General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Bolt is out of this world Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 3
 
 
2008-08-22 12:54 PM
in reply to: #1621578


18

Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world

docswim24 - 2008-08-22 12:27 PM Do you also believe Phelps was/is doping?

Can't really say about him, since no really big names have ever been busted for doping in swimming I would go ahead and say he is innocent until proven guilty. And the fact that he has won some of his gold medals by a slim margin also goes to his favour.



2008-08-22 12:59 PM
in reply to: #1621676

User image

Master
1420
1000100100100100
Reston, VA
Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world
Azzuri - 2008-08-22 1:54 PM

docswim24 - 2008-08-22 12:27 PM Do you also believe Phelps was/is doping?

Can't really say about him, since no really big names have ever been busted for doping in swimming I would go ahead and say he is innocent until proven guilty. And the fact that he has won some of his gold medals by a slim margin also goes to his favour.



Plenty of big name swimmers have been busted for doping....including entire teams.

So if Bolt won the 100 and 200 by a lot and 400 and 800 but by slim margins this would go in his favor?
2008-08-22 12:59 PM
in reply to: #1621595


18

Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world
DanielG - 2008-08-22 12:32 PM
Azzuri - 2008-08-22 1:10 PM

Even though i believe he dopes, tell truth i can't hate him for it I would too. If i spent the better part of my life training in a sport and I knew I was the best in the world at it but couldn't prove it because the top athletes were doping, then hell I would take the drugs too. The truth is way more money and science goes into preventing detection of drugs then actually detecting. So although I think Bolt is worthy or praise, let's not fool ourselves into thinking he is clean.

So, because you would, you believe everyone else would as well?

 

How sad. 

No, I do believe though that when most people are faced with the choice of making out a modest living or making millions by doping they will take the road to the millions every day of the week and twice on Sunday.

2008-08-22 1:03 PM
in reply to: #1621578

User image

Expert
938
50010010010010025
Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world

docswim24 - 2008-08-22 1:27 PM Do you also believe Phelps was/is doping?

Who cares?   Michael Phelps is not even the best American swimmer!  Chad Johnson says he can beat him swimming, as well as some of his friends could beat him.

Chad Johnson told ESPN last week that he knew several people in Liberty City, Miami who could beat Phelps in a race. He said if Phelps went there, he would find people that could beat him in the inner city, people who could not make it to Beijing to compete.

Johnson also stated that he was three-time champ at Charles Hadly school, an elementary school in Miami.

I mean what more of a resume do you need? 

 

2008-08-22 1:03 PM
in reply to: #1621676

User image

Giver
18427
5000500050002000100010010010010025
Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world
Azzuri - 2008-08-22 1:54 PM

 

Can't really say about him, since no really big names have ever been busted for doping in swimming I would go ahead and say he is innocent until proven guilty.

Dude...seriously? You don't know much about swimming then.

2008-08-22 1:09 PM
in reply to: #1621676

User image

Champion
5117
5000100
Brandon, MS
Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world
Azzuri - 2008-08-22 12:54 PM

docswim24 - 2008-08-22 12:27 PM Do you also believe Phelps was/is doping?

Can't really say about him, since no really big names have ever been busted for doping in swimming I would go ahead and say he is innocent until proven guilty. And the fact that he has won some of his gold medals by a slim margin also goes to his favour.

Jessica Hardy and Ouyang Kunpeng right before the games.

I just don't see how you can accuse Bolt of doping, yet at the same time give Phelps and other swimmers the benefit of the doubt after they obliterated world record after world record.

FWIW, Gary Hall, Jr. has said the new LZR suit is a convenient excuse to cover up a large doping problem in swimming.  While I'm not sure how much credence I give to his opionion, it happened in 1976 and could certainly be happening again.



2008-08-22 1:16 PM
in reply to: #1621692


18

Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world
docswim24 - 2008-08-22 12:59 PM
Azzuri - 2008-08-22 1:54 PM

docswim24 - 2008-08-22 12:27 PM Do you also believe Phelps was/is doping?

Can't really say about him, since no really big names have ever been busted for doping in swimming I would go ahead and say he is innocent until proven guilty. And the fact that he has won some of his gold medals by a slim margin also goes to his favour.

Plenty of big name swimmers have been busted for doping....including entire teams. So if Bolt won the 100 and 200 by a lot and 400 and 800 but by slim margins this would go in his favor?

I will admit I Know little to nothing about swimming so I can't comment on Phelps. However if he is able to smash the records of a swimmer who has been busted for doping then I think we can all come to a consensus about what he is taking.

All of us being athletes of one form or another can all understand the concept of diminishing marginal returns. The more and more you train at something the less results or benefit you will gain from additional training. This is why most often the top elite athletes in a certain sport will be fairly close to one another. This is because they train all day anyway, so if after training for 6 hrs. a day one of them decides to train an extra hr., he is not going to gain that great of a benefit for it because of diminishing returns.

This is why I'm very suspicious whenever I see an athlete completely tear up the competition like Bolt did. But hey don't let me stop you, if you trully believe he was engineered by God and is wholly clean who am I to stop you.

2008-08-22 1:26 PM
in reply to: #1621728

User image

Giver
18427
5000500050002000100010010010010025
Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world

Azzuri - 2008-08-22 2:16 PM However if he is able to smash the records of a swimmer who has been busted for doping then I think we can all come to a consensus about what he is taking.

I think this is the  flaw in your argument.

You seem to be assuming that if you dope, you set crazy world records. That's clearly not the case not the case. I could have a world-class pharmacy at my disposal, but I'm not going to hop in the pool and throw down a 46.5 100 free. So you can't assume that a performance by a doper equals the pinnacle of human acheivement.

Say, for instance, that today I can drop a 59 second 100 free. If I maintain my current training regimen and dope for a year, maybe I get down to 57.0 Hell, maybe I drop 4 seconds and go 55.0. Now...I'm a doper with a 55 second 100 free. Does that mean everyone in the world who can go faster must also be doping? Because that seems to be your argument.

You have every right to be skeptical; it's just that your logic seems to be extremely flawed.



Edited by run4yrlif 2008-08-22 1:27 PM
2008-08-22 1:58 PM
in reply to: #1616471

User image

Extreme Veteran
790
500100100252525
Rocklin
Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world
I think it's ridiculous to assume someone is doping because they are bigger, better, and faster than their predecessors. Here is my take on why that argument fails:

1. Better Training Plans -- There is no disputing that training regimens have evolved over the past 30 years. Heck, when I played baseball professionally, lifting weights was taboo (that was in 95') Now, training is mandatory. They are just getting better at figuring out how to get the most of the human body through training...there is no disputing that fact.

2. Better Nutrition -- We are constantly updating our idea of fueling the human body. Gone are the days of steak, potatos, and tons of carbs the night before. These guys are using science to figure out the optimum level of fuel for their particular sports.

3. Greater Facilities -- The olympic announcers called it before the track events that the track was the fastest they had ever seen. Not to mention, smaller countries are spending money on training facilities that provide a better structure for their athletes.

4. Better Recruiiting -- Gone are the days when the best athletes play football, basketball, and baseball by default. At least 3 of our sprinters played college football, and all three passed on the opportunity to pursue a lucrative career in the NFL for track and field.

5. Big Money for Olympic Sports -- Athletes can now focus on training alone since the best make tons of money in endorsements before they ever set foot on an olympic track. Appearance fees are also a big incentive for the elite track and field athletes and swimmers.

6. Technology -- speed suits, swim suits, lighter shoes, bikes, compression shorts. Each of these technologies helps when you measure records to the hundreth of a second.

I see at least six reasons why these guys are doing what they are doing. Just saying they are too good is a totally baseless conclusory statement. Let's see some facts regarding Phelps...Bolt...LA...Kobe...Michael Jordan...Ladanian Tomlinson...Barry Bonds (oops)

Edited by aggiecatcher 2008-08-22 2:02 PM
2008-08-22 2:49 PM
in reply to: #1616471

Regular
134
10025
SF Bay Area, CA
Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world
The problem is that we know there are drugs that they can take that can not be detected.  I believe if you take Human Growth Hormone (HGH) through adolescence you will grow up to be taller, stronger, etc.  (sound familiar?) So, since there are drugs that cant be detected, we can never know for sure if they doped.
2008-08-22 2:53 PM
in reply to: #1621974

User image

Extreme Veteran
790
500100100252525
Rocklin
Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world
Winston63 - 2008-08-22 12:49 PM

The problem is that we know there are drugs that they can take that can not be detected.  I believe if you take Human Growth Hormone (HGH) through adolescence you will grow up to be taller, stronger, etc.  (sound familiar?) So, since there are drugs that cant be detected, we can never know for sure if they doped.


Wow, that's sad that you think that way...you must be a lawyer. I believe that most people are clean, but its hard not to think about the few that get caught. You must be suffering from a Barry Bonds/Balco hangover.

P.S. I'm a black-hearted lawyer.


2008-08-22 3:02 PM
in reply to: #1616471

Regular
65
2525
Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world
I hate the fact that I am somewhat suspicious of an excellent performance. Whenever I see someone (in any sport) absolutely dominate their opposition, there is this voice in the back of my head that says "doper, doper, doper".

I always give the athlete the benefit of the doubt and try to suppress this voice, but it's becoming more and more difficult. I enjoy watching sports and I enjoy participating in them...and part of that enjoyment comes from watching athletes push themselves to their physical limits....it's inspirational and always puts me on such a high.

I will continue to try to assume the best in athletes and not the worst, but shame on those athletes who cheat with performance enhancing drugs...they ruin it for more the just the athletes they complete against!

I fail to see/understand how anyone using performance enhancing drugs could fee any sense of accomplishment from their false victories…it's so sad!
2008-08-22 3:38 PM
in reply to: #1619568

Veteran
197
100252525
Florida
Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world -- SPOILER
"Millco - 2008-08-21 3:51 PM "Bad form to post a spoiler like that without warning." Edited by JohnnyKay 2008-08-20 2:25 PM I am curious to why you would come to a current event forum, click on a link about an Olympic athlete, and be surprised to find out a result, and then post bad form to a person.

A couple of things:

1) It's not a current events forum.

2) Saying "Bolt is out of this world" in the thread title pretty much gives away what the thread is about *without* clicking on it. You don't have to be a genius to immediately discern, based onthe time the thread was posted and the olympic schedule that Bolt did something extraordinary in his race."






I hear what you are saying, but common sense says if you DONT want to know the outcome of a certain event in the largest sporting event in the world DO NOT LOOK AT THE NET, much less a forum that POSTS ABOUT SPORTS. YOU made the choice to go on the net and to check a forum that post about sporting events, and then complain about hearing about sporting events.

Sorry your fault IMHO, but hey in the long run who cares, peace man peace man.

2008-08-22 3:59 PM
in reply to: #1621693

User image

Subject: RE: Bolt is out of this world
Azzuri - 2008-08-22 1:59 PM
DanielG - 2008-08-22 12:32 PM
Azzuri - 2008-08-22 1:10 PM

Even though i believe he dopes, tell truth i can't hate him for it I would too. If i spent the better part of my life training in a sport and I knew I was the best in the world at it but couldn't prove it because the top athletes were doping, then hell I would take the drugs too. The truth is way more money and science goes into preventing detection of drugs then actually detecting. So although I think Bolt is worthy or praise, let's not fool ourselves into thinking he is clean.

So, because you would, you believe everyone else would as well?

 

How sad.

No, I do believe though that when most people are faced with the choice of making out a modest living or making millions by doping they will take the road to the millions every day of the week and twice on Sunday.

 

What a shame.  Perhaps you should look into changing your acquaintance group.  There are very few people I know that would cheat to get much of anything.  In the morning you still have to look at yourself in the mirror and that's a chore if you did not get where you are honestly.

 

Seriously, find new friends if that's the way everyone around you thinks.  They'll drag you down and you'll start believing it normal. 

New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Bolt is out of this world Rss Feed  
 
 
of 3