BT Development Mentor Program Archives » Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed Rss Feed  
Moderators: alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 188
 
 
2012-04-10 7:52 PM
in reply to: #4141971

User image

Expert
1480
1000100100100100252525
Somewhere in the Swamps of Philly
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed

As for me, I don't know a single person that has tried it and hasn't benefited from it.

Alright, I only joined this group over the winter and had the same skepticism about the collective following of the Maffetone way.  I'm a lawyer by trade and thus a professional skeptic. But, I too will bear witness to the way of the Maffetone.  After having followed the path since January, I am simply shocked at how much better my conditioning is and how much faster I am come race time.  

I did a comparison on two 11.5 mile runs I did almost one year apart.  Yr-1 pace was 7:56 and with an average HR of 165.  Yr-2 pace was 8:05 with an average HR of 144.  The :11 difference pace is negligible  when consider how much harder I was pushing myself a year ago.  In Yr-2, the effort seemed minimal and I could run for hours more at that pace.  

In terms of speed, in the last 4 months, I PR'd my 5 miler and ran two 5-K legs in a duathlon at or under PR time.  The biggest difficulty you may have is humbling yourself to run slowly and let those "faster" people pass you bye.  The solace here is that when I now race I hear people all around me panting like they are ready to drop a lung and I am working hard but breathing so much easier because my HR is much lower.  With a bigger engine, I now can find that extra gear to pick up the pace in the last mile or so when others are dropping back.  No better feeling!!!

As final evidence, my resting heart rate is now around 57 - down 10 bpm from a year ago.



2012-04-10 8:33 PM
in reply to: #4142097

User image

Master
1531
100050025
TORONTO
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
chapfallen - 2012-04-10 8:42 PM

Meant to post this sooner, but life/work got in the way.

We went for what felt like a mammoth bike ride on Sunday.  We did the whole route that we'd planned for the week before.  In total it was just over 85miles, which is only 5 miles longer than the previous week, but the elevation was ridiculous.  I actually had to get off and walk up a hill for the first time in about a year and half.  (I nearly cried...).  But I'm really proud that we did it.

Following on from a couple of weekends of long rides, I have a question for the group.  For those with experience of a lot of long riding, how saddle sore is normal?  I'm trying to decide if I should be looking for a new saddle.  I've currently got the Adamo Road, which dealt with a number of problems that I had with saddles last year.  However, the longer I ride on it, the more I realise that it's still quite uncomfortable.  After cycling 60 miles on Friday, when I got on the bike on Sunday I actually felt like someone was stabbing me in my sit bones.  And today (over 48 hours after finishing the last ride) I still have pain in the top of my left leg.  If I was new to riding, or just getting used to the saddle I'd kind of expect that, but I've been on this saddle since June last year, and riding at least twice a week pretty consistently since November. 

Do I need to HTFU, or is it time to go shopping?

Maybe it's your body adjusting to the larger volume?  I took a peek at your logs and it looks like you doubled your long ride from 43 miles to 80 in a week.  I get pain like that initially but when I slowly increase the volume my body adjusts and I feel no pain.  But if you are consistently riding that distance and still feeling the pain then I'd say it's probably your saddle. 

2012-04-10 8:39 PM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

Master
1531
100050025
TORONTO
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed

So I went to my local library and ordered the book everyone is talking about.  I didn't feel like spending more money on yet another running/cycling/triathlon book.  But... then my family bought me a Kindle for my birthday so now I get my own copy for less than I'd pay at the bookstore!  My hubby - a non runner/triathlete - must think I'm whacked.  The last book I read was "Run Less Run Faster" and now I'm about to start reading a book that will tell me to run slower.  ?!

Got an easy run in this morning but missed my evening swim.  I find it so hard between homework, dog walking, dinner etc etc to get my butt out the door in time for a decent pool swim!  The fear of having to swim 2000m in the not-so-distant future is a bit motivating!!

2012-04-10 8:39 PM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

Veteran
452
1001001001002525
Colorado Springs
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed

Someone posted about areo bars....  I started using clip ons at the beginning of the year and I love them.  Because it was to clod to ride outside I benefited from the trainer and just getting used to being in the aero  position.  I felt wobbly the first few times out doors but I am getting much better. Like everything it just takes a little time.

Today was supposed to be hill intervals on the bike but our son was sick so I waited for Scott to get home to do the Spinervals Speed/Power Intervals Time Saver workout.  

27:29 6.71 miles 14.65mph Avg HR 152.. Felt good to feel the burn!  But I didn't eat enough throughout the day.  Very light headed at the end.  Might be due to the lack of oxygen in this town...LOL!!!

2012-04-10 8:44 PM
in reply to: #4142097

User image

Extreme Veteran
622
500100
Dubai, United Arab Emirates
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
chapfallen - 2012-04-10 7:42 PM

Meant to post this sooner, but life/work got in the way.

We went for what felt like a mammoth bike ride on Sunday.  We did the whole route that we'd planned for the week before.  In total it was just over 85miles, which is only 5 miles longer than the previous week, but the elevation was ridiculous.  I actually had to get off and walk up a hill for the first time in about a year and half.  (I nearly cried...).  But I'm really proud that we did it.

Following on from a couple of weekends of long rides, I have a question for the group.  For those with experience of a lot of long riding, how saddle sore is normal?  I'm trying to decide if I should be looking for a new saddle.  I've currently got the Adamo Road, which dealt with a number of problems that I had with saddles last year.  However, the longer I ride on it, the more I realise that it's still quite uncomfortable.  After cycling 60 miles on Friday, when I got on the bike on Sunday I actually felt like someone was stabbing me in my sit bones.  And today (over 48 hours after finishing the last ride) I still have pain in the top of my left leg.  If I was new to riding, or just getting used to the saddle I'd kind of expect that, but I've been on this saddle since June last year, and riding at least twice a week pretty consistently since November. 

Do I need to HTFU, or is it time to go shopping?

I have similar experiences when I increase my distances quickly. Give it a couple more weeks with those distances and see how it feels then. If no changes, might want to consider changing saddle. Or, maybe the shorts are the problem?

2012-04-10 8:51 PM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

New user
90
252525
Austin
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed

First day back in the pool in a LONG time and although it wasn't a long workout, just 1500m, I felt great, didn't feel like I really worked hard AND my main set of 10x100m with 30second rest was my best ever as each 100 was about 1:55.  Normally I'm around 2:20. 

Don't know if it's because of all the running and I'm just able to go faster or what.  Maybe I learned a little better form by osmosis or something



2012-04-10 8:51 PM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

Veteran
452
1001001001002525
Colorado Springs
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed

Oh- Forgot to mention.. Garmin was great about replacing my HR monitor and I love the new one!!!!

Also- Chris... As you know I've been struggling with shoes and feet issues from the beginning.  I did take your advice and get a pair of Fivefingers.  I walk in them or wear them to the kids track practice so far.  I was looking into the Newton shoes and I think I want to try them out...  I ordered some Asics in the meantime.  The Brooks the Dr had me in were almost the death of me!  Let me know how they are.  I was looking at the Motion line though.  

2012-04-10 8:51 PM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

Master
1531
100050025
TORONTO
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed

For those of you using clip on aero bars - can you recommend a brand?

Thanks
Marcia

2012-04-10 9:07 PM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

Master
3022
20001000
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
Re: Maffetone - I've never done a MAF run - but the philosophy behind it is solid.  As Jim said, the MAF # works pretty spot on for the high majority of the population.  The key part of the philosophy is slowing down to build a large aerobic base through the ability to run consistently with higher volume...at least that is my understanding.  While never doing a MAF run I spent Nov. through Feb running pretty much 9+ minute miles - a first for me - and the benefits are obvious.  I can knock out 12 miles at a pace that would be a PR for me in the past and recover within a day and go back for more.  Build the engine slowly and you will benefit in the long run.  I don't think the magic is in the MAF # but what the MAF # or HR allows you to accomplish.

Edited by dangremond 2012-04-10 9:09 PM
2012-04-10 9:34 PM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

Veteran
419
100100100100
clayton
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed


Edited by markhodges1973 2012-04-10 9:47 PM
2012-04-10 9:34 PM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

Veteran
419
100100100100
clayton
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed

more MAF questions:

From what I have read it seems to be more suited to athletes performing longer distances?

I understand the idea of slower runs lowers HR over time, but all i read/see are people running really slow for several months before achieveing PR's - so does this MAF method eventually add 'speed' workouts that are typical to normal training programs?

Does it only improve running - I have seen no reference to cycling.

I am still a novice but I know importance of carbs in diet, but I get the impression that MAF reduces/removes carbs from a diet - is this right?

Mark.



Edited by markhodges1973 2012-04-10 9:42 PM


2012-04-10 9:36 PM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

Expert
2811
2000500100100100
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
Tonight what started as a TT ride while waiting for my daughter's softball practice turned into time trial Hell.  I went on a road I had never taken before, it had several rough patches, and the entire out was 25-30 mph head winds. Half way out light misty rain, then light snow. I finally made it to the turn around to get pelted with hail. The back was fun because 25-30 mph headwinds were now 25-30 mph tail winds. My split was 17:23 out, 13:09 back. So 9 miles in 30:32. 
2012-04-10 9:44 PM
in reply to: #4142097

User image

Master
2238
200010010025
Dallas
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
chapfallen - 2012-04-10 7:42 PM

Meant to post this sooner, but life/work got in the way.

We went for what felt like a mammoth bike ride on Sunday.  We did the whole route that we'd planned for the week before.  In total it was just over 85miles, which is only 5 miles longer than the previous week, but the elevation was ridiculous.  I actually had to get off and walk up a hill for the first time in about a year and half.  (I nearly cried...).  But I'm really proud that we did it.

Following on from a couple of weekends of long rides, I have a question for the group.  For those with experience of a lot of long riding, how saddle sore is normal?  I'm trying to decide if I should be looking for a new saddle.  I've currently got the Adamo Road, which dealt with a number of problems that I had with saddles last year.  However, the longer I ride on it, the more I realise that it's still quite uncomfortable.  After cycling 60 miles on Friday, when I got on the bike on Sunday I actually felt like someone was stabbing me in my sit bones.  And today (over 48 hours after finishing the last ride) I still have pain in the top of my left leg.  If I was new to riding, or just getting used to the saddle I'd kind of expect that, but I've been on this saddle since June last year, and riding at least twice a week pretty consistently since November. 

Do I need to HTFU, or is it time to go shopping?

First of all Rachel, congratulations to you and Kevin on accomplishing such a tough ride. I saw the pics on facebook too! About the saddle sores, it could be a bit of both (big mileage increase and wrong seat). The saddle is arguably the most rider specific piece of equipment in the entire bike, it has to do primarily with the distance between the sitbones, being male or female (there's a growing number of female specific saddles), weight of the user and most of all how it feels after mile fifty.

Lots of bicycle shops offer a no hassle return/exchange policy, some as long as 90 days. Make use of it and try until you find your match. It took me about a year.

2012-04-10 9:50 PM
in reply to: #4142308

User image

Master
2238
200010010025
Dallas
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
markhodges1973 - 2012-04-10 9:34 PM

more MAF questions:

From what I have read it seems to be more suited to athletes performing longer distances?

I understand the idea of slower runs lowers HR over time, but all i read/see are people running really slow for several months before achieveing PR's - so does this MAF method eventually add 'speed' workouts that are typical to normal training programs?

Does it only improve running - I have seen no reference to cycling.

I am still a novice but I know importance of carbs in diet, but I get the impression that MAF reduces/removes carbs from a diet - is this right?

Mark.

To question number one, the answer is no. Even the fastest olympic distance athletes in the world put an enormous amount of "slow" miles.

Speed training is addressed.

It applies to all three sports, mostly cycling and running. The pool is hard because of two reasons, perception in the pool is that you're going harder than what you really are and second, most HR monitors don't work in the water. Therefore you have to go by a (skewed) effort perception.

About the diet, it promotes the ingestion of healthy carbs and reduces almost to the point of elimination anything starchy like potatoes, rice, flours, grains, etc. Even certain types of beans are restricted. When it comes to the food part though, I suck at following my own advice...



Edited by ernestov 2012-04-10 9:53 PM
2012-04-10 10:01 PM
in reply to: #4141862

User image

Maple Grove, MN
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
FoggyGoggles - 2012-04-10 4:47 PM

Out of curiosity, if a person is doing a mix of sprint and long distance training would this method work for him or her. For example, I am doing two sprint tris prior to a HIM this season. I can easily hold a higher HR for 3.12 miles and push for a decent 5K time. Would this be counterintuitive to this type of training?



Adrian (Foggy),

I do a mix of sprints, olympics, and this season, my first HIM. I also do running races ranging from 5k's to marathons. My history is as follows.

I did a half marathon last May (the Maple Grove Half) and did ok, 1:38:02. Then I went right into training hard for the Liberty Tri Olympic. I felt really crappy about the whole race and was convinced I overtrained (all my workouts hard). (I did it in 2:48:17, or worse than 50% for my age group.) So I did nothing but Maffetone runs (heart rate 180 - age) for 3 weeks. When I started, I was doing between 10 and 12 minute miles to keep my heart rate at 180 - age. Then I switched to a marathon training plan and did all my runs except intervals and pace runs at 180-age (I totally dropped swimming and biking).

In August, I did the Maple Grove Tri (sprint) and did, for me, very well. 1:22:27. My bike was, according to my Garmin, about 19 mph and my run was at a 6:55 pace.

In October, I did the Twin Cities Marathon. 3:35:59, which is ok for a first.

In November, I did the Drumstick Dash 10k and improved my PR from a year previous by over 2 minutes. Between that and the end of January I did NO runs faster than Maffetone. and in January I did the Securian Half Marathon in 1:35:21, or a 2:40 improvement. So for two months, I basically did ALL 9 minute or slower miles and then ran a half with 7:18 miles.

Basically, if you do a lot of slow runs you do NOT forget how to run fast. When the time comes, you just do it.

And I have steadily improved the pace at which I can run at 180-age. (I'm now down to about 8:40. And remember, my 180-age is a hell of a lot smaller number than yours).

My guess is it helps most at longer distances, but it helps at shorter distances as well.

The actual 180-age doesn't matter is my guess. Instead, it is a simple rule that embodies the wisdom that most people do their slow runs too fast and their fast runs too slow.
2012-04-10 10:34 PM
in reply to: #4142353

User image

Veteran
419
100100100100
clayton
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed

thanks, Ernesto - I guess the proof is in the pudding as they say, so once I get this season out the way I'll look into giving it a tri :-)

... and James thanks for the links, posed good reading for and against.



Edited by markhodges1973 2012-04-10 10:35 PM


2012-04-11 5:33 AM
in reply to: #4142329

User image

Extreme Veteran
692
500100252525
England
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
ernestov - 2012-04-11 3:44 AM
chapfallen - 2012-04-10 7:42 PM

Meant to post this sooner, but life/work got in the way.

We went for what felt like a mammoth bike ride on Sunday.  We did the whole route that we'd planned for the week before.  In total it was just over 85miles, which is only 5 miles longer than the previous week, but the elevation was ridiculous.  I actually had to get off and walk up a hill for the first time in about a year and half.  (I nearly cried...).  But I'm really proud that we did it.

Following on from a couple of weekends of long rides, I have a question for the group.  For those with experience of a lot of long riding, how saddle sore is normal?  I'm trying to decide if I should be looking for a new saddle.  I've currently got the Adamo Road, which dealt with a number of problems that I had with saddles last year.  However, the longer I ride on it, the more I realise that it's still quite uncomfortable.  After cycling 60 miles on Friday, when I got on the bike on Sunday I actually felt like someone was stabbing me in my sit bones.  And today (over 48 hours after finishing the last ride) I still have pain in the top of my left leg.  If I was new to riding, or just getting used to the saddle I'd kind of expect that, but I've been on this saddle since June last year, and riding at least twice a week pretty consistently since November. 

Do I need to HTFU, or is it time to go shopping?

First of all Rachel, congratulations to you and Kevin on accomplishing such a tough ride. I saw the pics on facebook too! About the saddle sores, it could be a bit of both (big mileage increase and wrong seat). The saddle is arguably the most rider specific piece of equipment in the entire bike, it has to do primarily with the distance between the sitbones, being male or female (there's a growing number of female specific saddles), weight of the user and most of all how it feels after mile fifty.

Lots of bicycle shops offer a no hassle return/exchange policy, some as long as 90 days. Make use of it and try until you find your match. It took me about a year.

Thanks to everyone for your comments.  I know I've increased my mileage a lot recently, but looking back, even when I was doing all my winter training on the turbo and my longest ride was an hour, I was still getting quite a lot of pain.  At the time I took the attitude that I was just getting used to doing 3 rides a week, blah blah blah.  However, I think I've given it long enough, and of course with the increase in mileage comes an increase in pain.

Having spent the entire bike section of my HIM last year with significant saddle issues I REALLY don't want to have the same problem at IM (for twice as long!), so I guess it's time to start shopping around.

2012-04-11 5:37 AM
in reply to: #4142068

User image

Master
3022
20001000
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
gobluedds - 2012-04-10 8:20 PM

 

Racing this weekend.  Full marathon.  Maybe I'll see you there Mitch! Not looking for stellar time as training this winter was fairly sporadic.  Feeling pretty good this week so far and the weather looks decent for the weekend, so who knows....

 

Are you doing the Martian?  The full starts a bit before the half - maybe run into you at the finish?

2012-04-11 7:52 AM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

Extreme Veteran
592
500252525
Long Island
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
So what's the groups thoughts on a first time Marathon plan? I'm currently leaning towards the Hal Hidgon Novice 2 plan ( http://www.halhigdon.com/training/51138/Marathon-Novice-2-Training-Program  for MCM in the fall. It's basically 4 runs per week with one long and 1 tempo. It appeals to me because of the simplicity, I'm a real shiny object distractable kinda guy (Just ask Marcia or David )
2012-04-11 7:55 AM
in reply to: #4142385

User image

Expert
2811
2000500100100100
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
markhodges1973 - 2012-04-10 10:34 PM

thanks, Ernesto - I guess the proof is in the pudding as they say, so once I get this season out the way I'll look into giving it a tri :-)

... and James thanks for the links, posed good reading for and against.

I did a lot of research before I decided to try it, and then after chasing my tail for a few weeks decided to just try it. I was frusterated because I had plateaued and knew I needed to change soomething. I just started mixing in some speed work. To be honest, I don't like sprints, so I do most of my speed work playing adult soccer. Its fun to be the old guy with more endurance and better speed than 20 year olds Laughing.

2012-04-11 8:10 AM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

Master
3022
20001000
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed

Scott:

I was poking around your race listing and saw that you had done Big Fish back in 2009.  That was the last tri I did before my now 2 year old shook up my world for a bit.  In fact, we found out we were having her I think just a couple days before the race.  I woke up with vertigo that morning but got to the race regardless.  I finished a hair behind you...small world!

-Mitch

Place Sex/Tot  No.  Name    Ag Sex City/state     Rank Swim    Pace  T1      Rank Bike    Rate T2      Rank Run     Pace  Finish 

===== ======== ==== =================== == === =================== ==== ======= ===== 

   35  31/121   139 Scott          39 M   Ft. Gratiot MI        36    9:32  1:55    2:14   58   41:31  17.9    1:08   49   24:17  7:49 1:18:39

   37  33/121    44 Mitchell        38 M   Troy MI              122   12:03  2:25    1:53   34   39:30  18.8    1:07   52   24:25  7:52 1:18:56



2012-04-11 8:23 AM
in reply to: #4142748

User image

Master
3022
20001000
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed

Sammeg - 2012-04-11 8:52 AM So what's the groups thoughts on a first time Marathon plan? I'm currently leaning towards the Hal Hidgon Novice 2 plan ( http://www.halhigdon.com/training/51138/Marathon-Novice-2-Training-Program  for MCM in the fall. It's basically 4 runs per week with one long and 1 tempo. It appeals to me because of the simplicity, I'm a real shiny object distractable kinda guy (Just ask Marcia or David )

What other races do you have on your calendar prior to the Marathon.  How many weeks until the marathon from today?  I'm asking because I think (1) it's incredibly hard to train appropriately for HM and longer while also trying to focus on triathlon training (just my opinion) and (2) I think 4 days isn't enough.  I think if you want to run a marathon you should begin working toward running 5 to 6 days a week (preferably 6)...all easy and then slide into an appropriate training plan that has a similar # of days of running.  How much are you currently running per week (total miles, total days, how are the runs broken down)?  Also, your training log is restricted to friends for viewing - no issues with that - but wondering if you'd open it up to the mentor group?

2012-04-11 8:57 AM
in reply to: #4142845

User image

Extreme Veteran
592
500252525
Long Island
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
dangremond - 2012-04-11 9:23 AM

Sammeg - 2012-04-11 8:52 AM So what's the groups thoughts on a first time Marathon plan? I'm currently leaning towards the Hal Hidgon Novice 2 plan ( http://www.halhigdon.com/training/51138/Marathon-Novice-2-Training-Program  for MCM in the fall. It's basically 4 runs per week with one long and 1 tempo. It appeals to me because of the simplicity, I'm a real shiny object distractable kinda guy (Just ask Marcia or David )

What other races do you have on your calendar prior to the Marathon.  How many weeks until the marathon from today?  I'm asking because I think (1) it's incredibly hard to train appropriately for HM and longer while also trying to focus on triathlon training (just my opinion) and (2) I think 4 days isn't enough.  I think if you want to run a marathon you should begin working toward running 5 to 6 days a week (preferably 6)...all easy and then slide into an appropriate training plan that has a similar # of days of running.  How much are you currently running per week (total miles, total days, how are the runs broken down)?  Also, your training log is restricted to friends for viewing - no issues with that - but wondering if you'd open it up to the mentor group?

Thanks for the feedback Mitch. My training for the last coupla months has been basically nil but I'm 25 weeks out from the race and was planning on building base back up over the next 6-7 weeks to begin the 18 week Marathon plan. I don't have alot of races on the calendar, Oly at the end of July, coupla summer sprints, an Oly the first week of September and that's it. I was figuring I'd folllow the 4 days per week plan through the summer(last oly of the season) and have 8 weeks prior to the race to add runs during the week.

Been planning on adding the group to my logs as soon as I compile the list of peeps in the group

 

2012-04-11 9:14 AM
in reply to: #4123283

User image

Extreme Veteran
592
500252525
Long Island
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed
HAPPY BIRTHDAY MARCIA(KIMMAX). Hope you have a great day!!!
2012-04-11 9:42 AM
in reply to: #4143035

User image

Master
1531
100050025
TORONTO
Subject: RE: Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed

Sammeg - 2012-04-11 10:14 AM HAPPY BIRTHDAY MARCIA(KIMMAX). Hope you have a great day!!!

Way to keep a secret!!!

New Thread
BT Development Mentor Program Archives » Ernesto's group (4th season) - Closed Rss Feed  
 
 
of 188