BT Development Mentor Program Archives » SBR "U" Rss Feed  
Moderators: alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 97
 
 
2015-05-06 12:51 PM
in reply to: TankBoy

User image

Veteran
1677
1000500100252525
Houston, Texas
Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Glad to hear everything is okay!

I think I need to send my Quarq back, but I'm not particularly mechanically-inclined....how difficult is it to pull off and put my old crank back on?  I could go to the bike shop if I need to, but would rather not deal with the hassle of doing so.



2015-05-06 2:24 PM
in reply to: ligersandtions

User image

Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Originally posted by ligersandtions

Glad to hear everything is okay!

I think I need to send my Quarq back, but I'm not particularly mechanically-inclined....how difficult is it to pull off and put my old crank back on?  I could go to the bike shop if I need to, but would rather not deal with the hassle of doing so.

I'm pretty sure SRAM BB30 and GXP are the same installation method for Quarq.  I have a GXP quarq which replaced a SRAM Force BB30 crank than they install the same.

I'm pretty sure the only tools you need are a 8 mm allen key and maybe something like a rubber mallet to give a few gentle taps.  You don't actually need a rubber mallet...sometimes just tapping with my hand is good enough, but I remove my crank quite often to swap between bikes.  Sometimes cranks that haven't been removed in a while may not have good grease in there.  They key is getting a 8 mm allen key that will give you enough torque.  You're typical multi tool or 3 inch L wrenches likely won't cut it.  I use a 7 inch ratchet with socket keys.  The ratchet is nice because it takes a lot of turns to actually get the crank on and off.

There are youtube videos out there.  Just know that it's a self extracting bolt.  You'll see a 10 mm hole that is the end cap on the non drive side.  You don't remove that.  You work the 8 mm hole just beneath the cap to remove the crank arm.  The cap is what the bolt will push against to self extract.  I can give you more details if you want, but my guess is a youtube video would explain it better.

What exactly is making you think you need to send your quarq back in?

2015-05-06 2:32 PM
in reply to: Jason N

User image

Extreme Veteran
5722
5000500100100
Subject: RE: SBR "U"
Originally posted by Jason N

Originally posted by ligersandtions

Glad to hear everything is okay!

I think I need to send my Quarq back, but I'm not particularly mechanically-inclined....how difficult is it to pull off and put my old crank back on?  I could go to the bike shop if I need to, but would rather not deal with the hassle of doing so.

I'm pretty sure SRAM BB30 and GXP are the same installation method for Quarq.  I have a GXP quarq which replaced a SRAM Force BB30 crank than they install the same.

I'm pretty sure the only tools you need are a 8 mm allen key and maybe something like a rubber mallet to give a few gentle taps.  You don't actually need a rubber mallet...sometimes just tapping with my hand is good enough, but I remove my crank quite often to swap between bikes.  Sometimes cranks that haven't been removed in a while may not have good grease in there.  They key is getting a 8 mm allen key that will give you enough torque.  You're typical multi tool or 3 inch L wrenches likely won't cut it.  I use a 7 inch ratchet with socket keys.  The ratchet is nice because it takes a lot of turns to actually get the crank on and off.

There are youtube videos out there.  Just know that it's a self extracting bolt.  You'll see a 10 mm hole that is the end cap on the non drive side.  You don't remove that.  You work the 8 mm hole just beneath the cap to remove the crank arm.  The cap is what the bolt will push against to self extract.  I can give you more details if you want, but my guess is a youtube video would explain it better.

What exactly is making you think you need to send your quarq back in?





https://youtu.be/NSy4cK5EX9o
2015-05-06 3:47 PM
in reply to: TankBoy

User image

Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Originally posted by TankBoy Thanks - no worries though - diagnosis is pleurisy, not pericarditis, which I also have a history of. They are similar in nature: pericarditis is heart and pleurisy is lungs. Treatment is the same - just got NSAIDs in me - so hopefully the pain will resolve quickly. First time I dealt with this (about 20 years ago) I really did think I was having a heart attack though - it is pretty awful!

Glad to hear you're OK

2015-05-06 6:36 PM
in reply to: ligersandtions

User image

Master
2912
2000500100100100100
...at home in The ATL
Subject: RE: SBR "U"
Thanks all - pain is a little better, but still rough if I breath even a little deeply - going up stairs/walking up hill stinks.

Nicole - swapping cranks on a GPX bottom bracket is about the easiest thing you can do. I use a long torque wrench to break the bolt loose (easy to do even without a bike stand as you turn the wrench against the drivetrain direction). Then use an Allen wrench to take the bolt the rest of the way out. I also use the torque wrench to put it back on so I get it to spec. To send my Quarq in I had to take a crank off my old TT bike, and then take the Quarq crank off my road bike, and then put the first crank back on my road bike. It took a lot less than 5 minutes to do all that.

Also interested to hear what kind of problems you are having?

2015-05-06 7:14 PM
in reply to: TankBoy

User image

Master
8249
50002000100010010025
Eugene, Oregon
Bronze member
Subject: RE: SBR "U"
Sick here too. Cold, or maybe just really bad allergies, or more likely both. Can't believe it. It's happened for something like 60% of my races, and I hardly ever get sick at other times. Something about taper that messes with my immune system, I guess.I also tend to race around now and it's peak allergy season just before the rains start. Just really congested. I've done a few easy 20-30 minute trainer rides and jogs this week, and that's it. Will race if I feel I can breathe okay.If worst comes to worse, I will just focus on doing a good time on the bike and drop out, walk, or sandbag the run. Have really been working on the bike (plus have the new tri bike) and want to see what I can do on a flat course. The next HIM I could do is in late July and the thought of keeping up HIM training that long makes me sick(er)! Ugh.


2015-05-06 7:18 PM
in reply to: TankBoy

User image

Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Nicole, one more thing.  You'll also need to remove the chainrings before sending it back to Quark.  It is as simple as using two allen keys, I think 5 and 6 mm.  When you put them back on though, you probably want a torque wrench.  I believe it is 8 nm for aluminum bolts and 10 nm for steel botls.  You likely have steel, but Quarq can confirm what they came with.

2015-05-06 7:38 PM
in reply to: Jason N

User image

Master
2912
2000500100100100100
...at home in The ATL
Subject: RE: SBR "U"
Jason - every time I have returned mine (including this time) they told me to just leave the chainrings on. They do like you to wipe them down (they send you a funny little note that says the tech's appreciate it) and remove the pedals though. They are pretty easy to get on the phone during business hours, but also respond to email quickly. If they can't solve the problem they send you an email fedex label an all you have to do is drop it off at an authorized shipper. Like everyone always says, their customer service is outstanding, but 5 returns in 5 years is a little much, although it DOES keep extending my warranty out. Heh. My wife still has an original 975 that is 4.5 years old, and it has never had a moment of problems. And it is even bolted to a "non-compatible" set of DA chainrings. Go figure.
2015-05-06 7:47 PM
in reply to: Jason N

User image

Veteran
1677
1000500100252525
Houston, Texas
Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Thanks for the feedback on how to remove the Quarq!

The problem I'm having is that the power jumps around +/- 15-20 watts while holding steady cadence on the trainer (even with 10s power smoothing on).  It never used to do it until I upgraded to the latest firmware -- used to be that I could hold steady to within a couple watts.  It's not quite, but almost like a sine wave -- it'll be low for a few moments and then go high.  The average is probably where it should be, but it gets frustrating while on the trainer and trying to hold a steady power....watching it go between 155W and 185W while trying to hold 170W with a steady cadence.  

I've been dealing with it since last year (really should have sent it back while I took time off the bike over the winter, but I just didn't think about it), so I've gotten somewhat used to it, but when I first started dealing with it, I would try to correct for it and then my power would really be all over the place.  Now I just settle in and watch the cadence, but it's still irritating that it jumps around so much when it used to not.  

It does the same thing on the road, but I'm much more forgiving of that because I don't stare at it and watch it constantly!

2015-05-06 10:34 PM
in reply to: ligersandtions

User image

Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Nicole,

I believe you can take the raw garmin file and import it into excel.  That should give you (and Quarq) a better idea of what's actually being reported on a second by second basis.  If you're seeing those type of jumps with 10s smoothing, you must be getting some really erratic data.  

If you haven't taken off your crank in a long time, it might be a good time to take it into the shop and have your bottom bracket checked out.  It's one of those things that most cyclists neglect...especially if you ride a lot...and ride a lot on the trainer where sweat tends to drip towards the bottom bracket.

2015-05-07 10:36 AM
in reply to: Jason N

Master
5557
50005002525
, California
Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Originally posted by Jason N

Nicole,

I believe you can take the raw garmin file and import it into excel.  That should give you (and Quarq) a better idea of what's actually being reported on a second by second basis.  If you're seeing those type of jumps with 10s smoothing, you must be getting some really erratic data.  

If you haven't taken off your crank in a long time, it might be a good time to take it into the shop and have your bottom bracket checked out.  It's one of those things that most cyclists neglect...especially if you ride a lot...and ride a lot on the trainer where sweat tends to drip towards the bottom bracket.

Golden Cheetah will also show a table with that info, on the "Edit" tab.



2015-05-07 12:24 PM
in reply to: Jason N

User image

Veteran
1677
1000500100252525
Houston, Texas
Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Good advice -- thanks, Jason!  I'll shoot some info over to Quarq.  We had talked when this first started happening (it was fine until the day I did the firmware update, but they hadn't had anyone else with issues), so I'll follow up again and see if they still recommend me sending it in or if there are any diagnostics they can do remotely.

I haven't taken the crank off in a long time (since I got the PM...) and spend a lot of time on the trainer with my corrosive sweat!   Getting the bottom bracket checked out is probably something I should do!

2015-05-07 12:30 PM
in reply to: spudone

User image

Extreme Veteran
5722
5000500100100
Subject: RE: SBR "U"
Originally posted by spudone
Golden Cheetah will also show a table with that info, on the "Edit" tab.




Ya, what is cool is when you have it in GC, you can export to csv and then play in Excel

For example, Nicole, you sent me some files at one point. I looked at one from Nov 16/2014

I dumped it into excel. If I do a 10s running average, which is basically what your Garmin should be doing, there is no jumping around in the numbers which is weird.

You also have trainerroad. Are the numbers jumpy there ?


2015-05-07 12:35 PM
in reply to: marcag

User image

Veteran
1677
1000500100252525
Houston, Texas
Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Originally posted by marcag
Originally posted by spudone Golden Cheetah will also show a table with that info, on the "Edit" tab.
Ya, what is cool is when you have it in GC, you can export to csv and then play in Excel For example, Nicole, you sent me some files at one point. I looked at one from Nov 16/2014 I dumped it into excel. If I do a 10s running average, which is basically what your Garmin should be doing, there is no jumping around in the numbers which is weird. You also have trainerroad. Are the numbers jumpy there ?

TrainerRoad is where I notice it most....it's watching that where I see the almost sine wave power output most.  If I look at my Garmin at the same time, it'll do the same thing, so I don't think it's TR acting buggy.

2015-05-07 12:42 PM
in reply to: ligersandtions

User image

Extreme Veteran
5722
5000500100100
Subject: RE: SBR "U"
Originally posted by ligersandtions

Originally posted by marcag
Originally posted by spudone Golden Cheetah will also show a table with that info, on the "Edit" tab.
Ya, what is cool is when you have it in GC, you can export to csv and then play in Excel For example, Nicole, you sent me some files at one point. I looked at one from Nov 16/2014 I dumped it into excel. If I do a 10s running average, which is basically what your Garmin should be doing, there is no jumping around in the numbers which is weird. You also have trainerroad. Are the numbers jumpy there ?

TrainerRoad is where I notice it most....it's watching that where I see the almost sine wave power output most.  If I look at my Garmin at the same time, it'll do the same thing, so I don't think it's TR acting buggy.




did it do it when you were racing ?

2015-05-07 1:16 PM
in reply to: marcag

User image

Veteran
1677
1000500100252525
Houston, Texas
Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Originally posted by marcag
Originally posted by ligersandtions

Originally posted by marcag
Originally posted by spudone Golden Cheetah will also show a table with that info, on the "Edit" tab.
Ya, what is cool is when you have it in GC, you can export to csv and then play in Excel For example, Nicole, you sent me some files at one point. I looked at one from Nov 16/2014 I dumped it into excel. If I do a 10s running average, which is basically what your Garmin should be doing, there is no jumping around in the numbers which is weird. You also have trainerroad. Are the numbers jumpy there ?

TrainerRoad is where I notice it most....it's watching that where I see the almost sine wave power output most.  If I look at my Garmin at the same time, it'll do the same thing, so I don't think it's TR acting buggy.

did it do it when you were racing ?

It's hard to say for sure, but I think so.  I'd settle into it and watch it fluctuate (usually goes low), hold my power output steady, and then see it come back up to where I expected it to be.  I don't stare at my power out on the road the way I do on the trainer....and also understand that so many things affect power outside (wind, false flats, big trucks coming by, draft-legal slingshot benefit, etc.), whereas the trainer is a very controlled environment where I can hold the cadence steady and watch the power jump 15W in either direction...



2015-05-07 1:27 PM
in reply to: ligersandtions

User image

Veteran
2842
200050010010010025
Austin, Texas
Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Originally posted by ligersandtions

Originally posted by marcag
Originally posted by ligersandtions

Originally posted by marcag
Originally posted by spudone Golden Cheetah will also show a table with that info, on the "Edit" tab.
Ya, what is cool is when you have it in GC, you can export to csv and then play in Excel For example, Nicole, you sent me some files at one point. I looked at one from Nov 16/2014 I dumped it into excel. If I do a 10s running average, which is basically what your Garmin should be doing, there is no jumping around in the numbers which is weird. You also have trainerroad. Are the numbers jumpy there ?

TrainerRoad is where I notice it most....it's watching that where I see the almost sine wave power output most.  If I look at my Garmin at the same time, it'll do the same thing, so I don't think it's TR acting buggy.

did it do it when you were racing ?

It's hard to say for sure, but I think so.  I'd settle into it and watch it fluctuate (usually goes low), hold my power output steady, and then see it come back up to where I expected it to be.  I don't stare at my power out on the road the way I do on the trainer....and also understand that so many things affect power outside (wind, false flats, big trucks coming by, draft-legal slingshot benefit, etc.), whereas the trainer is a very controlled environment where I can hold the cadence steady and watch the power jump 15W in either direction...

Did you notice your HR dip with power drops?  Come back when the PM was reading what you'd expect?  Most of the things you list on the road will affect your speed for a power output, but your HR should be more closely linked with a real change in power (or not, if it's a bad reading). 

The trainer jumpiness sounds like it's broken, so being off in the race would make sense, but you might be able to use HR:W where you notice any sustained dips in power (that you didn't feel from an exertion standpoint) as a cross-check for the race data.

Matt

2015-05-07 1:28 PM
in reply to: TankBoy

User image

Veteran
2842
200050010010010025
Austin, Texas
Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Originally posted by TankBoy Thanks all - pain is a little better, but still rough if I breath even a little deeply - going up stairs/walking up hill stinks.

Nicole - swapping cranks on a GPX bottom bracket is about the easiest thing you can do. I use a long torque wrench to break the bolt loose (easy to do even without a bike stand as you turn the wrench against the drivetrain direction). Then use an Allen wrench to take the bolt the rest of the way out. I also use the torque wrench to put it back on so I get it to spec. To send my Quarq in I had to take a crank off my old TT bike, and then take the Quarq crank off my road bike, and then put the first crank back on my road bike. It took a lot less than 5 minutes to do all that.

Also interested to hear what kind of problems you are having?

Glad the pain is abating.  That is a scary feeling, even if you're thinking it's not a heart attack.  Anything that feels close, well... feels like a heart attack!

Any idea how long before you're mended?

Matt

2015-05-07 2:13 PM
in reply to: ligersandtions

Master
5557
50005002525
, California
Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Originally posted by ligersandtions

Originally posted by marcag
Originally posted by ligersandtions

Originally posted by marcag
Originally posted by spudone Golden Cheetah will also show a table with that info, on the "Edit" tab.
Ya, what is cool is when you have it in GC, you can export to csv and then play in Excel For example, Nicole, you sent me some files at one point. I looked at one from Nov 16/2014 I dumped it into excel. If I do a 10s running average, which is basically what your Garmin should be doing, there is no jumping around in the numbers which is weird. You also have trainerroad. Are the numbers jumpy there ?

TrainerRoad is where I notice it most....it's watching that where I see the almost sine wave power output most.  If I look at my Garmin at the same time, it'll do the same thing, so I don't think it's TR acting buggy.

did it do it when you were racing ?

It's hard to say for sure, but I think so.  I'd settle into it and watch it fluctuate (usually goes low), hold my power output steady, and then see it come back up to where I expected it to be.  I don't stare at my power out on the road the way I do on the trainer....and also understand that so many things affect power outside (wind, false flats, big trucks coming by, draft-legal slingshot benefit, etc.), whereas the trainer is a very controlled environment where I can hold the cadence steady and watch the power jump 15W in either direction...

Do you live in a condo or apartment?  Could be interference in the 2.4ghz wireless spectrum, which ANT+ uses.  Of course so do phones, microwaves, routers, etc...

2015-05-07 2:44 PM
in reply to: spudone

User image

Extreme Veteran
5722
5000500100100
Subject: RE: SBR "U"
Originally posted by spudone

Originally posted by ligersandtions

Originally posted by marcag
Originally posted by ligersandtions

Originally posted by marcag
Originally posted by spudone Golden Cheetah will also show a table with that info, on the "Edit" tab.
Ya, what is cool is when you have it in GC, you can export to csv and then play in Excel For example, Nicole, you sent me some files at one point. I looked at one from Nov 16/2014 I dumped it into excel. If I do a 10s running average, which is basically what your Garmin should be doing, there is no jumping around in the numbers which is weird. You also have trainerroad. Are the numbers jumpy there ?

TrainerRoad is where I notice it most....it's watching that where I see the almost sine wave power output most.  If I look at my Garmin at the same time, it'll do the same thing, so I don't think it's TR acting buggy.

did it do it when you were racing ?

It's hard to say for sure, but I think so.  I'd settle into it and watch it fluctuate (usually goes low), hold my power output steady, and then see it come back up to where I expected it to be.  I don't stare at my power out on the road the way I do on the trainer....and also understand that so many things affect power outside (wind, false flats, big trucks coming by, draft-legal slingshot benefit, etc.), whereas the trainer is a very controlled environment where I can hold the cadence steady and watch the power jump 15W in either direction...

Do you live in a condo or apartment?  Could be interference in the 2.4ghz wireless spectrum, which ANT+ uses.  Of course so do phones, microwaves, routers, etc...




A note on that and the reason I asked.

When I upgraded to FW23 I noticed that is I used 2 head units I would get sometimes 0w, for brief periods, sometimes constant.
I spoke to Q, and they didn't believe me. I could get my Garmin 800 to interfere with my 910. I could get my Ant+ stick talking to Qalvin to interfere with my 910. I wonder if the TR ant+ stick is interfering with the 910 or vice versa. I can still reproduce it today.
They argued it was a Garmin issue.

Did you ever have the problem only with TR or only with the 910, or do they always run in parralel ?
2015-05-07 7:33 PM
in reply to: marcag

User image

Extreme Veteran
5722
5000500100100
Subject: RE: SBR "U"
I rode a 15km TT tonight

Best 20min power ever, actually best 24min. 304w for best 20min, 303 w for best 24min

Finished, heard rubbiinhg rear brake rubbing on wheel. 37.9km/h on 303 watts. F!!! That's not 24mph.

Good news is my Quarq and Vectors were within 4 watts of each other.

305 out, 300 back and a bit lost at the turnaround.

I was riding that fast in Texas on 210w :-) Oh well, at least my FTP is up and I get an early start time next race.



2015-05-07 9:17 PM
in reply to: TankBoy

User image

Veteran
945
50010010010010025
South Windsor, CT
Subject: RE: SBR "U"
Originally posted by TankBoy

Thanks - no worries though - diagnosis is pleurisy, not pericarditis, which I also have a history of. They are similar in nature: pericarditis is heart and pleurisy is lungs. Treatment is the same - just got NSAIDs in me - so hopefully the pain will resolve quickly. First time I dealt with this (about 20 years ago) I really did think I was having a heart attack though - it is pretty awful!


They both can hurt a LOT.
Glad you know what it was and are on the mend.

Best to you Rusty.
2015-05-08 3:01 AM
in reply to: marcag

User image

Elite
7783
50002000500100100252525
PEI, Canada
Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Originally posted by marcag I rode a 15km TT tonight Best 20min power ever, actually best 24min. 304w for best 20min, 303 w for best 24min Finished, heard rubbiinhg rear brake rubbing on wheel. 37.9km/h on 303 watts. F!!! That's not 24mph. Good news is my Quarq and Vectors were within 4 watts of each other. 305 out, 300 back and a bit lost at the turnaround. I was riding that fast in Texas on 210w :-) Oh well, at least my FTP is up and I get an early start time next race.

Awesome news on the power Marc!  Not so awesome on the brakepad.

I've got a 19k TT tomorrow morning, gonna be cold!

2015-05-08 7:14 AM
in reply to: axteraa

User image

Extreme Veteran
5722
5000500100100
Subject: RE: SBR "U"
Originally posted by axteraa

Originally posted by marcag I rode a 15km TT tonight Best 20min power ever, actually best 24min. 304w for best 20min, 303 w for best 24min Finished, heard rubbiinhg rear brake rubbing on wheel. 37.9km/h on 303 watts. F!!! That's not 24mph. Good news is my Quarq and Vectors were within 4 watts of each other. 305 out, 300 back and a bit lost at the turnaround. I was riding that fast in Texas on 210w :-) Oh well, at least my FTP is up and I get an early start time next race.

Awesome news on the power Marc!  Not so awesome on the brakepad.

I've got a 19k TT tomorrow morning, gonna be cold!




thanks. I was happy with the effort. But I really wanted to do some aero testing so that was kind of a waste.

You realize with these tests that you can actually hold a power higher than you think, but the suffer threshold is brutal. I know I could have gone another 6 minutes, probably more, but man oh man it hurts.
2015-05-08 8:34 AM
in reply to: marcag

Master
10208
50005000100100
Northern IL
Subject: RE: SBR "U"

Originally posted by marcag
Originally posted by axteraa

Originally posted by marcag I rode a 15km TT tonight Best 20min power ever, actually best 24min. 304w for best 20min, 303 w for best 24min Finished, heard rubbiinhg rear brake rubbing on wheel. 37.9km/h on 303 watts. F!!! That's not 24mph. Good news is my Quarq and Vectors were within 4 watts of each other. 305 out, 300 back and a bit lost at the turnaround. I was riding that fast in Texas on 210w :-) Oh well, at least my FTP is up and I get an early start time next race.

Awesome news on the power Marc!  Not so awesome on the brakepad.

I've got a 19k TT tomorrow morning, gonna be cold!

thanks. I was happy with the effort. But I really wanted to do some aero testing so that was kind of a waste. You realize with these tests that you can actually hold a power higher than you think, but the suffer threshold is brutal. I know I could have gone another 6 minutes, probably more, but man oh man it hurts.

Just waiting for the Race Report before commenting.

New Thread
BT Development Mentor Program Archives » SBR "U" Rss Feed  
 
 
of 97
 
 
RELATED ARTICLES
date : March 15, 2013
author : writingrunner
comments : 1
The science behind the reasons that triathlons make us feel so good.
 
date : January 9, 2013
author : MultisportWorld
comments : 0
Jarrod Shoemaker, 2012 US Elite National Champion, discusses the importance of recovery for injury prevention.
date : December 12, 2004
author : Team BT
comments : 0
Ultraman champion, Shanna Armstrong, to ride across USA for science.
 
date : August 31, 2004
author : Ron
comments : 0
Everything you want to know (and then some).