General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Strokes per length Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 2
 
 
2010-10-26 10:22 PM

User image

Master
1858
10005001001001002525
Salt Lake City
Subject: Strokes per length
I swim in a 25m pool, and when counting my strokes per length I'm usually around 23-25 counting every time a hand goes in the water.  Would this be considered a lot, and does it suggest a big issue with my stroke?


2010-10-27 4:18 AM
in reply to: #3174153

User image

Regular
68
2525
Bromsgrove, Midlands
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
Thats about the same as mine but it all depends on your body measurements, eg height, arm length, etc.

I believe the shorter you are the faster your stroke count.

For the record Im 6 ft and arm length is pretty much equal to my height.
 
2010-10-27 5:25 AM
in reply to: #3174153

Extreme Veteran
458
1001001001002525
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
Yes, that's a lot, a whole lot.  I'd try to work on getting under 20, closer to 16-18,
2010-10-27 7:24 AM
in reply to: #3174153

User image

Extreme Veteran
681
500100252525
Mount Joy
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
Like h20 Killer said, that is way to much. Your stroke count should be anywhere from about 14-19. everyone has a different stroke, but taking that many strokes is just wasting energy. Try to develop your pull a little bit more so that you get more glide out of your stroke. 
2010-10-27 7:31 AM
in reply to: #3174153

User image

Master
1699
1000500100252525
Malvern, PA
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
I like dragging my thumb across my thigh on each stroke - makes for a longer stroke and almost automatically lowers your stroke count...

good luck!

2010-10-27 7:37 AM
in reply to: #3174153

Regular
174
1002525
CT
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
Yeah, sounds high, with some slight mods you should be 20-21 in no time.  I'm now 18-19 after not much work.   
But i did watch another guy do almost 50 strokes in 25 meters, that was just painful to observe.


2010-10-27 7:42 AM
in reply to: #3174153

User image

Master
3195
20001000100252525
Just South of Boston
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
I started swimming less than 4 months ago, and was mid 20's when I started (and dying after 25 yards). with a few lessons, and some pool time, I'm down to 18/20 consistently, and working on getting to 15-17 consistently. I think it comes down to pool time and knowing when you're stroke is proper vs fighting the water.
2010-10-27 7:50 AM
in reply to: #3174153

User image

Extreme Veteran
732
50010010025
Omaha, USA
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
2010-10-27 7:52 AM
in reply to: #3174153

User image

Pro
6191
50001000100252525
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
I do about 14, but I've been swimming forever.

A good drill to do is a set where you drop your stroke count by 2 strokes. At first, it's awkward, and you end up kicking a lot, but it helps you learn how to use your strokes effectively over time.

for example, do 6x50s with 20-30 seconds rest, and drop your stroke count per 25 from 25 to 15 over the set:
25-23-21-19-17-15

We used to do them down to 10. It's weird, but it really makes you think about getting the full power out of each stroke. 
2010-10-27 8:17 AM
in reply to: #3174153

New user
67
2525
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
First off, it depends on how fast you are going when you do this 23-25 spl, and how long your pushoffs are.

For context, you are taking about the same, or maybe even a few LESS strokes per length than Janet Evans (who was doing 50-55 in a 50m pool in her heyday, 15:50ish for a 1500m), and a good deal MORE than Grant Hackett during his 14:35 for a 1500m. Hacketts took about 34 strokes per length in a 50m pool, with a 5m pushoff at the beginning of each length. So, assuming the same pushoff in a 25m pool, he would be taking about 15 strokes per length ( (25-5) * ( 34 / (50-5)) ).

Of course, Hackett is over 6 feet, and Evans was just barely over 5. I give a bit more broad review of stroke rates in elite pool swimmer here (all done in a 50m pool): http://www.findingfreestyle.com/passive-technique-blog/strokeratesi...

regards,
r.b.
2010-10-27 9:45 AM
in reply to: #3174551

Extreme Veteran
458
1001001001002525
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
robertwb - 2010-10-27 8:17 AM First off, it depends on how fast you are going when you do this 23-25 spl, and how long your pushoffs are. For context, you are taking about the same, or maybe even a few LESS strokes per length than Janet Evans (who was doing 50-55 in a 50m pool in her heyday, 15:50ish for a 1500m), and a good deal MORE than Grant Hackett during his 14:35 for a 1500m. Hacketts took about 34 strokes per length in a 50m pool, with a 5m pushoff at the beginning of each length. So, assuming the same pushoff in a 25m pool, he would be taking about 15 strokes per length ( (25-5) * ( 34 / (50-5)) ). Of course, Hackett is over 6 feet, and Evans was just barely over 5. I give a bit more broad review of stroke rates in elite pool swimmer here (all done in a 50m pool): http://www.findingfreestyle.com/passive-technique-blog/strokeratesi... regards, r.b.


Most people consider Janet Evans to be the greatest female swimmer of all time.  I consider her to be the greatest swimmer, male or female, of all time.  Comparing a newbie to JE is crazy.  JE was taking this many strokes LCM, not SCM, as the OP stated, which makes a big difference.  She also has a legendary turnover rate.  I never think it is good to compare yourself to the studs of all time.


2010-10-27 9:52 AM
in reply to: #3174371

User image

Champion
11989
500050001000500100100100100252525
Philly 'burbs
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
H20 Killer - 2010-10-27 6:25 AM Yes, that's a lot, a whole lot.  I'd try to work on getting under 20, closer to 16-18,


swimmer04 - 2010-10-27 8:24 AM Like h20 Killer said, that is way to much. Your stroke count should be anywhere from about 14-19. everyone has a different stroke, but taking that many strokes is just wasting energy. Try to develop your pull a little bit more so that you get more glide out of your stroke. 


Are you counting every time each hand hits the water? I don't really count strokes, but I'm pretty sure for me that each hand goes in the water more than 7-9 times.

I suppose the wall push is a factor too. I see some swimmers glide under water a lot longer than I do.
2010-10-27 9:57 AM
in reply to: #3174371

User image

Coach
9167
5000200020001002525
Stairway to Seven
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
Try to develop your pull a little bit more so that you get more glide out of your stroke. 


Beware of confusing streamlining with propulsion...they are two different (but obviously connected) components of swimming well.

For the OP, a few things will probably help him optimize his stroke count...

1) First and foremost is always goign to be balance...front to back balance in the water will reduce your cross sectional area presented to the water, so the same movements that move you forward will move you FURTHER if your balance is good. No need to power more with the stroke.

2) Streamlining. Similar to #1, but more refined. What things are going on that are causing more drag than propulsion? Enjoy the streamline by reaching forward in a diagonal line from outreached arm to the opposite, rearward stretched leg. Reducing things like wide kicks, scissor kicks, a wobbly core that allows your body to wiggle from side to side while you swim...will all help you streamline more.

Both of these things will let you move further with each stroke, and while they may feel odd...they will feel EASIER while letting you swim faster.

Check this blog post I just wrote about streamlining...

What can Tuna teach us about swimmign?
http://www.steelcityendurance.com/index.php?option=com_content&view...

2010-10-27 10:01 AM
in reply to: #3174153

User image

Pro
4277
20002000100100252525
Parker, CO
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
a couple years ago I tried the TI thing with the lower stroke count.  I got lower but my swimming was slower as well.  I just couldn't keep the same pace with the stroke rate that feels comfortable to me.  23/25 might be on the high side as I am around 19/21 and people have told me that's too high...but that's what works for me.

However, when I see a good swimmer in the pool I often with stop and watch and even count their stroke rate.  I've see guys/girls swimming much faster than I do with stroke rates around 14/16.  They make it look so effortless.
2010-10-27 10:06 AM
in reply to: #3174928

User image

Coach
9167
5000200020001002525
Stairway to Seven
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
rayd - 2010-10-27 9:01 AM

a couple years ago I tried the TI thing with the lower stroke count.  I got lower but my swimming was slower as well.  I just couldn't keep the same pace with the stroke rate that feels comfortable to me.  23/25 might be on the high side as I am around 19/21 and people have told me that's too high...but that's what works for me.

However, when I see a good swimmer in the pool I often with stop and watch and even count their stroke rate.  I've see guys/girls swimming much faster than I do with stroke rates around 14/16.  They make it look so effortless.


You'll never be finished polishing your swim technique...how fast do you swim at 19-21 SPL? Have you ever practiced with a tempo trainier to train a faster rate at teh same stroke count? Or a slower rate with a lower stroke count, which non-intuitively, can sometimes help you swim faster?
2010-10-27 10:17 AM
in reply to: #3174917

Extreme Veteran
458
1001001001002525
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
AdventureBear - 2010-10-27 9:57 AM
Try to develop your pull a little bit more so that you get more glide out of your stroke. 
Beware of confusing streamlining with propulsion...they are two different (but obviously connected) components of swimming well. For the OP, a few things will probably help him optimize his stroke count... 1) First and foremost is always goign to be balance...front to back balance in the water will reduce your cross sectional area presented to the water, so the same movements that move you forward will move you FURTHER if your balance is good. No need to power more with the stroke. 2) Streamlining. Similar to #1, but more refined. What things are going on that are causing more drag than propulsion? Enjoy the streamline by reaching forward in a diagonal line from outreached arm to the opposite, rearward stretched leg. Reducing things like wide kicks, scissor kicks, a wobbly core that allows your body to wiggle from side to side while you swim...will all help you streamline more. Both of these things will let you move further with each stroke, and while they may feel odd...they will feel EASIER while letting you swim faster. Check this blog post I just wrote about streamlining... What can Tuna teach us about swimmign? http://www.steelcityendurance.com/index.php?option=com_content&...


Streamlining is done off the walls, not between the flags. Between the flags it is about technique and stroke, not streamlining. 


2010-10-27 10:32 AM
in reply to: #3174153

User image

New user
30
25
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
Some great suggestions here and I will use them (I'm awful at swimming and never even thought about counting my strokes in the pool). Question though that I thought about when reading through the thread--do you push off at the wall usually? It does feel like "cheating" and I know that when I am tired it seems as if I do more of a push off than when I am first starting my swim. Does anyone just touch the wall, push off with the arms and swim without the extra push fro the legs? Maybe I'll try that.... 
2010-10-27 10:40 AM
in reply to: #3175041

Extreme Veteran
458
1001001001002525
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
jlennon - 2010-10-27 10:32 AM Some great suggestions here and I will use them (I'm awful at swimming and never even thought about counting my strokes in the pool). Question though that I thought about when reading through the thread--do you push off at the wall usually? It does feel like "cheating" and I know that when I am tired it seems as if I do more of a push off than when I am first starting my swim. Does anyone just touch the wall, push off with the arms and swim without the extra push fro the legs? Maybe I'll try that.... 


Yes, most 4 year olds in guppy class at the Y do this.
2010-10-27 10:49 AM
in reply to: #3175041

User image

Subject: RE: Strokes per length
jlennon - 2010-10-27 11:32 AM

Some great suggestions here and I will use them (I'm awful at swimming and never even thought about counting my strokes in the pool). Question though that I thought about when reading through the thread--do you push off at the wall usually? It does feel like "cheating" and I know that when I am tired it seems as if I do more of a push off than when I am first starting my swim. Does anyone just touch the wall, push off with the arms and swim without the extra push fro the legs? Maybe I'll try that.... 


Nah, push off the wall. Just get to swimming quickly and don't use that glide half way down the lane.

BTW, a buddy of mine does 21 SPL and comes out of the water in about 55 minutes for an IM so there is a lot of room for individual leeway in asking these questions.

Try faster turn over. Try slower turnover. Try beating the water to death. Try shark smooth. See which works best for you. The race is about time, not how few strokes you take.
2010-10-27 2:38 PM
in reply to: #3174978

User image

Coach
9167
5000200020001002525
Stairway to Seven
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
H20 Killer - 2010-10-27 9:17 AM

AdventureBear - 2010-10-27 9:57 AM
Try to develop your pull a little bit more so that you get more glide out of your stroke. 
Beware of confusing streamlining with propulsion...they are two different (but obviously connected) components of swimming well. For the OP, a few things will probably help him optimize his stroke count... 1) First and foremost is always goign to be balance...front to back balance in the water will reduce your cross sectional area presented to the water, so the same movements that move you forward will move you FURTHER if your balance is good. No need to power more with the stroke. 2) Streamlining. Similar to #1, but more refined. What things are going on that are causing more drag than propulsion? Enjoy the streamline by reaching forward in a diagonal line from outreached arm to the opposite, rearward stretched leg. Reducing things like wide kicks, scissor kicks, a wobbly core that allows your body to wiggle from side to side while you swim...will all help you streamline more. Both of these things will let you move further with each stroke, and while they may feel odd...they will feel EASIER while letting you swim faster. Check this blog post I just wrote about streamlining... What can Tuna teach us about swimmign? http://www.steelcityendurance.com/index.php?option=com_content&view...


Streamlining is done off the walls, not between the flags. Between the flags it is about technique and stroke, not streamlining. 


You need to practice active streamlining with every stroke. Good swimmers do it without thiking, but slower/newer swimmers do all sorts of things wtih their body parts and balance that reduce streamlining and increases drag. Drag reduction is the most important thing any swimmer can do for all parst of the stroke (and all strokes)

Here is a great example...notice how much his streamlining is improved in teh after video...the segments near the end of the clinic demonstrate this well.

http://distancedave.com/2010/10/27/looking-fast-vs-being-fast/

Edited by AdventureBear 2010-10-27 2:42 PM
2010-10-27 2:50 PM
in reply to: #3174153

User image

Expert
790
500100100252525
Frisco
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
distance dave after looked like he was swimming 3 min 100's. I like the distance dave on crack before swimming 12 second 100's.


2010-10-27 2:52 PM
in reply to: #3175108

User image

Coach
9167
5000200020001002525
Stairway to Seven
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
DanielG - 2010-10-27 9:49 AM

Try faster turn over. Try slower turnover. Try beating the water to death. Try shark smooth. See which works best for you. The race is about time, not how few strokes you take.


Except in a triathlon...the fastest swimmer rarely wins the race. As the saying goes, you can't win a triathlon with the swim, but you can lose one...
2010-10-27 3:08 PM
in reply to: #3176491

User image

Coach
9167
5000200020001002525
Stairway to Seven
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
Boogie7247 - 2010-10-27 1:50 PM

distance dave after looked like he was swimming 3 min 100's. I like the distance dave on crack before swimming 12 second 100's.


Switch the paces and you've got it right. BTW, the guy in the video is the infamous Shinji whose swimming videos rank 2nd in popularity only to michael phelps.
2010-10-27 3:09 PM
in reply to: #3174946

User image

Pro
4277
20002000100100252525
Parker, CO
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
AdventureBear - 2010-10-27 9:06 AM
rayd - 2010-10-27 9:01 AM a couple years ago I tried the TI thing with the lower stroke count.  I got lower but my swimming was slower as well.  I just couldn't keep the same pace with the stroke rate that feels comfortable to me.  23/25 might be on the high side as I am around 19/21 and people have told me that's too high...but that's what works for me.

However, when I see a good swimmer in the pool I often with stop and watch and even count their stroke rate.  I've see guys/girls swimming much faster than I do with stroke rates around 14/16.  They make it look so effortless.
You'll never be finished polishing your swim technique...how fast do you swim at 19-21 SPL? Have you ever practiced with a tempo trainier to train a faster rate at teh same stroke count? Or a slower rate with a lower stroke count, which non-intuitively, can sometimes help you swim faster?


what is a tempo trainer?  normally at 19/21 I am just under 1-minute per 100-meters for about 500 meters.  Then I get slower.  When I was trying the lower stroke count I was about 10-seconds per 100 slower and felt off-balance.
2010-10-27 3:48 PM
in reply to: #3176534

User image

Expert
790
500100100252525
Frisco
Subject: RE: Strokes per length
AdventureBear - 2010-10-27 3:08 PM
Boogie7247 - 2010-10-27 1:50 PM distance dave after looked like he was swimming 3 min 100's. I like the distance dave on crack before swimming 12 second 100's.
Switch the paces and you've got it right. BTW, the guy in the video is the infamous Shinji whose swimming videos rank 2nd in popularity only to michael phelps.


who is michael phelps


New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Strokes per length Rss Feed  
 
 
of 2