I don't think Harry will die, I am not sure Dumbledore is completely dead. I don't think Snape is evil and Hogwarts will re-open. I think Voldemort will be killed and all of the Death Eaters will be rounded up or killed defending him.
2007-06-21 4:45 PM
in reply to: #854998

Expert
929
50010010010010025
Hawaii
Subject: RE: Is Harry going to die?

Clearly I have been delinquent about keeping up with info from Rowling. Thanks for the correction.

Glad to help. Clearly, I spend too much time on Harry Potter websites I’m tight with J.K. Rowling.



Edited by naners 2007-06-21 4:52 PM
New Thread
Other Resources My Cup of Joe » Is Harry going to die? Rss Feed  
 
 
of 5