General Discussion Triathlon Talk » New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2008-10-21 5:18 AM

User image

Master
1325
100010010010025
Lake Oswego, OR
Subject: New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue

So I am looking at my last race of the season just 18 days away. In this my first year I did 3 sprints, 2 Olys and the Escape from Alcatraz tri (I also threw in a couple of open water races for good measure,) Ye I'm hooked.

 Putting aside my nagging piriformis syndrome that I have learned to manage, I expect to focus exclusively on Oly distances, although I might consider a HIM, Why I don't know. The swim isn't any longer.

 That being said, if I can get my self into the first 25% to 30% of my racing season in good shape I want to buy an carbon tri bike. I now ride a very good road bike with clip ons. I have short(er) legs and longer torso. Have 41" chest 5'10" high and weigh 175 (my goal for next year is 165 easily achievable).  Can anyone point me in a good direction to help me get my search started. Please feel free to be completely subjective. Think I am in the $3500 to $4500 price range.



2008-10-21 6:57 AM
in reply to: #1755810

User image

Elite
2527
200050025
Armpit of Ontario
Subject: RE: New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue

your price range sets you up nicely on any number of great bikes, but because a bike can fit completely different from one model to the next, fit is critical; someone buying a low-end bike might scrimp on an exhaustive professional fitting, but spending that type of cash should give cause for having the best fit possible, IMO. Find a certified tri bike fitter in your area and they will be able to shorted the list of bikes that will fit you best.

On that note, the masses can't be entirely wrong and a Cervelo P2C with a set of race wheels would easily fit in your budget and leave some left over.

 



Edited by sty 2008-10-21 6:58 AM
2008-10-22 12:29 AM
in reply to: #1755860

User image

Master
1325
100010010010025
Lake Oswego, OR
Subject: RE: New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue
sty - 2008-10-21 4:57 AM

your price range sets you up nicely on any number of great bikes, but because a bike can fit completely different from one model to the next, fit is critical; someone buying a low-end bike might scrimp on an exhaustive professional fitting, but spending that type of cash should give cause for having the best fit possible, IMO. Find a certified tri bike fitter in your area and they will be able to shorted the list of bikes that will fit you best.

On that note, the masses can't be entirely wrong and a Cervelo P2C with a set of race wheels would easily fit in your budget and leave some left over.

 

 Thanks

2008-10-22 6:53 AM
in reply to: #1755810

User image

Pro
4528
2000200050025
Norwalk, Connecticut
Subject: RE: New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue

Sty is absolutly correct,

Great bike----Crappy fit------- Crappy ride

Ok bike--------good fit----------- Great ride

Great bike---------perfect fit-------really f'ing fast

You should be able to get to a RFF bike with that coin.

Good luck and don't forget to post pics ....er... i mean porn!!!!!

2008-10-22 8:57 AM
in reply to: #1755810

User image

Champion
19812
50005000500020002000500100100100
MA
Subject: RE: New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue

In that price range you have lots of choices.

I would suggest you shop around for the LBS you want to buy from. Go visit and see what they say, what they suggest, how they handle the buying process.

Ask on the BT board from your state where folks recommend.

Buying a bike that fits well like Sty and others have said is key. 

For great bike that fits well the process may work like this. Shop around find the place you like and want to buy from. Get a bike fit and have them recommend which bike or bikes would fit you best without a lot of adjusting and trading parts based on your body, riding style, flexibility etc., then trust them as to which bike you should get. Often if you get a bike fit and buy a high end bike they credit the cost of the fit back to you. The issue with buying a bike anywhere and bringing it to a different place for fit or doing fit after wards, it may not be the best fit bike for you.

Hard thing about that process is you are sort of married to one shop and it is harder to shop around. As if one shop is great at bike fits and another is great at carrying lots of brands but are bad at fitting you are sort of in a tough spot. I've been there before.

I have a bike fit guy that is fabulous. I trust him....last bike I told him what I wanted, the price range, he gave me 3 options plus custom option based on my measurements and geometry of the bikes and the material of the bikes.  I just ordered it, picked out custom paint, tweaked the parts package he suggested and rode it first time after it was paid for. He knows me and what I want and the trust part comes into him fitting me in the right bike for me.  The bike is awesome!

2008-10-22 9:11 AM
in reply to: #1755810

User image

Pro
3705
20001000500100100
Vestavia Hills
Subject: RE: New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue

Whatever you do, do not make it red.

All sage advice above.  For thsoe, however, who are reading this and do not have that much coin to drop I do not want them to get the impression that it is okay to skimp on a good bike fit because they have not met some bike cost threshold.

That simply is not true.

A good bike fit will not only increase performance and speed but also prevent injuries common to a poor fit (lower back, knee, etc.).

Bottom line: I believe that fit is everything - especially for a tri-bike when your body is "locked" into one position when in aero - regardless of the price of the bike.

 



2008-10-22 9:16 AM
in reply to: #1755810

Master
1728
100050010010025
portland, or
Subject: RE: New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue
If there was only a place in the Portland area where you could test ride tri-bikes....


scott

2008-10-22 9:16 AM
in reply to: #1755810

User image

Champion
4902
20002000500100100100100
Ottawa, Ontario
Subject: RE: New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue
You have the same build as me insofar as the short legs and long torso is concerned.  A 2009 P2 with DA (3200CND) or with Ultegra (2700CND) might be a good one to look at ... great bike ... great price.  At 5'10, you would most probably need a 56cm frame.  Whatever bike you do buy, make sure that you are fitted by a professional who knows his job well!

Edited by Machiavelo 2008-10-22 9:16 AM
2008-10-22 9:16 AM
in reply to: #1758731

User image

Resident Curmudgeon
25290
50005000500050005000100100252525
The Road Back
Gold member
Subject: RE: New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue
brian - 2008-10-22 9:11 AM

Whatever you do, do not make it red.

For sure. There are way too many FAST bikes out there already. Cool

2008-10-22 10:19 AM
in reply to: #1755810

User image

Master
1558
10005002525
Pensacola, Fl
Subject: RE: New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue

I will completely echo the statements of the bikefit requirement as being priority #1.  I had a 2004 Felt S22 and chose it because I liked it, but most importantly because it fit well.  Then I upgraded to a 2006 Kouta Kalibur...just because I liked it and wanted THAT bike.  Not to mention being of average size, I thought I could fit me to any bike.  I loved that Kalibur, but I never felt comfortable on it or did it ever feel as good as the Felt.  Therefore, I have recently (yesterday) returned to a Felt bike.

Hopefully, you will find a bike that you like and that fits....but fit comes first, trust me.  Good luck and I hope a Felt fits.  I am a bit partial to that brand as you can now see.

New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » New Bike this I know, but which Bike? I don't have a clue Rss Feed