Other Resources My Cup of Joe » The "No Kids Club" Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, the bear, DerekL, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 16
 
 
The "No Kids Club"
OptionResults
No Kids - by choice90 Votes - [37.19%]
No kids - b/c of medical reasons6 Votes - [2.48%]
No kids yet, but planning on it38 Votes - [15.7%]
Yes I/we have kids108 Votes - [44.63%]

2011-04-21 1:27 PM
in reply to: #3459109

User image

Extreme Veteran
1260
10001001002525
Miami
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
trinnas - 2011-04-21 2:16 PM
Cuetoy - 2011-04-21 1:56 PM
trinnas - 2011-04-21 1:44 PM
Cuetoy - 2011-04-21 1:36 PM
trinnas - 2011-04-21 1:31 PM
mmrocker13 - 2011-04-21 1:25 PM

Again, simply making a baby means nothing, in terms of contribution to the world as a whole. It's a mouth to feed and a consumer of resources.

 

Remind me of this statement when my child is paying for your social security.

Ummmm, i do not understand your point.  People without kids pay for public education with their taxes and they don't use it.

Really where did you get your education from then?

I did use public education, but i continue paying for it.  I simply don't understand what you meant by your child paying someone elses SS, he would be paying his own.

My point being the next generations will be relied upon by this generation as it gets older just as the previous generation will rely on us.  So the the next generation are more than just another mouth to feed and a consumer of resources.  Like it or not as a society we rely on one another of all ages.  Imagine what would happen to our generation as we got older if the whole world just stopped having kids.

To be clear if you choose to have kids or not have kids that is your choice IMO.  But for either side of the debate to devalue the others contribution is a poor argument; there are entirely too many what ifs and what abouts.  Both sides have very valid good and bad points.

I agree with you, i previously posted that "selfish" is the incorrect term to describe either decision, it is a personal choice.  I would never critizice anyone for having children, many people can not see their lifes complete without them.  I worked for many years in early childhood education and can see the joy that they can bring to a lot of people, but have also seem those that deserved better parents.



2011-04-21 1:31 PM
in reply to: #3459145

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
2011-04-21 1:33 PM
in reply to: #3459084

Elite
4235
2000200010010025
Spring, TX
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
Renee - 2011-04-21 1:09 PM

Just like I am leery of people who don't like dogs, I am leery of people who don't like kids (which is a different matter than not wanting to be a parent). I think people who don't like kids just don't like people in general - that's my read. Misanthropes are not my people.

I am intrigued by your take on this.  I'd like to offer a differing point of view, speaking as someone who doesn't like kids but loves humanity.

I'm uncomfortable around kids.  I always have been.  I see and respect others who are so natural with them, but despite repeated attempts to try, I simply can't connect with children.  I don't understand them and have nothing in common with them.  I don't understand how to entertain them or what it is they're looking for.  Moreover, because they aren't my own, I'm really not interested in learning about their interests.  I'm an adult and they're a child.  Our worlds are completely different and there's no incentive for me to reconcile those differences.  In 20 years when that child is an adult and can hold conversations that we both might find interesting, then great!  But as long as their interests are shiny objects, sticking stuff in their mouths, the newest GI Joe or avoiding cooties from the opposite sex, I can't bring myself to "like" them. 

This does not make me a misanthrope.  I'm sure if I had my own child I would love it and learn to overcome all those things in the last paragraph.  But since I don't have children, or have any desire to have them, then it's a moot point. 

 

2011-04-21 1:42 PM
in reply to: #3459166

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
2011-04-21 1:45 PM
in reply to: #3459202

Elite
4235
2000200010010025
Spring, TX
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
Fred Doucette - 2011-04-21 1:42 PM
AndrewMT - 2011-04-21 2:33 PM
Renee - 2011-04-21 1:09 PM

Just like I am leery of people who don't like dogs, I am leery of people who don't like kids (which is a different matter than not wanting to be a parent). I think people who don't like kids just don't like people in general - that's my read. Misanthropes are not my people.

I am intrigued by your take on this.  I'd like to offer a differing point of view, speaking as someone who doesn't like kids but loves humanity.

I'm uncomfortable around kids.  I always have been.  I see and respect others who are so natural with them, but despite repeated attempts to try, I simply can't connect with children.  I don't understand them and have nothing in common with them.  I don't understand how to entertain them or what it is they're looking for.  Moreover, because they aren't my own, I'm really not interested in learning about their interests.  I'm an adult and they're a child.  Our worlds are completely different and there's no incentive for me to reconcile those differences.  In 20 years when that child is an adult and can hold conversations that we both might find interesting, then great!  But as long as their interests are shiny objects, sticking stuff in their mouths, the newest GI Joe or avoiding cooties from the opposite sex, I can't bring myself to "like" them. 

This does not make me a misanthrope.  I'm sure if I had my own child I would love it and learn to overcome all those things in the last paragraph.  But since I don't have children, or have any desire to have them, then it's a moot point. 

 

Don't worry Andrew.

Personally I am not comfortable around dogs. Relates to an incident where my sister was attacked as a kid.

I am not leary of you for not being comfortable with kids.

You are simply being honest and I appreciate that.

Thanks, but I don't want to talk to you if you dont' like dogs...

2011-04-21 1:47 PM
in reply to: #3459166

Alpharetta, Georgia
Bronze member
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
AndrewMT - 2011-04-21 1:33 PM
Renee - 2011-04-21 1:09 PM

Just like I am leery of people who don't like dogs, I am leery of people who don't like kids (which is a different matter than not wanting to be a parent). I think people who don't like kids just don't like people in general - that's my read. Misanthropes are not my people.

I am intrigued by your take on this.  I'd like to offer a differing point of view, speaking as someone who doesn't like kids but loves humanity.

I'm uncomfortable around kids.  I always have been.  I see and respect others who are so natural with them, but despite repeated attempts to try, I simply can't connect with children.  I don't understand them and have nothing in common with them.  I don't understand how to entertain them or what it is they're looking for.  Moreover, because they aren't my own, I'm really not interested in learning about their interests.  I'm an adult and they're a child.  Our worlds are completely different and there's no incentive for me to reconcile those differences.  In 20 years when that child is an adult and can hold conversations that we both might find interesting, then great!  But as long as their interests are shiny objects, sticking stuff in their mouths, the newest GI Joe or avoiding cooties from the opposite sex, I can't bring myself to "like" them. 

This does not make me a misanthrope.  I'm sure if I had my own child I would love it and learn to overcome all those things in the last paragraph.  But since I don't have children, or have any desire to have them, then it's a moot point. 

 

I was intrigued by Renee's post as well, and I could have written the response Andrew did. In fact, I wrote something almost identical a few pages back.

It's not like I'm going to kick your kids in the grocery store or roll my eyes and move seats in the airport. In fact, I am always smiling at kids and am more than patient when they are acting up in public (more out of sympathy for the parents).

I like plenty of people in this world, and I feel it was a bit too broad of a generalization to imply otherwise (of those who don't "like" kids).
 



2011-04-21 1:51 PM
in reply to: #3459216

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
2011-04-21 1:58 PM
in reply to: #3459224

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.

Edited by Fred Doucette 2011-04-21 1:59 PM
2011-04-21 2:14 PM
in reply to: #3459262

Iron Donkey
38643
50005000500050005000500050002000100050010025
, Wisconsin
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
Fred Doucette - 2011-04-21 1:58 PM
lisac957

It's not like I'm going to kick your kids in the grocery store or roll my eyes and move seats in the airport. In fact, I am always smiling at kids and am more than patient when they are acting up in public (more out of sympathy for the parents).

I like plenty of people in this world, and I feel it was a bit too broad of a generalization to imply otherwise (of those who don't "like" kids).
 

Lisa, again to reiterate. I think your position is extremely reasonable. Also very honest, thanks.

However, isn't it a bit creepy smiling at people's kids all the time?

I get creeped out when she smiles at me.

2011-04-21 2:18 PM
in reply to: #3459262

Alpharetta, Georgia
Bronze member
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
Fred Doucette - 2011-04-21 1:58 PM
lisac957

It's not like I'm going to kick your kids in the grocery store or roll my eyes and move seats in the airport. In fact, I am always smiling at kids and am more than patient when they are acting up in public (more out of sympathy for the parents).

I like plenty of people in this world, and I feel it was a bit too broad of a generalization to imply otherwise (of those who don't "like" kids).
 

Lisa, again to reiterate. I think your position is extremely reasonable. Also very honest, thanks.

However, isn't it a bit creepy smiling at people's kids all the time?

Shhh... it's my secret for getting them to move far away from me!

2011-04-21 2:42 PM
in reply to: #3459166

Master
2083
2000252525
Houston, TX
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
AndrewMT - 2011-04-21 1:33 PM

I'm uncomfortable around kids.  I always have been.  I see and respect others who are so natural with them, but despite repeated attempts to try, I simply can't connect with children.  I don't understand them and have nothing in common with them.  I don't understand how to entertain them or what it is they're looking for.  Moreover, because they aren't my own, I'm really not interested in learning about their interests.  I'm an adult and they're a child.  Our worlds are completely different and there's no incentive for me to reconcile those differences.  In 20 years when that child is an adult and can hold conversations that we both might find interesting, then great!  But as long as their interests are shiny objects, sticking stuff in their mouths, the newest GI Joe or avoiding cooties from the opposite sex, I can't bring myself to "like" them. 

Just a tip: If you find yourself in an uncomfortable situation with a kid talking about G.I. Joe, poor water on his head.  He will go away. (jk)

 

edit: left too many "quotes" in.  paragraph looked all funny and stuff.



Edited by jgaither 2011-04-21 2:43 PM


2011-04-21 2:48 PM
in reply to: #3459166

Champion
11989
500050001000500100100100100252525
Philly 'burbs
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
AndrewMT - 2011-04-21 2:33 PM
Renee - 2011-04-21 1:09 PM

Just like I am leery of people who don't like dogs, I am leery of people who don't like kids (which is a different matter than not wanting to be a parent). I think people who don't like kids just don't like people in general - that's my read. Misanthropes are not my people.

I am intrigued by your take on this.  I'd like to offer a differing point of view, speaking as someone who doesn't like kids but loves humanity.

 

This statement seems completely incongruous to me. Kids, especially young kids, are the purest form humans can take.

2011-04-21 2:53 PM
in reply to: #3459402

Elite
4235
2000200010010025
Spring, TX
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
mrbbrad - 2011-04-21 2:48 PM
AndrewMT - 2011-04-21 2:33 PM
Renee - 2011-04-21 1:09 PM

Just like I am leery of people who don't like dogs, I am leery of people who don't like kids (which is a different matter than not wanting to be a parent). I think people who don't like kids just don't like people in general - that's my read. Misanthropes are not my people.

I am intrigued by your take on this.  I'd like to offer a differing point of view, speaking as someone who doesn't like kids but loves humanity.

 

This statement seems completely incongruous to me. Kids, especially young kids, are the purest form humans can take.

That's a subjective feeling you have.  Your use of the word purity doesn't really apply to my reasoning for why I don't like kids.  Loving humanity does not mean loving all humans. 

2011-04-21 3:00 PM
in reply to: #3037419

Champion
7821
50002000500100100100
Brooklyn, NY
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
I feel about dogs the way many people feel about kids, which is to say that I like other peoples' dogs. I have no desire to have one of my own, although I can see why other people like them. I enjoy playing with them and being around them as long as I don't have to be involved with feeding them, walking them or otherwise taking care of them.
2011-04-21 3:17 PM
in reply to: #3459096

Champion
6962
500010005001001001001002525
Atlanta, Ga
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"

SoberTriGuy - 2011-04-21 2:13 PM Be thankful that your parents had kids...

 

If I wasn't born to my parents I would have been born to another set of parents.  And, unfortunately, the population is not shrinking, so I would have been born at some point.

2011-04-21 3:19 PM
in reply to: #3459402

Iron Donkey
38643
50005000500050005000500050002000100050010025
, Wisconsin
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
mrbbrad - 2011-04-21 2:48 PM
AndrewMT - 2011-04-21 2:33 PM
Renee - 2011-04-21 1:09 PM

Just like I am leery of people who don't like dogs, I am leery of people who don't like kids (which is a different matter than not wanting to be a parent). I think people who don't like kids just don't like people in general - that's my read. Misanthropes are not my people.

I am intrigued by your take on this.  I'd like to offer a differing point of view, speaking as someone who doesn't like kids but loves humanity.

 

This statement seems completely incongruous to me. Kids, especially young kids, are the purest form humans can take.

Yeah, you can snatch one up in your arms so much quicker and easier than an adult.



2011-04-21 3:23 PM
in reply to: #3459475

Iron Donkey
38643
50005000500050005000500050002000100050010025
, Wisconsin
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
Marvarnett - 2011-04-21 3:17 PM

SoberTriGuy - 2011-04-21 2:13 PM Be thankful that your parents had kids...

 

If I wasn't born to my parents I would have been born to another set of parents.  And, unfortunately, the population is not shrinking, so I would have been born at some point.

In a whole different level of thought and discussion, the chances of "you" being "you" are highly not probable, whether in the way one thinks of a "soul" or identity, determined by "uniqueness".
Okay, discussion is getting askewed.

2011-04-21 3:55 PM
in reply to: #3459402

Buttercup
14334
500050002000200010010010025
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
mrbbrad - 2011-04-21 3:48 PM
AndrewMT - 2011-04-21 2:33 PM
Renee - 2011-04-21 1:09 PM

Just like I am leery of people who don't like dogs, I am leery of people who don't like kids (which is a different matter than not wanting to be a parent). I think people who don't like kids just don't like people in general - that's my read. Misanthropes are not my people.

I am intrigued by your take on this.  I'd like to offer a differing point of view, speaking as someone who doesn't like kids but loves humanity.

This statement seems completely incongruous to me. Kids, especially young kids, are the purest form humans can take.

That's beautiful and I fully concur.

I wrote that I am leery of people who don't like kids. Note that I did not say any of the following:

  • I am leery of people who are uncomfortable around kids
  • I am leery of people who don't want to talk to kids
  • I am leery of people who don't want to be parents

If someone said "I don't like people" or "I don't like people younger than 35 years old" I would feel the same way. Misanthrope, by definition. Children are merely little people.

We all have our negative inclinations; I'm entitled to mine. Just as those who don't like little people are entitled to theirs.

Misanthropes are not my people. I'm a people person; I take them one at a time, just as I find them. That includes little people.

2011-04-21 4:00 PM
in reply to: #3459475

Pro
4578
20002000500252525
Vancouver, BC
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
Marvarnett - 2011-04-21 1:17 PM

SoberTriGuy - 2011-04-21 2:13 PM Be thankful that your parents had kids...

 

If I wasn't born to my parents I would have been born to another set of parents.  And, unfortunately, the population is not shrinking, so I would have been born at some point.



Yeah, I don't really get this argument either. My mom has told me that she wishes she didn't have kids. She had me though and it doesn't make her love me any less, just that life would have been different for her and maybe she would have enjoyed life more. I'm okay with that.

I can also think of this world without me in it. I love myself and my life and I know that there are lots of others who love me, but I know that if I wasn't here, there would be others to love and everyone could be just as happy.
2011-04-21 4:05 PM
in reply to: #3459096

Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"

SoberTriGuy - 2011-04-21 11:13 AM Be thankful that your parents had kids...

Sorry.  Lost.  What does this have to do with my decision not to have them?

My parents, god bless 'em, did a LOT of things I wouldn't do.

2011-04-21 4:09 PM
in reply to: #3459475

Buttercup
14334
500050002000200010010010025
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
Marvarnett - 2011-04-21 4:17 PM

SoberTriGuy - 2011-04-21 2:13 PM Be thankful that your parents had kids...

If I wasn't born to my parents I would have been born to another set of parents.  And, unfortunately, the population is not shrinking, so I would have been born at some point.

That's an interesting take. I believe just the opposite - if my mother didn't birth me, I wouldn't exist. Not anywhere. I am who I am because my mother birthed me.

Would I be okay with not existing? There would be no "I" that could consider the question of my lack of existence! Que sera, sera.

So, Dan, why do you believe you would still be around even if your mother hadn't birthed you? Asking merely out of curiosity. I hadn't heard this perspective before.



2011-04-21 4:16 PM
in reply to: #3037419

Elite
3277
20001000100100252525
Minnetonka
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"

Whoa... My statement of being thankful that your parents had kids was directed at all of the not so positive statements about other people's kids throughout this thread.  Take a look around and be happy that we have this decision, and be thankful for the people that chose to have kids.  One day they will be taking care of you and running the nation etc...

 

O.K.  Let me have it...

2011-04-21 4:30 PM
in reply to: #3458989

Pro
5011
5000
Twin Cities
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
trinnas - 2011-04-21 12:31 PM
mmrocker13 - 2011-04-21 1:25 PM

Again, simply making a baby means nothing, in terms of contribution to the world as a whole. It's a mouth to feed and a consumer of resources.

 

Remind me of this statement when my child is paying for your social security.

Erm, I am paying into social security right now. So...IF for some odd reason, SS is still around and available by the time I get to an eligible age, I will have paid in my fair share. Your child will not be "paying" for me. I AM paying the taxes to support his school right now, though. ;-)

2011-04-21 4:32 PM
in reply to: #3459552

Elite
4235
2000200010010025
Spring, TX
Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
Renee - 2011-04-21 3:55 PM
mrbbrad - 2011-04-21 3:48 PM
AndrewMT - 2011-04-21 2:33 PM
Renee - 2011-04-21 1:09 PM

Just like I am leery of people who don't like dogs, I am leery of people who don't like kids (which is a different matter than not wanting to be a parent). I think people who don't like kids just don't like people in general - that's my read. Misanthropes are not my people.

I am intrigued by your take on this.  I'd like to offer a differing point of view, speaking as someone who doesn't like kids but loves humanity.

This statement seems completely incongruous to me. Kids, especially young kids, are the purest form humans can take.

That's beautiful and I fully concur.

I wrote that I am leery of people who don't like kids. Note that I did not say any of the following:

  • I am leery of people who are uncomfortable around kids
  • I am leery of people who don't want to talk to kids
  • I am leery of people who don't want to be parents

If someone said "I don't like people" or "I don't like people younger than 35 years old" I would feel the same way. Misanthrope, by definition. Children are merely little people.

We all have our negative inclinations; I'm entitled to mine. Just as those who don't like little people are entitled to theirs.

Misanthropes are not my people. I'm a people person; I take them one at a time, just as I find them. That includes little people.

Renee, please understand that I'm not trying to attack your point of view, but instead am trying to undertand it and have a conversation.

Are there individual people in the world that you do not like?  Have met someone who for some reason annoyed you and left you feeling like you just wanted to get away from them?  If not, then you're truly a wonderful person for being so understand and accepting of others.

I love people/humanity, but there have been plenty of people I've met who I dislike for various reasons.  Kids, due to the traits that I've mentioned before, generally fall into that category.  They're little humans who are usually very annoying and whom I have nothing in common with.  I have met kids that I like, but they're a rare exception. 

Mistanthropes, by definition hate all people/humanity, not specific individuals for whom there is a reason for the dislike. 

2011-04-21 4:33 PM
in reply to: #3459577

Subject: RE: The "No Kids Club"
SoberTriGuy - 2011-04-21 2:16 PM

Whoa... My statement of being thankful that your parents had kids was directed at all of the not so positive statements about other people's kids throughout this thread.  Take a look around and be happy that we have this decision, and be thankful for the people that chose to have kids.  One day they will be taking care of you and running the nation etc...

 

O.K.  Let me have it...

The logic doesn't hold.

Adolf Hitler.  Idi Amin.  Pol Pot.  They were all children.  Simply being born does not a benefit to society make.

New Thread
Other Resources My Cup of Joe » The "No Kids Club" Rss Feed  
 
 
of 16