Why does abortion scare so many in the US? (Page 4)
-
No new posts
Moderators: k9car363, the bear, DerekL, alicefoeller | Reply |
|
2009-01-15 12:58 PM in reply to: #1909989 |
Veteran 238 Raleigh, NC | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? maxmattmick - 2009-01-15 1:52 PM Tri'nNC - 2009-01-15 1:16 PM i believe they take the cases that would have the biggest effect on society as a whole and degree of merit? anybody know details?
"Of the 6,000 or so certiorari (cert) petitions filed each year, the Court agrees to consider no more than about 150 and sometimes fewer." "The Court relies on several criteria to decide if a case requires action. To win Supreme Court review, a case must fall within the Court’s jurisdiction, raise a justiciable legal issue, and concern an issue of constitutional or legal importance." Source: Encarta http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_761574302_3/supreme_court_of_the_united_states.html aren't all of those criteria met on some level with abortion?
depends on who's doing the deciding... |
|
2009-01-15 12:58 PM in reply to: #1909991 |
Master 1699 Malvern, PA | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? lisac957 - 2009-01-15 1:52 PM Rosshole - 2009-01-15 11:05 AM Where does "abortion" begin? With the morning after pill? or with Birth control medicines or other contraceptives? Is conception really the start, or are the sperm and egg not living cells/organisms? When you take the traditional pill as directed, your body does not ovulate. It does not produce an egg to begin with. Just wanted to point that out if it helps in the discussion (or not!).
that's what I thought... |
2009-01-15 12:59 PM in reply to: #1910010 |
Master 1699 Malvern, PA | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? Tri'nNC - 2009-01-15 1:58 PM maxmattmick - 2009-01-15 1:52 PM Tri'nNC - 2009-01-15 1:16 PM i believe they take the cases that would have the biggest effect on society as a whole and degree of merit? anybody know details?
"Of the 6,000 or so certiorari (cert) petitions filed each year, the Court agrees to consider no more than about 150 and sometimes fewer." "The Court relies on several criteria to decide if a case requires action. To win Supreme Court review, a case must fall within the Court’s jurisdiction, raise a justiciable legal issue, and concern an issue of constitutional or legal importance." Source: Encarta http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_761574302_3/supreme_court_of_the_united_states.html aren't all of those criteria met on some level with abortion?
depends on who's doing the deciding... that's what I mean by "some level" but no matter who you ask I think most everyone would agree that each of the criteria are met... |
2009-01-15 1:00 PM in reply to: #1909975 |
Veteran 238 Raleigh, NC | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? The woman currently has all rights to decide whatever she chooses. The man has no legal recourse. I've been there. My first marriage ended over this issue. We had discussed having children many times prior to marriage and she always indicated she wanted to have children. She was always very loving with the children of friends and relatives. Yet when she became pregnant, she decided it was not convenient for her to have a child at that time. I had no voice in the matter. It's not like the child would not have been loved or would be born into poor circimstances - or any of a host of other reasons people use to kill their offspring. It was simply done for a very selfish reason. Here's the real kicker - I actually forgave her for this. Then it happened again a couple years later and I could no longer stay with a woman who so callously exterminated human life. I often wonder what the children I never got the opportunity to know would have been like. Unbelievably heart wrenching story... much respect for both the decision "to stay" and to the "enough is enough". |
2009-01-15 1:02 PM in reply to: #1909991 |
Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? lisac957 - When you take the traditional pill as directed, your body does not ovulate. It does not produce an egg to begin with. Just wanted to point that out if it helps in the discussion (or not!).
Lisa, by my understanding most commonly prescribed birth control pills do have a tertiary abortifacient mechanism built in. Again by my understanding, this was done because the early formulations held a higher risk for cancer. By lowering the dosage of one drug, the cancer risk was reduced but the probability of conception increased. Therefore, the abortifacient mechanism needed to be added in. If anyone is concerned about using the pill if it has an abortifacient mechanism, just read the fine print that comes with the prescription. It should tell you there. Or just google it. Plenty of information out there. |
2009-01-15 1:06 PM in reply to: #1909991 |
Elite 3683 Whispering Pines, North Carolina | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? lisac957 - 2009-01-15 1:52 AM Rosshole - 2009-01-15 11:05 AM Where does "abortion" begin? With the morning after pill? or with Birth control medicines or other contraceptives? Is conception really the start, or are the sperm and egg not living cells/organisms? When you take the traditional pill as directed, your body does not ovulate. It does not produce an egg to begin with. Just wanted to point that out if it helps in the discussion (or not!).
woooooooaaaaaahh you're saying what? you consider that an abortion? an abortion begins when a fertilized egg is removed intentionally. an egg is an egg and a sperm is a sperm until they become fertilized. Ross, i would say conception is the start and that an egg and sperm are just cells...i'd hate to think that 250M people are dying every time somebody has pizza...little floating corpses |
|
2009-01-15 1:08 PM in reply to: #1910038 |
Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? tri_d00d - Ross, i would say conception is the start and that an egg and sperm are just cells...i'd hate to think that 250M people are dying every time somebody has pizza...little floating corpses Actually, the estimate is about 250 million conceived human beings in the US since the introduction of the oral contraceptive in the early 60's. These deaths have come from the abortifacient mechanism built into common birth control pills. Edited by dontracy 2009-01-15 1:13 PM |
2009-01-15 1:12 PM in reply to: #1910025 |
Alpharetta, Georgia | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? dontracy - 2009-01-15 1:02 PM lisac957 - When you take the traditional pill as directed, your body does not ovulate. It does not produce an egg to begin with. Just wanted to point that out if it helps in the discussion (or not!).
Lisa, by my understanding most commonly prescribed birth control pills do have a tertiary abortifacient mechanism built in. Again by my understanding, this was done because the early formulations held a higher risk for cancer. By lowering the dosage of one drug, the cancer risk was reduced but the probability of conception increased. Therefore, the abortifacient mechanism needed to be added in. If anyone is concerned about using the pill if it has an abortifacient mechanism, just read the fine print that comes with the prescription. It should tell you there. Or just google it. Plenty of information out there. From http://health.rutgers.edu/discussions/sex/preg&birthcon/thepill.asp The major mechanism by which the birth control pill works is by preventing ovulation (release of an egg from the ovary). A small percentage of women may occasionally ovulate on the birth control pill, but still are very unlikely to become pregnant. This is because the pill also makes the cervical mucosa more hostile to sperm, so that they are very unlikely to reach any egg that might be produced. Lastly, the pill also cause changes to the uterine lining which would make implantation of any fertilized egg extremely unlikely. The first question is when does pregnancy begin? Pregnancy is usually defined as the implantation of a fertilized egg into the uterine lining. By this widely accepted definition, then clearly the birth control is NOT an abortifacient (in fact it cannot be used to induce abortions since once an egg/embryo is implanted the birth control pill will not cause it to be dislodged). There is no similarity to how the birth control pill works and RU-486 (the "abortion pill" which will cause the uterus to expel an implanted embryo). There is a small segment of the population that believes that pregnancy begins as soon as a sperm meets and fertilizes an egg, and an abortion as any event that takes place after this. Even by this definition, the birth control pill would almost never cause an "abortion", since its mechanism of action takes place almost entirely before fertilization (by preventing ovulation and interfering with sperm reaching an egg). There may be a very few number of cases where sperm and egg join and then pregnancy is prevented by blocking implantation (a quite unusual event). |
2009-01-15 1:14 PM in reply to: #1910038 |
Alpharetta, Georgia | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? tri_d00d - 2009-01-15 1:06 PM lisac957 - 2009-01-15 1:52 AM Rosshole - 2009-01-15 11:05 AM Where does "abortion" begin? With the morning after pill? or with Birth control medicines or other contraceptives? Is conception really the start, or are the sperm and egg not living cells/organisms? When you take the traditional pill as directed, your body does not ovulate. It does not produce an egg to begin with. Just wanted to point that out if it helps in the discussion (or not!).
woooooooaaaaaahh you're saying what? you consider that an abortion? Did I say that??? Please. Don't put words into my mouth. Just stating some facts for the conversation.
|
2009-01-15 1:14 PM in reply to: #1910043 |
Champion 18680 Lost in the Luminiferous Aether | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? dontracy - 2009-01-15 2:08 PM tri_d00d - Ross, i would say conception is the start and that an egg and sperm are just cells...i'd hate to think that 250M people are dying every time somebody has pizza...little floating corpses Actually, the estimate is about 250 million in the US since the introduction of the oral contraceptive in the early 60's. These deaths have come from the abortifacient mechanism built into common birth control pills. The pill stops ovulation it does not induce abortion so unless you are referring to the morning after pill there were no deaths. Next question does that mean having an IUD is murder? |
2009-01-15 1:15 PM in reply to: #1910062 |
Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? lisac957 - Lastly, the pill also cause changes to the uterine lining which would make implantation of any fertilized egg extremely unlikely. That's the abortifacient mechanism. Primary mechanism is control of ovulation. Secondary is change in mucous preventing conception. Tertiary is rejection of the fertilized egg if conception takes place |
|
2009-01-15 1:17 PM in reply to: #1910069 |
Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? trinnas - Next question does that mean having an IUD is murder? The IUD is also believed to have at least a tertiary abortifacient effect. |
2009-01-15 1:17 PM in reply to: #1910075 |
Alpharetta, Georgia | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? dontracy - 2009-01-15 1:15 PM lisac957 - Lastly, the pill also cause changes to the uterine lining which would make implantation of any fertilized egg extremely unlikely. That's the abortifacient mechanism. Primary mechanism is control of ovulation. Secondary is change in mucous preventing conception. Tertiary is rejection of the fertilized egg if conception takes place Yes, for those that believe pregnancy/life begins BEFORE implantation.
Edited by lisac957 2009-01-15 1:18 PM |
2009-01-15 1:19 PM in reply to: #1910084 |
Extreme Veteran 614 | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? And now for something completely different: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0kJHQpvgB8
|
2009-01-15 1:20 PM in reply to: #1910069 |
Champion 14571 the alamo city, Texas | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? trinnas - 2009-01-15 2:14 PM dontracy - 2009-01-15 2:08 PM tri_d00d - Ross, i would say conception is the start and that an egg and sperm are just cells...i'd hate to think that 250M people are dying every time somebody has pizza...little floating corpses Actually, the estimate is about 250 million in the US since the introduction of the oral contraceptive in the early 60's. These deaths have come from the abortifacient mechanism built into common birth control pills. The pill stops ovulation it does not induce abortion so unless you are referring to the morning after pill there were no deaths. Next question does that mean having an IUD is murder? morning after pill is NOT the same as the "abortion pill" if fertilization occurs, morning after pill has zero effect. it is just a high dose of normal BC hormones. |
2009-01-15 1:24 PM in reply to: #1910075 |
Champion 18680 Lost in the Luminiferous Aether | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? dontracy - 2009-01-15 2:15 PM lisac957 - Lastly, the pill also cause changes to the uterine lining which would make implantation of any fertilized egg extremely unlikely. That's the abortifacient mechanism. Primary mechanism is control of ovulation. Secondary is change in mucous preventing conception. Prevents conceptions does not about any thing but the attempt Tertiary is rejection of the fertilized egg if conception takes place Hypothesized only and unlikly to be any important role due to the lack of ovulation in the first place Edited by trinnas 2009-01-15 1:25 PM |
|
2009-01-15 1:28 PM in reply to: #1910088 |
Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? lisac957 - Yes, for those that believe pregnancy/life begins BEFORE implantation.
One's beliefs should not impact scientific fact. It's a fact of biology that human life begins at conception, not implantation. |
2009-01-15 1:31 PM in reply to: #1910120 |
Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? trinnas -Hypothesized only and unlikly to be any important role due to te lack of o It's not hypothetical. Just look at the quote that Lisa posted. It's right there. It is not unimportant to someone who does not want to kill their offspring. The 250 million deaths is an estimate, but probably a pretty good one. I wasn't talking about the morning after pill, just your regular run of the mill birth control pill. There is a tertiary abortifacient mechanism built into the pill. And it can cause a fertilized egg, a human being, to be rejected by the mother's uterus should conception occur. That's just a fact. Do with it what you will. Edited by dontracy 2009-01-15 1:34 PM |
2009-01-15 1:32 PM in reply to: #1909338 |
Expert 1357 Mukwonago, WI | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? tri_d00d - 2009-01-15 9:46 AM how about a lesbian atheist wanting an abortion while stating she hates america? tie all those threads into one Rosie O'Donnell, welcome to BT! |
2009-01-15 1:33 PM in reply to: #1909325 |
Subject: ... This user's post has been ignored. |
2009-01-15 1:37 PM in reply to: #1909325 |
Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? Wow, whoda thunk knew this thread would go crazy???? me.... ten foot pole..... not a chance |
|
2009-01-15 1:40 PM in reply to: #1910162 |
Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? PennState - Can a physician following the hypocratic oath prescribe OCPs or place an IUD? Now there's a great question. |
2009-01-15 1:50 PM in reply to: #1910184 |
Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? Just to add one more thing to the mix. Carl Djerassi , the chemist who was the primary developer of the oral contraceptive, now says that his invention, the pill, has become a "demographic catastrophe". As reported in the UK Guardian :
|
2009-01-15 2:04 PM in reply to: #1909325 |
Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? And just one more tid bit about the pill, as reported by ABC News : In a study of about 100 college students in the U.K., scientists found that the pill may change how women find a man's scent sexually attractive. snip
|
2009-01-15 2:13 PM in reply to: #1910140 |
Alpharetta, Georgia | Subject: RE: Why does abortion scare so many in the US? dontracy - 2009-01-15 1:28 PM lisac957 - Yes, for those that believe pregnancy/life begins BEFORE implantation.
One's beliefs should not impact scientific fact. It's a fact of biology that human life begins at conception, not implantation. Well obviously, a lot of people don't believe human life begins at conception. Otherwise there would be no debate.
|
|