Triatheletes don't run enough (Page 2)
-
No new posts
| Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller | Reply |
|
2008-10-23 8:02 AM in reply to: #1760305 |
Master 2073![]() ![]() ![]() The Redlands, FL | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughToo much bla bla bla....GO FOR A RUN....LOL |
|
2008-10-23 8:30 AM in reply to: #1760953 |
Master 2355![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Houston, TX | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughvelorider62 - 2008-10-23 8:02 AM Too much bla bla bla....GO FOR A RUN....LOL Best advice on the whole thread? Probably. I just like to do everything 4 days a week.. With usually swim or running getting 5 in there. Edited by smilford 2008-10-23 8:33 AM |
2008-10-23 8:51 AM in reply to: #1760944 |
Subject: ...This user's post has been ignored. |
2008-10-23 9:13 AM in reply to: #1760305 |
Expert 986![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Michiana | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughI've found that a run-focused cycle early in the season builds a solid foundation that enables me to have a successful and more-balanced "in season." Targeting a March/April half-marathon with a 12-16 week solid run-focused training cycle gives me a "base." Then, as I go into April, I put running on maintenence mode with only 3-4 days per week of running. This helps me "handle" the required ramp up of long runs for half-iron training in stride. I also use Nov-Dec as swim-focus (while recovering from a fall marathon). |
2008-10-23 9:29 AM in reply to: #1761038 |
Expert 939![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Newton, MA | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughwgraves7582 - 2008-10-23 9:51 AM amiine - 2008-10-23 8:59 AM bryancd - 2008-10-22 9:03 PM I got news for all you runner cats, get off the bike too far back and your screwed. it is not about running more and ignoring the other two sports. It is about adding more runs to your training. Jorge, Not trying to get free coaching here but what is a general workout schedule you put together (i.e. days of running, cycling, swimming, weights (if any) Just curious to see how you balance the schedule so they are equally hit. Thanks. I'm not a coach, but I'm not sure you need to equally hit all 3 sports, especially in the off season. I'm a much faster runner than I am cyclist or swimmer, so I try to do more biking then running during the year. (I sort of neglect swimming, I admit it.) |
2008-10-23 9:36 AM in reply to: #1760305 |
Not a Coach 11473![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Media, PA | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughI generally agree with your runner friend. Especially when 2 of people's 3 runs are a long one and a "speed" one, i.e. 2 "hard" runs, on a relatively light base. Then they go from running 15-20mpw during the season and do a marathon in the off-season where they try to jump to 30-40mpw for 3 months. Numbers made up, but this is not uncommon from what I see. The result is often an overuse injury resulting in downtime, which means even less consistency. And that's the main key to better running (or swimming or biking): consistency. |
|
2008-10-23 9:53 AM in reply to: #1760305 |
Master 2355![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Houston, TX | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughIf you're training for a long race and you're doing 3 runs a week. If your weekly mileage looks something like, 7, 7, 14+ . Yea you would probably have less chance of injury by tossing in two more easy runs a week, over having a unproportioned long run. In that since, I can see where your friend is coming from. If you're mileage is more even, let's say 7, 6, 9 jumping up to two more runs a week would probably increase your chance of injury *if you jumped right up to it. If you took it slowly, shouldn't see increase in risk. Like johnny said, consistency is everything. Edited by smilford 2008-10-23 10:07 AM |
2008-10-23 10:03 AM in reply to: #1761152 |
Member 381![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughJohnnyKay - 2008-10-23 8:36 AM And that's the main key to better running (or swimming or biking): consistency. I think this is the most universal advice in this thread. Consistency is key. One can talk about running more or swimming more or whatever more. But that approach does not respect the fact that people generally plan their training with a finite amount of time to commit. You cannot arbitrarily grow the pie larger, so the debate must be over the relative proportion of each piece of the pie (run, swim, bike). In that regard, you cannot run more, unless you do something else less. So if the OP meant that we should ditch one of our weekly rides and throw in two more runs, fine; otherwise - yeah I should run more, I should sleep more, I certainly should make more money, and I should also be better looking... |
2008-10-23 11:54 AM in reply to: #1761038 |
Coach 10487![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Boston, MA | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughwgraves7582 - 2008-10-23 8:51 AM Jorge, Not trying to get free coaching here but what is a general workout schedule you put together (i.e. days of running, cycling, swimming, weights (if any) Just curious to see how you balance the schedule so they are equally hit. Thanks. To be honest that’s a bit of a tough question; the training frequency and total load (duration/volume + intensity) will depends on the athlete’s specific needs and where we are on the annual training plan (ATP). But in general, I’ll make my athletes work more on their limiters (usually what they dislike more For a strong runner will do the opposite, we’ll have him/her run less (3-4x week) and have him work on cycling power riding more (4-5x week) and as the ATP progresses we’ll balance that out having him run a bit more (4-5x week) and ride less (3-4x week). Most triathletes need to swim a lot more always! I only include weight training IF: the athlete requests it, there are specific muscles imbalances that need to be addressed, if the athlete can’t do all 3 sports (i.e. an athlete don’t have access to a pool) or he/she is nursing an injury. Otherwise we focus on running, biking and swim lots. But, an example of a very general weekly frequency during the specific phase (the last 6-8 weeks leading to the main event) could look something like this: In the end as JK posted, the most important part of training is consistency. There are no magic sessions or magic training approaches; usually the AG who wins or goes faster is the one who trains the most Define your needs (limiters), goals, and through the general phase (aka as base phase) focus on your limiters more and just maintain some of your fitness on your strengths. |
2008-10-23 11:59 AM in reply to: #1761152 |
Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughJohnnyKay - 2008-10-23 10:36 AM I generally agree with your runner friend. Especially when 2 of people's 3 runs are a long one and a "speed" one, i.e. 2 "hard" runs, on a relatively light base. Then they go from running 15-20mpw during the season and do a marathon in the off-season where they try to jump to 30-40mpw for 3 months. Numbers made up, but this is not uncommon from what I see. The result is often an overuse injury resulting in downtime, which means even less consistency. And that's the main key to better running (or swimming or biking): consistency. Those numbers are not made up... they mirror exactly what I'm going through right now When I was just running for 2 years straight, 30+ miles a week, I can honestly say I don't recall one single injury. This year, my first year of triathlon, I ran a lot less ...and now with the tri season over, I just recently started focusing on my running - training for Philly. And only after one 30+ mile week my right knee is killing me. I never had this problem when I was just running. So perhaps there is much truth in that statement. |
2008-10-23 12:04 PM in reply to: #1760305 |
Subject: ...This user's post has been ignored. |
|
2008-10-23 12:11 PM in reply to: #1760944 |
Champion 9600![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Fountain Hills, AZ | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughamiine - 2008-10-23 7:59 AM bryancd - 2008-10-22 9:03 PM I got news for all you runner cats, get off the bike too far back and your screwed. it is not about running more and ignoring the other two sports. It is about adding more runs to your training. I'm assuming most of us have time limitations that will be the ultimate arbiter of how much training we can actually do every week. Personally, it's rare that I run more than 4 times per week, unless it's a run focused week. |
2008-10-23 1:40 PM in reply to: #1760305 |
Member 297![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughFor triathletes, it's more important to learn to run off the bike. If you're doing that three times a week, I'd say you might throw in one other long run or track workout. So much depends on what distance race you are training for. Matt Cazalas
|
2008-10-23 1:43 PM in reply to: #1761859 |
Not a Coach 11473![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Media, PA | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughsbrstlouis - 2008-10-23 2:40 PM For triathletes, it's more important to learn to run off the bike. If you're doing that three times a week, I'd say you might throw in one other long run or track workout. So much depends on what distance race you are training for. There's not much to "learn" about running off the bike. Do a couple bricks and a few races and you'll have learned all you need. Other than that, there's no real "need" to run off the bike in training (though it is more time efficient for many of us). |
2008-10-23 1:57 PM in reply to: #1760352 |
Pro 3906![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Libertyville, IL | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughDaremo - 2008-10-22 6:56 PM If you decide you are going through with it in the dead of this winter, I am hoping to shoot for a sub 3 at Boston this year and my plan starts Dec 1st. Would be nice keeping tabs on someone taking on old man winter with training, so give me a holler if you want somebody to whine with. Ha! FWIW, I think the statement is ridiculous when pertaining to a triathlete with a full time job, fam, etc. Bike training takes up a ton of minutes and I heard that it should be the case with swimming too from my friends that dont stink it up in the water. Arent you gaining big aerobic benefits on the bike vs throwin in those extra 20-30 min runs? Just make the running you do count.Now I'm tossing around the idea of trying to go for that sub-3 again (yeah yeah yeah ..... said I'd never "race" another marathon ... sue me) but that stuff sticks in the back of my mind. I don't know if I want to put myself through the 60 - 80 mile weeks again in the dead of winter. |
2008-10-23 2:00 PM in reply to: #1761944 |
Cycling Guru 15134![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Fulton, MD | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughI did the sub-3 training attempt over last winter as well. Go check my logs for December, January, February for this/last year .......... it sucked at times. |
|
2008-10-23 2:03 PM in reply to: #1761961 |
Pro 3906![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Libertyville, IL | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughDaremo - 2008-10-23 2:00 PM I did the sub-3 training attempt over last winter as well. Go check my logs for December, January, February for this/last year .......... it sucked at times. I know its gonna as I run in pretty much everything though I might stick to treaddie tempo stuff if the roads are bad. Made that mistake and put me on the elliptical for a few weeks with a bum knee. |
2008-10-23 2:03 PM in reply to: #1761944 |
| Runner | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughjszat - 2008-10-23 2:57 PM Arent you gaining big aerobic benefits on the bike vs throwin in those extra 20-30 min runs? Just make the running you do count. What do you mean? |
2008-10-23 2:32 PM in reply to: #1761970 |
Pro 3906![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Libertyville, IL | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughScout7 - 2008-10-23 2:03 PM jszat - 2008-10-23 2:57 PM Arent you gaining big aerobic benefits on the bike vs throwin in those extra 20-30 min runs? Just make the running you do count. What do you mean? In the tri context, isnt a 60-90 min spin a better aerobic workout vs a 20-30 min recovery run and therefore more beneficial? Not for developing a better run per se, but in the overall building of a better all arounder vs a solid runner. Maybe I dont know what I am trying to say either as I am feeling its PM caffeine time. |
2008-10-23 2:35 PM in reply to: #1762073 |
| Runner | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughjszat - 2008-10-23 3:32 PM Scout7 - 2008-10-23 2:03 PM jszat - 2008-10-23 2:57 PM Arent you gaining big aerobic benefits on the bike vs throwin in those extra 20-30 min runs? Just make the running you do count. What do you mean? In the tri context, isnt a 60-90 min spin a better aerobic workout vs a 20-30 min recovery run and therefore more beneficial? Not for developing a better run per se, but in the overall building of a better all arounder vs a solid runner. Maybe I dont know what I am trying to say either as I am feeling its PM caffeine time. I guess my question is, if you have time to do a 60-90 minute session on the bike, why is that better than a 60-90 minute run session. Yeah, 60-90 minutes on the bike is better than 20-30 running. But that's not really a fair comparison. |
2008-10-23 2:50 PM in reply to: #1762084 |
Pro 3906![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Libertyville, IL | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughScout7 - 2008-10-23 2:35 PM Ha! Yeah, not apples to apples. Must really need a Dew. I will not rejoin this thread until I am truly functional again, cuz I am pretty sure I had a point. The root of the question here methinks is if Mr. Runner is aware of crossover benefits of cross training vs doing nothing but running. Will check back after brain gets working though.jszat - 2008-10-23 3:32 PM Scout7 - 2008-10-23 2:03 PM jszat - 2008-10-23 2:57 PM Arent you gaining big aerobic benefits on the bike vs throwin in those extra 20-30 min runs? Just make the running you do count. What do you mean? In the tri context, isnt a 60-90 min spin a better aerobic workout vs a 20-30 min recovery run and therefore more beneficial? Not for developing a better run per se, but in the overall building of a better all arounder vs a solid runner. Maybe I dont know what I am trying to say either as I am feeling its PM caffeine time. I guess my question is, if you have time to do a 60-90 minute session on the bike, why is that better than a 60-90 minute run session. Yeah, 60-90 minutes on the bike is better than 20-30 running. But that's not really a fair comparison. |
|
2008-10-23 2:51 PM in reply to: #1762073 |
Coach 10487![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Boston, MA | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughjszat - 2008-10-23 2:32 PM Scout7 - 2008-10-23 2:03 PM jszat - 2008-10-23 2:57 PM Arent you gaining big aerobic benefits on the bike vs throwin in those extra 20-30 min runs? Just make the running you do count. What do you mean? In the tri context, isnt a 60-90 min spin a better aerobic workout vs a 20-30 min recovery run and therefore more beneficial? Not for developing a better run per se, but in the overall building of a better all arounder vs a solid runner. Maybe I dont know what I am trying to say either as I am feeling its PM caffeine time. A 60-90 min spin is better for cycling and 20-30 min run is better for running. There is little specific fitness transfer from one to another. Each sport can complement the other but it can't substitute it. We are triathletes and we should strive to be strong on all 3 sports not just 2 out of the IMO. Yes AGers biggest limiter is time available for training and yes we are all different and require different training load to improve. But a good training plan should allow any athlete to prioritize and focus on weaknesses and solidify strengths. It is not too complicated to break down an annual training plan in cycles and focus more on your limiters early on the season and strengthen all 3 disciplines as the plan progresses to have you race ready prior the main event.The OP asked if Triathletes (AGers) in general don’t run enough and the answer is: yes. whether they can’t fit in more specific training due to the lack of training time available that’s a different story. Still it is a problem that can be addressed quite easy with proper planning. |
2008-10-23 2:56 PM in reply to: #1762139 |
| Runner | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughjszat - 2008-10-23 3:50 PM The root of the question here methinks is if Mr. Runner is aware of crossover benefits of cross training vs doing nothing but running. Will check back after brain gets working though. I am not sure just how much benefit exists. Obviously, it's necessary when talking triathlon, but I'm not sure how much benefit you gain as a runner from doing other things. To me, as someone who just runs, I have found that any time I could spend doing another activity, such as swimming or biking, I see more gains by spending it running. But, like I said, I'm only focused on one sport, so the decision is pretty easy to me. I know people who maintained a base fitness level while doing other things, but they were injured and couldn't run. In that case, I think it helps. |
2008-10-23 3:07 PM in reply to: #1760305 |
Subject: ...This user's post has been ignored. |
2008-10-24 10:39 AM in reply to: #1761871 |
Expert 2547![]() ![]() ![]() The Woodlands, TX | Subject: RE: Triatheletes don't run enoughJohnnyKay - 2008-10-23 1:43 PM sbrstlouis - 2008-10-23 2:40 PM For triathletes, it's more important to learn to run off the bike. If you're doing that three times a week, I'd say you might throw in one other long run or track workout. So much depends on what distance race you are training for. There's not much to "learn" about running off the bike. Do a couple bricks and a few races and you'll have learned all you need. Other than that, there's no real "need" to run off the bike in training (though it is more time efficient for many of us). Couldn't agree more. Do a couple of bricks and get over it.... |
|
login




2008-10-23 8:02 AM

The Redlands, FL




View profile
Add to friends
Go to training log
Go to race log
Send a message
View album
CONNECT WITH FACEBOOK