General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Aggressive Swimmers Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 3
 
 
2012-06-24 6:11 PM

New user
2

Subject: Aggressive Swimmers
I'm a slow swimmer at the back of the pack.  What do I do if someone is obviously trying to push me out of the way?  It would be very easy for them to swim around me, but they are purposefully being invasive.  It's not like they were really good and I was in their way.  I feel like I should assert myself and not let them get over.

Edited by smoothj 2012-06-24 6:24 PM


2012-06-24 6:21 PM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

Expert
1544
100050025
Alexandria, MN
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
First off, I'd be sure it's intentional contact meant to injure or intimidate. It's often hard to tell and what seems like aggressive behavior is not at all intentional. After that, my next suggestion is to line up somewhere further from the front where the most contact happens. Last, try to get a race number if you think it's intentional to injure and report it to the RD.
2012-06-24 6:24 PM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

Coach
9167
5000200020001002525
Stairway to Seven
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
Nothing...just swim your swim. REcall that you are swimming in water, which is a fluid medium. One or both of you will just float away from each other as the two cannot occupy the same space. you can be aggressive and waste energy, or you can just let it go and keep swimming.

Just keep swimming.
2012-06-24 6:28 PM
in reply to: #4277851

Expert
836
50010010010025
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
Agree with the above, let it go.
2012-06-24 6:34 PM
in reply to: #4277851

New user
2

Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers

How do I get a number when I'm in the water?  My theory is if you make contact you back off or go around.  The fast people just pass with no problem.  This person. once she made contact, kept trying to push me out of the way.  I didn't want to be rude, but I felt like I needed to show her that she couldn't push me around.  Is there a swin technique to handle this?

 

2012-06-24 6:34 PM
in reply to: #4277851


1660
10005001002525
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers

It's not that they're aggressive. It's that it's REALLY hard to see a much slower swimmer in the water if you're a faster swimmer and already dealing with sighting for buoys and the scrum.

 

I'm not even a fast swimmer, and I've accidentally swum right into the legs of 3-4 people from slower waves that I had no idea were in the way, and I make every effort to avoid contact in the water, including letting guys near me have the right of way even I have to stop momentarily. 

 

You would actually find the same exact situation if you had a similar speed differential to other swimmers - you'd swim right into the slow people's feet a few times.

Nobody's trying to run you down - it's just that it can be very hard to see people in the water. Just relax, let them pass, and continue.



2012-06-24 6:49 PM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

Master
2236
200010010025
Denison Texas
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
It may not even be the same person each time.....stay in your box, worry about the things you can control
2012-06-24 6:55 PM
in reply to: #4277887

Member
170
1002525
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
smoothj - 2012-06-24 7:34 PM

How do I get a number when I'm in the water?  My theory is if you make contact you back off or go around.  The fast people just pass with no problem.  This person. once she made contact, kept trying to push me out of the way.  I didn't want to be rude, but I felt like I needed to show her that she couldn't push me around.  Is there a swin technique to handle this?

 

Yes, the technique is to go faster.
2012-06-24 7:05 PM
in reply to: #4277887

User image

Coach
9167
5000200020001002525
Stairway to Seven
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
smoothj - 2012-06-24 5:34 PM

How do I get a number when I'm in the water?  My theory is if you make contact you back off or go around.  The fast people just pass with no problem.  This person. once she made contact, kept trying to push me out of the way.  I didn't want to be rude, but I felt like I needed to show her that she couldn't push me around.  Is there a swin technique to handle this?

 



How much energy do you want to waste? It's not worth changing your race strategy to prove a point...let it go. Speed up if you can, slow down if you need to or diverge paths. If you're swimming at the exact same pace let her go ahead 6 feet...your finish time won't be any different.
2012-06-24 7:09 PM
in reply to: #4277887

User image

Champion
10471
500050001001001001002525
Dallas, TX
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
smoothj - 2012-06-24 6:34 PM

How do I get a number when I'm in the water?  My theory is if you make contact you back off or go around.  The fast people just pass with no problem.  This person. once she made contact, kept trying to push me out of the way.  I didn't want to be rude, but I felt like I needed to show her that she couldn't push me around.  Is there a swin technique to handle this?

 



Well, I like to teach what I call "defensive swimming". It's really very basic.... 1) if someone touches your toes, you start kicking really hard. It will let them know someone is there, and that someone is NOT going down easy, so they better go around. 2) if someone is on your side, you can place a hand on them and push them away. Simple as that. Not push them UNDER, but away from you. Works best on the shoulder.

2012-06-24 7:09 PM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

Expert
1566
10005002525
Prattville Insane Asylum San Antonio
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers

I agree, there is nothing you can do, but waste energy.  If it was a wave start, and she was continually running into you, she might not have even known it was the same person every time.  She might have just been swimming and unaware of it.  In my races, I have no idea who is touching me or for what reason.  All I can do is go as fast as I can to find open space and keep going.  

I have been literally swam over, kicked in the face, grabbed from behind, etc.  It is just a part of racing.  



2012-06-24 8:23 PM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

Extreme Veteran
863
5001001001002525
West Michigan
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
I've pushed a swimmer like mentioned above.  Nothing aggressive just move over. Other than that, if a swimmer want's to go faster, they wont waste a lot of time bumping you, they will know it's faster to go around.  A swimmer that is just trying to climb over you is most likely a good swimmer but a beginner OWS. 
2012-06-24 9:02 PM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

Pro
5755
50005001001002525
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers

smoothj - 2012-06-24 7:11 PM I'm a slow swimmer at the back of the pack.  What do I do if someone is obviously trying to push me out of the way?  It would be very easy for them to swim around me, but they are purposefully being invasive.  It's not like they were really good and I was in their way.  I feel like I should assert myself and not let them get over.

I'm a slow swimmer and was in contact off and on with someone for about 200 yards today at an Oly. If I were to guess I'd say neither of us wanted this, but for whatever reason it happened. I wasn't trying to be aggressive and I doubt they were either. We just couldn't seem to get out of each other's way.

Believe me, if they were faster than you and it was intentional (or not) this would have been over in 15 seconds. They would have swam over you and been gone. That's the way it is.

2012-06-24 9:12 PM
in reply to: #4277928

User image

Champion
6627
5000100050010025
Rochester Hills, Michigan
Gold member
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
KSH - 2012-06-24 8:09 PM
smoothj - 2012-06-24 6:34 PM

How do I get a number when I'm in the water?  My theory is if you make contact you back off or go around.  The fast people just pass with no problem.  This person. once she made contact, kept trying to push me out of the way.  I didn't want to be rude, but I felt like I needed to show her that she couldn't push me around.  Is there a swin technique to handle this?

 

Well, I like to teach what I call "defensive swimming". It's really very basic.... 1) if someone touches your toes, you start kicking really hard. It will let them know someone is there, and that someone is NOT going down easy, so they better go around. 2) if someone is on your side, you can place a hand on them and push them away. Simple as that. Not push them UNDER, but away from you. Works best on the shoulder.

Holy hell. You teach that? So much to say here that I won't. 

Whatever happened to picking the right starting spot, finding some open water, and adjusting as you go? 

To the OP, AdventureBear got it right: swim your race, adjust as you need to, and don't burn a lot of energy trying to deal with goofy swimmers. You'll save energy and get 'em on the bike and run. Just stay cool. 

2012-06-24 9:20 PM
in reply to: #4277915


27
25
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
Nhmountainman - 2012-06-24 6:55 PM
smoothj - 2012-06-24 7:34 PM

How do I get a number when I'm in the water?  My theory is if you make contact you back off or go around.  The fast people just pass with no problem.  This person. once she made contact, kept trying to push me out of the way.  I didn't want to be rude, but I felt like I needed to show her that she couldn't push me around.  Is there a swin technique to handle this?

 

Yes, the technique is to go faster.

I despise this mentality.  It implies that a slow swimmer isn't going as hard as he/she can...just because you are a strong swimmer doesn't mean that the rest of the field will be...

 

To the OP:  I'm a slow swimmer too & have experienced what you describe a number of times.  Initially, I just accepted it as part of the race & dealt with it; after a few races, I realized that when I was passing somebody that I found a way to go around the person I was passing without grabbing their legs, hitting their torso, etc.  When I came to this realization, I also decided that people who wish to pass me could do the same thing.

Today, if somebody passes me, they get a 10-second pass of making excess contact--after that, I'm kicking...HARD.  I've found that one solid kick generally dissuades those 'aggressive' swimmers from swimming 'over' you and they take the extra few seconds to go around you.

2012-06-24 9:22 PM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

Alpharetta, Georgia
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
Gotta agree with the "let it go" mentality and don't agree at all with defensive swimming as a go-to solution.

Even in an Ironman start with ~3000 people (and I am a smack in the MOP swimmer), I was able to swim away from a "goofy" swimmer as someone else put it. His arm swung smack into the back of my head 4 or 5 times in a row. So I moved. Problem solved, even in a washing machine sea of Ironman.  


2012-06-24 9:25 PM
in reply to: #4278097

User image

Master
3127
2000100010025
Sunny Southern Cal
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
rkreuser - 2012-06-24 7:12 PM
KSH - 2012-06-24 8:09 PM
smoothj - 2012-06-24 6:34 PM

How do I get a number when I'm in the water?  My theory is if you make contact you back off or go around.  The fast people just pass with no problem.  This person. once she made contact, kept trying to push me out of the way.  I didn't want to be rude, but I felt like I needed to show her that she couldn't push me around.  Is there a swin technique to handle this?

 

Well, I like to teach what I call "defensive swimming". It's really very basic.... 1) if someone touches your toes, you start kicking really hard. It will let them know someone is there, and that someone is NOT going down easy, so they better go around. 2) if someone is on your side, you can place a hand on them and push them away. Simple as that. Not push them UNDER, but away from you. Works best on the shoulder.

Holy hell. You teach that? So much to say here that I won't. 

Whatever happened to picking the right starting spot, finding some open water, and adjusting as you go? 

To the OP, AdventureBear got it right: swim your race, adjust as you need to, and don't burn a lot of energy trying to deal with goofy swimmers. You'll save energy and get 'em on the bike and run. Just stay cool. 

I don't quite get that either.  You can spend your time pushing people, or you can spend your time swimming.  Swimming will get you to the finish line.  People touch toes.  If they are drafting off of you, they will touch your toes sometimes.  People bump into each other.  People get disoriented and swim at a funny angle.  It happens.  I ignore it and keep swimming.  Why get worked up over that, it's just an OWS with lots of bodies in the water.  The better and faster you are, the less you will have to contend with.

2012-06-24 9:29 PM
in reply to: #4278073

User image

Master
2177
2000100252525
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
BrianRunsPhilly - 2012-06-25 1:02 AM

smoothj - 2012-06-24 7:11 PM I'm a slow swimmer at the back of the pack.  What do I do if someone is obviously trying to push me out of the way?  It would be very easy for them to swim around me, but they are purposefully being invasive.  It's not like they were really good and I was in their way.  I feel like I should assert myself and not let them get over.

I'm a slow swimmer and was in contact off and on with someone for about 200 yards today at an Oly. If I were to guess I'd say neither of us wanted this, but for whatever reason it happened. I wasn't trying to be aggressive and I doubt they were either. We just couldn't seem to get out of each other's way.

Believe me, if they were faster than you and it was intentional (or not) this would have been over in 15 seconds. They would have swam over you and been gone. That's the way it is.

This happened to me. This guy and I were side by side for some time, constantly crashing into each other, kicking and smacking one other trying get some space between us. Not intentional, but we both knew we're on the right line to the buoy so no way were either of us going to go wide to give space. We each tried to just get ahead of each other. Then, as usual, I drifted off course. Sigh.

The pushing could be to get a little space too by someone nervous about being close in the water.



Edited by Blanda 2012-06-24 9:33 PM
2012-06-24 10:11 PM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

Coach
9167
5000200020001002525
Stairway to Seven
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
So here's the thing about being in the line of sight for a bouy....

Suppose the bouy is 50 yards away and you and the person next to you are both swimming towards it, the same speed, and bumping constantly . One of you moves 3 feet to the right. Which one is closer to the bouy? How far is X?

OK...this little diagram below didn't work....the diagonal slashes represted the "longer distance" to the bouy...but you can get the idea even though the diagram is not to scale

* ---------50m------------*
| /
| /
1m /
| /
| / X ?
| /
*

Pythagorean Theorem:
a squared + b squared = C squared

1 + 2500 = c squared
c = Square Root of 2501
c = 50m (rounded to nearest meter)


you are the same distance away. So just move over, you'll be fine and they will be out of your way.


Edited by AdventureBear 2012-06-24 10:12 PM
2012-06-24 10:24 PM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

Champion
7595
50002000500252525
Columbia, South Carolina
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers

x10 to whatever AB was trying to say.  Wink

Seriously, moving left or right a meter costs you basically nothing.  If it gets you out of the way of someone who is causing problems, it is by far a net gain.

2012-06-24 10:26 PM
in reply to: #4278184

User image

Master
2177
2000100252525
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers

I eventually do move over. Faaaar over. Like swimming to the next island over, haha! I need help sighting. I dunno. I lose sight of the packed of feet and I'm all sorts of disorientated.

I do enjoy the swim while I'm at though!



Edited by Blanda 2012-06-24 10:26 PM


2012-06-25 12:10 AM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

New user
38
25
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
If you are going the same speed or slightlty slower then let them pass and then draft.  If they are faster then it makes much more sense to go around rather than over someone.  I bump into other swimmers and have others bump into me but the problem is always resolved in a few seconds.  Maybe a little more during the start and close to buoys.
2012-06-25 2:54 AM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

Elite
7783
50002000500100100252525
PEI, Canada
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers

+1 to just swimming your race - move over a few feet and get on with it.

I'd be willing to bet that the other swimmer was thinking the same thing as you - that you were being aggressive with her and intentionally pushing her out of the way.

2012-06-25 3:10 AM
in reply to: #4277928

User image

Extreme Veteran
929
50010010010010025
, Kobenhavns Kommune
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers

I'm one of those fast swimmers. Nobody is intentionally aggressive, everyone just want to do their thing. It can be really hard to see somebody in time to go around, it happens to me regularly that I touch some slower swimmer and by the next stroke I'm half way over while trying to get around. 

In OWS you'll likely meet the faster swimmer only once, even if you have to do multiple loops, by the second loop people have been spread out and it's not a problem. In the beginning it's a big chaos and either may have a problem giving room because other swimmers have taken that space. 

If you find yourself swimming next to someone who want to pass the easiest it to let him slip by, slow down slightly while he pass and you'll have one less to mess with.

Better yet, avoid the problem entirely: The trick is to learn to place yourself in the pack, if you know you're a slow swimmer, no point rushing to be the first in the water. Also, you can place yourself away from the centre out to the side, it's only slightly longer to the first buoy and much easier swim.

Last thing, could be it's not really a faster swimmer but one of you is off course? Do your sighting to check you're on the right course, if not adjust, else keep going, let the other slip around and get off track. 

KSH - 2012-06-25 2:09 AM Well, I like to teach what I call "defensive swimming". It's really very basic.... 1) if someone touches your toes, you start kicking really hard. It will let them know someone is there, and that someone is NOT going down easy, so they better go around. 2) if someone is on your side, you can place a hand on them and push them away. Simple as that. Not push them UNDER, but away from you. Works best on the shoulder.

Touching your toes is the fast swimmer's way of "honking". If somebody intentionally touches your toes it's a gentle way to let you know that you will be passed. Don't fight it, just keep at your thing, he'll slip around.

If somebody unintentionally touches your toes, by the next stroke they may be half way over your legs trying to figure out which way to go around you. Kicking vigorously you can kick him in the face and cause injury, that's not defensive swimming, it's aggressive swimming.

If I find myself trying to pass somebody who's trying to fight the inevitable, swimming "defensively" kicking hard and getting in the way or kicking me in the face, that might just be the time that I grab them by ankle and pull. No ... it's not something I resort to on a regular basis. 

Cheers, Erik

2012-06-25 5:24 AM
in reply to: #4277851

User image

Regular
160
1002525
Albury, Australia
Subject: RE: Aggressive Swimmers
I started my swimming many years ago playing water polo. I am now a BOP swimmer, but have never had any real problems with the contact in OWS's, it is all so tame compared to a "spirited water polo game! In saying that, you really do burn a lot of energy "defensive swimming" (oh I love that term, we called it trying to kick/hit someone). I mean a LOT. It is/was the hardest part of polo. MUCH easier to let them by, the distance spent will be much better than the energy spent on a struggle.
New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Aggressive Swimmers Rss Feed  
 
 
of 3