General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Carbon Water Bottle Cages Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2010-01-24 8:56 AM


59
2525
Subject: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
I posted this question in the Gear Question forum but wanted to see what you IM'ers thought as my setup is mainly for an IM.

http://www.beginnertriathlete.com/discussion/forums/thread-view.asp?tid=194238&posts=1&start=1

Is the carbon cages worth the cost for the weight difference? I am assuming as the bike distance increases the benefit increases. Thanks for any input.


2010-01-24 10:53 AM
in reply to: #2631408

User image

Master
1718
1000500100100
Loughborough, England
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
The weight difference is a couple of grams. If you want them then get them but only hard work and dedication to your training is going to make you faster.
2010-01-24 11:33 AM
in reply to: #2631408

User image

Champion
7595
50002000500252525
Columbia, South Carolina
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
No.  The weight savings is about the weight of one swallow of water.

But if you like to ponder that sort of thing, check this out.
2010-01-24 12:31 PM
in reply to: #2631588

User image

Master
1718
1000500100100
Loughborough, England
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
Experior - 2010-01-24 5:33 PM  

But if you like to ponder that sort of thing, check this out.


Wow, you can get a bottle cage that weighs 4g!!!  Doesn't look like it will hold the bottle in place very well though. 

Edited by tridantri 2010-01-24 12:31 PM
2010-01-24 5:21 PM
in reply to: #2631408

User image

Pro
3705
20001000500100100
Vestavia Hills
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
But if you are going to get one (or three) then do not opt for the "name brand" cages as the prices are ridiculous. I bought three of these no name brand and they have worked great over the years.

2010-01-25 11:59 AM
in reply to: #2631408

User image

Extreme Veteran
484
100100100100252525
Glen Burnie, MD
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
I had carbon cages (bike shop gave them to me for free w/the purchase of the bike) and my water bottles always popped out - which made them useless (on a seat mount.. I think it's an x-lab).  Stopping to go back and get the bottle or being without your nutrition is going to cost you more in terms of time than the weight savings will get you.  Plus I was always freaked out riding whenever I hit a bump wondering if I would lose the bottles.


2010-01-25 12:31 PM
in reply to: #2633415

User image

Pro
3705
20001000500100100
Vestavia Hills
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
Hmmm ... may be there was a reason why those particular carbon were free?  Which brand were they?

If you have rear bottle cages then at one point or another you will hit the "right" pot hole or train track that will eject bottles - regardless of whether they are carbon, titanium or aluminum.  Most cages are designed to "dig" into the bottle a little in order to keep friction against such occurances - and some cages are designed better than others.

More often than not a bottle is ejected through a cumulative effect of rough terrain - e.g. the first bump will loosen it, the next a little more and then third *bam* it is rolling down the street.  Whenever I go over rough terrain or a pot hole, I reach back to ensure my bottles are seated in their cages. It has gottent to the point where it is now instinctive and I do it while still in aero.

Regardless of what type of cages you use with a rear hydration system, you might want to do the same in order to prevent launching your nutrition.



dolelicious - 2010-01-25 12:59 PM I had carbon cages (bike shop gave them to me for free w/the purchase of the bike) and my water bottles always popped out - which made them useless (on a seat mount.. I think it's an x-lab).  Stopping to go back and get the bottle or being without your nutrition is going to cost you more in terms of time than the weight savings will get you.  Plus I was always freaked out riding whenever I hit a bump wondering if I would lose the bottles.
2010-01-25 4:32 PM
in reply to: #2631408

User image

Champion
5495
5000100100100100252525
Whizzzzzlandia
Silver member
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
I have carbon bottle cages... not for the weight savings necessarily, but because they hold my bottles the best.

I use the X-Lab Gorilla bottle cages. I have not launched a SINGLE BOTTLE since I put them on my bike. I was using a Profile Design Plastic model and I lost at least one bottle on every long ride. Kind of a bummer.

They are pricey, but WELL WORTH the money:

www.xlab-usa.com/gorilla.html

That link should work... it looks weird, though...
2010-01-25 6:17 PM
in reply to: #2634031

User image

Master
1376
1000100100100252525
Chicago
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
Whizzzzz - 2010-01-25 4:32 PM I have carbon bottle cages... not for the weight savings necessarily, but because they hold my bottles the best.

I use the X-Lab Gorilla bottle cages. I have not launched a SINGLE BOTTLE since I put them on my bike. I was using a Profile Design Plastic model and I lost at least one bottle on every long ride. Kind of a bummer.

They are pricey, but WELL WORTH the money:

www.xlab-usa.com/gorilla.html

That link should work... it looks weird, though...


I use Gorilla cages as well for the same purpose.  I haven't launched any either.  They are costly, but if you are performance member with BT you can get a nice discount at trisports.com.   
2010-01-25 6:55 PM
in reply to: #2634031

User image

Master
2202
2000100100
Canton, Michigan
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages

Whizzzzz - 2010-01-25 5:32 PM I have carbon bottle cages... not for the weight savings necessarily, but because they hold my bottles the best.

I use the X-Lab Gorilla bottle cages. I have not launched a SINGLE BOTTLE since I put them on my bike. I was using a Profile Design Plastic model and I lost at least one bottle on every long ride. Kind of a bummer.

They are pricey, but WELL WORTH the money:

X3!  Carrying my Infinit during B2B was something that I couldn't lose, with the training I did on crappy Michigan roads I knew I couldn't launch a bottle and that's what was most important, keeping my nutrition for 112 miles and that was worth every penny.

2010-01-25 7:55 PM
in reply to: #2634215

User image

Champion
5495
5000100100100100252525
Whizzzzzlandia
Silver member
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
rottieguy - 2010-01-25 6:55 PM

Whizzzzz - 2010-01-25 5:32 PM I have carbon bottle cages... not for the weight savings necessarily, but because they hold my bottles the best.

I use the X-Lab Gorilla bottle cages. I have not launched a SINGLE BOTTLE since I put them on my bike. I was using a Profile Design Plastic model and I lost at least one bottle on every long ride. Kind of a bummer.

They are pricey, but WELL WORTH the money:

X3!  Carrying my Infinit during B2B was something that I couldn't lose, with the training I did on crappy Michigan roads I knew I couldn't launch a bottle and that's what was most important, keeping my nutrition for 112 miles and that was worth every penny.



Notice that all 3 of us do our long rides on crappy Midwestern roads! Freeze! Thaw! Freeze! Thaw! Pothole! Crater! Freeze! Thaw!

Take it from us... this is what works!!!!


2010-01-26 7:13 AM
in reply to: #2634215

User image

Pro
4675
20002000500100252525
Wisconsin near the Twin Cities metro
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages

rottieguy - 2010-01-25 6:55 PM

Whizzzzz - 2010-01-25 5:32 PM I have carbon bottle cages... not for the weight savings necessarily, but because they hold my bottles the best.

I use the X-Lab Gorilla bottle cages. I have not launched a SINGLE BOTTLE since I put them on my bike. I was using a Profile Design Plastic model and I lost at least one bottle on every long ride. Kind of a bummer.

They are pricey, but WELL WORTH the money:

X3!  Carrying my Infinit during B2B was something that I couldn't lose, with the training I did on crappy Michigan roads I knew I couldn't launch a bottle and that's what was most important, keeping my nutrition for 112 miles and that was worth every penny.

X4

2010-01-26 12:40 PM
in reply to: #2631408

User image

Elite
3658
200010005001002525
Roswell, GA
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages

A standard aluminum cage weighs 36 grams while a Carbon Gorilla Cage weighs 38 grams per all3sports.com

The more important thing might be that 24 ounces of water weighs 680 grams.  Do they make carbon water?

2010-01-27 4:39 PM
in reply to: #2635452

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
2010-02-04 3:09 PM
in reply to: #2635452

Member
591
500252525
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
brown_dog_us - 2010-01-26 10:40 AM

A standard aluminum cage weighs 36 grams while a Carbon Gorilla Cage weighs 38 grams per all3sports.com

The more important thing might be that 24 ounces of water weighs 680 grams.  Do they make carbon water?



Kind of begs a good question:  For long rides where you know you can fill up on water, do you just put your drink powder in the bottle and fill the water down the road, or do you carry the water the whole way?  I'm doing IMSG in May, and prefer the EFS drink to the Gatorade, but at the same time, don't want to  carry multiple bottles up the hills.  Wondering if I should just put the powder in my rear cage bottles and add water at the top of hills.

Thoughts?
2010-02-04 3:16 PM
in reply to: #2655587

Champion
5495
5000100100100100252525
Whizzzzzlandia
Silver member
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
SAquavia - 2010-02-04 3:09 PM
brown_dog_us - 2010-01-26 10:40 AM

A standard aluminum cage weighs 36 grams while a Carbon Gorilla Cage weighs 38 grams per all3sports.com

The more important thing might be that 24 ounces of water weighs 680 grams.  Do they make carbon water?



Kind of begs a good question:  For long rides where you know you can fill up on water, do you just put your drink powder in the bottle and fill the water down the road, or do you carry the water the whole way?  I'm doing IMSG in May, and prefer the EFS drink to the Gatorade, but at the same time, don't want to  carry multiple bottles up the hills.  Wondering if I should just put the powder in my rear cage bottles and add water at the top of hills.

Thoughts?


Sounds like a lot of work to me.

Plus, you are going to want to be getting fluids in you throughout the bike ride.

I didn't carry ALL my bottles with me... I kept a couple in SN, and swapped them out quickly there. I carried 3 bottles most of the ride... but I was drinking them the whole ride thru. Very important not to get dehydrated on the bike.


2010-02-04 3:40 PM
in reply to: #2655605

Pro
3705
20001000500100100
Vestavia Hills
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
Whizzzzz - 2010-02-04 4:16 PM
Sounds like a lot of work to me.

Plus, you are going to want to be getting fluids in you throughout the bike ride.

I didn't carry ALL my bottles with me... I kept a couple in SN, and swapped them out quickly there. I carried 3 bottles most of the ride... but I was drinking them the whole ride thru. Very important not to get dehydrated on the bike.


Special needs at IMFL was a complete time sponge ... easily added 10 to 13 minutes as the bags were difficult to find and, if I recall correctly, there was no water available at the special needs stop.

For IM CdA this year I plan on taking what I need on my bike and then "living off the land" through the 112 ride.
2010-02-04 4:54 PM
in reply to: #2655640

Cycling Guru
15134
50005000500010025
Fulton, MD
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
I run carbon cages.

Then again my bike is a rolling project to get it insanely light while still being fully functional under all race conditions.
2010-02-04 5:20 PM
in reply to: #2634659

Champion
9600
500020002000500100
Fountain Hills, AZ
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
Birkierunner - 2010-01-26 7:13 AM

rottieguy - 2010-01-25 6:55 PM

Whizzzzz - 2010-01-25 5:32 PM I have carbon bottle cages... not for the weight savings necessarily, but because they hold my bottles the best.

I use the X-Lab Gorilla bottle cages. I have not launched a SINGLE BOTTLE since I put them on my bike. I was using a Profile Design Plastic model and I lost at least one bottle on every long ride. Kind of a bummer.

They are pricey, but WELL WORTH the money:

X3!  Carrying my Infinit during B2B was something that I couldn't lose, with the training I did on crappy Michigan roads I knew I couldn't launch a bottle and that's what was most important, keeping my nutrition for 112 miles and that was worth every penny.

X4



X5, Whizzzz is so smart.
2010-02-05 7:34 AM
in reply to: #2655640

Champion
6962
500010005001001001001002525
Atlanta, Ga
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
brian - 2010-02-04 4:40 PM
Whizzzzz - 2010-02-04 4:16 PM
Sounds like a lot of work to me.

Plus, you are going to want to be getting fluids in you throughout the bike ride.

I didn't carry ALL my bottles with me... I kept a couple in SN, and swapped them out quickly there. I carried 3 bottles most of the ride... but I was drinking them the whole ride thru. Very important not to get dehydrated on the bike.


Special needs at IMFL was a complete time sponge ... easily added 10 to 13 minutes as the bags were difficult to find and, if I recall correctly, there was no water available at the special needs stop.

For IM CdA this year I plan on taking what I need on my bike and then "living off the land" through the 112 ride.


Next time don't take a nap while you're there.   I was in an out in less than 1 minute the last two IM races I had. 
2010-02-05 7:55 AM
in reply to: #2631408

Champion
9600
500020002000500100
Fountain Hills, AZ
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
I've never stopped at Special Needs. I can't even imagine why anyone would have to, to be honest.


2010-02-05 12:22 PM
in reply to: #2655587

Master
2638
200050010025
Subject: RE: Carbon Water Bottle Cages
SAquavia - 2010-02-04 4:09 PM
brown_dog_us - 2010-01-26 10:40 AM

A standard aluminum cage weighs 36 grams while a Carbon Gorilla Cage weighs 38 grams per all3sports.com

The more important thing might be that 24 ounces of water weighs 680 grams.  Do they make carbon water?



Kind of begs a good question:  For long rides where you know you can fill up on water, do you just put your drink powder in the bottle and fill the water down the road, or do you carry the water the whole way?  I'm doing IMSG in May, and prefer the EFS drink to the Gatorade, but at the same time, don't want to  carry multiple bottles up the hills.  Wondering if I should just put the powder in my rear cage bottles and add water at the top of hills.

Thoughts?


Start with your drink in "disposable" bottles and carry the powder (pre-measured) with you.  Drop your empties at the water stop, pick up a water, take a few sips and then mix your drink powder into it at an opportune moment.  A Gu flask will hold 2 servings of drink mix, so you can stash as many as you need in your bento or just buy the single-serving envelopes (most companies make these).  I think the flask is easiest, though. 

Daremo (I think it was him) has a point about living off of the land, but I just can't stomach Gatorade.
New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Carbon Water Bottle Cages Rss Feed