BT Development Mentor Program Archives » Fred D Mentor Group Part III Rss Feed  
Moderators: alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 115
 
 
2012-12-07 11:27 AM
in reply to: #4433790

User image

Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
Had a good ride yesterday.  Did a 2x16' and was able to manage 263 and 271 watts on the road bike without totally wiping myself out. 


2012-12-07 12:02 PM
in reply to: #4526281

User image

Master
1927
100050010010010010025
Guilford, CT
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
KansasMom - 2012-12-07 11:23 AM

I hope I'm not taking this too far afield, and if I am, just tell me. That's okay. I'm really not understanding all of the language, but the more I hear it, I think I'm picking up some things.

Does any of this translate to heart rate? I ask because I don't have a power meter, but I do have a heart rate monitor. I know Jorge has a winter plan for HR and one for Power. I'm just wondering how I would use the HR monitor on the trainer to judge how hard I am pushing. Do I just need to look at Jorge's plan again for my answer, or is there more to it than that? (My zones haven't ever been tested, so there's not much help there.)

Or am I such a newb (which I am), that for me just riding as hard as I can for as long as I can and then resting is enough. For now? Worry about all of this other stuff later?

Just wondering.

Hmm.  Well this is a big discussion you are opening up to here.  As far as training goes, you can absolutely use RPE or heart rate for the workouts.  Trying to compare your HR for speed relative to others won't work like watts because it isn't a measure of power.  Watts are watts (for the most part without the discussion of crank based vs hub based and maybe some measure a little different).  So 230 watts for one person and 230 for another gives you a means to start comparing speed and then determine what variable need to be tweaked for wind/rolling resistance.

From a training standpoint which you are more concerned about right now, I'd absolutely consider using Jorge's plan and use HR or even just RPE.  I will be honest and say that I train a lot by RPE on the bike but I record watts and HR as data points to be considered and to gauge progress (if that makes sense).  I think the most important thing is determining what your threshold is (you can do a field test with a HR monitor...search the forum or articles there is a lot of info on that).  For me, what I notice and this is something to look out for is that "some" people don't know what high intensity on the bike really is and they don't know how to "suffer".  It's too easy to back off on the bike and until you figure out how hard you can push it is hard to find the right level of intensity...just my perspective not sure if people agree or not.  Riding is very easy to do a lot of moderate efforts, but 100% or more of threshold efforts hurt a lot.  There are many times on the trainer where I just fail to do what I know I could do on a better day or a testing situation (hr is lower, power a bit lower, just not mentally prepared to lay it down, etc...that's where all those tools come in handy).

Really rambling.  Summary:  Look up how to do a field test for your HR, then follow Jorge's HR based plan which will go by a % of your HR.  For me, it is honestly a little too much structure for bike training.  I can't handle that, but your last sentence is the right spirit.  Hammer, rest, hammer, rest, repeat.

Was that helpful or no?

2012-12-07 12:29 PM
in reply to: #4526355

User image

Master
2770
20005001001002525
Central Kansas
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
acumenjay - 2012-12-07 12:02 PM
KansasMom - 2012-12-07 11:23 AM

I hope I'm not taking this too far afield, and if I am, just tell me. That's okay. I'm really not understanding all of the language, but the more I hear it, I think I'm picking up some things.

Does any of this translate to heart rate? I ask because I don't have a power meter, but I do have a heart rate monitor. I know Jorge has a winter plan for HR and one for Power. I'm just wondering how I would use the HR monitor on the trainer to judge how hard I am pushing. Do I just need to look at Jorge's plan again for my answer, or is there more to it than that? (My zones haven't ever been tested, so there's not much help there.)

Or am I such a newb (which I am), that for me just riding as hard as I can for as long as I can and then resting is enough. For now? Worry about all of this other stuff later?

Just wondering.

Hmm.  Well this is a big discussion you are opening up to here.  As far as training goes, you can absolutely use RPE or heart rate for the workouts.  Trying to compare your HR for speed relative to others won't work like watts because it isn't a measure of power.  Watts are watts (for the most part without the discussion of crank based vs hub based and maybe some measure a little different).  So 230 watts for one person and 230 for another gives you a means to start comparing speed and then determine what variable need to be tweaked for wind/rolling resistance.

From a training standpoint which you are more concerned about right now, I'd absolutely consider using Jorge's plan and use HR or even just RPE.  I will be honest and say that I train a lot by RPE on the bike but I record watts and HR as data points to be considered and to gauge progress (if that makes sense).  I think the most important thing is determining what your threshold is (you can do a field test with a HR monitor...search the forum or articles there is a lot of info on that).  For me, what I notice and this is something to look out for is that "some" people don't know what high intensity on the bike really is and they don't know how to "suffer".  It's too easy to back off on the bike and until you figure out how hard you can push it is hard to find the right level of intensity...just my perspective not sure if people agree or not.  Riding is very easy to do a lot of moderate efforts, but 100% or more of threshold efforts hurt a lot.  There are many times on the trainer where I just fail to do what I know I could do on a better day or a testing situation (hr is lower, power a bit lower, just not mentally prepared to lay it down, etc...that's where all those tools come in handy).

Really rambling.  Summary:  Look up how to do a field test for your HR, then follow Jorge's HR based plan which will go by a % of your HR.  For me, it is honestly a little too much structure for bike training.  I can't handle that, but your last sentence is the right spirit.  Hammer, rest, hammer, rest, repeat.

Was that helpful or no?

Oh, yes. Very helpful. Thanks. I agree with you that I am prone to take it too easy. Even if I just kept track of my HR to gauge the effort, data to compare one day to another, I think that would give me something. I have suspected for a while that what separates the front from the back of the pack is the ability to suffer. (Natural talent comes into play, too, but suffering is huge, I think.) Our natural inclination is to pull back when we begin to suffer. Well, my natural inclination is to pull back.

Thanks again!



Edited by KansasMom 2012-12-07 12:30 PM
2012-12-07 12:44 PM
in reply to: #4526214

User image

Extreme Veteran
5722
5000500100100
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
acumenjay - 2012-12-07 10:50 AM

edit: Ya, I just checked IMLP and I rode 5:25 at 20.67mph on 196aw/217np..at 185lbs so it 2.4/2.5 w/kg on what some consider a 'hillier' course...for 112miles.

 

You can suck that file into Golden Cheetah, open the Aerolab tab, enter your weight, an approximate air density and it will tell you your Cda. Or email it to me and I'll do it for you.

2012-12-07 12:46 PM
in reply to: #4525908

User image

Champion
6656
500010005001002525
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
ratherbeswimming - 2012-12-07 7:23 AM

Congrats Melissa - did the swim skin make it to you?

Godo luck Yanti - stay WARM!

Don't think it has yet. I'm not at home right now though so I'll email my dad and ask him. Thanks again for sending!
2012-12-07 12:51 PM
in reply to: #4526442

User image

Master
1927
100050010010010010025
Guilford, CT
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
marcag - 2012-12-07 12:44 PM
acumenjay - 2012-12-07 10:50 AM

edit: Ya, I just checked IMLP and I rode 5:25 at 20.67mph on 196aw/217np..at 185lbs so it 2.4/2.5 w/kg on what some consider a 'hillier' course...for 112miles.

 

You can suck that file into Golden Cheetah, open the Aerolab tab, enter your weight, an approximate air density and it will tell you your Cda. Or email it to me and I'll do it for you.

Marc, can I do that with any file or just that because it is specific to a loaded course?  I would like to see if I put in Rev 3 Quassy or the relay leg I did this summer to and see if they all match up pretty close.  Can't do it now..but will fetch them tomorrow.



2012-12-07 12:57 PM
in reply to: #4526281

User image

Extreme Veteran
5722
5000500100100
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
KansasMom - 2012-12-07 11:23 AM

Does any of this translate to heart rate?

 

Yes!

There is a correlation between HR and power. Some people would say it's not a close one but I can tell you, for me, it is very close. I can almost predict to the beat what my HR is by looking at my power and vice versa.

If I put out 200w, my HR will be at 140. Every 10w more, my HR goes up 3-4 beats.

Now, on a bad day, with no sleep, dehydrated and after 6 coffees, it will be off. So I never have more than 5.

Jorge did a version of his plan with HR. The only problem with HR it lags a little. Let's say I am doing 180watts and my HR is 131. The all of a sudden I go harder at 210watts. It will take about 30 sec before my HR gets to 140. This is fine when you are doing 10min intervals, but when you are doing 30second intervals HR is harder to use.

But Jorge had a good plan, even for HR users.

While I have a PowerMeter I do use HR when I travel. I could easily race by HR and be fine.

2012-12-07 1:04 PM
in reply to: #4526469

User image

Payson, AZ
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
marcag - 2012-12-07 11:57 AM
KansasMom - 2012-12-07 11:23 AM

Does any of this translate to heart rate?

 

Yes!

There is a correlation between HR and power. Some people would say it's not a close one but I can tell you, for me, it is very close. I can almost predict to the beat what my HR is by looking at my power and vice versa.

If I put out 200w, my HR will be at 140. Every 10w more, my HR goes up 3-4 beats.

Now, on a bad day, with no sleep, dehydrated and after 6 coffees, it will be off. So I never have more than 5.

Jorge did a version of his plan with HR. The only problem with HR it lags a little. Let's say I am doing 180watts and my HR is 131. The all of a sudden I go harder at 210watts. It will take about 30 sec before my HR gets to 140. This is fine when you are doing 10min intervals, but when you are doing 30second intervals HR is harder to use.

But Jorge had a good plan, even for HR users.

While I have a PowerMeter I do use HR when I travel. I could easily race by HR and be fine.

I did Jorge's HR plan but I did it by RPE, cause like you said, HR lags.  Somewhere on his site he had a chart that mapped his HR ranges to RPE

2012-12-07 1:09 PM
in reply to: #4526456

User image

Extreme Veteran
5722
5000500100100
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
acumenjay - 2012-12-07 12:51 PM
marcag - 2012-12-07 12:44 PM
acumenjay - 2012-12-07 10:50 AM

edit: Ya, I just checked IMLP and I rode 5:25 at 20.67mph on 196aw/217np..at 185lbs so it 2.4/2.5 w/kg on what some consider a 'hillier' course...for 112miles.

 

You can suck that file into Golden Cheetah, open the Aerolab tab, enter your weight, an approximate air density and it will tell you your Cda. Or email it to me and I'll do it for you.

Marc, can I do that with any file or just that because it is specific to a loaded course?  I would like to see if I put in Rev 3 Quassy or the relay leg I did this summer to and see if they all match up pretty close.  Can't do it now..but will fetch them tomorrow.

 

Any course

What aerolab does it takes the power, your weight and your speed and it calculates what it thinks would be an elevation profile. It compares it to an actual elevation profile from the GPS data. To make the two match, it needs to calculate a CDA.

So yes, any GPS file with power, speed and elevation data, preferably barometric elevation data since it's more accurate will work. If you have a Garmin 500 or 910, that's the best.

2012-12-07 1:12 PM
in reply to: #4433790

Master
10208
50005000100100
Northern IL
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III

A few have suggested joining this group, so here's a bio. Thanks for letting me in!

Name: brigby1 / Ben

Story: I’ve been involved with a number of sports my entire life, the biggest ones growing up were soccer & basketball, but at least bits of everything were tried at one point. After college it was harder to do any team sports, so ended up doing various workouts, more strength oriented though. Also rode the bike around, trails, roads, whatever. Occasionally ran too. Not really a swimmer but had lessons to stay afloat. Lots of familiarity with water from canoeing, kayaking, fishing, etc.

Think I always had some interest in tri, but could not get over the swimming. Not until a friend with almost identical capabilities started and found being able to make it came fairly easy. From there, everything kind of came together and took off.

Family Status: Single

2012 Races: An assortment of sprint, Olympic and Half Iron races. There was a duathlon in there as well. A few bike events just took the place of a long ride that day. All for fun. Pretty good season (4th yr in) even though I fell short of goals for a number of events.

2013 Races: Still picking things out. Was close to burning out this past year, so am going short to start. Then maybe HIM at the end of the season.

Weightloss: More of a body type change. Converted from general strength/fitness to endurance, which seems to be a more natural build for me.

Winter Goals: Learn from last year so I can put up a strong training load again, but keep it going more consistently. Lots of running. Smarter, directed swimming (and more of it). Keep it going on the bike, but balance work/recovery better.

What Would Make Me a Good Member: I love to learn & figure things out, then share that with others.

 

2012-12-07 1:17 PM
in reply to: #4433790

User image

Payson, AZ
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
welcome Ben


2012-12-07 1:27 PM
in reply to: #4433790

User image

Elite
3779
20001000500100100252525
Ontario
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III

Wish I could use aerolab for a previous race, but I had no GPS data to go with the power file at the time.  I hear what you guys are saying about all the intangibles, and I'm not expecting some miracle by going lower - I'm just trying to see what else will lend itself to additional speed.

Here's my pic after I dropped the front end as low as it will go.  I'd consider getting the Zipp Alumina clips because they are ultra adjustable, and I *could* go lower with them if it was to my advantage to do so.

Edit to add - I'll need to meaure again, but I think I'm running about 12-13cm of drop from top of saddle to top of pads.



Edited by GoFaster 2012-12-07 1:38 PM




(New Side.JPG)



Attachments
----------------
New Side.JPG (59KB - 4 downloads)
2012-12-07 1:29 PM
in reply to: #4526484

User image

Elite
7783
50002000500100100252525
PEI, Canada
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
Welcome to the group Ben!
2012-12-07 1:38 PM
in reply to: #4433790

User image

Elite
3779
20001000500100100252525
Ontario
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
Welcome Ben!
2012-12-07 2:11 PM
in reply to: #4433790

Master
5557
50005002525
, California
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III

Hey Neil I don't think your position is much different from mine.  You're probably getting into small nitpicky things to adjust, which is why it's helpful to test with GC Aerolab if possible.  This was the only photo I had from the side (Australia last year):

 

Can't see it here but my arms are pretty lined up with my legs and I'm compact in the front.  I keep my legs close to the frame and head mostly down.  This pic is "relaxed" for me.. I turtle better in an Olympic race.

(Yeah my race number was loose) Tongue out

The only other recent change I made was to go to a torpedo bottle up front.

2012-12-07 2:29 PM
in reply to: #4526484

User image

Master
2770
20005001001002525
Central Kansas
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
Welcome, Ben!


2012-12-07 3:20 PM
in reply to: #4433790

User image

Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III

Question for the group:

 Doing Whistler. Will also be doing Oceanside and Wildflower, so all fairly bumpy but plenty of opportunities on all 3 courses to get in aero and "hammer". Been racing on HED3s since 2008, and don't really see upgrading wheels for the near future.

I know HEDs aren't the lightest wheelset. I hope to be racing around 190#.

Stick with the HEDs or get a wheelbuilder cover for my training wheel (weighs the same as the trispoke) and run a disc rear/HED3 front?

Course is here (sorry, can't link to the pdf as my desktop is acting up...)http://www.ironman.com/triathlon/events/ironman/canada/course.aspx#axzz2EP4TIwdp

2012-12-07 3:50 PM
in reply to: #4526671

User image

Elite
7783
50002000500100100252525
PEI, Canada
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
Chris, personally I would get the cover without hesitation.
2012-12-07 3:57 PM
in reply to: #4526573

User image

Elite
7783
50002000500100100252525
PEI, Canada
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III

*far from a fit expert*

Looking at the two pics of Neil and Mark, the things that jump out to me are:

1. Mark just looks more relaxed - obviously riding outside vs the trainer could have a big impact on this.

2. Head position.  Neil, if you were to just lower your head more, it might make a big difference.  I remember a post by Leegocrapp on the TT forum where he went to the wind tunnel and he said that adjustments in head position made a huge difference in drag.

2012-12-07 5:59 PM
in reply to: #4526706

User image

Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III

axteraa - 2012-12-07 11:50 AM Chris, personally I would get the cover without hesitation.

x2 on the cover. 

2012-12-07 6:08 PM
in reply to: #4433790

User image

Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III

Any plans for this weekend besides following Yanit at IMWA?

Going for a long ride tomorrow, then will pick up my packet for the Honolulu Marathon which is on Sunday.  I only plan to do about 11 miles of it (from 11-22) and will spectate the rest of it.  Hopefully I won't get yelled at for cutting the first 11 miles of the course



2012-12-07 6:16 PM
in reply to: #4526865

User image

Payson, AZ
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
tri808 - 2012-12-07 5:08 PM

Any plans for this weekend besides following Yanit at IMWA?

Going for a long ride tomorrow, then will pick up my packet for the Honolulu Marathon which is on Sunday.  I only plan to do about 11 miles of it (from 11-22) and will spectate the rest of it.  Hopefully I won't get yelled at for cutting the first 11 miles of the course

just a training run or pacing a friend?  Either way have fun.  Nothing much on my training schedule, just a medium run.

2012-12-07 7:08 PM
in reply to: #4526868

User image

Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
bzgl40 - 2012-12-07 2:16 PM
tri808 - 2012-12-07 5:08 PM

Any plans for this weekend besides following Yanit at IMWA?

Going for a long ride tomorrow, then will pick up my packet for the Honolulu Marathon which is on Sunday.  I only plan to do about 11 miles of it (from 11-22) and will spectate the rest of it.  Hopefully I won't get yelled at for cutting the first 11 miles of the course

just a training run or pacing a friend?  Either way have fun.  Nothing much on my training schedule, just a medium run.

Part of it is just training, part of it will be to help pace a few friends (if I can keep up). 

2012-12-07 7:09 PM
in reply to: #4526671

User image

Champion
9407
500020002000100100100100
Montague Gold Mines, Nova Scotia
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
Chris,

I'd probably lean toward the cover, especially if it allows you to ride with power.

In addition, the cover should allow you to run a wider tire without compromising aerodynamics so should be more comfortable.

Shane
2012-12-07 7:10 PM
in reply to: #4433790

User image

Elite
3779
20001000500100100252525
Ontario
Subject: RE: Fred D Mentor Group Part III
Hoping to do the 5min power test tomorrow morning - today didn't work out.  Run on Sunday as I avoid a choir concert while up at the in laws.
New Thread
BT Development Mentor Program Archives » Fred D Mentor Group Part III Rss Feed  
 
 
of 115