General Discussion Triathlon Talk » ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??! Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 6
 
 
2008-04-27 3:33 PM
in reply to: #1364831

User image

Champion
8936
50002000100050010010010010025
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!

PennState - 2008-04-27 3:23 PM That's just friggin' weird man.... for not coming to a complete stop??

What's weird about it?  Not to pile on, but if we want to be treated as vehicles on the road, we should obey the same laws cars do.



2008-04-27 3:43 PM
in reply to: #1364836

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
2008-04-27 3:47 PM
in reply to: #1364844

Champion
8936
50002000100050010010010010025
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
PennState - 2008-04-27 3:43 PM
DerekL - 2008-04-27 4:33 PM

PennState - 2008-04-27 3:23 PM That's just friggin' weird man.... for not coming to a complete stop??

What's weird about it?  Not to pile on, but if we want to be treated as vehicles on the road, we should obey the same laws cars do.

Your right... it's perfectly normal and expected... my mistake

Normal and expected have nothing to do with it.  You wouldn't complain (much) if you got a similar ticket in your car.

2008-04-27 3:49 PM
in reply to: #1364817

Champion
10157
500050001002525
Alabama
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
sty - 2008-04-27 3:07 PM

My unpopular honest reply would be that as cyclists, we're always wanting the same rights to use the roadways as automobiles and want to be respected on the roadways as automobiles, so why wouldn't we be expected to follow the same rules of the road and laws as automobiles?

I'll agree that the cop likely had a bee up his arse in his bonnet and 9 out of 10 cops might turn a blind eye, but dude, the law is the law and just as I try to set a good example for my kids by always wearing a helmet on the bike, I always follow the rules of the road when on the bike. Respect begets respect.

 

 

 

The law also says that if you exeed the speed limit by 1 mph you are breaking the law.  That's why we have the human element....to judge the spirit of the law and the letter of the law.  How long does one have to 'stop' at a stop sign in a car?  Do you have to rebound on your shocks?  Is a momentary pause sufficent?  Does that meet the letter of the law?  Sure it does.  Is that the spirit of the law?  No.

A question to the OP is, did you slow down and 'almost stop' or did you just blow right through the intersection? 

I was driving behind/beside a teenager recently who was text messaging on his cell phone.  He was weaving as he was driving.  I followed him for a few miles and he just kept typing away on his cell phone.  I pulled up beside him a traffic light and since he had his window down I told him "You're a road hazard.  Hang up the damn phone!?"  He flipped me off.

We don't have no-phone use laws here but we do have reckless driving laws and I think cops would do more for traffic safety by writting tickets for cell phone use than for giving tickets to bicyclists.

~Mike

2008-04-27 3:55 PM
in reply to: #1364423

Regular
357
1001001002525
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
Move to Idaho. Not entirely sure about this, but I've heard that it's the only state where cyclists can use stop signs like Yield signs.
2008-04-27 3:57 PM
in reply to: #1364748

Pro
4481
20002000100100100100252525
Reston
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!

rayd - 2008-04-27 3:27 PM That's pretty chicken sh#t if you ask me!  If you weren't putting anybody at risk he should have let it go. 

So it's okay to ignore the laws, just so long as we aren't putting others at risk?



2008-04-27 4:07 PM
in reply to: #1364863

Champion
10157
500050001002525
Alabama
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
3558 - 2008-04-27 3:57 PM

rayd - 2008-04-27 3:27 PM That's pretty chicken sh#t if you ask me!  If you weren't putting anybody at risk he should have let it go. 

So it's okay to ignore the laws, just so long as we aren't putting others at risk?

 

Absolutely!  Where do we get the idea that it is the gubment's job to protect the citizenry from themselves? 

2008-04-27 4:19 PM
in reply to: #1364878

Champion
8936
50002000100050010010010010025
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
Rogillio - 2008-04-27 4:07 PM
3558 - 2008-04-27 3:57 PM

rayd - 2008-04-27 3:27 PM That's pretty chicken sh#t if you ask me!  If you weren't putting anybody at risk he should have let it go. 

So it's okay to ignore the laws, just so long as we aren't putting others at risk?

 

Absolutely!  Where do we get the idea that it is the gubment's job to protect the citizenry from themselves? 

Well, when your ancestors accepted citizenship here.  You can work to change the laws if you'd like, but they're still the law until that happens.

2008-04-27 4:38 PM
in reply to: #1364899

Champion
10157
500050001002525
Alabama
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
DerekL - 2008-04-27 4:19 PM
Rogillio - 2008-04-27 4:07 PM
3558 - 2008-04-27 3:57 PM

rayd - 2008-04-27 3:27 PM That's pretty chicken sh#t if you ask me!  If you weren't putting anybody at risk he should have let it go. 

So it's okay to ignore the laws, just so long as we aren't putting others at risk?

 

Absolutely!  Where do we get the idea that it is the gubment's job to protect the citizenry from themselves? 

Well, when your ancestors accepted citizenship here.  You can work to change the laws if you'd like, but they're still the law until that happens.

 

Is this an opinion or are you referring to a specific part of the US Constitution that says "the government's role shall include protecting people from their own stupidity".  If there is such a clause, then we need more laws ASAP.  Riding a motorcyle is dangerous.  Eating too much red meat....sednetary lifestyle....smoking cigarettes....drinking alchohol.  Opps, already tried to ban that once.

I'm not defending or condeming the OP becuase we don't know the details.  If he just blew right through the intersection than he was a danger not only to himself but to motorists who might hit him or take evasive action to not hit him.  But it he slowed down to a crawl and can see no traffic coming from either direction then so what if he did not unclip and put a foot down?!  My point is that there needs to be some judgement exercised....by the cyclist and the cops.  The 'serves your right attitude' amazes and apalls me.

BTW, while we're stoning this guy....Do have a mirror on your bike to be able to see cars behind them?  Do have a flashing taillight to increase visability?  Do you wear high-vis phlorescent yellow when you ride?  These might not be "laws" but they ought to be.  How many of us took the reflectors off our wheels when we bought out bikes becuase that wasn't cool?

~Mike



Edited by Rogillio 2008-04-27 4:50 PM
2008-04-27 4:42 PM
in reply to: #1364836

Coach
10487
50005000100100100100252525
Boston, MA
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
DerekL - 2008-04-27 3:33 PM

PennState - 2008-04-27 3:23 PM That's just friggin' weird man.... for not coming to a complete stop??

What's weird about it?  Not to pile on, but if we want to be treated as vehicles on the road, we should obey the same laws cars do.

DerekL - 2008-04-27 3:33 PM

What's weird about it?  Not to pile on, but if we want to be treated as vehicles on the road, we should obey the same laws cars do.

exaclty, cyclists b*tch that drivers don't treat us with respect, we are at risk, and bla bla bla but many want it both ways; they want us to have the right to ride on the road as any other vehicle but they don't want to follow the traffic rules.

2008-04-27 4:47 PM
in reply to: #1364922

Champion
8936
50002000100050010010010010025
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
Rogillio - 2008-04-27 4:38 PM  The 'serves your right attitude' amazes and apalls me.

 

~Mike

Nobody's saying anything of the sort.  Most are saying to quit complaining that you got caught breaking a law.  You can disagree with the law all you want.

None of the rest of your rant is remotely relevant, even though I probably agree with most of it.



2008-04-27 4:55 PM
in reply to: #1364936

Champion
10157
500050001002525
Alabama
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
DerekL - 2008-04-27 4:47 PM
Rogillio - 2008-04-27 4:38 PM  The 'serves your right attitude' amazes and apalls me.

 

~Mike

Nobody's saying anything of the sort.  Most are saying to quit complaining that you got caught breaking a law.  You can disagree with the law all you want.

None of the rest of your rant is remotely relevant, even though I probably agree with most of it.

 

You are right.  Point taken.  I guess I'm assuming he is complaining becuase he did not feel the ticket was justified.

If you got a speeding ticket for going 2 miles over the speed limint, would you not complain?

2008-04-27 4:57 PM
in reply to: #1364678

Member
37
25
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!

 

Even though you don't have a driver's license you can still have a driving record and you still must pay the fine. People who are cited for driving without a license have a driving record that shows the offense of driving without a license - points and all.

The real issue here is safety. If the OP goes to court and explains that what he did was safer for himself and the public ,the judge may very well find him to be not guilty. Good Luck! 

LaurenSU02 - 2008-04-27 1:35 PM

swbkrun - 2008-04-27 11:21 AM 65 miles into my ride yesterday I get pulled over by a COP for a FAILURE TO COME TO A COMPLETE STOP @ A STOP SIGN!!! I knew I didn't stop fully, but I stopped enough to let another car go ahead of me!! I am so sticking mad. He gave me a $124 ticket.... WHICH IS A MOVING VIOLATION and goes on my driving record! I need advice from anyone- lawyers, cops, experienced (this before) people, etc.... This sucks!

So what happens to the people who don't have driver's licenses? My uncle got pulled over once for doing 30 in a 25 on his bicycle. The cop asked for his license, which he had. He ended up getting a citation and not a ticket, but what happens if you aren't a licensed driver? I guess they can still give you a ticket, there's just no driving record for it to go on?

2008-04-27 5:15 PM
in reply to: #1364852

Extreme Veteran
422
100100100100
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
Rogillio - 2008-04-27 3:49 PM

sty - 2008-04-27 3:07 PM

My unpopular honest reply would be that as cyclists, we're always wanting the same rights to use the roadways as automobiles and want to be respected on the roadways as automobiles, so why wouldn't we be expected to follow the same rules of the road and laws as automobiles?

I'll agree that the cop likely had a bee up his arse in his bonnet and 9 out of 10 cops might turn a blind eye, but dude, the law is the law and just as I try to set a good example for my kids by always wearing a helmet on the bike, I always follow the rules of the road when on the bike. Respect begets respect.

The law also says that if you exeed the speed limit by 1 mph you are breaking the law. That's why we have the human element....to judge the spirit of the law and the letter of the law. ....I think cops would do more for traffic safety by writting tickets for cell phone use than for giving tickets to bicyclists.

~Mike



But its up to the police to enforce the letter of the law. The judge gets to interpret the spirit.

2008-04-27 5:17 PM
in reply to: #1364949

Extreme Veteran
422
100100100100
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
Rogillio - 2008-04-27 4:55 PM

DerekL - 2008-04-27 4:47 PM
Rogillio - 2008-04-27 4:38 PM The 'serves your right attitude' amazes and apalls me.

~Mike

Nobody's saying anything of the sort. Most are saying to quit complaining that you got caught breaking a law. You can disagree with the law all you want.

None of the rest of your rant is remotely relevant, even though I probably agree with most of it.

You are right. Point taken. I guess I'm assuming he is complaining becuase he did not feel the ticket was justified.

If you got a speeding ticket for going 2 miles over the speed limint, would you not complain?





No, cause I was speeding.
2008-04-27 5:35 PM
in reply to: #1364949

Champion
8936
50002000100050010010010010025
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
Rogillio - 2008-04-27 4:55 PM
DerekL - 2008-04-27 4:47 PM
Rogillio - 2008-04-27 4:38 PM  The 'serves your right attitude' amazes and apalls me.

 

~Mike

Nobody's saying anything of the sort.  Most are saying to quit complaining that you got caught breaking a law.  You can disagree with the law all you want.

None of the rest of your rant is remotely relevant, even though I probably agree with most of it.

 

You are right.  Point taken.  I guess I'm assuming he is complaining becuase he did not feel the ticket was justified.

If you got a speeding ticket for going 2 miles over the speed limint, would you not complain?

I would complain.  I just wouldn't expect anybody to listen.  



2008-04-27 6:34 PM
in reply to: #1364863

Pro
4277
20002000100100252525
Parker, CO
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
3558 - 2008-04-27 2:57 PM

rayd - 2008-04-27 3:27 PM That's pretty chicken sh#t if you ask me! If you weren't putting anybody at risk he should have let it go.

So it's okay to ignore the laws, just so long as we aren't putting others at risk?

In this case absolutely!   I see plenty of stupidness on the road where I would love to see our traffic police enforcing the law.  But really, if the guy slowed down and there was no traffic...he didn't interfere with anyone...what's the deal?  If it really  bothered him...give the cyclist a warning.  Really, who hasn't done this at some point when riding a bike.

2008-04-27 6:42 PM
in reply to: #1364423

Champion
9600
500020002000500100
Fountain Hills, AZ
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
Good Lord, this thread won't die! The law is the law. Period. Can Police exercise some discretion as to it's enforcement? Sure. Do they? Often. Did they in this case? No. Does it change the fact that a law was violated and the rider was cited? No. Is it fair? Probably not, but suck it up. That's it, end of story.

Edited by bryancd 2008-04-27 6:43 PM
2008-04-27 6:49 PM
in reply to: #1364423

Master
2491
2000100100100100252525
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!

Yeah, it sucks.  I would assume that the cop: was bored, doesn't like cyclists, has issues, thinks you look like someone that done him wrong, etc.  If you slowed down, tapped a foot, you would be good to go with most law enforcement officers, except for in the above instances.

I once got a ticket after a run for crossing in an intersection moments before my light turned green, because the turn arrow, for which no cars had been in line, was directing imaginary vehicles into my path.  I had jogged across and was 'pulled over' by a motorcycle cop while i was on a sidewalk.  I chalked it up to the pony tail I sported at the time and various and sundry issues a fat motorcycle cop might have had with someone who looked like me.

 I'd see about showing up in court, reducing the charge, as others have posted.

2008-04-27 7:02 PM
in reply to: #1364423

Champion
6962
500010005001001001001002525
Atlanta, Ga
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!

First off, if you blew the stop sign, ticket is warranted.  

BUT, you DO NOT have to put a foot down to come to a complete stop.  I've come to a stop and stayed clipped in.  Now you could go to court with your bike and show the court that you can be stopped and clipped in.

2008-04-27 7:05 PM
in reply to: #1365167

Pro
4100
20002000100
Wherever the trail takes me, WA.
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
monkeyboy64 - 2008-04-27 4:49 PM

  If you slowed down, tapped a foot, you would be good to go with most law enforcement officers, except for in the above instances.



CAN EVERYONE THAT IS SAYING IT IS THE LAW SUCK IT UP SAY THEY STOP BEHIND THE WHITE LINE FOR 3 SECONDS, UNCLIP THEN PROCEED!!! EVERYTIME!?

NOT LIKELY!


2008-04-27 7:17 PM
in reply to: #1365208

Champion
8936
50002000100050010010010010025
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
swbkrun - 2008-04-27 7:05 PM
monkeyboy64 - 2008-04-27 4:49 PM

  If you slowed down, tapped a foot, you would be good to go with most law enforcement officers, except for in the above instances.

CAN EVERYONE THAT IS SAYING IT IS THE LAW SUCK IT UP SAY THEY STOP BEHIND THE WHITE LINE FOR 3 SECONDS, UNCLIP THEN PROCEED!!! EVERYTIME!? NOT LIKELY!

Calm down.  What everybody else has or hasn't done doesn't change anything about your situation.  I've sped before, and I'd have no sympathy if you got a speeding ticket either.

2008-04-27 7:19 PM
in reply to: #1364522

Expert
1024
1000
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!

KSH - 2008-04-27 11:27 AM That sucks. I know people here in Dallas who have gotten tickets for the same thing out a lake we all ride around. So, as annoying as it is, I always stop at stop signs and put a foot down. It's a pain, but I do it to avoid a ticket. Guess I can see it like interval training? HA!

 I've heard that those tickets around the lake are very expensive.  Like $200 or more.  But, I saw two bicycle cops at the 7-11 so I asked them about it.  They said as long as I slow way down and look both ways, I don't have to unclip or put a foot down.

To the OP.  That really sucks.  Call the court and see if you can get deferred adjudication without having to go to court and actually talk to the judge.  

2008-04-27 7:37 PM
in reply to: #1365202

Master
1686
1000500100252525
Royersford, PA
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!
Marvarnett - 2008-04-27 8:02 PM

First off, if you blew the stop sign, ticket is warranted.  

BUT, you DO NOT have to put a foot down to come to a complete stop.  I've come to a stop and stayed clipped in.  Now you could go to court with your bike and show the court that you can be stopped and clipped in.



Now that would be funny. I could bring my bike in, fall on the officer there to witness it, and get booked for assult with a deadly weapon, or at least contempt of court cause everyone in the room would be laughing their tails off.

However, I don't see how that can go on your driving record. You weren't using a motor vechile, so unless Jay-Walking does as well I think you have a leg to stand on to contest that part of it.
2008-04-27 7:41 PM
in reply to: #1365253

Expert
1379
1000100100100252525
Woodland, California
Subject: RE: ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??!

southwestmba - 2008-04-27 5:37 PM

However, I don't see how that can go on your driving record. You weren't using a motor vechile, so unless Jay-Walking does as well I think you have a leg to stand on to contest that part of it.

You can also get a DUI on a bike and from what I've heard the consequences are the same as if you are driving a car..... not completely sure though and I'm guessing it varies by state or county.

New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » ARE YOU KIDDING ME!??! Rss Feed  
 
 
of 6