General Discussion Triathlon Talk » What's a "good" resting heart rate Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2006-06-09 9:31 AM

User image

Regular
84
252525
Subject: What's a "good" resting heart rate
Hey guys,

I know there is some talk here about ditching the HRM and all that, but i like mine just to see how well i'm working my body and how many calories i've burned and what not. My dad told me that anything over 200bpm was kind of scary territory. Well yesterday i went on a new route and after about 20 mins of running/walking i went up this HUGE hill for about a mile and when i got to the top my HR was at 212!! I am 28/female and while yes overweight, that still seemed REALLY high. I have a mild condition of EIAsthma but did some good breathing exercises to calm myself down and kept walking the rest of the way until i got my HR back down and was able to jog home.

ANyway, in light of that story, i just checked my resting HR and it was 70bpm. i've walked around a little this morning at work so i guess it's not my TRUE resting HR like if i were sleeping, but ti'll still fairly accurate I guess. Just curious if that is horrible or not. I read somewhere that Lance Armstrong's was like 10 bpm (not really but something low). But i know being my size that it'll take a while to lower.


2006-06-09 9:47 AM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Champion
7036
5000200025
Sarasota, FL
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate

Hi Jenn,

Yes, 212 bpm is pretty high.  Resting HR is a very individual thing, determined not only by conditioning, but also genetics.  Suggest you review this thread, it's a pretty comprehensive discussion of HR issues:

http://www.beginnertriathlete.com/discussion/forums/thread-view.asp?tid=25733&posts=208&start=1

Mark

2006-06-09 9:54 AM
in reply to: #448652

Elite
3650
200010005001002525
Laurium, MI
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate

i'm willing to bet you didn't hit 212.  Sometimes the HRM will glitch and get interference in the signal and cause readings like that.  The more you use the HRM, the better you will get and telling if the reading is right or if it is absolute crap.  Usually huge jumps like that are erroneous, especially if it jumps back down just as fast.

The HRM is a training tool.  You have to use it in conjunction with how you feel and what your body is telling you.  To say that the HRM is the finite measuring device and to only listen to it is as silly as saying that monitoring your HR is useless and you should only run by feel.  It's a happy medium.

If you want a good feeling for your RHR, every morning, before you get up, take it and record it (you can do it in your logs).  Over time you will start to see what is normal for you and you will be able to tell when you are about to get sick, or are pushing too hard, as it will suddenly elevate a little bit.

2006-06-09 9:57 AM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Extreme Veteran
347
10010010025
Sturtevant, WI
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
I'm going to agree that it was most likely interference, not a 212 HR. I know that my HRM jumps to 268 when I run near one of those invisible fences they have for dogs.
2006-06-09 9:58 AM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Coach
10487
50005000100100100100252525
Boston, MA
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
1st of all, who told you to ditch the HR? I use mine everyday for training with good results. Of course you shouldn’t solely rely on that because it is just another tool. You should be use as a as a method to gauge your training intensity and combine it with PE. (Remember to always listen to your body )

About your Q, there is not such a thing as a good RHR. This vary for each person and as you get fitter and older your RHR drops but to say that having "x" RHR is better than other just doesn’t make sense to me. Of course if someone is not active, overweight, with an unhealthy lifestyle and dealing with lots of stress, probably he/she will have a higher RHR than someone on the opposite end.

2006-06-09 10:05 AM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Regular
84
252525
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
heyguys, thanks. when i saw 212 I also was like, what the ****? i've manually calculated like 180 at some of my highest points of workout so I'm sure it was maybe like 185 or something cuz i definitely felt the most beats ever, but i agree that maybe it was a computer glitch. I was in a neighborhood so it coulda been a fence orsomething.

And i agree that the HRM should be a tool/aide not a sole device when working out. I've only recently bought it...used it like a month maybe. I like that it shows calories burned and was thinking of wearing it over a 24 hr period to see if it shows how many cals i burn in one day. I like the watch aspect too and being able to jump back from what time it is, to how long i've worked out, to what my current HR is and so forth. so i don't want to ditch it. I was referring to some posts I've seen where people say to ditch it and listen to your body. That is my number one rule as far as this training goes...listen to my body. And at the top of the hill my body was like...PLEASE GIVE ME SOME LONG DEEP BREATHS SO I CAN GET SOME SUFFICENT AIR FLOW!! so i did..instead of freaking out that my heart was gonna explode.

At the pool the other day for some reason my shoulder was hurting and i figured that maybe my stroke was sloppy at the end and i was overrotating, so i cut my swim short by a couple hundred yaards and just did some kicking work to cool down as to not further damage my shoulder.

Anyway thanks for all the advice. I didn't know that RHR were dfiferent for everyone so that's good to know.


2006-06-09 10:15 AM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Champion
6962
500010005001001001001002525
Atlanta, Ga
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate

I know that 0 bpm is BAD! 

Seriously, like everyone else says...it was probably a glitch.  Just like when I forgot my HR strap and I got a reading of 50 bpm 4 times when i was riding out in the middle of nowhere.  As long as you are being active, it will drop and you're all the better for it.

2006-06-09 10:18 AM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Elite
2661
20005001002525
DC Metro, slowly working my way to NC
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate

On the 212, it very well could have been a hiccup.  If I've got the out of zone alarm set to beep, I wait for it to go off 3 times in a row before I pay attention to it, because sometimes it will be 141, 144, 142, 268!!, 141. 

To get an RHR, once or twice a week I'll just wear the HRM to bed and take the overnight average.  It sounds especially anal retentive, but I am terrible at remembering to try to get an RHR in the morning before I am up and moving around. 

2006-06-09 10:41 AM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Master
1359
10001001001002525
South of SLC
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
I figure that anything over 0 when I wake up is good. Even at my most fit portion of last season, I was still only in the mid 50's. People who get down into the 40's and 30's are amazing. I am pretty sure that has something to do with genetic predisposition.

Mike
2006-06-09 11:05 AM
in reply to: #448704

User image

Extreme Veteran
367
1001001002525
Lufkin (East Texas)
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
Marvarnett - 2006-06-09 9:15 AM

I know that 0 bpm is BAD!

Funny.

It's the trend that counts not the absolute number.  Watch what it does over time.

2006-06-09 11:51 AM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Extreme Veteran
579
500252525
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
Yeah, most likely a little interference on your HRM, I have a route that has a few very low hanging power wires, when passing them mine shows 227 nearly every time. As soon as I'm past that spot it will go back down to 130 or whatever.


2006-06-09 12:11 PM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Champion
19812
50005000500020002000500100100100
MA
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate

I think your resting HR is a great tool to see how fit you are, if you are getting sick or overtrained. What is a good resting heart rate depends on you. Best way to track it is to see the change. Mine used to be in the 60's 15 months ago and now it is in the high 40's which means my heart pumps more blood so the stroke volume is higher which is a good thing. Since I still have a lot of potential to get fitter which means I should continue to see that my resting HR  get lower. Women's resting HR is normally higher than men in a general trend.

My HR I see in the 220's frequently I just ignore those weird high readings.



Edited by KathyG 2006-06-09 12:12 PM
2006-06-09 12:42 PM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Regular
84
252525
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
I wish i'd thought to measure it back when i was heavier and inactive (i've lost 40 pounds since i started training) but then again, I was inactive so the thought never even occurred to me! haha. I'll keep a log. I'd say mine is prob high 60s. i'm still def overweight so it'll be interesting to see how it changes as I get more and more fit. I might wear my HRM for 24 hrs oe day to see how many calories i burn on average and while doing nothing. i really don't "stop" until about 10:59 when i'm crawling into bed, and i don't even have kids or anything.

Glad to hear others have computer glitches. I was surprised at the 212 when i saw it (not till i was home and read my summary totals) b/c even at the top of that hill i didn't TOTALLY think i was dying, just felt like i was REALLY working out.
2006-06-09 1:40 PM
in reply to: #448616

Expert
936
50010010010010025
Salisbury
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
You could check with a doctor for past RHR. My dentist takes it so know mine has improved a lot since I started training. I'm especially looking forward to my next visit.

Did I just say I was looking forward to my visit to my dentist?!!
2006-06-09 2:07 PM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Expert
897
500100100100252525
Seattle WA
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
I'll be happy as long as my RHR stays above zero
2006-06-09 2:19 PM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Veteran
239
10010025
Grand Rapids MI
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
My resting heart rate is low 50s - but i don't doubt you that your heart rate was 212. When I first started training I could blow past 200 if I really pushed it, however not really a great idea to do alot.

I would keep using the heart rate monitor, use the charts to find your approx aerobic zones and train in the correct zone. You will soon be able to tell that you getting better by how quickly you recover after you stop or slow down.

Happy training

ps : If you can get a lactate threshold test, its a great way to find your specific training zones.


Scott

Edited by slider 2006-06-09 2:21 PM


2006-06-09 2:51 PM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Champion
8936
50002000100050010010010010025
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
Keeping it on all day long is not going to show how many calories you burn in a day either.  It would only give you a crude approximation of how many are burned based on the distance you travel.  It's not even terribly useful for calories burned during training since people are so variable.  It's a nice novelty, but I wouldn't take it seriously.
2006-06-09 3:03 PM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Master
2052
20002525
Colorado
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate

Having an HR that is over 200 isn't something to worry about .. sustaining an HR over 200 might be cause for some concern.

I go over 200 all the time, but as long as it doesn't stay there when I'm done excersizing, we're all good.

2006-06-09 11:30 PM
in reply to: #448616

User image

Elite
3020
20001000
Bay Area, CA
Subject: RE: What's a "good" resting heart rate
I'm overweight, (very) but been at this for a while.  My RHR is around 56-62 depending on the day.  RHR measures your overall aerobic fitness and whether you're working too hard rather than if you're skinny or not, IMO.  You might still be overweight but have a great RHR.  It just depends.
New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » What's a "good" resting heart rate Rss Feed