Other Resources The Political Joe » Catholics - Why do you do that? Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 4
 
 
2013-04-29 10:42 PM

User image

Master
2380
2000100100100252525
Beijing
Subject: Catholics - Why do you do that?

In response to some questions in another thread, I decided to post this thread.

Ever had something you wanted to ask a Catholic, but just haven't?

Ever been really curious but afraid to ask?

Ever asked, but never understood the answer?

Let this thread be your opportunity.   As with all threads of this nature, please be civil. 

I hope that DonTracy(CoJ's most prominent Catholic? :^)  and all of the other Catholics here will feel free to chime in when you see someone ask a question that you feel you can answer.

If you are too shy to ask, or just want to see for yourself, you can start with the online Catechism of the Catholic Church. It's a really great research tool, and it's annotated to try to indicate WHERE the church teaching comes from.

Please, ask away!



2013-04-30 12:26 AM
in reply to: #4720103

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?

I was Catholic......Irish Catholic by heritage.  

Since you brought up the other thread, I'll answer a question that was asked there:

 

In light of the systematic abuse of children at the hands of Catholic priests and other officials, and the institutional denial and cover-up by the Catholic Church,  I no longer identify myself, in any way, with the Catholic Church.  I cannot, and will never be able to, connect myself or my beliefs with any organization that does not stand up and protect children above and beyond any tenant or benefit of the organization as a whole.  

As far as I'm concerned, the Catholic Church should no longer exist in any form.

2013-04-30 5:46 AM
in reply to: #4720103

User image

Veteran
485
100100100100252525
Elmira, ON
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?

In my late 30's and last Easter was confirmed Catholic.  Took the Catholic Rite of Initiation Classes all winter and was happy to join the Catholic Communion.  Didn't leave the Anglican Church per say, but considering the closest Anglican church is over 1/2 hour away and the Catholic is about 3 minutes....well..you get the idea.    

My questions...which our Priest was very passionate about but I never got a sufficient answer due to time constraints, and the class dynamics.....

1)What is it with praying to Saints.  The bible specifically says you don't get to God except through his Son.  Where is the basis for this?  Please don't tell me it's "just tradition."  Seriously...praying to dead people?  gimme some info. on this one.

2)Whats up with purgatory?  Nothing in the bible on this one I could find.  The two bible verses that were given to us on this seemed awfully vague and when read with respect to the entire chapter didn't seem to relate....  So...whats up with that?

Thanks dude.  You know...beginnertriathlete.com forum always amazes me....threads from guns, to catholics, to the economy....maybe it's me, but I don't see such a great range of topics even in off topic sections in other forums I subscribe too.

 

2013-04-30 5:49 AM
in reply to: #4720103

User image

Regular
217
100100
The Sipp
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?

The abuse of children is just the small tip of the iceberg of the (what is called now), “crimes against  humanity”, the is associated with the Catholic church. 

I am not going to go into any history lesson here as it is just a Google click away, and I am not going to bash any persons personal beliefs, but I will say that I sure hope God is forgiving as everyone says he is.

 



Edited by pprice72 2013-04-30 5:52 AM
2013-04-30 6:13 AM
in reply to: #4720103

User image

Elite
3770
200010005001001002525
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
And these are reasons why I don't like identifying my religion or political beliefs.... And why I'm more moved by spirituality, not the laws of the man made church. Man is flawed, God is not.
2013-04-30 6:30 AM
in reply to: #4720138

User image

Regular
5477
5000100100100100252525
LHOTP
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
Left Brain - 2013-04-30 12:26 AM

I was Catholic......Irish Catholic by heritage.  

Since you brought up the other thread, I'll answer a question that was asked there:

 

In light of the systematic abuse of children at the hands of Catholic priests and other officials, and the institutional denial and cover-up by the Catholic Church,  I no longer identify myself, in any way, with the Catholic Church.  I cannot, and will never be able to, connect myself or my beliefs with any organization that does not stand up and protect children above and beyond any tenant or benefit of the organization as a whole.  

As far as I'm concerned, the Catholic Church should no longer exist in any form.

I got wet eyes and goosebumps reading your post LB.  That's a very powerful statement. Thank you.



2013-04-30 7:07 AM
in reply to: #4720200

User image

Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
TheCrownsOwn - 

1)What is it with praying to Saints.  The bible specifically says you don't get to God except through his Son.  Where is the basis for this?  Please don't tell me it's "just tradition."  Seriously...praying to dead people?  gimme some info. on this one.

2)Whats up with purgatory?  Nothing in the bible on this one I could find.  The two bible verses that were given to us on this seemed awfully vague and when read with respect to the entire chapter didn't seem to relate....  So...whats up with that?

Thanks dude.  You know...beginnertriathlete.com forum always amazes me....threads from guns, to catholics, to the economy....maybe it's me, but I don't see such a great range of topics even in off topic sections in other forums I subscribe too.

It's good to remember that not all doctrine or dogma can be found directly in the Bible.  For example, no where in the Bible does it say that the Bible alone is the final authority on doctrine, dogma, faith, and morals.  

No where in the Bible will you find the dogma of the trinity or the incarnation.

From the beginning of the Church it was understood that the authority for teachings rested with the Church herself.  This understanding we actually do find in the Bible in 1 Timothy 3:15:

if I am delayed, you will know how people ought to conduct themselves in God's household, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and foundation of the truth.

It was also understood from the beginning that the authority within the Church for defining doctrine and dogma rested with the magisterium, the college of bishops, with the bishop of Rome being the head.

There was no agreed upon cannon of books of scripture until late in the 4th century. The magisterium, with the final authority of Pope Damasus, then defined the cannon of scripture that came to be called the Bible.  (Luther later changed the books included in the cannon, but maybe that's better left for the thread: Why to Protestants to that)

So for the first four hundred years of the Church, there was scripture but no Bible. It took the authority of the magisterium of the Church to define the books included in what we now call the Bible.

(I didn't answer your two questions yet.  I'll come back to them or maybe someone else will jump in. )



Edited by dontracy 2013-04-30 7:07 AM
2013-04-30 7:33 AM
in reply to: #4720103

User image

Champion
7347
5000200010010010025
SRQ, FL
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?

OK so one my questions was already asked (child abuse issues) but to be honest I've heard the answer before anyway.  The CC needs to clean house if they want to try to regain any respect IMHO.

Moving on... what's up with lack of birth control?  Seems like a VERY outdated belief. And one that VERY few Catholics follow.  So what has the church been so slow to change?

Finally, what's up with the Pope?  Why do you need a single person to "rule" the church?  What makes this person any more special then you or I.  I think by placing him on a pedestal you go against some of the very teachings of the Bible.  The very theory of "Papal Infallibility" seems to fly in the face of "For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God"

2013-04-30 7:50 AM
in reply to: #4720138

User image

Champion
7036
5000200025
Sarasota, FL
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
Left Brain - 2013-04-30 1:26 AM

I was Catholic......Irish Catholic by heritage.  

Since you brought up the other thread, I'll answer a question that was asked there:

 

In light of the systematic abuse of children at the hands of Catholic priests and other officials, and the institutional denial and cover-up by the Catholic Church,  I no longer identify myself, in any way, with the Catholic Church.  I cannot, and will never be able to, connect myself or my beliefs with any organization that does not stand up and protect children above and beyond any tenant or benefit of the organization as a whole.  

As far as I'm concerned, the Catholic Church should no longer exist in any form.

Unfortunately the Catholic Church doesn't have an exclusive on abusive behavior or organizational cover-ups.  I'm a life-long Presbyterian and have been an elder at my congregation for the past 25 years.  During that time we're removed two ordained pastors, one who was found to be a pedophile and most recently a senior pastor who was abusive and threatening to women.  In both cases we discovered after the fact that the Church heirarchy knew about, and had covered up these individuals' histories over the course of their careers.  Our General Presbyter (head of our region) even admitted to me at one point that the Church's priority was to protect and counsel the ordained pastors, rather than looking after the welfare of the congregation they were serving.   

The Catholic Church may get more headlines, but abuses are going on elsewhere too.  One advantage our Presbyterian denomination has is the local congregation has the automomy to both hire and fire ordained staff.   

Mark

 

 

2013-04-30 8:07 AM
in reply to: #4720311

User image

Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?

Kim Rhode is a five time Olympic clay shooting champion. She just won a gold medal at London in Skeet. Her first medal was gold at Atlanta.  I think she's the only American Olympian to win a medal in five consecutive games. She recently said that the first question she's asked these days when she speaks is what she thinks about Newtown.

I guess it's human nature.

I have someone very close to me who was sexually abused as a child.  It was by a member of a Protestant denomination who was a known perpetrator and was shuttled around by church elders.  

We watched Les Miserables this past weekend.  One of Jean Valjean's early moral discernments is whether to save his soul or the livelihood of the hundred who worked for him.  Maybe that's what was going on with the elders of the church my survivor belonged to.  Hard to say.

My survivor.

For several years now, I've been a member of a peer support group of those who ourselves support survivors of childhood sexual abuse.  I've learned more about the long term effects of sexual abuse than I ever cared to know.  I understand now that with rare exceptions, survivors of childhood sexual abuse can never really fully recover from their wounds.  They are too deep and they happen at a time when brain development can be organically affected.  The best strategy I believe now is for survivors to learn to manage their very real disability.

I deal in a very real way with the legacy of childhood sexual abuse every day of my life.  It is a life long wound that can have bitter effects to the seventh generation.

My middle child was being baptized when the sexual abuse scandal in the Catholic Church first surfaced.  I was living a life of objective sin, and doing so happily.  Or so I thought. There was  always something tugging at my conscience.

This was all fine more or less since I belonged to a very liberal parish. Call it the "Parish of what's happening now." I remember other parents bringing their children for baptism.  They were also happily living in objective sin.  They were also vehemently criticizing the Church and her leaders.

I thought, "You know what? something is off here. How can I criticize the bishops for what they've done when I myself glibly refuse to follow Church teaching?"

So instead of putting energy toward criticizing the Church, I set about cleaning up my own sins. I'm still working on it.



Edited by dontracy 2013-04-30 8:08 AM
2013-04-30 8:20 AM
in reply to: #4720277

User image

Elite
4564
200020005002525
Boise
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
dontracy - 2013-04-30 6:07 AM
TheCrownsOwn - 

1)What is it with praying to Saints.  The bible specifically says you don't get to God except through his Son.  Where is the basis for this?  Please don't tell me it's "just tradition."  Seriously...praying to dead people?  gimme some info. on this one.

2)Whats up with purgatory?  Nothing in the bible on this one I could find.  The two bible verses that were given to us on this seemed awfully vague and when read with respect to the entire chapter didn't seem to relate....  So...whats up with that?

Thanks dude.  You know...beginnertriathlete.com forum always amazes me....threads from guns, to catholics, to the economy....maybe it's me, but I don't see such a great range of topics even in off topic sections in other forums I subscribe too.

It's good to remember that not all doctrine or dogma can be found directly in the Bible.  For example, no where in the Bible does it say that the Bible alone is the final authority on doctrine, dogma, faith, and morals.  

No where in the Bible will you find the dogma of the trinity or the incarnation.

From the beginning of the Church it was understood that the authority for teachings rested with the Church herself.  This understanding we actually do find in the Bible in 1 Timothy 3:15:

if I am delayed, you will know how people ought to conduct themselves in God's household, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and foundation of the truth.

It was also understood from the beginning that the authority within the Church for defining doctrine and dogma rested with the magisterium, the college of bishops, with the bishop of Rome being the head.

There was no agreed upon cannon of books of scripture until late in the 4th century. The magisterium, with the final authority of Pope Damasus, then defined the cannon of scripture that came to be called the Bible.  (Luther later changed the books included in the cannon, but maybe that's better left for the thread: Why to Protestants to that)

So for the first four hundred years of the Church, there was scripture but no Bible. It took the authority of the magisterium of the Church to define the books included in what we now call the Bible.

(I didn't answer your two questions yet.  I'll come back to them or maybe someone else will jump in. )

Don, in regards to the church being the authority for teachings. Why was this originally set up in this manner? I'm sure even a few thousand years ago everyone knew that that kind of power can go to someone's head. This would leave the sole authority for interpreting God's will open to corruption. I don't think it's a stretch to say that we have in fact seen that during the history of the church (think Indulgences).



2013-04-30 8:20 AM
in reply to: #4720103

User image

Master
1795
1000500100100252525
Boynton Beach, FL
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?

I send my kids to catholic school and it is to get a good base in the principles of our religion.  This is not exclusive to catholic religion, but to me there are some great lessons in honesty, trust, belief, morals, etc that go hand in hand with the teachings and study of religion.   That doesn't mean you cant teach those things otherwise, it is just the reason I chose.  

2013-04-30 8:52 AM
in reply to: #4720386

User image

Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?

JoshR - in regards to the church being the authority for teachings. Why was this originally set up in this manner?

Gotta look to Jesus for that one.

Jesus says in Matthew 16:18-19

And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of the netherworld shall not prevail against it.
I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.” 

This is an echo of Isaiah and would have been understood as such.  From Isaiah 22:20-22

On that day I will summon my servant
Eliakim, son of Hilkiah;
I will clothe him with your robe,
gird him with your sash,
confer on him your authority.
He shall be a father to the inhabitants of Jerusalem,
and to the house of Judah.
I will place the key of the House of David on his shoulder;
what he opens, no one will shut,
what he shuts, no one will open.

In Isaiah, Eliakim holds the key to the kingdom as a minister to the king, not as the key's owner. In a sense, Eliakim is the prime minister.

Jesus' words to Peter would not have been lost on the other disciples.  Jesus was referencing Isaiah. Peter is Eliakim, the prime minister holding the key for Jesus the king.

Think of it in just a practical sense. Why would Jesus leave the Church without some sort of authoritative structure?  We know historically that authority wasn't the Bible. The Bible as we know it didn't exist.

What did exist in the early Church was the magisterium; the prime minister and the other ministers, the bishops.

 

 

 



Edited by dontracy 2013-04-30 8:53 AM
2013-04-30 9:02 AM
in reply to: #4720203

User image

Veteran
312
100100100
St. Paul
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
pprice72 - 2013-04-30 5:49 AM

The abuse of children is just the small tip of the iceberg of the (what is called now), “crimes against  humanity”, the is associated with the Catholic church. 

I am not going to go into any history lesson here as it is just a Google click away, and I am not going to bash any persons personal beliefs, but I will say that I sure hope God is forgiving as everyone says he is.

 

... this went the predicatable route faster than I expected.  I think I'll be avoiding this thread.

2013-04-30 9:11 AM
in reply to: #4720460

Master
2009
2000
Charlotte, NC
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
Nathanm74 - 2013-04-30 10:02 AM
pprice72 - 2013-04-30 5:49 AM

The abuse of children is just the small tip of the iceberg of the (what is called now), “crimes against  humanity”, the is associated with the Catholic church. 

I am not going to go into any history lesson here as it is just a Google click away, and I am not going to bash any persons personal beliefs, but I will say that I sure hope God is forgiving as everyone says he is.

 

... this went the predicatable route faster than I expected.  I think I'll be avoiding this thread.

I had the same thought.

2013-04-30 9:14 AM
in reply to: #4720364

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
dontracy - 2013-04-30 8:07 AM

Kim Rhode is a five time Olympic clay shooting champion. She just won a gold medal at London in Skeet. Her first medal was gold at Atlanta.  I think she's the only American Olympian to win a medal in five consecutive games. She recently said that the first question she's asked these days when she speaks is what she thinks about Newtown.

I guess it's human nature.

I have someone very close to me who was sexually abused as a child.  It was by a member of a Protestant denomination who was a known perpetrator and was shuttled around by church elders.  

We watched Les Miserables this past weekend.  One of Jean Valjean's early moral discernments is whether to save his soul or the livelihood of the hundred who worked for him.  Maybe that's what was going on with the elders of the church my survivor belonged to.  Hard to say.

My survivor.

For several years now, I've been a member of a peer support group of those who ourselves support survivors of childhood sexual abuse.  I've learned more about the long term effects of sexual abuse than I ever cared to know.  I understand now that with rare exceptions, survivors of childhood sexual abuse can never really fully recover from their wounds.  They are too deep and they happen at a time when brain development can be organically affected.  The best strategy I believe now is for survivors to learn to manage their very real disability.

I deal in a very real way with the legacy of childhood sexual abuse every day of my life.  It is a life long wound that can have bitter effects to the seventh generation.

My middle child was being baptized when the sexual abuse scandal in the Catholic Church first surfaced.  I was living a life of objective sin, and doing so happily.  Or so I thought. There was  always something tugging at my conscience.

This was all fine more or less since I belonged to a very liberal parish. Call it the "Parish of what's happening now." I remember other parents bringing their children for baptism.  They were also happily living in objective sin.  They were also vehemently criticizing the Church and her leaders.

I thought, "You know what? something is off here. How can I criticize the bishops for what they've done when I myself glibly refuse to follow Church teaching?"

So instead of putting energy toward criticizing the Church, I set about cleaning up my own sins. I'm still working on it.

I always enjoy your posts about religion and the Catholic Church......it is obvious you put alot of time and thought into your religious beliefs.

I have seen the destruction firsthand as well, and then I had the unfortunate circumstance to investigate some of the crimes on a professional level.  The behavior involved in the denial and attempted coverup sickened me worse then the actual acts committed by individuals.

Personal sin or not, I'm done with that bunch.



2013-04-30 9:33 AM
in reply to: #4720364

User image

Master
1327
100010010010025
Ann Arbor, Michigan
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
dontracy - 2013-04-30 9:07 AM

I have someone very close to me who was sexually abused as a child.  It was by a member of a Protestant denomination who was a known perpetrator and was shuttled around by church elders.  

For several years now, I've been a member of a peer support group of those who ourselves support survivors of childhood sexual abuse.  I've learned more about the long term effects of sexual abuse than I ever cared to know.  I understand now that with rare exceptions, survivors of childhood sexual abuse can never really fully recover from their wounds.  They are too deep and they happen at a time when brain development can be organically affected.  The best strategy I believe now is for survivors to learn to manage their very real disability.

I deal in a very real way with the legacy of childhood sexual abuse every day of my life.  It is a life long wound that can have bitter effects to the seventh generation.

Question-I'm confused, are you making these statements as someone who IS a survivor or supporting someone who is a survivor?

2013-04-30 9:34 AM
in reply to: #4720200

User image

Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
TheCrownsOwn - 

1)What is it with praying to Saints.  The bible specifically says you don't get to God except through his Son.  Where is the basis for this?  Please don't tell me it's "just tradition."  Seriously...praying to dead people?  gimme some info. on this one.

2)Whats up with purgatory?  Nothing in the bible on this one I could find.  The two bible verses that were given to us on this seemed awfully vague and when read with respect to the entire chapter didn't seem to relate....  So...whats up with that?

There is one Universal Church, itself comprised of human persons alive in three states:

  • Those in heaven
  • Those still striving on earth
  • Those in purgatory

Human persons in heaven we call saints.  

Christians ask each other all the time to pray for them.  It happens here on BT on a regular basis.  So Christians seem to have a universal understanding that it is a good thing to ask for intercession from another or to intercede for them.

In the old meaning of the english word, we pray to each other when we do this: "Pray, please beg God on my behalf that I might be healed of this illness."

Does that make sense?

We know from scripture that the saints in heaven pray. Revelation 5:8:

When he took it, the four living creatures and the twenty-four elders fell down
before the Lamb. Each of the elders held a harp and golden bowls full of incense,
which are the prayers of the holy ones.

Why would the saints pray?  They are already enjoying the beatific vision and have no need of anything, yet they intercede in prayer for someone.

Yes, we ask each other to pray for us, to intercede on our behalf. That is a good thing. Who better to intercede for us than one who already enjoys the beatific vision of God, the holy ones in heaven?  

(I know I didn't answer your second question yet. )



Edited by dontracy 2013-04-30 9:44 AM
2013-04-30 9:36 AM
in reply to: #4720523

User image

Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?

travljini - Question-I'm confused, are you making these statements as someone who IS a survivor or supporting someone who is a survivor?

Supporting a survivor.  I wish to keep them confidential.

2013-04-30 9:47 AM
in reply to: #4720490

User image

Philadelphia, south of New York and north of DC
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?

Left Brain - Personal sin or not, I'm done with that bunch.

I went clay busting with one of my sons over the weekend. He's got potential to be great.
Me, I'm hopeless.

2013-04-30 9:53 AM
in reply to: #4720200

User image

Regular
641
50010025
Chicago
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
TheCrownsOwn - 2013-04-30 5:46 AM

1)What is it with praying to Saints.  The bible specifically says you don't get to God except through his Son.  Where is the basis for this?  Please don't tell me it's "just tradition."  Seriously...praying to dead people?  gimme some info. on this one.

I don't think praying to the saints is strictly a Catholic thing, as Eastern Orthodox religions do this too.

In the Apostles' Creed, Catholics state that they believe in the "communion of saints", which includes (but is not limited to) those in heaven.

We ask the saints to hear our prayers and use their influence w/God to intercede on our behalf. It's not that we aren't praying to God - but we are praying to God and also the saints.

In the other thread, some people pointed out that Catholics might not interpret the Bible as literally as those in other faiths, which I support in my view, and as a Catholic, bc I wouldn't say that the Bible "specifically" says you don't get to God except through Jesus.



2013-04-30 9:54 AM
in reply to: #4720103

User image

Extreme Veteran
2263
20001001002525
Ridgeland, Mississippi
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?

Nvm.  I'm just going to sit this one out.



Edited by msteiner 2013-04-30 9:55 AM
2013-04-30 9:54 AM
in reply to: #4720545

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
dontracy - 2013-04-30 9:47 AM

Left Brain - Personal sin or not, I'm done with that bunch.

I went clay busting with one of my sons over the weekend. He's got potential to be great.
Me, I'm hopeless.

That's a great way to spend an afternoon.  I have found that kids are frequently good shooters right out of the gate.......and then the bad habits creep in as they don't practice (like the rest of us).  If he's got the eye, keep him going!

2013-04-30 9:56 AM
in reply to: #4720561

User image

Regular
5477
5000100100100100252525
LHOTP
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
msteiner - 2013-04-30 9:54 AM

I know that it's been echoed through this thread, but it's really unfortunate that a conversation about the Catholic faith can't happen without someone bring up sexual abuse.  It's unfortunate that it happened, but it's something that occurs in all denominations.

The systemic, institutional cover-up happens in all denominations?

2013-04-30 9:57 AM
in reply to: #4720561

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Catholics - Why do you do that?
msteiner - 2013-04-30 9:54 AM

I know that it's been echoed through this thread, but it's really unfortunate that a conversation about the Catholic faith can't happen without someone bring up sexual abuse.  It's unfortunate that it happened, but it's something that occurs in all denominations.

True, it happens in ALL walks of life.  But in this case, the abuse was systematic and the coverup was a matter of practice.  The Cathlolic Church has itself to blame.  Period.

I hate that it happened.....but I can't be associated with it, my conscience won't allow it.

New Thread
Other Resources The Political Joe » Catholics - Why do you do that? Rss Feed  
 
 
of 4