General Discussion Triathlon Talk » 5K Strategy Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 5
 
 
2009-11-12 6:50 PM
in reply to: #2508489

User image

Master
2355
20001001001002525
Houston, TX
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
To learn 5k strategy, just go run a butt load of 5ks... you will figure it out. That's what I did


2009-11-12 7:14 PM
in reply to: #2508489

User image

Master
1348
100010010010025
Gurnee, IL
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
I don't really understand when people run a 5K or any other "race" at "training" pace.   Why even enter it then?

Spending $20-$30 or whatever to run in a 5K for a training run, makes no sense to me.    No matter how fast/Slow some one is, run it as hard as you can.  See what you can do when you give it your all.  Then try and better that time each RACE. 

2009-11-13 8:14 AM
in reply to: #2511605

User image

Master
2802
2000500100100100
Minnetonka, Minnesota
Bronze member
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
"I don't really understand when people run a 5K or any other "race" at "training" pace.   Why even enter it then?

Spending $20-$30 or whatever to run in a 5K for a training run, makes no sense to me.    No matter how fast/Slow some one is, run it as hard as you can.  See what you can do when you give it your all.  Then try and better that time each RACE. "

uhhhh, maybe because they have an "A" race the  next weekend and they just want to have some fun and enjoy the whole race atmosphere, or maybe they want to run with slower family members or friends and the $30 for the fun factor and a T-shirt is no big deal.  To each his own, right?

2009-11-13 8:27 AM
in reply to: #2512127

User image

Cycling Guru
15134
50005000500010025
Fulton, MD
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
Yes, to each their own.

But the difference in an A, B, or C race is not how hard you race it, it is the preparation and the lead up to it.  Going into a race totally cooked and training through it is a C race.  Going into one planning it as a hard training session but not being exhausted makes it a B.  And the A race is the one that all the training is for and you enter it properly trained and rested.

All 3 of them are done at the same level of intensity and effort.  Just you can't expect to have as good a result in the C or B as you hope for in the A.

One of the 5k's I do every year I rode 52 miles each of the days before (Saturday and Sunday) at a pretty decent clip.  I was absolutely thrashed just doing my warm up on race day!  But I still raced the 5k as hard as I could that day and was only :20 off of my PR.  I was just exhausted afterward because of the previous days training.
2009-11-13 12:05 PM
in reply to: #2511605

User image

Elite
3683
20001000500100252525
Whispering Pines, North Carolina
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
oriolepwr - 2009-11-12 8:14 PM I don't really understand when people run a 5K or any other "race" at "training" pace.   Why even enter it then?

Spending $20-$30 or whatever to run in a 5K for a training run, makes no sense to me.    No matter how fast/Slow some one is, run it as hard as you can.  See what you can do when you give it your all.  Then try and better that time each RACE. 



x2
2009-11-13 12:52 PM
in reply to: #2508489

User image

Expert
829
50010010010025
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
I did a 5k yesterday.  No entry fees or anything, I just used my GPS to measure the distance.  I ran it as if it were a race, and am pretty sore today (relative to a typical training run)...  I typically train in the 10-11min/mile range, did the 5k yesterday in 26:10.  I'm curious if I'll go any faster in my actual race (thanksgiving day) given the excitement of other runners and an actual race, not just me against my gps.


2009-11-13 1:24 PM
in reply to: #2512774

User image

Elite
3683
20001000500100252525
Whispering Pines, North Carolina
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
norcal_SAHD - 2009-11-13 1:52 PM I did a 5k yesterday.  No entry fees or anything, I just used my GPS to measure the distance.  I ran it as if it were a race, and am pretty sore today (relative to a typical training run)...  I typically train in the 10-11min/mile range, did the 5k yesterday in 26:10.  I'm curious if I'll go any faster in my actual race (thanksgiving day) given the excitement of other runners and an actual race, not just me against my gps.


based off of my experience...YES. no way i'm pushing myself that hard unless there's motivation. i hate being the fastest runner at a race. i want somebody that is slightly better than me to be there. i'll push it harder.
2009-11-13 2:34 PM
in reply to: #2508489

User image

Expert
1342
100010010010025
Apex, NC
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy

Giving Daremo's advice a shot tomorrow on a flat trail race.  Haven't run a standalone 5k since May '08, so should be interesting.  My past 5k "experiences":

5/8/05: 5k in a sprint tri: 29:49-just hanging on for dear life during the trauma of my first full tri

8/14/05: 5k in a super-sprint tri: can't remember results, but it was hilly, off-road, and it sucked

11/19/05: standalone 5k: 24:13-ran it just as hard as I could the entire time.

4/1/06: 5k in a sprint: 28:50...I was completely wiped out after the bike

7/9/06: 5k in a sprint: 26:29...better, but still not good

3/31/07: 5k in a sprint: 24:49 (8:08, 9:13, 7:27...mile markers weren't in the right places though)

5/6/07: 5k in a sprint: 22:37 (7:41, 7:53, 7:02).  I truly feel that I "raced" the last 1.1 of this race.

11/17/07: standalone 5k: 20:28 (6:02 mile 1 (went out pretty strong) 6:39 mile 2 (hills during this portion) 7:01 mile 3, including the long hill 0:44 1/10 mile; no kick left My lungs were burning, my arms felt SO heavy)

5/17/08: standalone 5k: 19:48 (5:54 mile 1 6:27 mile 2 7:26 mile 3.1 Mile 1 was a little too quick, but I did that to put a little separation on some guys on a hilly section. I was holding the hills pretty good, but I just don't run fast downhill for some reason!)

5/3/09: 5k in a sprint: 21:02 (First mile was marked WAAAAYYYY short. It came up in 4:45, and I thought holy crud! But, alas, it was short. I negative split it from the turnaround, but I forget the splits. Something like 10:39, 10:21, or something like that.)

7/12/09: 5k in a sprint: 20:35 (Not my best effort. Was able to find a rhythm pretty quickly, easier than on the brick the other day, but just wasn't comfortable. I was basically just making sure that I had cushion on Kevin :). He had a faster swim and slower bike, so when I saw him enter the park once I was about 2:00 out of T2, I knew I had him. Paul was up 5 minutes on me after the bike, so I knew I couldn't catch him. So, I just ran my race. Cramping in right quad with 1 mile to go, so backed it off a little more.)

2009-11-13 2:39 PM
in reply to: #2508489

User image

Veteran
273
1001002525
Monadnock
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
I have never run an actual 5K race. In fact, prior to this past weekend, I don't believe I ever ran 5K straight without walking. Might have 25 years ago in college, but that would have been in some altered state and I don't recall for sure.

On Saturday morning I decided to "see what I could do" on 5K course I'd mapped out. This was my strategy....

First 1/2 K- Fiddle with my !!**@@!!! ipod earbud because it keeps bouncing out of my ear. Allow heartrate to increase 10-15 bpm with the extra effort and wonder if my ears are mis-shapen or something.
1 K marker - Contemplate how much time I'll lose if I stop and take that pebble out of my right shoe. Keep jamming the earbud in, hoping to maybe reshape the cartlidge in my left ear.
2 K Marker - Take on fuel with a small moth and what I believe might have been a lady bug. Give up on the earbud and tuck it down the back of my shirt.
3K Marker - Wonder if I shouldn't have ignored all those people who told me to ditch my cheesey $30 running shoes and go to the local shoe place to get fitted with a decent pair of runners.
4K Marker - Feel extreme tightening and pain in my right calf. Begin my final kick/hobble and wonder why I had to make the last two K's of this course all uphill.
5K Finish Line - 27:10 min....Keel over, cough up two bugs, throw my ear-buds in the woods and walk home.

But that's just MY strategy...worked for me...not saying it's what anyone else should do....
2009-11-13 2:53 PM
in reply to: #2512774

User image

Expert
1073
10002525
scottsdale, az
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
norcal_SAHD - 2009-11-13 12:52 PM

I did a 5k yesterday.  No entry fees or anything, I just used my GPS to measure the distance.  I ran it as if it were a race, and am pretty sore today (relative to a typical training run)...  I typically train in the 10-11min/mile range, did the 5k yesterday in 26:10.  I'm curious if I'll go any faster in my actual race (thanksgiving day) given the excitement of other runners and an actual race, not just me against my gps.


YESS!!!! You will go faster in a race! I can't imagine doing almost sub. 8 miles for 3.1 miles in anything but a race right now.
2009-11-13 3:44 PM
in reply to: #2508489

User image

Member
46
25
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy

well i've got my first 5k tomorrow, i'm a complete newbie and will be pushing daughter in jogging stroller. goal for tomorrow is not to finish last. and enjoy it, don't want to put myself off doing these in the future.

however, for "race" experience, well thats something different, when younger and dafter i used to race enduro's (motorcycles) races typically start at 3 hours (up to multiday events), and even in that environment the guys winning are the ones that go out hard and hang on.



Edited by michlong 2009-11-13 3:46 PM


2009-11-13 7:26 PM
in reply to: #2512127

User image

Master
1348
100010010010025
Gurnee, IL
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
ejshowers - 2009-11-13 8:14 AM "I don't really understand when people run a 5K or any other "race" at "training" pace.   Why even enter it then?

Spending $20-$30 or whatever to run in a 5K for a training run, makes no sense to me.    No matter how fast/Slow some one is, run it as hard as you can.  See what you can do when you give it your all.  Then try and better that time each RACE. "

uhhhh, maybe because they have an "A" race the  next weekend and they just want to have some fun and enjoy the whole race atmosphere, or maybe they want to run with slower family members or friends and the $30 for the fun factor and a T-shirt is no big deal.  To each his own, right?




Did you really mean to say that a person would need an entire WEEK to recover from a 5K?      Thats crazy.

Sure I can see entering a 5K or whatever with the intention of pacing a family member or friend. But then that's not really what was being implied.  

Tell you what....  Honestly  I see people pushing baby strollers, little kids (not talking about the real fast ones heh) and others that are lining up "just for fun".   Many times they will actually lineup near the front, and have to be dodged out and zig-zagged around.  I really don't care WHY they enter.  Just lineup at/near the rear if you are NOT racing.
2009-11-13 7:30 PM
in reply to: #2513386

User image

Elite
3683
20001000500100252525
Whispering Pines, North Carolina
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
oriolepwr - 2009-11-13 8:26 PM
ejshowers - 2009-11-13 8:14 AM "I don't really understand when people run a 5K or any other "race" at "training" pace.   Why even enter it then?

Spending $20-$30 or whatever to run in a 5K for a training run, makes no sense to me.    No matter how fast/Slow some one is, run it as hard as you can.  See what you can do when you give it your all.  Then try and better that time each RACE. "

uhhhh, maybe because they have an "A" race the  next weekend and they just want to have some fun and enjoy the whole race atmosphere, or maybe they want to run with slower family members or friends and the $30 for the fun factor and a T-shirt is no big deal.  To each his own, right?




Did you really mean to say that a person would need an entire WEEK to recover from a 5K?      Thats crazy.

Sure I can see entering a 5K or whatever with the intention of pacing a family member or friend. But then that's not really what was being implied.  

Tell you what....  Honestly  I see people pushing baby strollers, little kids (not talking about the real fast ones heh) and others that are lining up "just for fun".   Many times they will actually lineup near the front, and have to be dodged out and zig-zagged around.  I really don't care WHY they enter.  Just lineup at/near the rear if you are NOT racing.


Why do you hate baby strollers, and non-racers, and America?
2009-11-13 7:36 PM
in reply to: #2513392

User image

Master
1348
100010010010025
Gurnee, IL
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
tri_d00d - 2009-11-13 7:30 PM
oriolepwr - 2009-11-13 8:26 PM
ejshowers - 2009-11-13 8:14 AM "I don't really understand when people run a 5K or any other "race" at "training" pace.   Why even enter it then?

Spending $20-$30 or whatever to run in a 5K for a training run, makes no sense to me.    No matter how fast/Slow some one is, run it as hard as you can.  See what you can do when you give it your all.  Then try and better that time each RACE. "

uhhhh, maybe because they have an "A" race the  next weekend and they just want to have some fun and enjoy the whole race atmosphere, or maybe they want to run with slower family members or friends and the $30 for the fun factor and a T-shirt is no big deal.  To each his own, right?






Did you really mean to say that a person would need an entire WEEK to recover from a 5K?      Thats crazy.

Sure I can see entering a 5K or whatever with the intention of pacing a family member or friend. But then that's not really what was being implied.  

Tell you what....  Honestly  I see people pushing baby strollers, little kids (not talking about the real fast ones heh) and others that are lining up "just for fun".   Many times they will actually lineup near the front, and have to be dodged out and zig-zagged around.  I really don't care WHY they enter.  Just lineup at/near the rear if you are NOT racing.


Why do you hate baby strollers, and non-racers, and America?



C'mon now, I never mentioned America! Wink
2009-11-13 8:04 PM
in reply to: #2508489

User image

Veteran
173
1002525
S.E Asia
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy

I just beat my 5km PR in a 6.3km race today and intrestingly I have always been trying to hit even splits or even negative split. However, today I went out a bit too hard and hung on till the end of the 6.3km, but I went through 5km in PR time. Splits from my Garmin.

3:17

3:17

3:14

3:29

3:29

So, it seems there's something to this "Go out hard and hang on".

2009-11-13 8:09 PM
in reply to: #2513425

User image

Regular
51
2525
Winston-Salem
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
Wow dude!  Those are some excellent split times!
May I ask you, what was your 5k times before you started training for it, and how long did it take you to get to this point?  A year?


2009-11-13 8:16 PM
in reply to: #2513430

User image

Veteran
173
1002525
S.E Asia
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy

Thanks for the compliment. I don't actually train for 5km, I just do the for fun while training through for tris ,though where I am in Asia there aren't many.

I mentioned in another thread I don't do any speedwork apart from the odd tempo run and run most of my runs at 4:30-4:40 per km pace. I just try to run consistently.

I've been doing tris for just over 3 years now. I think I've been lucky with the genetics!!! ;

 

Forgot to add: I think my first ever 5km I did in around 21 -22vminutes



Edited by Beanster 2009-11-13 8:21 PM
2009-11-13 9:54 PM
in reply to: #2513425

User image

Master
1404
1000100100100100
Saratoga Springs, Utah
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
Beanster - 2009-11-13 7:04 PM

I just beat my 5km PR in a 6.3km race today and intrestingly I have always been trying to hit even splits or even negative split. However, today I went out a bit too hard and hung on till the end of the 6.3km, but I went through 5km in PR time. Splits from my Garmin.

3:17

3:17

3:14

3:29

3:29

So, it seems there's something to this "Go out hard and hang on".



That is some good running! Converted to miles that is :11 between your fastest pace and your average.
2009-11-15 5:06 AM
in reply to: #2512993

User image

Expert
1342
100010010010025
Apex, NC
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
fgump - 2009-11-13 3:34 PM

Giving Daremo's advice a shot tomorrow on a flat trail race.  Haven't run a standalone 5k since May '08, so should be interesting. 



I gave it a shot, went out hard and hung on as long as I could.  There was no one behind me, and I wasn't going to catch the guy ahead, so at about mile 2.5 I eased off a tad.  Wish I wouldn't have, or I would've broken 19.  There were no markers on the course, so I could not gauge my splits at all.  It wasn't even a split out/back.  Start and finish were two different locations. 

Ended up 1st AG, 4th male, 19:07

2009-11-15 7:12 AM
in reply to: #2514462

User image

Cycling Guru
15134
50005000500010025
Fulton, MD
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
Congrats on the new PR!!

It is hard to find the motivation to really push when there is no rabbit right there or someone breathing down your neck!

So ...... did my strategy work then?
2009-11-15 7:44 AM
in reply to: #2514485

User image

Expert
1342
100010010010025
Apex, NC
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
Daremo - 2009-11-15 8:12 AM Congrats on the new PR!!

It is hard to find the motivation to really push when there is no rabbit right there or someone breathing down your neck!

So ...... did my strategy work then?
I would say it did.  By going out hard, I put separation on the pack (and looked faster than I was).  I could've made up the 7 seconds at the start had I been aggressive, but I didn't elbow my way to the front.  When I pushed past the young cross-country girls, I think that gave me the confidence to keep rolling.  When I made the turnaround and saw the next male was 55 seconds back, I knew he wouldn't catch me, so maybe I actually slowed up a bit there.  But looks like I kept growing the gap on him, as he ended up 2+ minutes behind me.  Either he backed off more than I did, or I didn't back off as much as I thought...


2009-11-17 7:13 PM
in reply to: #2508489

Member
34
25
st. paul, Minnesota
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
Today I ran my own mock 5k just to gauge where I am at before running a local 5k next week on thanksgiving.  Looking for some feedback about how I should pace myself next week.

3 mile warm up, ran at 8:30 pace (was mostly done to measure out my intended course which was an out and back).  Then did 15 minutes of walking around/strides to simulate waiting for the start of the race. Warm up next week will probably be shorter, more like 2 miles.

Mile 1:    5:34
Mile 2:    6:23
Mile 3:    6:32
Last .1:  0:23
Overall time: 18:52

Mile 1 I clearly think I went out too fast, as I feel like my drop off was too much the next two miles.  Last two miles I was just hanging on and had zero go.

Think I am better off shooting for a 6 flat first mile, 6 again on the second, and seeing if I have anything left and try to go sub 6 on the last mile, or should I just go out hard and try to hang on like I did today?
2009-11-17 7:34 PM
in reply to: #2518828

User image

Veteran
173
1002525
S.E Asia
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy

Looking at your splits, I would go with something like a 5:50, 6:00, 6:10. It's hard though, not to bolt at the beginning! You should feel like you've run comfortably hard after the first mile, then the 2nd will hurt to try to stay at the same pace, and the last mile is all about hanging on!!!!

2009-11-17 8:22 PM
in reply to: #2518858

User image

Master
1404
1000100100100100
Saratoga Springs, Utah
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
I agree with what Beanster said. You will start to make up time over what you did previously during the second mile and your last one should be much better time wise, but it will still be painful. Hopefully you will have someone to push you when it gets tough. I would not be suprised if you went sub 18:30 or about there under the same conditions and terrian, with better pacing and competition.
2009-11-18 12:02 AM
in reply to: #2508489

User image

Member
381
100100100252525
Subject: RE: 5K Strategy
I haven't run a 5k in over a year, but am preparing for a 4mile race in a few weeks. My last 5k was 18 and change and the splits were consistent with the 6% positive split idea. however, it seems to me that there is a significant difference between post-race data analysis of splits from your best 5k and the apriori "strategy".

my strategy was not "go out as fast as I can". I bet I could have hit a sub-5 mile. I doubt (opinion with no evidence) that I would have had a faster 5k time in that case. i think the distinction is how relatively easy it feels to blast a fast mile with all of the adrenaline and whatever other mental factors present in a race situation. it does not feel like "as hard as you can" to me.

i don't disagree with the anecdotes and some studies posted here regarding positive splits, but I embrace the strategy put forward by Scout "just race it". go out aware of what you are doing and know that it should be fast. really, it ought to be relatively easy to hit your first mile split fast. don't be stupid and post a 1-mile PR on the first mile. (BTW, it may be semantics, but what else would hard as you can mean?)

New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » 5K Strategy Rss Feed  
 
 
of 5